Man accused of 1979 kidnap and murder of Etan Patz in New York has conviction overturned
Patz's disappearance on his way to a school bus stop in Manhattan rattled the city, and was unsolved for decades before Pedro Hernandez was convicted of the killing in 2017.
But that conviction has now been overturned and Hernandez will face a new trial, where his confession to the crime will be under scrutiny.
Here's what to know about the young boy's disappearance and why Hernandez's conviction has been overturned.
Patz was a first grader who always wanted "to do everything that adults did", his mother, Julie Patz, told jurors in 2017.
So on the morning of May 25, 1979, she agreed her son could walk by himself to the school bus stop, two blocks away.
It was the first time he was allowed to go alone, and the last time she saw her son.
When Patz did not come home from school that day, his parents reported him missing and the police searched for him for weeks.
For decades, his parents kept the same apartment and even phone number in case he might try to reach them.
Patz's body has never been found, and a civil court declared him dead in 2001.
Hernandez was a teenager working at a convenience store in the neighbourhood when Patz vanished.
Police met him while canvassing the area but didn't suspect him until 2012, when they got a tip from a relative.
He had made remarks during a prayer group years earlier about having killed a child in New York.
While there was no physical evidence against Hernandez, police said he confessed during a seven-hour interrogation to luring Patz into the store's basement by offering him a soft drink.
Hernandez said he choked the young boy because "something just took over me".
Hernandez said he put Patz, still alive, in a "garbage bag" before stuffing him into a box and leaving it outside with a pile of rubbish.
In one of the recorded confessions, he added that he'd wanted to tell someone, "but I didn't know how to do it. I felt so sorry".
Hernandez, however, later recanted and pleaded not guilty to murder.
His lawyers said the admissions were the false imaginings of a man with mental illness, low intelligence and a propensity towards vivid hallucinations.
But in 2017, Hernandez was sentenced to 25 years to life in prison after being convicted of second-degree murder and first-degree kidnapping.
This was his second trial; the first in 2015 ended in a hung jury after 18 days of deliberations.
"After all these years we finally know what dark secret you had locked in your heart," Etan's father, Stanley Patz, said at the sentencing.
Hernandez's lawyers have long argued that their client's mental illness and the circumstances of his confession undermined the fairness of the 2017 trial.
In a ruling on Monday, local time, a federal appeals court said the trial judge gave a "clearly wrong" and "manifestly prejudicial" response to a jury note during the trial.
The note addressed how the jury should interpret recordings of the police interrogation in which Hernandez confessed.
Police said he initially confessed before they read him his Miranda rights — a constitutionally mandated warning about self-incrimination.
Immediately after, he was given a legally required warning that his statements could be used against him in court, and was asked to repeat his confession on tape.
Several hours later, he did so again for a federal prosecutor.
At the trial, jurors sent repeated queries about the multiple confessions.
The last inquiry asked whether they had to disregard the two recorded confessions, if they concluded that the first one — given before the Miranda warning — was invalid.
The judge said "no".
The appeals court ruled that the jury should have received a more thorough explanation of its options, which could have included disregarding all of the confessions as improperly obtained.
The court ordered Hernandez's release unless the 64-year-old gets a new trial within a "reasonable period".
The Manhattan District Attorney's Office, which prosecuted the case, said it was reviewing the decision.
Patz's missing persons campaign attracted national attention and became a cautionary tale during the 80s.
The six-year-old was one of the first children whose disappearance was publicised in what became a high-profile way: on billboards and milk cartons.
His case also ushered in an age of parental anxiety around child safety.
Parents became more protective of kids who were once allowed to roam and play unsupervised in their neighbourhoods.
The Patzs' advocacy also helped establish a national missing-children hotline.
US president Ronald Reagan marked the anniversary of the boy's disappearance in 1983, proclaiming it National Missing Children's Day.
