‘Eddington' review: Joaquin Phoenix and Pedro Pascal, once upon an early COVID time in the West
This summer, in 2025, history can barely contain each new 24-hour blurt. It feels less like we're in history and more like we're choking on it. So we remember Shakespeare's perfect three syllables to describe dark political machinations. 'Out of joint,' Hamlet says of his country and his time. Like a dislocated shoulder.
Ari Aster's 'Eddington' is not Shakespeare, and isn't trying, and half the time it can't be said to know what it's doing, or how to dramatize what it's going for. But I've seen it twice for the good stuff, and for the riddle-solving of why whole, frustrating chunks of this two-and-a-half-hour American fable compete with the rest of it.
Aster has taken on one of the toughest challenges a writer-director can attempt: extremely recent history, out of joint and somehow present, not past. 'Eddington' is set in May 2020, three months into the COVID-19 pandemic, in a part of the world where personal freedoms trump the common good — which is another way of saying there's a lot of unmasked transmitters around town.
Joaquin Phoenix takes the role of Joe Cross, sheriff of the (fictional) New Mexico town of Eddington. Part blunt-force satire, part topical, state-of-the-nation drama, 'Eddington' is also a Western, an early COVID-era Western at that, with the sheriff — a foolish mediocrity and the son-in-law of the previous sheriff, now deceased — squaring off against the town's mayor Ted Garcia, a crafty operator played by Pedro Pascal.
Garcia, running for re-election, backs a controversial 'data center' construction project, which threatens to cripple the region's already drought-prone water supply. The First Nation tribal residents of this corner of New Mexico are fighting this development. Even without it, Sheriff Cross has unrelated and unresolvable issues with Mayor Garcia; years earlier Garcia may have had some sort of relationship with Louise (Emma Stone, underused, to say the least), now the sheriff's wife. The sexual trauma in Louise's past, and her present, rickety state, is something her husband does not have the emotional resources to confront.
Both Eddington and 'Eddington' trade in soap opera-y secrets and subterranean conspiracies involving dirty law enforcement, incest, male sexual jealousy, good lawmen getting shafted, a small clutch Eddington's young Black Lives Matter protesters spouting newly acquired racial reckoning verbiage they barely comprehend, and so much more. In the immediate wake of the George Floyd murder in Minneapolis, things are getting hot all over. Eddington does not know how to deal with its present historical moment.
Unhelpfully for 'Eddington,' the movie, Aster responds to the question of 'how to wrap this thing up?' with a wildly florid action climax. This pits the sheriff against anonymous killers, Eastwood style, but with pesky drones and shadowy corporate interests raising the stakes. The last 30 minutes of the film feel almost completely misjudged, and absurd, but not satirically effective; it's just a dive into adolescent Tarantino ultraviolence.
But getting there, 'Eddington' is none of those things. It's particularly astute in Aster's little details and flurries of early COVID. Sheriff Cross isn't really having the whole masking thing, and Phoenix wisely keeps the character's bullheadedness realistic, not exaggerated. When the story begins, COVID has yet to officially arrive in Eddington. The pandemic is like the Black Lives Matter protests and the national violence so often flashed on TV screens and laptops; it's 'not a 'here' problem,' Cross says, partly to reassuring his own crumbling confidence.
The filmmaker gave us the punishing family nightmare 'Hereditary,' the 'Wicker Man' riff 'Midsommar' and the half-wondrous, half-exasperating dreamlike odyssey 'Beau is Afraid.' With 'Eddington,' Aster has made a distinct period piece, nailing many woeful details about where we were five years ago. And where we are now. Too few American movies, ever, have caught current history successfully. And as London-based critic Damon Wise wrote about 'Eddington' in its Cannes Film Festival premiere earlier this year: 'How do you make a satirical movie about modern America when the news that comes out of there every day is quite literally beyond a joke?'
This is the peculiar thing about 'Eddington': At Cannes, it apparently played like sledgehammer satire of both idiot conservatives and ridiculous, self-loathing liberals, and it still does, I suppose. Yet it's hitting differently now. When Aster lays off the easy comic despair in favor of more ambiguous and dimensional feelings, interactions and moments, 'Eddington' becomes the movie he wanted. His script has a million problems with clarity, coincidence and the nagging drag of a protagonist set up for a long, grisly comeuppance, yet 'Eddington' is probably Aster's strongest film visually, with cinematographer Darius Khondji creating the light and shadow for some sweeping, gently ironic evocations of Old West and Old Hollywood myth-making.
