Controversial police directive saw retail crime investigations halve in some regions
Photo:
Calvin Samuel / RNZ
A former police directive to staff on retail crime thresholds has led to a significant decrease in the number of files being investigated across the country, documents released to RNZ reveal.
The directive, which has since been scrapped, told staff they would no longer be investigating allegations of retail crime below certain financial thresholds .
In the first 12 days of the directive, Wellington had the biggest shift in total number of cases going from an average of 60 per day to 30.
Auckland City had a 26 percent drop, Tasman 56 percent, Canterbury 13 percent and Southern 37 percent.
RNZ earlier revealed a directive was sent to staff relating to police's File Management Centre (FMC) titled 'Assignment Changes - Theft and Fraud'.
The directive said FMC was applying "nationally standardised value thresholds" when assessing theft and fraud files. The value thresholds were: General theft $200, petrol drive off $150, shoplifting $500, fraud (paywave, online, scam etc) $1000, and all other fraud $500.
"When assessing files with these offences, you will apply the relevant value threshold and file any file under that threshold regardless of any lines of enquiry or IFA score," it said.
Following the revelations, Police Commissioner Richard Chambers canned the directive, which he called "confusing and unhelpful" following significant backlash.
On Wednesday, a series of documents from police under the Official Information Act was released to RNZ.
The documents include an email from 7 April revealing the number of files being assigned for investigation since the rules were put in place 12 days earlier.
In the email, the police advisor said Wellington had the biggest change from an average of 60 per day to an average of 30. The numbers were being compared to baseline data over a 47-day period before the threshold was put into place.
During the same period Auckland City had a 26 percent decrease, Counties Manukau 21 percent, Eastern 38 percent, Central 42 percent and Canterbury 13 percent. Waikato had a 2.7 percent
increase, which the staffer said was due to filed being reassigned and appearing twice.
The OIA also includes a template that had been created to send to victims whose crimes did not meet the threshold.
The email thanked the victims for reporting their crime but said they "regret to advise, at this time, police is unable to investigate further".
"While we would like to resolve all matters to our victims' complete satisfaction, there are occasions where we cannot," it said.
"Investigations are prioritised using a range of factors including legal timeframes and the likelihood of a successful conviction."
The email said police appreciated this may be "frustrating and upsetting" to hear, "particularly if you reported the incident recently or provided lines of enquiry".
"We will however review your case if our ability to resolve this matter changes."
Police earlier launched a review to establish how many cases of retail crime were filed while the controversial directive was in place.
A police spokesperson earlier confirmed to RNZ the national value threshold applied to the prioritisation of lower-level theft and fraud offences was being removed.
"A review is being completed on any cases that may have been impacted by those thresholds to assess whether they should be assigned to districts for follow-up," the spokesperson said.
The review will be done by police's data quality team.
"Police want to reassure that cases will continue to be managed locally balancing demand, resources and priorities to ensure the best possible service to victims in those communities."
Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero
,
a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Otago Daily Times
a day ago
- Otago Daily Times
Staff 'responded immediately' to patient escape
By Sam Sherwood of RNZ Mental Health Minister Matt Doocey has reiterated to Health New Zealand that patient and public safety are of "paramount importance", after a man absconded from a mental health facility. Canterbury police released a statement about 9pm on Thursday appealing for information about the 35-year-old who had absconded from the care of another agency. Police had been notified about 6pm that the man was missing. They said he was dangerous and shouldn't be approached. The man was found about 10pm. RNZ understands the man absconded from Hillmorton Hospital. He was found about 6km away from the mental health facility. Health New Zealand has been approached for comment. A spokesperson for Mental Health Minister Matt Doocey told RNZ his office was advised on Thursday night about a patient leaving Hillmorton. "The Minister was advised by Health New Zealand that safety of the individual and community was at the forefront in how they responded with police." HNZ staff "responded immediately" and worked with Police to safely locate the person and return them to Hillmorton last night. "Health New Zealand is taking the incident seriously and there will be a rapid review and will take appropriate action as required. "The Minister reiterated to HNZ that patient and public safety are of paramount importance, and Health New Zealand have assured the Minister that they are taking all the necessary steps to ensure both." The incident comes three years after Hillmorton forensic mental health patient Zakariye Mohamed Hussein murdered Laisa Waka Tunidau as she walked home from work. Hussein was on community leave at the time of the killing. Two reviews were ordered, one into Hussein's care, and another looking at Canterbury District Mental Health Services. In June another Hillmorton mental health patient, Elliot Cameron was sentenced in the High Court at Christchurch to life imprisonment with a minimum term of 10 years for murdering 83-year-old Frances Anne Phelps, known as Faye in October last year. Following his sentencing a suppression order was lifted allowing RNZ to report Cameron killed his brother Jeffrey Cameron in 1975. A jury found him not guilty of murder by reason of insanity and he was detained as a special patient. Cameron was made a voluntary patient at Hillmorton Hospital in 2016, and then in October last year murdered Phelps, striking her with an axe. RNZ exclusively obtained emails from Cameron to his cousin Alan Cameron sent over more than a decade, detailing his concerns that he might kill again. In response to the revelations, Chief Victims Advisor Ruth Money said it was hard to see Phelps' death as "anything other than preventable". RNZ earlier revealed another case involving a man who was made a special patient under the Mental Health Act after his first killing was recently found not guilty of murder by reason of insanity for a second time, after killing someone he believed was possessed. After that article, Money called for a Royal Commission of Inquiry into forensic mental health facilities. After Cameron's first killing was revealed, Money said she stood by her recommendation. "The public deserves an inquiry that can give actionable expert recommendations, as opposed to multiple coroners' inquests and recommendations that do not have the same binding influence. The patients themselves, and the public will be best served by an independent inquiry, not another internal review that changes nothing."
