logo
Strong argument for cockpit video recording, says IATA chief in wake of Air India crash report

Strong argument for cockpit video recording, says IATA chief in wake of Air India crash report

The Star16-07-2025
SINGAPORE: There is a strong argument to be made for video recorders to be installed in aircraft cockpits to aid in accident investigations, said International Air Transport Association chief Willie Walsh in his first comments about an interim report on the Air India crash in June that killed 260 people.
'Based on what little we know now, it's quite possible that a video recording, in addition to the voice recording, would significantly assist the investigators,' said Walsh on July 16 in an interview with Singapore media.
Pilot unions have long resisted calls for cockpit video recording, citing concerns over privacy and potential misuse. The International Federation of Air Line Pilots' Associations, for instance, said it was sceptical that confidentiality of such recordings could ever be fully guaranteed, according to a July 16 report by Reuters.
Walsh, a former pilot turned airline chief executive, said he can understand the reluctance among flight crew to have video cameras installed in the cockpit.
But the head of Iata, a global airline trade body representing some 350 carriers, emphasised the need for air accident investigations to be conducted fully and properly.
'Our industry has always been very open in sharing information,' he added.
Walsh also called on governments to publish accident reports in a timely manner in line with international obligations.
'I think we would all benefit from the publication of these reports so that we can assess them and learn from any issues that are relevant to the rest of the industry,' he said.
The debate on whether video cameras should be installed in airplane cockpits was reignited after the release of the preliminary report on the ill-fated Air India Flight AI171 on July 11.
The report by India's Aircraft Accident Investigation Bureau (AAIB) raised questions about the movement of the fuel control switches on the Boeing 787 jet, which were toggled to the cutoff position one after the other seconds after take-off, shutting down both of the plane's engines.
The AAIB shared a snippet from the cockpit voice recording, noting that one of the pilots was heard asking the other why he had cut off fuel to the engines. The other pilot responded that he did not do so. The report did not say how or why the fuel switches were moved.
The AAIB report also flagged a 2018 advisory from the US Federal Aviation Administration, which recommended the inspection of the locking feature of fuel switches of several Boeing models.
This prompted airlines around the world, including national carrier Singapore Airlines and its budget arm Scoot, to carry out precautionary checks in the days after the report's release.
Walsh commended the AAIB for the release of its interim report, which he said contained more information about the crash than most people were expecting.
He said it was sensible for airlines to check the fuel switches on their Boeing aircraft despite there being no formal recommendation from the US aircraft maker to do so.
Switching gears, the Iata chief also addressed questions about the impact of trade tariffs, which he said may lead to airlines being reluctant to take delivery of new aircraft, given the uncertainty over how this will affect the cost of planes
'We'll wait and see... It'll impact all aspects of the aerospace industry and have an impact on most, if not all, airlines as well,' he added.
Walsh was in Singapore to attend a series of high-level aviation meetings held in the city-state over the week.
He was also taken on a visit to the development site of the upcoming Terminal 5 (T5), which will take Changi Airport's handling capacity to 140 million passengers yearly, up from 90 million today, when it opens in the mid-2030s.
Walsh said he was impressed by the design and thinking behind the future mega-terminal, noting the investments being made in innovation and technology, and the planning that has been done to ensure minimal connection times for passengers.
'Some of the work that I see Changi undertaking... ultimately will benefit everybody in the industry in the areas of automation and AI (artificial intelligence),' he added.
Walsh said the team at Changi Airport has a 'laser focus' on the cost of the T5 development, revealing that the multi-billion dollar project is 'significantly under budget'.
'Critically, everything they're doing is to ensure that they do it in a cost-effective manner, so that the charges that airlines and ultimately the passenger faces are being controlled,' he said.
Rising fees at Changi Airport have been a bugbear among airlines here, and it was cited as a factor behind the demise of low-cost carrier Jetstar Asia.
Asked if there is a place for budget carriers at Changi and other high-cost airports, Walsh said he does not agree that the low-cost airline model is dead, but there are certain airports where it may not make sense.
He cited London's Heathrow Airport as one example, noting the cost of operations and lack of access to take-off and landing slots there.
Walsh said the fact that some airlines are categorised as budget or low-cost does not automatically ensure their financial success. 'We are a very competitive industry,' he added. - The Straits Times/ANN
Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Soccer-England's Walsh hope Spain can enjoy Euro final after Rubiales controversy
Soccer-England's Walsh hope Spain can enjoy Euro final after Rubiales controversy

The Star

time2 hours ago

  • The Star

Soccer-England's Walsh hope Spain can enjoy Euro final after Rubiales controversy

