Investments in Balochistan: a target of hostile propaganda
The writer is a public policy analyst based in Lahore. She can be reached at durdananajam1@gmail.com
Listen to article
A well-orchestrated propaganda campaign has emerged against Saudi Arabia's investments in Balochistan, particularly in the Reko Diq mining project and the proposed oil refinery. This negative media campaign bears striking similarities to the smear efforts against CPEC, aimed at derailing projects that are vital for Pakistan's economic growth.
The objective is clear: to create distrust between Pakistan and Saudi Arabia, dissuade much-needed foreign investments and keep Balochistan underdeveloped.
Pakistan and Saudi Arabia share a longstanding relationship based on mutual respect, economic cooperation and strategic interests. Saudi Arabia has been one of Pakistan's key economic partners, providing financial assistance during economic crises and investing in sectors vital to Pakistan's development. From direct financial aid to energy investments, Saudi Arabia has played a critical role in stabilising Pakistan's economy. In return, Pakistan has supported Saudi Arabia diplomatically and militarily, strengthening their bilateral ties.
The recent Saudi investments in Balochistan, particularly the $540 million stake in the Reko Diq mining project and the planned $10 billion oil refinery, mark a significant step in diversifying and deepening this relationship. These projects are not just economic ventures but strategic initiatives that will boost Pakistan's industrial capacity, create thousands of jobs and strengthen Pakistan's position in global markets.
The Reko Diq project, one of the world's largest untapped copper and gold reserves, represents a game-changer for Pakistan. With an estimated 5.9 billion tonnes of ore, this project is expected to generate approximately $74 billion over its 37-year lifespan. Saudi Arabia's involvement through Manara Minerals underscores its commitment to the global mining sector while ensuring economic growth in Pakistan.
Similarly, the proposed $10 billion oil refinery will enhance Pakistan's energy security by reducing reliance on imported petroleum products. With a refining capacity of 300,000 barrels per day, this project will not only bolster Pakistan's industrial capabilities but also create thousands of direct and indirect jobs, modernise infrastructure and attract further foreign investments.
Beyond economic growth, these projects provide skill development opportunities, enhance regional infrastructure and promote technological transfer, contributing to long-term economic stability in Balochistan. However, despite these benefits, certain hostile elements continue to spread misinformation and attempt to sabotage these projects.
The opposition to Saudi investments follows the same pattern of disinformation used against CPEC. Hostile actors, including Indian intelligence agency RAW and other anti-Pakistan elements, seek to create hurdles for Pakistan's economic progress by fabricating narratives around environmental damage, forced displacements and resource exploitation. The same rhetoric was used against CPEC, attempting to dissuade international investors and incite unrest in Balochistan.
Misinformation campaigns claim that Saudi investments are exploiting Balochistan's resources without benefiting its people. However, Balochistan holds a 25% stake in Reko Diq, ensuring substantial revenue generation for the province. The investments will fund infrastructure, healthcare and education initiatives, directly benefiting the local population. The reality is that these projects bring prosperity, not exploitation, to Balochistan.
The question is: Who is behind this campaign?
Pakistan's enemies, particularly India, have a vested interest in keeping Balochistan unstable. A prosperous and economically integrated Balochistan would strengthen Pakistan's national economy, reducing external dependencies and creating strategic depth.
The objective is clear: to prevent Pakistan from capitalising on its natural resources and by sowing discord between Pakistan and Saudi Arabia, these hostile elements seek to undermine Pakistan's alliances and economic stability.
To protect these strategic investments, Pakistan must take proactive measures:
Strengthen diplomatic engagement: Pakistan should enhance diplomatic efforts to reaffirm Saudi confidence in its investment climate and counter false narratives at international forums.
Launch public awareness campaigns: The government and media should actively counter misinformation by highlighting the economic and social benefits of these projects, particularly for Balochistan's development.
Enhance security measures: Ensuring the safety of investment sites and personnel through better security arrangements will deter sabotage attempts and reassure investors.
Having legal framework for investment protection: A robust legal structure should be in place to protect foreign investments from external interference and political instability.
Integrating Balochistan economically: By ensuring that locals are the primary beneficiaries through employment, education and infrastructure development, Pakistan can neutralise separatist narratives.
The smear campaign against Saudi investments is a continuation of the broader strategy to hinder Balochistan's development and, by extension, Pakistan's economic rise. The same tactics used against CPEC are now being employed to create rifts between Pakistan and its key allies. However, the benefits of these projects are undeniable. Saudi investments will transform Balochistan, create jobs, enhance infrastructure and position the region as a key economic hub.