Hashtags

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles

News.com.au
9 hours ago
- News.com.au
Five dead including gunman in New York office shooting spree
Four people including a police officer were killed Monday after a gunman walked into a skyscraper in central Manhattan and opened fire in broad daylight, officials said. A fifth victim was also in critical condition after being shot, while the gunman apparently took his own life, Mayor Eric Adams told a late-night briefing at a hospital near the scene of the shooting. The gunman was caught on camera exiting a black BMW carrying an M-4 rifle, then entering the building, immediately opening fire on a police officer before "spraying the lobby" with bullets, police commissioner Jessica Tisch told the press conference. He then took an elevator to the 33rd floor, of Rudin Management which owns the building, where the man continued his spree before apparently shooting himself. He was later discovered by officers next to his weapon. The office tower block at 345 Park Avenue is also home to hedge fund giant Blackstone, auditor KPMG and the National Football League. Tisch told the briefing that the suspect was believed to have acted alone but inquiries were ongoing, with the FBI assisting in the investigation. She identified the shooter as Shane Tamura of Las Vegas and said a revolver, ammunition and magazines were found in his vehicle along with medication bearing his name. The man had a history of mental health issues according to Las Vegas law enforcement -- but did appear to possess a valid firearms permit for Nevada, Tisch said. He drove cross-country from the southwestern state in recent days and arrived in New York on Monday, she said. The incident began around 6:00 pm (2200 GMT) when reports of gunfire prompted hundreds of police to swarm a busy office district on the storied Park Avenue, an area popular with tourists and visiting businesspeople. A worker from a nearby office building wept as she left the area after a local lockdown was lifted, while another described a gunman going floor to floor as staff prepared to leave for the day. Adams said the fallen police officer, an immigrant from Bangladesh who was 36 years old, was among the dead. Two other males and a female died, and another man remained in a critical condition, officials said without giving any preliminary motive for the shootings. - Rush hour - Office worker Shad Sakib told AFP that he was packing his things to leave work when a public address announcement warned him and his colleagues to shelter in place. "Everyone was confused with like, 'wait, what's going on?' And then someone finally realized that it's online, that someone walked in with a machine gun," said the witness who wore a grey suit jacket. "He walked right into a building right next door. We saw the photo of him walking through the same area that I walked through to get lunch here. "You would think it won't happen to you, and then it does." Mass shootings are common in the United States, where a constitutional right to bear arms outweighs demands for stricter rules. There have been 254 mass shootings in the United States this year including Monday's incident in New York, according to the Gun Violence Archive -- which defines a mass shooting as four or more people shot. Police officers deployed a drone near Park Avenue at the height of the evening rush-hour as dozens of officers swarmed the area, some carrying long guns and others wearing ballistic vests. The area is home to several five-star business hotels, as well as a number of corporate headquarters. The United Nations headquarters is nearby. New York Governor Kathy Hochul said she has been briefed on the shooting. The frontrunner in the race for mayor Zohran Mamdani wrote on X that he was "heartbroken to learn of the horrific shooting in midtown and I am holding the victims, their families, and the NYPD officer... in my thoughts."

ABC News
10 hours ago
- ABC News
Gunman kills four people in New York office building shooting before taking his life
A man carrying a rifle killed four people, including an off-duty police officer, in a New York office building that houses some of the country's top financial firms and the National Football League (NFL), officials said. Police identified the gunman as Shane Tamura, of Las Vegas, and said he also wounded a fifth person before taking his own life. He had a "documented mental health history", but the motive was still unknown, Police Commissioner Jessica Tisch said at a news conference. "We are working to understand why he targeted this particular location," she said. The officer who was killed was a 36-year-old immigrant from Bangladesh and had served as a police officer in New York City for three and a half years. "He died as he lived. A hero," Ms Tisch said. Mayor Eric Adams said the man who was injured remained in a critical condition. He added that officials were still "unravelling" what took place. "Five innocent people were shot," he said. Surveillance video showed a man exiting a double-parked BMW with an M4 rifle before he walked toward the building. He immediately opened fire on the NYPD officer as he entered the building, shot a woman who tried to take cover, then began "spraying" the lobby with gunfire, Commissioner Tisch said. The man then made his way to the elevator bank and shot a security guard who was taking cover behind a security desk, and another man in the lobby, the commissioner said. Officers found a rifle case, a revolver, magazines and ammunition in his car, she added. The Fire Department of New York said emergency crews were called to the Park Avenue office building following a report someone had been shot. A spokesperson said the call came in at about 6:30pm on Monday, local time, but provided no other details. Jessica Chen told ABC News US she was watching a presentation with dozens of other people on the second floor when she "heard multiple shots go off in quick succession from the first floor". She and others ran into a conference room and barricaded tables against the door. "We were honestly really, really scared," she said, adding that she texted her parents to tell them that she loved them. Mayor Adams posted a clip to social media urging people still inside the office building to stay put because police officers were conducting a floor-by-floor search. The Democrat said he was headed to the hospital to speak with the family and loved ones of those involved. Local TV footage showed lines of people with their hands above their heads evacuating the office building. Finance workers at an office building down the block were picking up dinner at a corner eatery when they heard a loud noise and saw people running, AP reported. "It was like a crowd panic," said Anna Smith, who joined the workers pouring back into the finance office building. They remained there for about 2 hours before being told they could leave. The building includes offices for Blackstone and the Consulate General of Ireland, located a short walk north from Grand Central Terminal. The city's emergency management alert system warned of traffic delays, road closures and disruptions to public transportation in the area. Through late July, New York City is on pace to have its fewest murders and fewest people hurt by gunfire than any year in recent decades. AP

News.com.au
11 hours ago
- News.com.au
Chilling clip emerges of NYC gunman
The gunman who opened fire inside Midtown Manhattan office tower has been identified as Shane Tamura, a 27-year-old licensed private investigator from Las Vegas who once dreamed of a life in football. He arrived in Manhattan by car on Monday and walked into 345 Park Avenue with a concealed weapon permit issued by the Las Vegas Sheriff's Department. What followed was a terrifying and targeted shooting spree that police believe was premeditated. 'It appears that he knew it would be his last stand,' said CNN chief law enforcement analyst John Miller, a former NYPD deputy commissioner. 'He fully intended to shoot his way through the lobby and make his way to that target - whatever that might have been.' The building, home to the NFL's headquarters and offices of investment giant Blackrock, became the scene of a major lockdown. While the league's offices are housed in the tower, sources confirmed Tamura was not on the NFL floor and that no known connection has yet been established between the shooter and the sports organisation. However, Tamura appears to have been a keen football fan and player. Tamura grew up in Hawaii, where he attended high school and began playing the sport. He was a promising football player in junior varsity. In a video posted online, Tamura can be heard giving a post-game interview in which he spoke of his victory with the Granada Hills football team. Shane was instrumental in his teams victory after scoring several touchdowns. 'We were down 10-0, stay disciplined came together as a team,' he said. 'Couple of touchdowns.' He eventually relocated to Las Vegas, where he earned a private investigator's license and obtained a concealed carry permit to carry firearms, both legally granted through Nevada's Sheriff's Department. The latter part of Tamura's life remained private. Investigators are now urgently combing through his car, phone, and computer in search of answers to try and work out what stressors or perceived injustices led him to carry out the deadly shooting. 'Police want to know what brought him to that building, who or what the target was, and what the grievance or motive behind it might have been,' Miller explained. 'These cases often involve people who experience a downfall and begin to blame others - bosses, institutions, society at large. 'Then they decide to get even with everybody, even though in most cases, the problem is usually them,' Miller said. Miller said shooters like Tamura often spiral quietly, building a world of resentment that no one sees until it erupts in tragedy. 'They blame their problems on other people and entities,' he said. 'Then they decide to get even - with the world, with everyone - even though the problem usually begins and ends with themselves.' No motive has yet been officially released, but police believe he was suicidal.