logo
Lawyer argues Call of Duty maker can't be held responsible for actions of Uvalde, Texas, shooter

Lawyer argues Call of Duty maker can't be held responsible for actions of Uvalde, Texas, shooter

First Post20-07-2025
Three sets of parents who lost children in the shooting were in the audience at the Los Angeles hearing. read more
A lawyer for the maker of the video game Call of Duty argued Friday that a judge should dismiss a lawsuit brought by families of the victims of the Robb Elementary School attack in Uvalde, Texas, saying the contents of the war game are protected by the First Amendment.
The families sued Call of Duty maker Activision and Meta Platforms, which owns Instagram, saying that the companies bear responsibility for promoting products used by the teen gunman.
STORY CONTINUES BELOW THIS AD
Three sets of parents who lost children in the shooting were in the audience at the Los Angeles hearing.
Activision lawyer Bethany Kristovich told Superior Court Judge William Highberger that the 'First Amendment bars their claims, period full stop.'
'The issues of gun violence are incredibly difficult,' Kristovich said. 'The evidence in this case is not.'
She argued that the case has little chance of prevailing if it continues, because courts have repeatedly held that 'creators of artistic works, whether they be books, music, movies, TV or video games, cannot be held legally liable for the acts of their audience.'
The lawsuit, one of many involving Uvalde families, was filed last year on the second anniversary of one of the deadliest school shootings in U.S. history. The gunman killed 19 students and two teachers. Officers finally confronted and shot him after waiting more than an hour to enter the fourth-grade classroom.
Kimberly Rubio, whose 10-year-old daughter Lexi was killed in the shooting, was among the parents who came from Texas to Southern California, where Activision is based, for the hearing.
'We travelled all this way, so we need answers,' Rubio said outside the courthouse. 'It's our hope that the case will move forward so we can get those answers.'
STORY CONTINUES BELOW THIS AD
An attorney for the families argued during the hearing that Call of Duty exceeds its First Amendment protections by moving into marketing.
'The basis of our complaint is not the existence of Call of Duty,' Katie Mesner-Hage told the judge. 'It is using Call of Duty as a platform to market weapons to minors.'
The plaintiffs' lawyers showed contracts and correspondence between executives at Activison and gunmakers whose products, they said, are clearly and exactly depicted in the game despite brand names not appearing.
Mesner-Hage said the documents show that they actually prefer being unlabeled because 'it helps shield them from the implication that they are marketing guns to minors,' while knowing that players will still identify and seek out the weapons.
Kristovich said there is no evidence that the kind of product placement and marketing the plaintiffs are talking about happened in any of the editions of the game the shooter played.
The families have also filed a lawsuit against Daniel Defense, which manufactured the AR-style rifle used in the May 24, 2022, shooting. Koskoff argued that a replica of the rifle clearly appears on a splash page for Call of Duty.
STORY CONTINUES BELOW THIS AD
Josh Koskoff, the families' Connecticut-based lead attorney, also represented families of nine Sandy Hook Elementary School shooting victims in a lawsuit against gunmaker Remington and got a $73 million lawsuit settlement.
He invoked Sandy Hook several times in his arguments, saying the shooters there and in Uvalde shared the same gaming obsession.
Koskoff said the Uvalde shooter experienced 'the absorption and the loss of self in Call of Duty.'
He said that immersion was so deep that the shooter searched online for how to obtain an armored suit that he didn't know only exists in the game.
Video game is 'in a class of its own,' lawyer says
Koskoff played a clip from Call of Duty Modern Warfare, the game the shooter played, with a first-person shooter gunning down opponents.
The shots echoed loudly in the courtroom, and several people in the audience slowly shook their heads.
'Call of Duty is in a class of its own,' Koskoff said.
STORY CONTINUES BELOW THIS AD
Kristovich argued for Activision that the game, despite its vast numbers of players, can be tied to only a few of the many U.S. mass shootings.
'The game is incredibly common. It appears in a scene on 'The Office,'' she said. She added that it is ridiculous to assert that 'this is such a horrible scourge that your honor has to essentially ban it through this lawsuit.'
Highberger told the lawyers he was not leaning in either direction before the hearing. He gave no time frame for when he will rule, but a quick decision is not expected.
The judge did tell the plaintiffs' lawyers that their description of Activision's actions seemed like deliberate malfeasance, where their lawsuit alleges negligence. He said that was the biggest hurdle they needed to clear.
'Their conduct created a risk of exactly what happened,' Mesner-Hage told him. 'And we represent the people who are exactly the foreseeable victims of that conduct.'
STORY CONTINUES BELOW THIS AD
Meta's attorneys will make arguments on a similar motion next month.
Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