Pakistan must remain vigilant against these malicious efforts and work towards safeguarding its economic interests. By fostering regional development, securing investments and countering hostile propaganda, Pakistan can ensure that Balochistan emerges as a beacon of economic growth rather than a battleground for external agendas.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Express Tribune
an hour ago
- Express Tribune
India a perpetrator of foreign interference: Canadian intelligence
Sikh protesters participate in a rally as world leaders gather in Kananaskis for the G7 leaders' summit in Calgary, Alberta, Canada, on June 16, 2025. Photo: Reuters Listen to article India is a perpetrator of foreign interference, Canada's intelligence agency said in a report published on Wednesday, just after India's and Canada's prime ministers vowed to strengthen ties at a global summit hosted by Canada. Canadian Prime Minister Mark Carney and Indian Prime Minister Narendra Modi held what both sides called productive talks on Tuesday at the G7 summit in Alberta and agreed to reinstate top diplomats they had withdrawn last year. Carney drew outrage from some members of Canada's Sikh community when he invited Modi to the G7. Canada-India relations have been tense since former Prime Minister Justin Trudeau in 2023 accused India's government of involvement in the June 18, 2023, murder of Hardeep Singh Nijjar, a Sikh separatist leader in Canada. Read More: Fury among Canadian Sikhs as Modi invited to G7 despite alleged threats Modi's government has denied involvement in Nijjar's killing and has accused Canada of providing a safe haven for Sikh separatists. The intelligence report noted transnational repression "plays a central role in India's activity in Canada," though it said China poses the greatest counter-intelligence threat to Canada and also named Russia, Iran and Pakistan. The Royal Canadian Mounted Police said in October they had communicated more than a dozen threats to Sikhs advocating for the creation of a homeland carved out of India. "Indian officials, including their Canada-based proxy agents, engage in a range of activities that seek to influence Canadian communities and politicians," the Canadian Security Intelligence Service report reads. Also Read: Trudeau says 'clear indications' India violated Canadian sovereignty amid Sikh separatist row "These activities attempt to steer Canada's positions into alignment with India's interests on key issues, particularly with respect to how the Indian government perceives Canada-based supporters of an independent homeland that they call Khalistan." The Indian High Commission and the Chinese embassy in Canada did not immediately respond to requests for comment.
Express Tribune
3 hours ago
- Express Tribune
Trump says he stopped India-Pakistan war after India says no US mediation
US President Donald Trump attend a Make America Healthy Again (MAHA) Commission event, in the East Room of the White House in Washington on May 22, 2025. Photo: REUTERS Listen to article US President Donald Trump insisted on Wednesday that he had stopped the war between India and Pakistan, hours after Indian Prime Minister Narendra Modi told him the ceasefire after a four-day conflict in May was achieved through talks between the neighbors' militaries, not US mediation. "Well, I stopped a war... I love Pakistan. I think Modi is a fantastic man. I spoke to him last night. We're going to make a trade deal with Modi of India. But I stopped the war between Pakistan and India. This man was extremely influential in stopping it from the Pakistan side. Modi from the India side and others. They were going at it – and they're both nuclear countries. I got it stopped," Trump added. 'Well I stopped the war between pakistan. I love Pakistan. Modi is a fantastic man I spoke to him last night we can now make a trade deal with him but I stopped the war between India and Pakistan' - US President Donald Trump — Murtaza Ali Shah (@MurtazaViews) June 18, 2025 Pakistan conducted Operation Bunyanum Marsoos in response to Indian military's dastardly attacks that began on the night of May 6 and 7, resulting in the loss of innocent civilian lives, including women, children, and the elderly. On May 10, Pakistan deployed its Al-Fatah missile and targeted multiple Indian military installations. However, after the intervention of Donald Trump, a full and immediate ceasefire was reached between India and Pakistan. Trump made his remarks just before he was scheduled to host COAS Field Marshal Asim Munir in a rare meeting at the White House on Wednesday, something likely to upset India, a country the US president and his predecessor Joe Biden assiduously courted as part of efforts to push back against China. White House spokeswoman Anna Kelly said Trump would host Asim Munir after he called for the president to be nominated for the Nobel Peace Prize for preventing a nuclear war between India and Pakistan. Read More: Modi tells Trump 'no' US role in ceasefire with Pakistan Trump had said last month that the nuclear-armed South Asian neighbours agreed to a ceasefire after talks mediated by the US, and that the hostilities ended after he urged the countries to focus on trade instead of war. However, Modi told Trump late on Tuesday that the ceasefire was achieved through talks between the Indian and Pakistani militaries and not US. mediation, according to India's most senior diplomat, Foreign Secretary Vikram Misri. Pakistan has thanked Washington for playing a mediating role. India has repeatedly denied any third-party mediation and Tuesday's phone call between Modi and Trump on the sidelines of the G7 summit in Canada, which Modi attended as a guest, was the two leaders' first direct exchange since the May 7-10 conflict. Also Read: 'If you don't stop, no trade': Trump on Pakistan-India ceasefire "PM Modi told President Trump clearly that during this period, there was no talk at any stage on subjects like India-US trade deal or US mediation between India and Pakistan," Misri said in a press statement. "Talks for ceasing military action happened directly between India and Pakistan through existing military channels, and on the insistence of Pakistan. Prime Minister Modi emphasised that India has not accepted mediation in the past and will never do," he said. Misri said the two leaders had been due to meet on the sidelines of G7 summit but Trump left a day early due to the situation in the Middle East. Trump asked Modi if he could stop by the US on his return from Canada, Misri said, but the Indian leader expressed his inability to do so due to a pre-decided schedule. "He invited Trump to visit India later this year for the summit of the leaders of the Quad grouping, which Trump accepted," Misri said.
