PlayStation sues Tencent over Horizon ‘clone' Light Of Motiram
Last November, Chinese conglomerate Tencent announced a brand new survival game for PC called Light Of Motiram; one that you can play with friends as you explore a post-apocalyptic world populated by animal-like machines.
The game's announcement quickly went viral, not because it looked any good, but because it looked an awful lot like Sony's Horizon Zero Dawn and its sequel. Even the woman depicted in the key art shared many similarities with Horizon protagonist Aloy.
At the time, some wondered if Sony would take umbrage with Light Of Motiram. Turns out the answer to that is yes, as the company has formally filed a lawsuit against Tencent, accusing it of copyright and trademark infringement.
According to Reuters the lawsuit explicitly describes Light Of Motiram as a 'slavish clone of Sony Interactive Entertainment's immensely popular, award-winning Horizon series of video games.'
Sony even cites the initial public response and comments from gaming news websites as evidence of Tencent copying Horizon developer Guerrilla Games' homework.
Interestingly, Sony also mentions that representatives of Tencent and one of its internal developers, Aurora Studios, previously approached the company to pitch a new Horizon game – one that would retain the established open world setting but feature 'Eastern aesthetics', survival mechanics, and multiplayer options (so presumably it would've been set in Asia, rather than the US).
Sign up to the GameCentral newsletter for a unique take on the week in gaming, alongside the latest reviews and more. Delivered to your inbox every Saturday morning.
They went so far as to share a photo of Aurora Studios' team members playing one of the Horizon games at work alongside screenshots of their PlayStation trophy lists to demonstrate how they were 'diehard fans' of the series.
Sony rejected the pitch and is convinced that Tencent has repurposed the idea as Light Of Motiram, except they ditched the planned Eastern aesthetic and instead copied Horizon wholesale.
'The Light Of Motiram Promotional Material reflects that even though Sony Interactive Entertainment rejected Tencent's pitch to create a licensed Horizon Franchise game, Tencent continued to produce a game that makes unauthorized use of Sony Interactive Entertainment's rights in the Horizon Franchise intellectual property,' reads the lawsuit.
'In doing so, Tencent misappropriates many of the most distinctive and recognisable protected elements of the Horizon Franchise, including the franchise's overall tone and feel, setting, narrative, characters, and visual expression, leading to confusion as to source, affiliation, and sponsorship of the Light Of Motiram game.'
Elsewhere, Sony also gives away that the Horizons series has sold a collective 38 million units in total. According to the PlayStation Blog, 32.7 million units had been sold as of April 2023, meaning roughly six million more have been sold since then.
As a reminder, the only Horizon games to have come out in that time were a PlayStation 5 remaster of the first game and the multiplatform Lego Horizon Adventures spin-off.
You can read the whole lawsuit in full for yourself, but ultimately Sony is seeking to block Light Of Motiram from ever been released, plus $150,000 'for each separate work in the Horizon Franchise infringed' in damages and for Tencent to hand over any and all marketing materials so Sony can destroy them.
At the time of writing, Tencent has yet to issue any sort of response, so it's unclear if it will comply or if it feels it can win the court case. More Trending
This situation is reminiscent of the still ongoing Nintendo/Palworld legal battle. As a reminder, Palworld quickly gained infamy for its obvious similarities to Pokémon, to the point where some suspected developer Pocketpair of using AI to copy multiple pokémon designs for its catchable cartoon animals.
Nintendo's lawsuit, however, is based on Pocketpair allegedly infringing on Nintendo's patents for certain game mechanics. Since then, Palworld has had some of its mechanics changed. For instance, Pals are no longer summoned by throwing the equivalent of a pokéball, they just appear next to you.
All that said, a report by IP consultant Florian Mueller for GamesFray earlier this month argues that Nintendo isn't guaranteed a clean win. In fact, the company has had one of its patents modified which Mueller believes is a Hail Mary to try and obfuscate the issue.
The Light Of Motiram situation is different, though, since Sony isn't accusing Tencent of copying Horizon's mechanics but the entire concept and aesthetic, thus potentially confusing people into thinking it's an official Horizon game.
Email gamecentral@metro.co.uk, leave a comment below, follow us on Twitter.
To submit Inbox letters and Reader's Features more easily, without the need to send an email, just use our Submit Stuff page here.
For more stories like this, check our Gaming page.
MORE: Horizon Forbidden West review – robosaurs wrecks
MORE: Horizon Call Of The Mountain review – the summit of PSVR2 achievements
MORE: Ubisoft lands itself a Tencent bail out worth £1,000,000,000
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Metro
8 hours ago
- Metro
Why is Sony trying to kill the concept of the video game console?
A reader worries that Sony's plans to make more of their games multiformat will destroy the entire concept of consoles, as they follow the same path as Xbox. At this point I think it's clear that Xbox is dead. They're the biggest publishers in the West but at such a terrible cost it's almost poetic. No one's buying their hardware and no one is ever likely to again. All the famous Xbox exclusive franchises are not only about to be not exclusive but they're just one more disaster away from being dead franchises. Xbox basically doesn't exist anymore, the way it used to be. All it is, is the combination of Activision Blizzard and Bethesda. Everything else is an insignificant extra, that will probably end up being shut down in short order. It's a classic example of being careful what you wish for but disturbing because, like all rich bullies, Microsoft is now pretending that, actually, they meant to do that and rather than feel bad about turning the industry on its head they're just going to carry on and make things worse. And I'm afraid that Sony is now doing the same thing. Given Microsoft is many times their size, Sony should never have had a chance against them, if they were run by competent people. Call me naïve, but if I were Sony and I saw my long-time rival on the ropes I'd give them the old one-two and finish them off for good. As we've seen though they've done the opposite. It almost seems like they're trying to copy Microsoft, except without the infinite funds and not owning two of the biggest publishers in the world. Suddenly, Sony doesn't care for exclusives and they're embracing multiformat releases, even though that makes absolutely no sense for their business. Sure, they will make more money in the short term, but in the long term… there will be no long term if they destroy the whole concept of a video game console. If you want to play Xbox games now you've got two choices: buy a dying console that Xbox aren't even bothering to sell in some countries now or play them on PC or streaming. Microsoft make money out of this, of course, but they have no control over those formats and so they become just like any other publisher, like EA or Ubisoft. Sign up to the GameCentral newsletter for a unique take on the week in gaming, alongside the latest reviews and more. Delivered to your inbox every Saturday morning. There are two basic reasons to buy a console: the lack of fuss and bother (and generally lower price) compared to a PC and the exclusive games. I have long said that Sony releasing their exclusives on PC is a mistake because while you get some short term cash from it you're eating away at the reason anyone would buy a console in the first place. But now we hear that the August release of Helldivers 2 on Xbox Series X/S is not going to be a one-off, that Sony wants to release more games on Xbox and Nintendo Switch. Anything to make the smallest amount of extra money now, even if it means destroying their future forever. Is Sony short of cash or something? Are their financials so bad they have to do the corporate equivalent of going to the pawn shop to make it to the end of the week? Not as far as I know, but that's what they're doing anyway. There seems no point me even complaining at this point, as not only are they obviously not going to listen to me or any other fan but it seems to late. Sony had two choices when Microsoft messed up: go all out to show how good the PlayStation 5 and its line-up of exclusives is or… just sort of roll up and die for no reason. And yes, I know the PlayStation 5 is still selling well but that's because it's the only game in town at the moment, now the Xbox Series X/S has gone to an early grave. But every year the PC becomes more and more popular and that's only going to accelerate as one of the main reasons to buy a console is removed. It's not the end of gaming or anything – third party games will be unaffected – but the sort of exclusive games that Sony used to make are going to become rarer and rarer. They already are but when they don't need them to show off their console, and act like a killer app, they'll just keep reducing the budgets and the number of them they make until they don't bother at all. More Trending In the end, Sony will become a third party publisher too and even more choice and variety will be removed from the games industry. By reader Dunbar The reader's features do not necessarily represent the views of GameCentral or Metro. You can submit your own 500 to 600-word reader feature at any time, which if used will be published in the next appropriate weekend slot. Just contact us at gamecentral@ or use our Submit Stuff page and you won't need to send an email. MORE: The Nintendo Switch 2 is the closest thing to a modern day Commodore Amiga – Reader's Feature MORE: Star Wars Outlaws is Ubisoft's best game and you should get it now it's cheap - Reader's Feature MORE: It is madness that Konami still hasn't made a new Castlevania - Reader's Feature
Metro
a day ago
- Metro
Games Inbox: Was the Nintendo Direct a disaster?
The Friday letters page worries about Nintendo's third party support for Switch 2, as one reader is unimpressed by Assassin's Creed Shadows. To join in with the discussions yourself email gamecentral@ Worst. Direct. Ever. What the hell was that? All that talk about the Nintendo Direct and that may be the most disappointing one of these livestreams I've ever seen, including from Sony and Microsoft. I can't say there was a single thing that took my interest, out of any of the 'big' games. Definitely not Monster Hunter Stories 3 and those two 2D-HD games. I mean, two of them?! And then they both turn out to be multiformat anyway. I think Square Enix and Nintendo are completely overestimating how popular that art style is, as I've always thought it was ugly and boring. I'm sure others must like it but I'm also sure that those games are not big sellers and that nobody's going to run out and buy a Switch 2 to play The Adventures Of Elliot (I thought I'd made that name up at first, but that really is what it's called!). An absolute disaster as far as I'm concerned, in terms of showing the Switch 2 had good third party support and giving an update on games that have already been announced. Where the heck was Elden Ring? How hard can that be to port to the Switch 2? It was on PlayStation 4, so it's not even a current gen game. Nintendo are being far too comfortable about all this at the moment and every time a games company does that it ends in ruin. I have a horrible feeling the Switch 2 is going to end up being Nintendo's PlayStation 3. Campbell Direct delay I was mostly disappointed by the Direct on Thursday. Nothing hugely exciting or impressive, or even release dates for a lot of already announced games like Elden Ring. Sign up to the GameCentral newsletter for a unique take on the week in gaming, alongside the latest reviews and more. Delivered to your inbox every Saturday morning. The new Katamari looks good, though why it only said Switch not Switch 2 is a mystery, especially as it seems it's coming to PlayStation 5, Xbox, and PC too. I think if there'd been a not-E3 Direct, this one would have felt less disappointing. But the lack of big presentations from this Nintendo has meant any sniff of news has a higher bar to cross. This one was nearly as bad as a typical State Of Play. Euclidian Boxes GC: A lot of games being released at the moment are Switch 1 only (Once Upon A Katamari is out in less than three months) and that will continue to be the case for some time, given how long a game takes to make and how many developers have had trouble getting Switch 2 devkits. Dead service game This Monster Hunter Wilds situation is pretty crazy. I'm reading that Capcom's share price has taken a hammering because it's taken a nose dive, and they were doing so well before (there goes my Dino Crisis remake). Once again we see just how unpredictable and unreliable live service games can be. We're talking about the best-selling game of the year here and now it's doing so badly it's tanking the entire company. This madness has got to end. Just make a game and release some DLC if you have to, it doesn't need to be any more complicated than that. Focus Email your comments to: gamecentral@ Pre-deforestation After waiting for a price drop I've finally got Assassin's Creed Shadows. I don't know what your review said but if I'm honest I'm disappointed in it. Whenever you're running in the open you either can't see in front of your nose, because of the 20 million trees and bushes they have put in it, or you're sliding back down a hill you can't climb. It's like they went to Japan, counted the trees and bushes, and timesed them buy a 100 and said that's how many is needed. It's not the worst Assassin's Creed, all the others I've 100% but this one I might give it a miss. Also, if I'm honest, it's boring. The best one I've played has to be Assassin's Creed Origins with the DLC. I don't know what it is but I love ancient Egypt and that game ticked all the boxes. David Never beaten on price Vampire Survivors on the Switch must be the best value for money I've ever spent on games. Still playing the base game months after buying it, the more you play it the more things unlock. Just bought the Ode To Castlevania DLC, which is really good as well. Full credit to the developers, no microtransactions or any other rubbish. Long story cut short, it's just a really good game if you like the old games like Smash T.V. and Robotron 2084 (yes, I'm old). Chevy Malibu (PSN ID) PS: The base game and the Ode DLC cost me about 8 quid… not even two pints nowadays. Super Pocket change I pulled the trigger only last week on the Evercade Neo Geo Super Pocket and it was by sheer accident that I found out about it whilst I was browsing online. The 14 games included are Metal Slug X, Fatal Fury Special, Samurai Showdown 2, Alpha Mission 2, Blazing Star, King Of The Monsters 2: The Next Thing, Last Resort, Mutation Nation, Over Top, Sengoku 3, Shock Troopers: 2nd Squad, Soccer Brawl, The Last Blade, and Top Hunter: Roddy & Cathy. Personally, three of my standout favourites are Over Top, Soccer Brawl, and King Of The Monsters 2. I'd never played any of these before, never mind heard of them? There all so addictive and simple to play. The 2.8″ screen is very clear and bright even for my late young 50s eyesight. The built-in rechargeable battery last approximately four hours on a single charge and the build quality is pretty decent too. In all honesty, I think £50 with 14 games included is an actual steal especially in this day and age. HAJ GC: King Of The Monsters is fairly well known, for a Neo Geo game. The underrated Godzilla: Destroy All Monsters Melee always felt like a spiritual successor. New outlet Animal Well is getting a physical release from the new game shop site Lost in Cult, based in the UK. It is £29.99 plus £6 postage, which is a lot cheaper than buying the Limited Run version from eBay like I was thinking of doing, until I saw this release. I've pre-ordered a copy at that price. There are a choice of two covers for PlayStation 5 or Switch physical standard versions. They do take the money up front though when you pre-order. take the money just before dispatch and they have the games listed but not available to pre-order yet. Lost in Cult also have Thank Goodness You're Here! and Immortality standard physical versions to pre-order too. Andrew I have been avoiding the game sites today, so when I watch the new Nintendo Direct I watch it without any spoilers. Currently playing: The Last Campfire (PS4 version on PS5) and The Messenger (PS5 physical version) Hard memories Definitely a great anniversary to celebrate the Amiga 1000 and all the versions of the Amiga that came out after. My first gaming machine was the Commodore Amiga 500 Plus with the Cartoon Classics package, including The Simpsons: Bart Vs. The Space Mutants, Lemmings, Captain Planet, and Deluxe Paint 3. All of these were varying in quality but Lemmings was the exceptional one, with it becoming a super classic game. I found a lot of these games very challenging and very old school, with not many mechanics which I enjoyed as much as the later SNES and Mega Drive games. Bart Vs. The Space Mutants was so difficult, with extreme precision jumping and some not too obvious puzzles and was something I had to admit defeat on. To be honest, the amount of games I completed on the Amiga was so low in comparison to ones I failed at, though not through lack of trying. I think games were still being designed like the Spectrum and old Commodore games and were harder than FromSoftware's games. I think that's why I preferred the later 16-bit consoles. As hard as games were they weren't as hard as the retro games of this home generation of gaming computers in the '80s and '90s. But games like Turrican, Mega-Lo-Mania, Chaos Engine, Monkey Island, Canon Fodder, Speedball, North And South, Zool, Shadow Of The Beast, Wolfchild, and Jim Power. All or most where graphically amazing at the time, with some awesome, memorable tunes. Overall, it was a great system, with Lemmings being the best at adapting difficulty and making it a fair learning curve. But the memories were great and got me interested in gaming and set my course for my gaming hobby into console gaming and on into the present day. So there's a lot to celebrate the 40th anniversary of one of gaming's finest bits of technology. Alucard Inbox also-rans I don't know what to say about that Pikachu with breasts story except… wow. Actually I do know what to say: can I have someone of what those marketing execs are having. Lobo I'd never dream of playing an online shooter for any stretch of time, so I have no real interest in Battlefield 6, but I've got to say, those are some nice graphics it's sporting. Gangrene More Trending Email your comments to: gamecentral@ The small print New Inbox updates appear every weekday morning, with special Hot Topic Inboxes at the weekend. Readers' letters are used on merit and may be edited for length and content. You can also submit your own 500 to 600-word Reader's Feature at any time via email or our Submit Stuff page, which if used will be shown in the next available weekend slot. You can also leave your comments below and don't forget to follow us on Twitter. MORE: Games Inbox: When is the next State of Play for PS5? MORE: Games Inbox: Is there a secret Nintendo Switch 2 Christmas game? MORE: Games Inbox: Are gamers too entitled about video games?
Geeky Gadgets
2 days ago
- Geeky Gadgets
AirPods Pro 3 Just Leaked: Apple's Next-Level Audio!
Apple's AirPods Pro 3 could mark a pivotal moment in the evolution of wireless earbuds. With rumors swirling about advanced features and significant design upgrades, this release has the potential to reshape the premium audio market. As competition in the sector intensifies and growth slows, Apple's ability to maintain its dominance may depend heavily on the success of this product. Here's an in-depth look at the anticipated features, market dynamics, and what this could mean for consumers and the industry in a new video from SaranByte. Apple's Role in the Wireless Earbuds Market Apple has consistently been a leader in the premium wireless earbuds market, but the competitive landscape is becoming increasingly crowded. Major players like Samsung and Sony continue to innovate, while budget-friendly brands such as Xiaomi and JBL are gaining traction. Despite this, Apple's AirPods Pro remain a cornerstone of its revenue, underscoring their importance to the company's ecosystem. In the United States, an estimated 44% of iPhone users own Bluetooth earbuds, with 59% of them choosing AirPods. However, Apple's market share has shown signs of plateauing, reflecting a maturing market. The AirPods Pro 3 could be a critical product for Apple to not only sustain its leadership but also to reinvigorate interest in its audio lineup. By addressing emerging consumer needs and introducing innovative features, Apple aims to stay ahead of its competitors in this increasingly saturated space. What to Expect: Rumored Features of the AirPods Pro 3 The AirPods Pro 3 are rumored to bring a host of upgrades that could set them apart from competitors. These enhancements are expected to appeal to a wide range of users, from audiophiles to fitness enthusiasts. Here's a closer look at the most talked-about features: Design Refinements: The AirPods Pro 3 are expected to feature a slimmer case with a hidden LED indicator and a capacitive button for added functionality. While the iconic stem design is likely to remain, Apple may introduce new color options to appeal to a broader audience. However, the classic white finish is expected to remain the default choice. The AirPods Pro 3 are expected to feature a slimmer case with a hidden LED indicator and a capacitive button for added functionality. While the iconic stem design is likely to remain, Apple may introduce new color options to appeal to a broader audience. However, the classic white finish is expected to remain the default choice. Performance Upgrades: Powered by the rumored H3 chipset, the AirPods Pro 3 could deliver improved noise cancellation, enhanced transparency modes, and better spatial audio. Additionally, the new chipset is expected to improve battery efficiency, making sure longer listening times. Powered by the rumored H3 chipset, the AirPods Pro 3 could deliver improved noise cancellation, enhanced transparency modes, and better spatial audio. Additionally, the new chipset is expected to improve battery efficiency, making sure longer listening times. Health Monitoring: The inclusion of in-ear heart rate sensors and temperature tracking could position the AirPods Pro 3 as a hybrid device. These features are likely to appeal to fitness enthusiasts and health-conscious users, further integrating Apple's ecosystem into daily wellness routines. The inclusion of in-ear heart rate sensors and temperature tracking could position the AirPods Pro 3 as a hybrid device. These features are likely to appeal to fitness enthusiasts and health-conscious users, further integrating Apple's ecosystem into daily wellness routines. Real-Time Translation: On-device live language translation could make these earbuds a must-have for travelers and professionals. While initial language support may be limited, this feature has the potential to transform communication across language barriers. These rumored features suggest that Apple is not merely refining its audio technology but also expanding the functionality of its earbuds into new domains. By integrating health monitoring and real-time communication tools, the AirPods Pro 3 could appeal to a broader audience and redefine what consumers expect from wireless earbuds. Release Timeline and Pricing Speculation The release date for the AirPods Pro 3 remains a topic of speculation. Some industry analysts predict a launch as early as late 2023, while others suggest a 2025 release. Recent code leaks and inventory clearance sales have fueled rumors of an imminent debut, but Apple has yet to make any official announcements. As for pricing, the AirPods Pro 3 are expected to see a modest increase from the current $249 price point. Analysts speculate that the new model could be priced between $279 and $299, reflecting the addition of advanced features and positioning the earbuds firmly in the premium segment of the market. While this price increase may deter some budget-conscious buyers, Apple's reputation for quality and innovation could justify the cost for many consumers. Why the AirPods Pro 3 Matter The AirPods Pro 3 represent more than just an incremental upgrade; they are a strategic move by Apple to solidify its position in the premium audio market. By addressing emerging consumer demands—such as health tracking, real-time translation, and improved audio performance—Apple aims to stay ahead of its competitors in a market that is showing signs of slowing growth. For potential buyers, the AirPods Pro 3 promise a compelling blend of innovative technology and practical functionality. Whether you're drawn to the improved audio quality, the health monitoring features, or the sleek new design, these earbuds could offer significant value. As Apple continues to innovate, the AirPods Pro 3 may set a new standard for what wireless earbuds can achieve. Keep an eye on Apple's announcements, as this release could redefine your expectations for personal audio devices. Here are additional guides from our expansive article library that you may find useful on AirPods Pro 3. Source & Image Credit: SaranByte Latest Geeky Gadgets Deals Some of our articles include affiliate links. If you buy something through one of these links, Geeky Gadgets may earn an affiliate commission. Learn about our Disclosure Policy