FILE PHOTO: Soccer Football - UEFA Women's Euro 2025 - Semi Final - England v Italy - Stade de Geneve, Lancy, Switzerland - July 22, 2025 England's Keira Walsh in action with Italy's Manuela Giugliano REUTERS/Denis Balibouse/File Photo ZURICH (Reuters) -England and former Barcelona midfielder Keira Walsh hopes that Spain are able to enjoy the Euro 2025 final on Sunday after the controversy that clouded their 2023 World Cup triumph. Defending champions England meet Spain in Basel on Sunday, two years on from a World Cup final that was overshadowed by then Spanish football federation chief Luis Rubiales kissing striker Jenni Hermoso on the lips after the game. "There's a lot of respect between both the teams and, I think the most important thing for them as a footballer, is that they can enjoy this final – that there's not the controversy surrounding it," Walsh said from England's base camp on Thursday. "The girls deserve to be there to play incredible football. The way our league jumped after we won the (2022) Euros, if you compare it to Spain it probably wasn't the same and they won the World Cup," said Walsh, who played 64 games for Barcelona before joining Chelsea. "After the final there was a lot of controversy and I don't think, for them, there was enough spotlight on how incredible they played. It was all about the other stuff. "As a professional, that was disappointing to see. I have a lot of friends in that team and I think they probably deserved a little bit more than what they got." Rubiales was found guilty of sexual assault for the unsolicited kiss during the World Cup medal ceremony, and fined over 10,000 euros ($12,000). The incident sparked widespread debate about sexism in Spanish society and women's football, fuelling momentum for the "Me Too" movement in the country. ($1 = 0.8500 euros) (Reporting by Lori Ewing)

Jeju Air crash families denounce report blaming pilot error
Jeju Air crash families denounce report blaming pilot error

Free Malaysia Today

timea day ago

  • Free Malaysia Today

Jeju Air crash families denounce report blaming pilot error

The final investigation report on the Jeju Air flight crash is planned to be released in June next year. (EPA Images pic) SEOUL : The families of victims of South Korea's deadliest plane crash on home soil have denounced a government report which blamed the disaster on pilot error, a representative told AFP Tuesday. The Boeing 737-800 was flying from Thailand to South Korea's southwest on Dec 29 last year but ended up belly-landing at Muan airport and exploding in a fireball after slamming into a concrete barrier, killing 179 people. South Korea's land ministry told AFP it had planned to release the partial findings of the investigation into the crash at the weekend but called off a briefing and withheld the report after the families objected, claiming it could be misleading. The report said a bird strike damaged the plane's right engine, but the pilot then mistakenly shut down the left engine instead, a representative for the families, who saw the report, told AFP. The error resulted in a total power loss and a failure of the landing gear system, they said. The pilot said, 'Let's shut down engine number 2 (the right engine),' but the flight data recorder showed that actually it was the left engine that was shut down, according to the report. 'No one has directly seen or heard the cockpit voice recorder or the flight data recorder,' Kim Youn-mi, a representative of the victims' families, told AFP. 'We weren't given any proper explanation about those things. We need to hear that to know. We have the right,' she added. The Jeju Air pilots' union also criticised the report, saying it was 'strongly angered' by the findings and would 'firmly reject the malicious attempt to shift blame onto the pilot'. The findings were part of an ongoing probe by South Korean and US investigators, who are still investigating the cause of the disaster. A bird strike – feathers and bloodstains were found in both engines – a faulty landing gear and the runway barrier are among the possible issues. The final report is planned to be released in June next year.

Air India completes fuel switch checks on Boeing planes after crash report
Air India completes fuel switch checks on Boeing planes after crash report

The Star

time2 days ago

  • The Star

Air India completes fuel switch checks on Boeing planes after crash report

Air India, in a official statement on Tuesday, announced that it has completed the fuel control switch inspection of its Boeing fleets. NEW DELHI: (Bernama) Air India said on Tuesday (July 22) it has completed fuel switch checks on all its Boeing 787 and Boeing 737 aircraft as ordered by India's aviation regulator. An initial report this month on the June 12 crash of the Air India Boeing 787 Dreamliner found that fuel to both engines was abruptly cut off seconds before the plane went down after takeoff from Ahmedabad airport in Gujarat state. "Air India has completed precautionary inspections on the locking mechanism of Fuel Control Switch (FCS) on all Boeing 787 and Boeing 737 aircraft in its fleet. Boeing 737 aircraft are part of the fleet of Air India Express, Air India's low cost subsidiary. "With this, the two airlines have complied with the directives of the DGCA (Directorate General of Civil Aviation) issued on July 14, 2025," the airline said in a statement. "In the inspections, no issues were found with the said locking mechanism," it said. The London-bound flight AI171 carrying 242 people crashed into a medical college building. All aboard except one passenger died in the disaster, with the total death toll, including victims on the ground, being 260. The aircraft began to lose altitude before crossing the airport perimeter wall, the preliminary report found. "In the cockpit voice recording, one of the pilots is heard asking the other why did he cutoff. The other pilot responded that he did not do so," the report released by India's Aircraft Accident Investigation Bureau (AAIB) said. The Wall Street Journal, citing sources familiar with US officials' early assessment of data, reported on July 16 that a black-box recording of dialogue between the flight's two pilots indicated it was the captain who moved the switches from "run" to "cutoff" setting. Reuters, a day later, carried a similar report, suggesting it was the captain who cut the flow of fuel. The Federation of Indian Pilots has sent legal notices to the two media organisations, calling the reports "irresponsible" and "speculative". - Bernama

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store