Devin Williams helps Yankees enter their beard era. Plus, 2 NL East aces return

New York Times

24-02-2025

The Windup Newsletter ⚾ | This is The Athletic's MLB newsletter. Sign up here to receive The Windup directly in your inbox.
Full disclosure, I've been putting players with beards on the Yankees in 'MLB: The Show' for years now. Plus: Ken on Anthony Rizzo's desire to keep playing, two aces I'm excited to see in 2025 and just when you thought baseball's TV landscape was settled … it is not. I'm Levi Weaver, here with Ken Rosenthal. Welcome to The Windup!
Yes, this is silly. Yes, it is also our lead story today, precisely because the whole thing is just so ridiculous. Nearly 50 years after then-owner George Steinbrenner laid down the law — no long hair, no facial hair on the Yankees — the team announced Friday it will now allow 'well-groomed' beards.
As for the reasoning, you might think the answer is 'because it was kind of ridiculous in the first place,' but no — there's a more practical reason: Owner Hal Steinbrenner mentioned the change is about roster construction, saying he doesn't want the Yankees to miss out on any players for whom their beard is a big part of their identity.
Advertisement
Who, you might ask, would care that much? Their new closer, for one. Devin Williams was so annoyed by having to shave his beard that he requested a meeting with team ownership. Asked if the policy would be a factor when he hit free agency, he said, 'It's something that I would consider, for sure.'
How big a deal is this? Brendan Kuty even has a story about how it will impact the team barber. Tyler Kepner has another writeup here about the end of a tradition, and the ones that will remain in place — but there's one more that is going away: Frank Sinatra's 'New York, New York' won't play after losses (it will still be played after wins).
More Yankees: In actual baseball news, manager Aaron Boone — perhaps helped by the support of Aaron Judge — has signed an extension through 2027. And Kuty has the story from the early workouts, where Yankees players are still angry about losing the World Series last year.
From my latest story with Brendan Kuty:
Anthony Rizzo is only 35. But with spring training games underway, he continues to linger on the free-agent market. Rizzo wants to play. He's healthy enough to play. Yet he knows the end of his career might be near.
'I've definitely thought about it. I think I have a lot to give to the game still,' the three-time All-Star and four-time Gold Glove winner at first base said Friday. 'But at the same time, if teams are not going to want to pay a few million dollars for veterans, I've seen it the last 10 years of my career. It's what happens to the older guys. They kind of get squeezed. You've seen it happen more and more. I'm not naive to it. It could be it.'
Rizzo, a 14-year veteran, became a free agent when the Yankees declined his $17 million option, giving him a $6 million buyout that increased his career earnings to $127.6 million. The Yankees replaced him by awarding a one-year, $12.5 million free-agent contract to an even older first baseman, 37-year-old Paul Goldschmidt.
Advertisement
Rizzo, after two injury-marred seasons, understands why his market is less than robust. But he said he would not sign a deal that damages the future earning potential of players behind him.
'I'm surprised, but not like crazy surprised just because I'm a realist in the game and you're getting older,' Rizzo said. 'The fact that teams want you to play for basically league minimum ($760,000), I'm like, you guys are crazy. You're almost trying to ruin the market for the next guy.'
Rizzo's injuries the past two seasons resulted from incidents largely out of his control. He suffered a concussion stemming from a collision at first base, a fractured right forearm resulting from another collision while running out a ball and two broken knuckles in his right hand after he was hit by a pitch.
The last of those injuries occurred on Sept. 28. Rizzo missed the Division Series but returned from the ALCS. He said he received multiple numbing injections in multiple areas of his hand before and during postseason games. But the hand returned to full strength after the season ended, and Rizzo went through his normal offseason training regimen.
More here.
This happens to me twice a year: Christmas and spring training. The calendar will sneak up on me, and I'm just not feeling the seasonal spirit until — BAM — something cracks through my exterior, and I'm ready to get festive.
This year's spring training breakthrough came when I saw headlines about two NL East pitchers I missed watching in 2024: Sandy Alcantara of the Marlins and Spencer Strider of the Braves.
More returning pitchers: Matt Gelb has the inside story on Andrew Painter's two years away from action with the Phillies. And don't forget the Dodgers, who are bringing back Shohei Ohtani, Tony Gonsolin and Dustin May to their stacked rotation.
Just when we got one TV rights conversation behind us with the FanDuel (née Bally) Sports contracts all sorted for local broadcasts … well, here comes another bit of upheaval.
2025 will be the last year we see MLB on ESPN for the foreseeable future. Both sides have agreed to opt out of the rest of a deal that would have run through 2028.
Advertisement
So why did the split happen? From the story:
'Manfred wrote (in a memo) the league has 'not been pleased with the minimal coverage that MLB has received on ESPN's platforms over the past several years outside of the actual live game coverage.''
Further down in the story, Evan Drellich and Andrew Marchand report ESPN actually opted out first, prompting MLB to follow suit. The package was going to pay the league $550 million per year over the next three years. ESPN felt it was too high, and MLB said, in so many words, 'You don't talk about us enough anyway.'
Ever the diplomats, the parties both seemed to indicate that they might get back together later. As Marchand reports here, it's messy. Again.
So much for that new ownership plan in Minnesota. Justin Ishbia will now be purchasing more shares in the White Sox instead, leaving the Twins back at square one.
ABS updates: Cody Poteet of the Cubs made the first successful challenge, while Reds manager Terry Francona has told his players not to use it since it won't be in play during the regular season. Aaron Gleeman writes on how the system will impact the value of catchers.
Katie Woo has the inside story on the Cardinals' attempts to trade Nolan Arenado this offseason. The level of detail in the reporting is incredible.
Justin Verlander (newly a Giant) is 42 years old, but he's not just trying to hang around. He wants to be excellent for a few more years.
Cody Stavenhagen has stories on three Tigers starters: Tarik Skubal bought his catcher a Rolex, Jackson Jobe's new curveball and Kenta Maeda's prove-it season.
Keith Law has a list of 25 potentially high-impact rookies.
If we told you Brent Rooker was the centerpiece of the A's rebuild, would you believe it? Or are we getting the rug pulled out from under us again in a few years?
Most-clicked in our last newsletter: Jayson Stark's comprehensive explainer on the robo-umps.
📫 Love The Windup? Check out The Athletic's other newsletters.