Business Recorder
3 hours ago
- Business Recorder
EV hopes hit by China rare earths curbs
China's curbs on exports of some rare earth materials and magnets - used in automobiles, cell phones and myriad other devices - have stirred anxiety in corporate boardrooms the world over, including in India where automakers warn that production of new vehicles could soon grind to a halt. While supplies have started to trickle in for some European and American companies, India, which has tense relations with its Asian neighbour, is still waiting. Come July, the world's third-largest car market fears severe disruptions - especially in its nascent electric vehicle sector - if magnet supplies don't resume. That is the focus of our analysis this week. And, India mourned the victims of last week's fatal airliner crash in Ahmedabad while executives from Boeing and Air India discussed the search for the cause of the disaster. Scroll down for the latest. China's magnet dominance threatens Indian EV output This was supposed to be the year that electric vehicles finally made their mark in India, the world's third-largest auto market. But China had other ideas. China has a stranglehold on global processing capacity for rare earths, which are crucial for magnets that power the motors in EVs, and it has been wielding that dominance in recent months in trade spats with the U.S. and others. India, increasingly at odds with its giant neighbour over border disputes and competing with it for influence in the region, is particularly vulnerable. Industry executives worry, moreover, that other supply chain snags may loom on the horizon, given India's reliance on China for EV batteries as well. Tata Motors ( opens new tab and Mahindra & Mahindra ( opens new tab, two of India's biggest EV makers, depend almost entirely on batteries from China's BYD Co ( opens new tab and Gotion ( opens new tab. China's decision in April to restrict its exports of rare earth materials and magnets comes at a crucial time for India, with several EV launches lined up this year including the first from its top carmaker, Maruti Suzuki ( opens new tab. Maruti has been forced to cut its near-term production targets for its e-Vitara EV due to rare earth supply constraints, while hoping to recover lost ground later in the year as availability improves - an approach analysts say other Indian automakers could adopt to avoid a complete output halt. Bajaj Auto ( opens new tab, a major producer of electric scooters in India, has also warned of a serious cutback in EV production by July if Beijing does not approve rare earth import permits soon. While India has initiated talks with China on stabilising supplies, the industry fears progress could be slow, not only because Beijing is overwhelmed with similar requests from across the world, but also given the tense relationship between the two Asian giants. Five years ago, in a move aimed at Chinese corporate takeovers in India that New Delhi saw as opportunistic, the trade ministry placed restrictions on investments from nations that share a land border with India. Chinese automakers BYD Co ( opens new tab and Great Wall Motor ( opens new tab were both forced to drop billion-dollar investment plans for Indian car manufacturing. Since 2020, New Delhi has banned dozens of Chinese apps such as TikTok and WeChat over national security concerns, and is yet to resume direct flights between India and China that were halted during the pandemic. India plans long-term development of its own rare earths For now, India has no reasonable alternatives to rare earth magnets from China, which controls about 90% of the world's production. But for the medium-to-long term, New Delhi plans to make good use of its own rare earth reserves - the world's fifth-largest at 6.9 million metric tons. It is urgently drawing up an incentive scheme for domestic rare earth magnet production, although it lacks reserves of some of the heavy rare earths needed to make magnets, as well as much of the technology to produce them. Auto companies warn that any domestic commercial production of magnets from rare earths or alternative materials would need extensive testing and is likely many years away. India also has asked state-run miner IREL to stop exports of rare earth materials, forcing it to walk back on a 13-year-old supply agreement with Japan as it prioritises national interests. Prime Minister Narendra Modi wants EVs to make up 30% of India's total passenger car sales by 2030, versus about 2.5% in 2024, both to meet his decarbonisation goals and to clean up the air over India's cities, which are some of the world's most polluted. Analysts say that, while it may take India a decade to build its own EV supply chain, it must start now if Modi is to achieve those targets. Will China disrupt India's EV story by curbing supplies of crucial parts like magnets and, potentially, batteries? What are your thoughts? Write to me at [email protected], opens new tab Update on Air India crash India this week was mourning victims of last Friday's air disaster in Ahmedabad that killed all but one of the 242 people on board, while executives from Boeing and Air India met to discuss their search for the cause of the crash. India's aviation regulator has ordered the inspection of all Boeing 787 jets operated by domestic carriers. India's trade deficit narrowed marginally to $21.88 billion in May, from $26.42 billion the previous month, due in part to moderation in oil and gold imports, economists said. Markets are closely watching trade statistics for any signs of front-loading of shipments during the 90-day pause on planned reciprocal tariffs by the U.S., which ends on July 8. India's exports in May were $38.73 billion, 2% below a year ago, but shipments of electronic goods surged 47% while chemicals rose 16%. Exports of gems and jewellery fell sharply.