The myths this time are not reassuring. 'Eddington' will probably age rather well — even, and perhaps especially, if Aster's explicit anticipation of martial law as America's next great experiment proves accurate.
'Eddington' — 3 stars (out of 4)
MPA rating: R (for strong violence, some grisly images, language, and graphic nudity)
Running time: 2:25
How to watch: Premieres in theaters July 18
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Newsweek
5 minutes ago
- Newsweek
Jason Momoa's "Chief of War" Is a Polynesian Cultural Moment
It's not every day that Hollywood hands the keys to an epic, large-scale historical drama over to an Indigenous creative team, but with Apple TV+'s Chief of War, Jason Momoa and Thomas Pa'a Sibbett seized their opportunity and built a breathtaking cultural monument. The sweeping nine-episode saga, premiering August 1, centers on the unification of the Hawaiian islands at the turn of the 18th century, an era fraught with tribal warfare, political upheaval and the looming threat of Western colonization. At its heart, Chief of War is more than a story about battles won or lost. It's a reclamation of cultural identity, told through the eyes of Polynesian people by Polynesian people, in their language. "It's mind-blowing to be able to tell this incredible story of my ancestors and to do it with an amazing cast and brilliant team behind the camera," Momoa says in the show's production notes. "Ka'iana knew what was coming from the outside world. He was fearless, devoted, a visionary. His journey is full of action, drama, and romance—but it's ultimately about love for his people." Ka'iana (Momoa) is a complex figure in Hawaiian history who has been both celebrated and condemned by historians for his shifting allegiances in the tumultuous years before unification. In Chief of War, Ka'iana is portrayed as a man struggling between tradition, ambition and survival in the face of rapid change. A former war chief returning home after years abroad, he finds himself caught between competing chiefs, colonial powers and his own internal battles with loyalty and legacy. Jason Momoa as Ka'iana in new series "Chief of War," which he co-created. Jason Momoa as Ka'iana in new series "Chief of War," which he co-created. Nicola Dove/AppleTV Cultural Deep Dive While Ka'iana's personal journey drives much of the drama, the larger narrative belongs to King Kamehameha, played by Kaina Makua. The series traces Kamehameha's mission to unify the islands of Hawai'i, Maui, O'ahu and Kaua'i under one rule—an unprecedented political and spiritual undertaking that would forever alter the destiny of the Pacific. Kamehameha's campaign is not depicted as a straightforward military conquest; it's complicated by fractured alliances, internal betrayals and the weight of prophecy. Through this lens, Chief of War offers a rare glimpse into a chapter of history often overlooked by Western media. It dives deep into the customs, hierarchies and belief systems that shaped precolonial Hawai'i, with a particular emphasis on the role of women, spiritual leaders and the sacred ties to the land and sea. For Temuera Morrison, who plays cunning King Kahekili of Maui, bringing this story to life required tapping into something deeper than craft. "I had to draw on thunder and lightning for my performance," he says. "I wanted to bring a little bit of what Polynesians call that inner power—that essence, that scariness. Fortunately, we're trained in Māori haka. Haka—if you break it down—'ha' is the breath, 'ka' is the fire. We needed a lot of that in this epic." Morrison credits the trust placed in him by Momoa and the writers. "When they said 'action,' it was our time to ignite ourselves and do the best we possibly could," he adds. Prince Kupule, right, played by Brandon Finn. Prince Kupule, right, played by Brandon Finn. Nicola Dove/AppleTV Cliff Curtis, who plays King Kamehameha's rival chief Keoua, also stepped in as a co-producer, helping to shepherd the series through the complex cultural protocols of filming across Polynesia. "What's unique about the series is that it's been written, directed, produced by Hawaiians, by Jason and Thomas Pa'a Sibbett, and drawn from their ancestral stories," Curtis says. "We filmed a large segment in Aotearoa [New Zealand], and it was important to honor the tribes of those lands. I was proud to help lead that process—acknowledging the many tribal boundaries where we worked, engaging with about 25 different tribes." That reverence extended far beyond location agreements. Morrison shares how the production functioned on multiple cultural levels. "We'd stamp our feet to connect to Mother Earth. We'd say prayers to connect us to the heavens above. We're just manifestations of that energy," he says. "So when it came time to work, we brought that energy with us." For Makua, a cultural practitioner and taro farmer from Kaua'i, stepping into the role of King Kamehameha required some persuasion. "I wasn't looking to be an actor," he says. "My purpose is with our youth, grounding them in farming, in culture, every day." Initially, Makua gave Momoa's offer a polite brush-off. "But after prayer, talking to our elders, I came to the decision. I was told, 'If not you, then who?' So I tried my best to fill the shoes of Kamehameha." On set in Aotearoa, he made a point of speaking only 'Ōlelo Hawai'i—the Hawaiian language—whenever possible. "It helped the other actors get comfortable, get accustomed to the language. It made it easier for them to do them, on set." 