'No magic bullets': Can the Papua New Guinea public and the police learn to get along?
The public no longer respects the police as they did, according to a PNG police commander.
Photo:
AFP/RNZ Pacific
In recent weeks, RNZ Pacific has been looking at the issues confronting policing in Papua New Guinea.
There have long been issues of police brutality being meted out to members of the PNG public, while the Royal Papua New Guinea Constabulary faces an increasingly tough environment, underpowered, under-resourced, and underappreciated.
Recently, a PNG police commander
lamented
that the public no longer respects the police as they did when he was a young recruit.
RNZ Pacific asked security expert Professor Sinclair Dinnen from the Australian National University's Coral Bell School of Asia-Pacific Affairs, what is going on and how to turn it around.
(This transcript has been edited for brevity and clarity).
SINCLAIR DINNEN:
The first thing I would say is that none of this, unfortunately, is that terribly new.
And really, what we're seeing is a sort of continuation of a pattern of police community relations that goes back many, many years in Papua New Guinea.
It's kind of difficult to measure with any degree of accuracy. But I think popular discontent with the police in Papua New Guinea is something that has remained relatively constant, certainly over the years that, I've been looking at it.
Possibly more in the news of late with a lot more social media and other ways of capturing behaviour on the part of the police that contributes to that discontent.
DON WISEMAN: We did last week have a senior policeman in the National Capital District speaking out about the very large number, as he saw it, of people appearing, this was just in the Boroko District Court on charges of attacks on police or refusing arrest or whatever. Nine, I think it was, in one week, and he said that this would not have happened when he began as a policeman many years ago.
SD:
Or perhaps they wouldn't have been arrested. I mean, who knows what lies behind that particular increase in one court in Port Moresby.
But the larger picture is one of a kind of police force that has never really, in recent times, had the kind of support that it needs from the community in order to do its job.
Policing in Papua New Guinea and in a kind of democratic setting, to a large extent, depends on consent. And I think what we've seen over many years, is a fraying of that consent. Some of which can be attributed to behaviour on the part of the police itself. Others probably relate to the fairly violent context in which many people find themselves living in in PNG.
There are a lot of sort of social stresses, or a lot of pressures that have manifested in violent behaviour. If anything, those sorts of issues, which are usually talked about as law and order problems, have increased, and that's placed great pressure on the police, but also great pressure on the people in the broader community and their expectations of the police to be able to assist them to do something about it.
Police are simply not in a position to help out in many respects. The police are very thin on the ground. Their numbers have not really increased significantly since independence, despite the fact that the overall population has more than trebled.
There are a lot more issues, such as the availability of firearms and the use of those firearms for defensive purposes, for criminal purposes, in the context of sort of tribal conflicts, in the context of election related activities, the environment, the context of policing, has changed quite dramatically over the years.
And if anything, that's placed more challenges on the police as well as the wider public, but the police have not been particularly well equipped in order to deal with those. There's a lot of disappointment and frustration in the broader public with the limitations of policing.
Against that background, we've seen a massive growth of private security. Private security guards probably outnumber the combined numbers in the police and the Defence Force and the Correctional Services - PNG's three disciplined forces.
Whenever you go to Papua New Guinea, the first thing you see are security, private security everywhere. That is one indication of kind of discontent with the police and looking for other options in terms of security.
But of course, private security is only available to those who can afford it.
A police landcruiser patrols the streets of the Papua New Guinea capital Port Moresby.
Photo:
RNZ Pacific/ Koroi Hawkins
DW: You've touched on a few of the things that need to happen. But this is not a situation that can be allowed to continue, if the country's going to advance and prosper. So what can be done to turn it round?
SD:
Well, if there were any magic bullets or quick fixes, I'm sure they would have been tried by now.
As you're well aware, donors, traditional partners, including New Zealand and significantly Australia, have been working with the RPNGC over many years.
In the case of Australia, really going back to the 1980s, with significant sort of inputs in terms of attempts to improve the efficacy of the RPNGC, often talked about in terms of capacity.
DW: Has that actually achieved anything?
SD:
It's a very good question. In some areas, it may have done. But overall, the results are really quite difficult to discern, perhaps. I should say that that is not unique to PNG.
What's often referred to as police building where external police forces try to help develop the capacity of a domestic police actor, have not been that successful, really, anywhere, although in many places have been more successful than PNG.
But it's not a it's not a simple sort of process. So that's one thing. I think what it's possibly done is provide technical assistance in certain areas where that sort of technical assistance was not available. But in terms of applying it on the ground, it's a very difficult situation for PNG police to operate in, and potentially a very dangerous environment as well.
