Former MACC chief questions legality of second seizure of Ilham Tower
Former Malaysian Anti-Corruption Commission (MACC) Chief Commissioner Tan Sri Dzulkifli Ahmad has questioned the legality of the second seizure of Ilham Tower, suggesting the move may exceed the bounds of Malaysian law.
Now a practising lawyer, Dzulkifli pointed out that the asset had already been seized under Section 38(1) of the MACC Act on Dec 18, 2023.
He said action under Section 38 requires the Deputy Public Prosecutor (DPP) to be satisfied that the asset in question - Ilham Tower - either constitutes the proceeds of, or is evidence related to, a corruption offence.
"If no charges are brought or civil forfeiture proceedings initiated before June 17, 2025 - the end of the statutory 18-month period - it raises a fundamental question as to whether the original seizure was justified," he said in a statement today.
Dzulkifli, the MACC's third chief commissioner, added that although the MACC Act and the Anti-Money Laundering Act (AMLA) operate under different legal frameworks, two overlapping seizure orders on the same property may be seen as an overreach of authority.
"This is because legal powers must be exercised based on necessity, fairness, and proportionality," he said.
It was reported yesterday that Ilham Tower, located on Jalan Binjai, had once again been seized by MACC.
The commission said it had obtained approval from the DPP to seize the building, which is linked to the late former finance minister Tun Daim Zainuddin.
According to the agency, the latest seizure was carried out via an Immovable Property Seizure Notice dated June 4, 2025, under Section 51(1) of the Anti-Money Laundering, Anti-Terrorism Financing and Proceeds of Unlawful Activities Act 2001 (AMLATFPUAA).
Dzulkifli said enforcement actions must be grounded in clear legal thresholds, not procedural convenience.
"If AMLA is invoked merely to maintain control of the asset as the earlier MACC order nears expiry, it may undermine the rule of law and call into question the legitimacy of the original seizure," he said.
He also noted that the absence of further action by June 18 would suggest that Ilham Tower was never genuinely linked to a corruption offence under the MACC Act.
"This raises a critical question: why is there now a need for a new seizure order under Section 51 of AMLA? What new evidence, if any, justifies this action?" he asked.
He added that the Ilham Tower case presents a significant test of how far enforcement and prosecutorial powers may be exercised within the law.
"With the June 17 deadline approaching, all eyes are on the DPP's next move. Will there be a charge? Forfeiture? Or will the order lapse - signalling that the asset was wrongly targeted from the outset?" he said.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Star
an hour ago
- The Star
Chinese students may turn to M'sia
Making the right choice: (From left) Li, Pei and Lou at the USM campus. — LIM BENG TATT/The Star GEORGE TOWN: President Donald Trump's order to tighten visa rules in the United States for students from China may benefit universities in Malaysia. Pei Qi, a 42-year-old English teacher from China who is pursuing a postgraduate degree at Universiti Sains Malaysia (USM), said he has noticed more of his students in China considering Malaysia over the US. 'Many of my students who initially planned to go to the US are now considering Malaysia for further studies. 'One of them gave up on her US application because of visa delays and uncertainty, and then applied to Monash University Malaysia and USM,' he said. Pei said that the student and her mother visited Penang and were drawn to the island's safety, lifestyle and international feel. 'They were worried about whether they could get into a public university here, but the affordability and global rankings of Malaysian institutions have prompted them to apply,' he said, adding that Malaysia's strong ties with China is an important factor. 'Malaysia takes education seriously. I see effort going into improving curriculum, research and global rankings,' Pei added. He recalled seeing China's content creators on Douyin (China's version of TikTok) mentioning that Malaysia has become the seventh most popular study abroad destination for students from China. Pei said the United States' new policy against students from China had affected the global standing of the US. 'I see real, long-term damage to America's reputation as the world's leader,' he said. 'The global landscape has changed. The US is no longer the only option for high-quality, English-medium education. 'It's sad to lose access to the US, but it's not the end of the road.' First-year Bachelor of Arts in English student Lou Xiaoxiao, 20, said studying in the US is still a dream for many from her homeland. 'It's still the top choice for a lot of us because of its academic resources and reputation. 'At the moment, I can say Malaysia is more of an option,' she said. Lou added that visa issues and parents' concerns about global tensions do play a role and more families are looking at safety and cost when making decisions. She feels that China's families are prioritising "cost-effectiveness" and "a sense of security" in their decision-making regarding their children's studies overseas. Another student, Li Hehe, 25, said despite the visa crackdown, he felt most Chinese families still hope to send their children to the US, believing strongly in the value of an American education. 'I've worked in the study abroad consultancy field. Students and parents who choose the US believe in it deeply. 'Even though the US might be the most expensive option, the choice of the US often reflects a serious commitment,' said Li, who is in his final year of a Bachelor's degree in urban and regional planning at USM. On May 28, US Secretary of State Marco Rubio confirmed that some Chinese students would have their visas revoked, especially those studying in sensitive fields or linked to the Chinese Communist Party. China is the second-largest source of international students in the US after India. More than 270,000 students from China enrolled in American institutions in the 2023–2024 academic year, about a quarter of all international students there. USM lecturer Dr Kamaruzzaman Abdul Manan, from the School of Communication, said Malaysian universities should seize the opportunity. "China sends more students abroad than any other country. Even a 10% to 15% drop in those heading to the US means thousands will look for other destinations,' he said. He added that Malaysia's strong education system and position in Asean made it an ideal choice for students from China. 'Having more students from China can raise a university's profile, attract funding and increase global partnerships,' he said.
The Star
2 hours ago
- The Star
Grappling with AI investments
MALAYSIAN companies are often said to be lagging in digital transformation, which could impact their competitiveness. The discussion gets more animated if artificial intelligence (AI) is the subject. Companies are encouraged to embrace AI as it is expected to revolutionise every aspect of business, and those that fail to adapt may face significant challenges, even closure. Billed as RM9.73 for the 1st month then RM13.90 thereafters. RM12.33/month RM8.63/month Billed as RM103.60 for the 1st year then RM148 thereafters. Free Trial For new subscribers only
The Star
2 hours ago
- The Star
Foreign crew ban not quite the catch
KLANG: The price of fish in Malaysia could see a sharp increase if the current restriction preventing Zone A and Zone B fishermen from hiring foreign crew members continues, fishing industry representatives have warned. Selangor Fishermen's Association chairman Omar Abdul Rahman said the shortage of local workers willing to work on fishing boats has left many small-scale fishermen heavily reliant on foreign labour. 'There is a high chance the industry will be adversely affected, with prices surging indiscriminately due to the lack of manpower,' he said. Omar noted that since pricing is determined by demand and supply, the reduced stock caused by fewer boats going out to sea would be a key factor in driving up prices. 'We have been constantly asking the authorities to allow Zone A and Zone B fishermen to hire foreign workers, but our pleas have gone unheard,' he added. Omar explained that Zone A vessels are traditional boats using small nets (pukat jerut bilis), while Zone B vessels are larger and use both small and trawler nets (pukat jerut and pukat tunda). Zone A boats are permitted to operate up to five nautical miles from the shore, while Zone B vessels may operate up to 12 nautical miles. 'Zone B trawlers yield the largest catch, while Zone A boats offer the best quality fish due to the type of net used,' said Omar. Currently, only Zone C vessels, which are much larger, are allowed to operate up to 30 nautical miles from the shore, including into maritime border areas. These vessels are permitted to hire foreign workers. Echoing this sentiment, Sekinchan Fishermen's Association adviser Chia Tian Hee said the restriction has forced some fishermen to resort to hiring illegal foreign workers out of desperation. When enforcement operations are conducted by the Malaysian Maritime Enforcement Agency (MMEA) or the Fisheries Department, Chia said many boats do not go out to sea, resulting in reduced catches and higher prices. Chia said while Malaysian waters are rich in fish, the dangerous nature of the job is one reason many local fishermen prefer to hire foreign workers to do the fishing. According to Selangor MMEA records, 17 Zone A and Zone B boats, owned by Malaysian fishermen but fully manned by foreigners, were detained in 2024, with seven more detained so far in 2025 for similar offences. Meanwhile, Selangor Fisheries Department director Noraisyah Abu Bakar said the restrictions on Zones A and B are based on valid and well-considered reasons. She said Zone A and Zone B boat owners must hire only local workers, as the authorities do not want to deprive Malaysians of job opportunities. 'We also have to be careful not to become overly dependent on foreign labour, as the fisheries sector is an important component of our national food security chain,' she said. Noraisyah also explained that the fishing zone system was introduced to prevent overfishing and protect marine resources. 'Fish is an important food source for our people, and we have the necessary procedures in place to ensure this resource is safeguarded,' she said. She added that when prohibitions and regulations are introduced by the Fisheries Department, they are not implemented arbitrarily. 'They are backed by extensive research and studies conducted by our Fisheries Research Institute,' she said. Noraisyah acknowledged that larger vessels in Zone C require more manpower, which is why operators are permitted to hire foreign workers in accordance with Immigration Department regulations.