What Is Golf Force One, Donald Trump's New Armoured Buggy
What Is Golf Force One, Donald Trump's New Armoured Buggy

NDTV

timean hour ago

  • NDTV

What Is Golf Force One, Donald Trump's New Armoured Buggy

A heavily armoured black buggy was spotted trailing and keeping a close watch on US President Donald Trump during a weekend round of golf at his resort in Scotland. The vehicle, a stark contrast to Trump's usual white golf cart, has fuelled speculation about a new layer of protection following past threats to his life. The vehicle, which resembles a modified Polaris Ranger XP, moved silently but visibly close to the US President as he played, its presence hardly blending in with the manicured greens. While the US Secret Service reportedly declined to confirm whether the cart forms part of Trump's security detail, security experts have little doubt about its purpose. What Is Golf Force One? Nicknamed informally ' Golf Force One ', the armoured buggy appears to be a bespoke creation tailored for defensive mobility on the golf course. Its features, including a darkened windscreen, reinforced side panels and thick rear casing, suggest it has been specially fortified to withstand ballistic threats. "Just looking at the front windscreen, that looks armoured," Gary Relf, director of Armoured Car Services, was quoted as telling The Telegraph. Relf added that such modifications are often subtle yet significant. "From those photos, that is 100% armoured," he said. "The windscreen is a giveaway, as are the side panels, doors and the large panel at the rear above the load tray." The buggy's tinted windows may indicate transparent armour, according to Relf. He also pointed out that the overall design appears to prioritise defence, offering strong protection while remaining lightweight enough to preserve the integrity of the golf course surface. Heightened Security After Attempted Attacks According to The Telegraph, the secret service neither confirmed nor denied whether the cart was armoured or connected to Donald Trump 's security arrangements. The agency does not disclose the tools or techniques used to protect the president. In September 2024, Trump narrowly escaped an assassination attempt at Trump International Golf Club in West Palm Beach, Florida. A man named Ryan Routh aimed a Soviet-style SKS rifle at the US President. Agents conducting a sweep spotted Routh hidden about 400 yards away and fired at him. He dropped the weapon and fled in an SUV, only to be arrested during a traffic stop less than an hour later. It was the second assassination attempt on Trump in 2024. The first took place in July at a campaign rally in Butler, Pennsylvania, when a gunman opened fire, killing one person and wounding Trump in the ear.

‘Golf Force One': The Armoured Buggy That Stole The Show During Donald Trump's Scotland Visit
‘Golf Force One': The Armoured Buggy That Stole The Show During Donald Trump's Scotland Visit

News18

time4 hours ago

  • News18

‘Golf Force One': The Armoured Buggy That Stole The Show During Donald Trump's Scotland Visit