Police don't feel that they're particularly well looked after by government and so on. We, in fact, saw at the beginning of 2024 what was in effect a police strike, which led to widespread looting, especially in Port Moresby, but also in some other places.
There's a lot of discontent and grievance within the police. If you want to put that another way: if you don't have high morale amongst your police, or a certain level of morale, that in itself, is a kind of recipe for police misbehaviour or underperformance, or whatever you want to call it.
I think there are issues about, putting it fairly blandly, that often you end up with a police force you deserve, and if the police force are not looked after in terms of their conditions and other things that can contribute to the kind of problems that we're talking about today.
But of course, that's not the only factor at play. I did mention there the pretty extraordinary law and order environment in which the police are expected to operate.
If you just take the Highlands, for example, where in effect, you have these small wars being conducted with high powered military firearms, even nowadays the use of drones, but really high powered guns, mercenaries being employed by different groups to fight in these things.
What would the New Zealand police do in a situation like that? That is not a kind of traditional policing environment, and yet, the PNG police force are expected to operate across all these different environments with pretty minimal resources.
I think we need to spend a little bit more time trying to understand this context in which this lack of improvement and in many respects, backward movement, of deterioration, is taking place.
There are lots of very complex factors at play here, some of them within the institution of the police themselves, but many of them also to do with the larger environment in which they're operating.
DW: We know the force is ridiculously small. How big should it be? Do you think now if the population is 10 or 11 million?
SD:
The UN has a recommended police to population ratio of, you know, one police officer to every 450 people. Well, the sort of figure, insofar as we can estimate, and the figures are always very wobbly in PNG, is one police officer to over 1145 people.
Now that's a an aggregate figure. It doesn't tell us about the dispersal of the police, their distribution. There are many parts of Papua New Guinea where that figure is likely to be much, much higher. It may be very difficult to find any police in certain parts. They tend to be concentrated in urban areas, whereas a large majority of Papua New Guineans live in rural areas.
A lot of the sort of conflict and the violence that we see in parts of rural areas like the Highlands essentially resort to self help policing in the absence of state policing.
The actual distribution of the police in a place like Papua New Guinea is also a big issue. Not just the numbers of police available, it's how they are allocated.
So again, these are not new issues, Don, they've been around forever, and there's been endless sort of commitments to, you know, increasing the size of the police.
I think under the current government, they're hoping to add another 10,000 police officers onto what is probably about 6,500 sworn officers at the moment. We're not absolutely certain, but that's probably the figure.
DW: They've [the Marape Government has] added almost none.
SD:
Yeah, yeah. We've been hearing politicians talking about this forever. Each administration says, Oh no, we're going to double the number of police. We're going to do this. We're going to do that. But nothing really eventuates.
DW: It's two years out from the next election. The last two election cycles have been the two most violent to date. It doesn't augur well for the next one, does it? Can anything be done between now and the election in two years time to improve the prospects of a more secure election?
SD:
I think it's not a new issue and it is the sort of situation that has been getting progressively worse, certainly in some parts of the country. But problems that initially were sort of viewed as being largely confined to certain areas. Notably, election related violence in the Highlands seems to have spread to some other parts.
In the last election we saw election related violence in the National Capital District, essentially Port Moresby, so it tends to sort of travel. There's really two ways of looking at that. One is how to improve the kind of security operation that goes on around elections.
And there is a big, always a big emphasis on a sort of major security operation, which includes the police. But also includes the Defence Force, and includes the Correctional Services, those arms of the three discipline services that I mentioned earlier on.
So they work together, and they sort of travel around, in accordance with the kind of voting which takes place in different places at different times. A massive exercise, a very expensive exercise where a lot of the kind of movement has to take place by air because of the lack of roads in some rural areas. So that massive operation, can it be more effective?
A lot of the kind of conflict occurs, when the security operation has moved on to the next place. This conflict will erupt after they have gone. They can't be everywhere at one time. Can a security operation like that be improved? Of course, it can be improved.
I'm sure there are people sitting down already beginning to plan the next operation, and you know what lessons were learned from the last one? But the second, probably even more critical issue to consider, Don, is what is leading to the kind of violent conflict that we see increasing in the electoral context, guns is one issue, the widespread availability of these high powered weapons.
Where are they coming from? Who's distributing them, who's buying them, where's the ammunition coming from? All those sort of things have to be looked at. In addition, many people would suspect that political players are involved in stirring up these sorts of conflicts for their electoral advantage.
Politics is really the main game, the primacy of politics in Papua New Guinea speaks to the fact that getting into political office is the way to access resources. There are few alternatives to that. There isn't a massive private sector as such. The private sector that does exist, obviously, in the resource development side of things, is largely owned by multinationals and operated by multinationals.
It is not necessarily open to Papua New Guineans, and we're talking about really high levels of poverty and increasing levels of poverty in many parts of the country, growing inequalities and grievances. So the expectations by people of their elected members is going up and up and up and up.
People really expect, their sole expectations, of being able to access services and development, rely on them getting their person up in the election. And so the disappointment about not succeeding in that class that also contributes to the sort of conflict.
The stakes in electoral competition are increasing, and that's a kind of reflection of the political economy in PNG, where so much depends on, you know, having your member in office looking after your community, or being able to access resources and bring them back home.
So that kind of politics is a massive issue, and again, a very complex one for which there are no magic bullets.
But I mean electoral reform and other areas are really required, other kind of measures are really required in trying to address that broader issue, to try and reduce the stakes, if you like, what's happened over many years is that service delivery has been increasingly taken over by individual Members of Parliament who now have access to large amounts of what used to be called discretionary funds.
These funds are taken away from bureaucratic service delivery. The sort of public service providers service delivery is going down as the money is taken away. It is increasingly individual members of parliament who provide those services by using their discretionary funds to that effect.
So, that increases their importance in the eyes of their constituents, which increases the extraordinary competitiveness of elections and the very high stakes that are involved, and that's the kind of context of electoral violence.
Hashtags

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


Scoop
an hour ago
- Scoop
More Deaths Reported Out Of West Papua Clashes
Article – RNZ Further reports of civilian casualties are coming out of West Papua, while clashes between Indonesia's military and the armed wing of the Free Papua Movement continue. Caleb Fotheringham, RNZ Pacific Journalist Further reports of civilian casualties are coming out of West Papua, while clashes between Indonesia's military and the armed wing of the Free Papua Movement continue. One of the most recent military operations took place in the early morning of 14 May in Sugapa District, Intan Jaya in Central Papua. Military spokesperson Lieutenant Colonel Iwan Dwi Prihartono, in a video statement translated into English, said 18 members of the West Papua National Liberation Army (TPNPB) were killed. He claimed the military wanted to provide health services and education to residents in villages in Intan Jaya but they were confronted by the TPNPB. Prihartono said the military confiscated an AK47, homemade weapons, ammunition, bows and arrows and the morning star flag – used as a symbol for West Papuan independence. But, according to the TPNPB, only three of the group's soldiers were killed with the rest being civilians. The United Liberation Movement for West Papua said civilians killed included a 75-year-old, two women and a child. Both the women were allegedly found on 23 May in shallow graves. A spokesperson from the Embassy of Indonesia in Wellington said all 18 people killed were part of the TPNPB, as confirmed by the military. 'The local regent of Intan Jaya has checked for the victims at their home and hospitals; therefore, he can confirm that the 18 victims were in fact all members of the armed criminal group,' they said. 'The difference in numbers of victim sometimes happens because the armed criminal group tried to downplay their casualties or to try to create confusion.' The spokesperson said the military operation was carried out because local authorities 'followed up upon complaints and reports from local communities that were terrified and terrorized by the armed criminal group'. Jakarta-based Human Rights Watch researcher Andreas Harsono said it was part of the wider, Operation Habema which started last year. 'It is a military operation to 'eliminate' the Free Papua guerilla fighters, not only in Intan Jaya but in several agencies along the central highlands,' Harsono said. He said it's been intensifying since the TPNPB killed 17 miners in April, which the armed group accused of being 'military informers'. RNZ Pacific has been sent photos of people who have been allegedly killed or injured in the 14 May assault, while others have been shared by ULMWP. Harsono said despite the photos and videos it's hard to verify if civilians had been killed. He said Indonesia claimed civilian casualties – including of the women who were allegedly buried in shallow graves – were a result of the TPNPB. 'The TPNPB says, 'of course, it is a lie why should we kill an indigenous woman?' Well, you know, it is difficult to verify which one is correct, because they're fighting the battle [in a very remote area]. 'It's difficult to cross-check whatever information coming from there, including the fact that it is difficult to get big videos or big photos from the area with the metadata.' Harsono said Indonesia is now using drones to fight the TPNPB. 'This is something new; I think it will change the security situation, the battle situation in West Papua. 'So far the TPNPB has not used drones; they are still struggling. In fact, most of them are still using bows and arrows in the conflict with the Indonesian military.'