NZ Herald
a day ago
- NZ Herald
Pest control: Ferrets enlisted in Queenstown rabbit fight
Over two days of methodical work, the ferrets managed to flush out more than 100 rabbits, which were quickly dispatched with a break of the neck. Elson said it was just another job in what had become a near non-stop string of requests since relocating their business, 'Jim's Bunny Hunters', to Queenstown. She said they took on work across farms, lifestyle blocks and commercial sites, often booked by curious locals who had seen their rabbit-laden ute. 'They'll stop and follow us into like petrol station or cafe or something, because they've seen what we've got on the ute,' she said. 'People will literally stalk you into a petrol station, saying 'I saw your licence plate. We need you.' Curry said school pick-ups were especially time-consuming because of the ferrets' popularity - and trips around the country often garnered a lot of attention. 'We're the only people licensed to transport ferrets all around New Zealand, between islands, which gets you some interesting looks on the ferries,' he said. A safer way to tackle the problem As the ferrets flush out the warrens, rabbits emerge into a fenced-off area where they're caught by detection dogs. Photo / RNZ, Katie Todd Each of the ferrets was caught from the wild, mostly by Curry. They could not be imported or bred because ferrets are classified as an 'unwanted organism' under the Biosecurity Act. While Curry and Elson were not the only ferreters in the region, they had special MPI approval to keep more than the usual limit of three ferrets. Elson said the ferrets were highly effective hunters and were a safer alternative to poison. On a recent job, she said their results eclipsed those of professional shooters. 'The commercial shooters were getting, I think they said about 900, 1000 in a year, and we got about that, including young ones, in three-and-a-half days,' she said. Jim Curry says they are the only people licensed to transport ferrets all around New Zealand. Photo / RNZ, Katie Todd 'They were getting predominantly males, whereas because we're using the ferrets to get into the holes, we're getting predominantly females with young as well. 'So it's more efficient, makes a huge difference.' Elson said they made the most of each rabbit caught. 'We can use an introduced pest to then catch other introduced pests, and then use the rabbits to give back to wildlife rescues for hawks and falcons, little owls, or other zoos. 'Whatever else isn't fed to our animals then goes to trapping programmes for wild cats, other ferrets, stoats, rats.' After each hunt, Elson and Curry filled in the rabbit holes to make sure the area was clear, then, if any rabbits remained, they would return under the cover of darkness for shooting. Curry said often the most challenging part of the operation was coaxing the ferrets back out, which were known to linger obstinately underground, despite wearing special tracking collars. 'The stubborn ones can take a bit of work to get out,' he said. A dream realised Hillary Clinton, Kamala Harris and Jacinda Ardern waiting to be deployed for work. Photo / RNZ, Katie Todd Ferrets have been a lifelong obsession for Curry, who grew up in the United Kingdom. 'I'd been reading all the Farmer's Weekly magazines and various hunting magazines and books and things about ferreting for years," he said. 'I always wanted to do it, but I didn't have the money or the knowledge or the land.' Seven years ago in Darfield, someone posted on Facebook about a chicken killer, and Curry retrieved the culprit - a ferret he dubbed Colin Farrell. Two more followed, and soon Curry was not just rescuing ferrets but putting them to work. 'I just went 'right, sod this, I've always wanted to do it,'' he said. 'I ordered some trackers and then ordered purse nets from the UK. 'It basically started with me knocking on people's doors, saying 'hi, I see you've got some rabbits. Can I come and catch them?'' The pair began in Canterbury, but Elson said it was a no-brainer when the opportunity arose to shift to rabbit-plagued Queenstown. Curry said the ferret flock had expanded to a star-studded line-up over time. 'We have Oprah Winfrey, Hillary Clinton, Kamala Harris, and Jacinda Ardern, an R Kelly, a P Diddy and a Drake. And then we have a Joe Biden,' he said. A persistent problem Jim Curry grew up in the UK and said ferrets had been a "lifelong obsession". Photo / RNZ, Katie Todd Otago Regional Council (ORC) considered rabbits one of the area's worst pests, posing a serious threat to local biodiversity, the environment and economy. Southern Lakes Sanctuary chief executive Paul Kavanagh said they were known to let other predators thrive and tore up land and ate fertile grass, with 10 rabbits devouring the equivalent of one sheep's requirements. 'In many of our ecosystems in central Otago, predator numbers are controlled by food availability,' he said. 'So where we get a lot of rabbits, we in turn get a lot of feral cats, stoats, ferrets, weasels.' He described the region's rabbit numbers as 'relatively out of control'. 'Anecdotally, we've heard it's getting worse in some areas, especially Cromwell, places like that,' he said. In 2023, the ORC discovered rabbit densities of up to 16 rabbits per square kilometre in some parts of Otago. The council said it was undertaking further rabbit night counts across the region and expected to have updated population estimates soon. Staff regularly carried out inspections across the region to identify rabbit hotspots and had helped to develop five 'community rabbit management programmes' across the region, the council said. The ORC said it could help landowners tackle their rabbit problem, but ultimately it was the landowners' or occupiers' responsibility to manage the problem. - RNZ
RNZ News
2 days ago
- RNZ News
Police monitoring hundreds of street racers in Wellington's Spotlight carpark
Police are monitoring a gathering involving hundreds of cars and people. Photo: RNZ / Mark Stevens Police are monitoring a large gathering of what RNZ understands to be street racers in Wellington. A witness said hundreds of cars and people were gathered in the Spotlight carpark on Hutt Road on Friday evening. Several police were also in attendance. Police said they were monitoring the gathering, but no issues had been reported so far.