Last Updated: While Donald Trump is usually driven in the presidential limo known as 'The Beast', the buggy at Turnberry offered a scaled-down version built for the golf course A heavily fortified black buggy stole the spotlight as US President Donald Trump played golf over the weekend at his Turnberry resort in South Ayrshire, Scotland. Nicknamed 'Golf Force One" by media outlets, the vehicle moved closely behind Trump's white golf cart through the course, drawing attention for its sheer bulk, tinted windows and military-grade silhouette. The vehicle's deployment came nearly 10 months after Trump survived two assassination attempts and amid a four-day UK visit marked by intense protests, tight security and a bomb scare. A Buggy Like No Other The vehicle trailing Trump was identified by experts as a modified Polaris Ranger XP, a lightweight off-road vehicle commonly used in the UK by rural police, mountain rescue and rescue teams. However, the version seen at Turnberry appeared to be heavily customised. According to reports, the buggy was likely meant to serve as a rapid evacuation option should a threat arise on the open course. Despite its reinforced structure, it was designed to remain light enough to avoid damaging the greens. Security analysts cited in The Telegraph pointed out that the black band across the front windscreen, along with reinforced side and rear panels, suggested the buggy had been armoured extensively. One of the experts said the modifications would typically include replacing internal components like the floor and roof with hidden armour plating, while maintaining the vehicle's outward appearance. The heavily tinted windows were also interpreted as signs of thick, bullet-resistant transparent armour, the darker the tint, the more protection likely built into the glass. No Confirmation From Secret Service The United States Secret Service refused to confirm whether the armoured buggy was officially part of its protective operations. Responding to queries from The Telegraph, the agency said it uses a range of tools and methods to safeguard protectees but does not disclose specifics for security reasons. Why Was It Deployed? The appearance of the armoured vehicle follows two assassination attempts on Donald Trump in 2024, both during public engagements. In July 2024, during a campaign rally in Butler, Pennsylvania, a rooftop sniper, 20-year-old Thomas Matthew Crooks, opened fire with an AR-style rifle. One bullet grazed Trump's ear, while another killed former firefighter Corey Comperatore and seriously injured another attendee. The shooter was taken down by a counter-sniper team. Just two months later, in September, a man identified as 58-year-old Ryan Wesley Routh was spotted with an SKS-style rifle at Trump's West Palm Beach golf club. Routh was allegedly 300-500 yards away from Trump when the Secret Service agent spotted his rifle in the tree line, according to Palm Beach County Sheriff Ric Bradshaw. Agents fired at him before he fled in a vehicle and was later apprehended about 40 miles from the course. He has pleaded not guilty to federal charges. Lockdown At Turnberry Security at Turnberry during Trump's visit was among the most intense seen in recent years. The Telegraph reported that army trucks, road checkpoints and snipers were deployed across the area. According to The Independent, 1,500 officers, roughly a third of Police Scotland's active force, were pulled from their regular duties for the operation. Protests And A Bomb Threat The trip was also marred by protests and a security scare. Demonstrators gathered in Edinburgh and other cities to voice opposition to Trump's views on climate change and the Gaza conflict. Meanwhile, a Glasgow-bound flight was forced to make an emergency landing after a passenger claimed he had a bomb and wanted to 'send a message" to the president. Drawing Parallels With 'The Beast' While Trump is usually driven in the presidential limousine known as 'The Beast" — a $1.5 million Cadillac fortified against bullets, blasts and chemical attacks — the Turnberry buggy seems to serve a similar function scaled down for outdoor mobility. Experts told The Telegraph that such vehicles are tailored to specific threat levels. Depending on the nature of risk, from blunt force weapons to high-calibre sniper rifles, vehicles are customised with corresponding grades of armour and materials like laminated glass or plexiglass. tags : donald trump scotland The Beast view comments Location : New Delhi, India, India First Published: July 28, 2025, 11:27 IST News world 'Golf Force One': The Armoured Buggy That Stole The Show During Donald Trump's Scotland Visit Disclaimer: Comments reflect users' views, not News18's. Please keep discussions respectful and constructive. Abusive, defamatory, or illegal comments will be removed. News18 may disable any comment at its discretion. By posting, you agree to our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.