Scoop
an hour ago
- Scoop
Macron Talks New Caledonia At Pacific-France Summit
Article – RNZ Macron dedicated a significant part of his address to the situation in New Caledonia. , Correspondent French Pacific Desk French president Emmanuel Macron chaired a Pacific-France summit on Tuesday, in the margins of the UN Ocean Conference (UNOC) held in Nice. In his opening speech, the French head of state touched on several aspects of France's cooperation in the Pacific region, including in terms of environment, defence and geostrategy. €2 million Euros for Pacific Forum's Resilient Facility Pledging to maintain France's diplomacy 'in very close connection with our common interests in the Pacific', including the recent opening of a new Embassy in Apia, Samoa, Macron acknowledged the 'central' role played by the Pacific Islands Forum, which will receive about €2 million Euros as a contribution to the Pacific Resilient Facility fund for the region. He also mentioned the opening of a project to introduce new air links connecting French Polynesia, the Cook Islands, Fiji, Tonga and Samoa. He also touched on France-Pacific cooperation at 'strategic and military' levels, through a recently-created 'Pacific Academy' and regular joint regional exercises in order to foster 'common credibility to protect our zones and fight against illegal fishing'. High on the agenda were key issues such as climate change and its adverse effects on Pacific Island states on human lives and biodiversity, natural disasters affecting the region, breaches of sovereignty and security resulting from illegal fishing, and trans-regional crime, especially the rising problem of drug trafficking. In terms of regional maritime security and fight against criminality, especially illegal, unreported and unregulated fishing (IUU), France, but also Australia and New Zealand Navys are regularly contributing to patrols in the Pacific Islands Forum's Fisheries Agency (FFA) member states' exclusive economic zones (EEZs). Significant part dedicated to New Caledonia Macron dedicated a significant part of his address to the situation in New Caledonia, one year after the deadly riots that broke out in May 2024 (causing 14 deaths and and estimated €2.2 billion Euros in damages). He told Pacific leaders he was aware of Pacific concerns about 'the events that destabilized New Caledonia a year ago '. 'I want to tell you here… The French state has respected its commitments made decades ago by organizing in recent years three referendums with United Nations observers which were validated and noted. 'But a year ago, violence broke out, triggered by several factors… which we took very seriously.' Macron said since then, France has unlocked 'more than €3 billion Euros' for New Caledonia's economic reconstruction. 'And we have spared no effort with the government, in particular the Minister of State [Minister for Overseas Manuel Valls] to restore dialogue between all parties.' Since February Valls has managed to bring all of New Caledonia's political camps around the same table, something that had not happened since 2022. But the proposal he put on the table in early May, during a behind-closed-doors 'conclave', drew ire from parties in favour of New Caledonia remaining a part of France. They objected, saying Valls' project failed to take into account that the three recent referendums had expressed a rejection of independence and that the Minister's 'sovereignty with France' offer (including transfer of key powers from France to New Caledonia, a dual Kanaky-France citizenship and an international standing) was tantamount to some form of independence which they strongly objected to. A 'new project' on the table in July? On discussions about a resumption of talks to find a bipartisan and comprehensive agreement on the French Pacific territory's future political status, Macron also confirmed that he will 'hold a summit in Paris in the coming weeks to bring together all stakeholders again and manage to come up with a new project'. Macron said after holding three referendums between 2018 and 2021 on New Caledonia's sovereignty, he was not in favour of holding yet another one. 'I must say I honestly believe Pacific, Oceanian or Melanesian cultures are more based on consultation and circularity, not really suited for referendums …whereby you're supposed to express a clearcut yes or no.' We won't make the same mistakes again 'We will not make the same mistakes again in the future,' Macron told Pacific islands leaders, including those from the three French Pacific territories of New Caledonia, French Polynesia and Wallis and Futuna. He said building a political solution for New Caledonia was still work in progress 'with a lot of humility, together'. And in this process, he told regional leaders 'we welcome your advice' and 'recommendations'. He mentioned and thanked Pacific Islands Forum leaders for a fact-finding mission that travelled to New Caledonia in late 2024 and gave rise to 'very productive exchanges'. 'We will do all we can to succeed and I am confident we'll do it with respect for everyone and for all (New) Caledonians, for peace, unity and stability in the region. 'But we are trying to hold this dialogue while respecting the various opinions and the principles of democracy.' During the same Pacific-France summit, Macron also held talks with leaders from Papua New Guinea, Palau, Samoa, Tonga, Fiji, Marshall Islands, Kiribati, the Federated States of Micronesia, Solomon Islands and Vanuatu. The Pacific Islands Forum delegation was headed by its secretary-general Baron Waqa.


Scoop
3 hours ago
- Scoop
Macron Talks New Caledonia At Pacific-France Summit
Article – RNZ Macron dedicated a significant part of his address to the situation in New Caledonia. , Correspondent French Pacific Desk French president Emmanuel Macron chaired a Pacific-France summit on Tuesday, in the margins of the UN Ocean Conference (UNOC) held in Nice. In his opening speech, the French head of state touched on several aspects of France's cooperation in the Pacific region, including in terms of environment, defence and geostrategy. €2 million Euros for Pacific Forum's Resilient Facility Pledging to maintain France's diplomacy 'in very close connection with our common interests in the Pacific', including the recent opening of a new Embassy in Apia, Samoa, Macron acknowledged the 'central' role played by the Pacific Islands Forum, which will receive about €2 million Euros as a contribution to the Pacific Resilient Facility fund for the region. He also mentioned the opening of a project to introduce new air links connecting French Polynesia, the Cook Islands, Fiji, Tonga and Samoa. He also touched on France-Pacific cooperation at 'strategic and military' levels, through a recently-created 'Pacific Academy' and regular joint regional exercises in order to foster 'common credibility to protect our zones and fight against illegal fishing'. High on the agenda were key issues such as climate change and its adverse effects on Pacific Island states on human lives and biodiversity, natural disasters affecting the region, breaches of sovereignty and security resulting from illegal fishing, and trans-regional crime, especially the rising problem of drug trafficking. In terms of regional maritime security and fight against criminality, especially illegal, unreported and unregulated fishing (IUU), France, but also Australia and New Zealand Navys are regularly contributing to patrols in the Pacific Islands Forum's Fisheries Agency (FFA) member states' exclusive economic zones (EEZs). Significant part dedicated to New Caledonia Macron dedicated a significant part of his address to the situation in New Caledonia, one year after the deadly riots that broke out in May 2024 (causing 14 deaths and and estimated €2.2 billion Euros in damages). He told Pacific leaders he was aware of Pacific concerns about 'the events that destabilized New Caledonia a year ago '. 'I want to tell you here… The French state has respected its commitments made decades ago by organizing in recent years three referendums with United Nations observers which were validated and noted. 'But a year ago, violence broke out, triggered by several factors… which we took very seriously.' Macron said since then, France has unlocked 'more than €3 billion Euros' for New Caledonia's economic reconstruction. 'And we have spared no effort with the government, in particular the Minister of State [Minister for Overseas Manuel Valls] to restore dialogue between all parties.' Since February Valls has managed to bring all of New Caledonia's political camps around the same table, something that had not happened since 2022. But the proposal he put on the table in early May, during a behind-closed-doors 'conclave', drew ire from parties in favour of New Caledonia remaining a part of France. They objected, saying Valls' project failed to take into account that the three recent referendums had expressed a rejection of independence and that the Minister's 'sovereignty with France' offer (including transfer of key powers from France to New Caledonia, a dual Kanaky-France citizenship and an international standing) was tantamount to some form of independence which they strongly objected to. A 'new project' on the table in July? On discussions about a resumption of talks to find a bipartisan and comprehensive agreement on the French Pacific territory's future political status, Macron also confirmed that he will 'hold a summit in Paris in the coming weeks to bring together all stakeholders again and manage to come up with a new project'. Macron said after holding three referendums between 2018 and 2021 on New Caledonia's sovereignty, he was not in favour of holding yet another one. 'I must say I honestly believe Pacific, Oceanian or Melanesian cultures are more based on consultation and circularity, not really suited for referendums …whereby you're supposed to express a clearcut yes or no.' We won't make the same mistakes again 'We will not make the same mistakes again in the future,' Macron told Pacific islands leaders, including those from the three French Pacific territories of New Caledonia, French Polynesia and Wallis and Futuna. He said building a political solution for New Caledonia was still work in progress 'with a lot of humility, together'. And in this process, he told regional leaders 'we welcome your advice' and 'recommendations'. He mentioned and thanked Pacific Islands Forum leaders for a fact-finding mission that travelled to New Caledonia in late 2024 and gave rise to 'very productive exchanges'. 'We will do all we can to succeed and I am confident we'll do it with respect for everyone and for all (New) Caledonians, for peace, unity and stability in the region. 'But we are trying to hold this dialogue while respecting the various opinions and the principles of democracy.' During the same Pacific-France summit, Macron also held talks with leaders from Papua New Guinea, Palau, Samoa, Tonga, Fiji, Marshall Islands, Kiribati, the Federated States of Micronesia, Solomon Islands and Vanuatu. The Pacific Islands Forum delegation was headed by its secretary-general Baron Waqa.