'Part of Something Special' Language is a central pillar of Chief of War. Much of the series is performed entirely in 'Ōlelo Hawai'i, a remarkable choice in a global television landscape often driven by English-first storytelling. "One of the privileges we had was, I didn't speak one word of English in the whole series," Curtis says. "It made me feel like I was part of something special. We're connected to our ancestors and our descendants, and this is for them—to give future generations a remnant of their culture to look upon and celebrate their own language in the way we've tried to portray them." Authenticity ripples through Chief of War, from handcrafted kapa garments and feathered capes to the precise recreation of 18th-century Hawaiian villages. The commitment to accuracy extended to collaboration with Hawaiian cultural practitioners and language supervisors on set. As Morrison says, "It all goes back to the script. It's written with care, and it's our job to interpret it with as much integrity as possible." Moses Goods, who portrays Moku—Kamehameha's adviser and father to Ka'ahumanu—says that the depth of cultural nuance in the storytelling only enriched his performance. "That's what an actor wants, right? Roles that are complex and layered, full of conflicting emotions," he says. "Moku is navigating the new world coming to them while trying to balance that with their gods and traditions. At the same time, he's marrying off his daughter. It's all of these things kind of jumbled up inside of me. That just makes for a much more interesting and complex character to watch and portray." That dynamic plays out powerfully in one of Ka'ahumanu's most pivotal moments: her encounter with the prophetess who reveals a heavy destiny. For Luciane Buchanan, who plays the future queen, this doesn't just shape her path—it deepens her connection to her father. "It creates a secret between them that carries through the series," Buchanan says. "How they're going to make it work, they don't know, but they know they'll face it together." Te Ao o Hinepehinga, who plays Kupuohi, described the cultural advisers on the production as the voices of the characters. Te Ao o Hinepehinga, who plays Kupuohi, described the cultural advisers on the production as the voices of the characters. Nicola Dove/AppleTV Buchanan's portrayal captures the weight of inherited responsibility and the quiet resilience of women navigating a world of powerful men. The shared sense of Pacific connection was palpable across the production, particularly among the women. Buchanan and Te Ao o Hinepehinga, who portrays Kupuohi, both spoke of the strength they drew from the women guiding them, both on set and in spirit. "We're very privileged in Polynesia to be raised by strong women," Hinepehinga says. "My greatest inspiration was my language coach. She and the other cultural advisors weren't just teaching us the language—they were the voices of these characters. We were just the mouthpieces." Buchanan agrees. "They really helped, but they didn't override our performances. They would ask, 'How do you want to do it?' It felt collaborative, empowering." Her connection to Ka'ahumanu deepened with a pilgrimage to the queen's birthplace in Maui before filming. "It was a very beautiful moment. It kind of set me up to bring that intention, to physically see a place where she had been. Those moments are rare in this industry." Both actresses emphasized the unique challenge and reward of portraying women whose power isn't always wielded through physical strength, but through strategy, influence and quiet resilience. "These women aren't just strong; they're the silent leaders, the unsung heroes," says Hinepehinga. "The show shines a light on that. I hope women watching feel empowered to continue that work." Deep Connections That spirit of unity extends beyond the screen. Goods reflects on how Chief of War subtly reframes our understanding of Polynesia itself. "We call it the blue continent. The water isn't a barrier—it's a highway that connected us. There was a time when we traveled freely between islands and our languages, our customs, our stories were shared. This show reminds us of that connection." It's a connection Momoa felt deeply. "When people come from far and wide to Hawai'i, they fall in love with it because there's something special—it's an umbilical cord to the center of the Earth," he says. "But many people have no idea of our history." With Chief of War, that history has been given the platform it deserves: one paddled forward not just by its creators, but by generations who came before and those still to come.