‘Golf Force One' vs. ‘The Beast', how this armoured golf cart tailing Trump compares to his $1.5 million Presidential limo
‘Golf Force One' vs. ‘The Beast', how this armoured golf cart tailing Trump compares to his $1.5 million Presidential limo

Time of India

time5 hours ago

  • Time of India

‘Golf Force One' vs. ‘The Beast', how this armoured golf cart tailing Trump compares to his $1.5 million Presidential limo

A heavily armored black golf cart, nicknamed 'Golf Force One', was spotted over the weekend following Donald Trump during a game at the Trump Turnberry golf course in South Ayrshire, Scotland. The reinforced cart followed Trump at close range, as Trump chose to cruise the course in a regular white golf cart. Explore courses from Top Institutes in Please select course: Select a Course Category PGDM Management MBA Design Thinking MCA Finance Operations Management Data Science others Data Analytics Degree Digital Marketing Artificial Intelligence Healthcare Product Management Data Science Leadership Others Project Management Public Policy Technology healthcare CXO Skills you'll gain: Financial Analysis & Decision Making Quantitative & Analytical Skills Organizational Management & Leadership Innovation & Entrepreneurship Duration: 24 Months IMI Delhi Post Graduate Diploma in Management (Online) Starts on Sep 1, 2024 Get Details Photos and videos of the jet-black vehicle, moving amid army trucks and security personnel, quickly drew attention online. The buggy's bulk, darkened windows, and militarised design sparked comparisons to Trump's presidential limousine, 'The Beast.' Also Read: WWII vet who married at 100 in Normandy, plans Bar Mitzvah at 103 at the Pentagon; still chasing dreams 81 years after D-Day The heightened security presence is not without cause. In September 2024, a man armed with an SKS-style rifle was spotted attempting to approach Trump during a golf match in Florida. Two months prior, a 20-year-old gunman opened fire from a rooftop during a campaign rally in Pennsylvania, grazing Trump's ear and killing a supporter. Live Events Since then, the US Secret Service has visibly increased its protective measures around Trump. Snipers were seen stationed on rooftops at Turnberry during this recent Scotland trip, and the presence of Golf Force One adds a new layer of mobile defense. What is 'Golf Force One'? According to experts cited by The Telegraph, the buggy appears to be a modified Polaris Ranger XP, a vehicle typically used by UK rural police and sometimes by US law enforcement. Though it resembles a regular golf cart in size, the vehicle is reportedly equipped with armor plating and reinforced windows. Security specialist Gary Relf told the Telegraph that key indicators of armoring include a tinted, banded windscreen, thick side panels, and an enclosed rear section. 'From those photos, that is 100% armored,' adding that its transparent armor likely makes the windows appear heavily tinted. Despite its added protection, the vehicle is believed to be light enough to avoid damaging the golf course turf, a consideration that makes it suitable for moving discreetly across fairways without drawing mechanical or visual attention. The vehicle likely serves a defensive function, possibly as a mobile shield or rapid escape vehicle in case of sudden threats. Using such a cart can also allow Trump's security to remain nearby during a relatively exposed activity like golfing, where conventional armored vehicles can't follow. How 'Golf Force One' compares to 'The Beast' While Golf Force One is built for mobility and close-range protection in outdoor environments, The Beast, the presidential limousine officially known as Cadillac One, is a fully fortified mobile command center. The Beast weighs 8–10 tonnes and features: Eight-inch-thick armor plating Bulletproof, sealed doors with no keyholes An independent oxygen supply Blood bags matching the president's blood type Run-flat tires and an armored fuel tank Encrypted communication systems for secure command during emergencies Tear gas dispensers and electrified door handles for defense By contrast, Golf Force One is a smaller, faster, and more flexible machine, designed for open, less secure terrain like golf courses. Its primary function appears to be defensive mobility rather than heavy protection and communication infrastructure. It allows agents to stay within close range of Trump during casual outdoor activities without compromising safety.

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store