New York Times
5 minutes ago
- New York Times
Free Shakespeare's Central Park Home Gets an $85 Million Glow Up
After an 18-month, $85 million overhaul, the Delacorte Theater reopens next month with a starry new version of 'Twelfth Night.' I'll leave it to playgoers and critics to deliver their verdicts on the production. I'm happy to report, in the meantime, that the renovation deftly fixes much of what ailed the city's beloved home of free Shakespeare in Central Park. It was on its last legs before it was shuttered. Built during the Kennedy era for the current price of a two-bedroom condo in Fort Lee, N.J., the Delacorte from Day One was a glorified, rickety high-school grandstand, with water leaking into ramshackle dressing rooms and raccoons nesting backstage. Watching great actors and directors put on 'Hamlet' there was roughly akin to consuming truffled langoustine on the L train. The modesty was part of its charm. Like the park, it spoke to the city's egalitarian soul and cultural ambition. Its makeover is the latest change to a park that has recently undergone, or is considering, a variety of alterations, which include the opening of the excellent Davis Center in Harlem, plans to revamp Wollman Rink and a proposal by the Metropolitan Museum to replace an old wing with a new one, a stone's throw from the Delacorte. It may seem odd to think of Central Park as a work in progress. It can come across as a grand relic from another century. But this middle stretch of the park in particular, which includes the Delacorte, has undergone a surprising number of upheavals over the past 200-odd years that mirror changes across the city. Want all of The Times? Subscribe.
Miami Herald
34 minutes ago
- Miami Herald
Celebrate go-go music at this annual event that takes over Miami this weekend
The culture and sounds of Washington, D.C.'s go-go music will fill South Florida this weekend as Miami Takeover returns to Miami Beach. Now in its 17th year, the four-day event includes a comedy show at the Hard Rock Cafe in downtown Miami, pool parties, an all-white party at Urban, and two community service events. The event is expected to draw more than 2,000 people and was founded by two Florida A&M University graduates and friends, Wiley Kynard and Antwoine McCoy. The festival began in 2007 as a going away party for Kynard, who had been offered a job in his native D.C. after having worked in Miami for about 10 years, McCoy told the Miami Herald. They brought the party back again in 2008 and every year since, excluding 2020 during the COVID-19 pandemic. McCoy said along the way they added in a third business partner Vincent Peden. It's main event, The Art of Go-Go Culture and Art Fest, will feature a bevy of D.C. go-go performers which include the Black Passion Band, Top 5 Band, and the legendary Junkyard Band, who recently performed on Amerie's NPR Tiny Desk concert. The cornerstone event, held on Saturday, will also feature visual artists from D.C. and Miami, and will pay homage to the 50th anniversary of the go-go sound, a subgenre of funk that incorporates call and response. McCoy said showcasing go-go in Miami was a way to put the music on a national platform outside of D.C. 'We still want to also put go-go on a national platform to show that it is great music, that a lot of times it's something that has to be digested live,' McCoy said. 'You got to see the energy. You got to see the enthusiasm of not just the crowd, but also the performers as well.' McCoy, 48, said that the featured performers are established musicians in their own right and that Top5, one of the bands performing, worked for Mary J. Blige after she heard them providing back up for another band. 'One thing led to another, and she was on tour with them,' he said. 'A lot of the band members work with major artists, whether it's keyboard players, bass players, or drummers.' Beyond the parties and music, McCoy said the Takeover hosts two community service events, a beach clean up and free dental cleanings to children under 12 years old. Though he lives in D.C., McCoy feels an affinity for South Florida. 'I've been coming down to Miami and going to the beaches for as long as I can remember,' said McCoy, who was raised near the D.C. area but grew up visiting family in the Miami Gardens area during summers. The event helps visitors have a more personal experience in Miami, said McCoy. 'We wanted to show people the city through the eyes of locals who could really move around Miami.' IF YOU GO: What: The Miami Takeover When: July 24 - July 27 Where: Various locations, including Miami Beach Bandshell for The Art of Go-Go Fee: Pricing starts at $23.18 for The Art of Go-Go Info:
