Shane O'Farrell: Dáil hears allegations driver in fatal hit and run was ‘garda informer'
Jim O'Callaghan
has apologised in the Dáil to the family of the law graduate killed in a hit-and-run incident while cycling near his Carrickmacross, Co Monaghan home, by a repeat offender out on bail.
Mr O'Callaghan has appointed a senior counsel to review the bail laws in memory of 23-year-old Shane O'Farrell and the Government is to establish a legal scholarship at UCD.
Road traffic legislation in place since 1962 will also be amended to allow a jury convict a person of a lesser offence of careless driving where a person is acquitted for the more serious offence of dangerous driving.
The O'Farrell family had called for a full public inquiry into his death in August 2011 when he was struck by Zigimantas Gridziuska, who should have been in prison at the time.
READ MORE
Mr O'Callaghan signalled however that instead of an inquiry, he has asked senior counsel Lorcan Staines to assess bail laws and identify any necessary changes that need to be made.
'This is not a report that needs to establish facts since those facts are very readily apparent from the charges laid against Garidziuska in the year leading up to the death of Shane O'Farrell.'
The minister said the report would not result in people having to invoke their right and 'lawyering up in a process that would inevitably take years. More importantly, it will not need to establish any facts since the relevant facts are already known.'
During a Dáil debate Sinn Féin said Gridziuska was a 'garda informer' and had been protected 'above all else'.
Mr O'Farrell's family, who had campaigned since his death for an inquiry, were in the distinguished visitors' gallery for the apology and debate.
The minister said 'it is incumbent on me, as Minister for Justice to apologise to Shane O'Farrell and the O'Farrell family for the fact that the criminal justice system did not protect him as it should have.
'I do so apologise.'
Mr O'Callaghan said 'the loss resulting from his death was incalculable and for the family, interminable'.
The State's first failing related to documentation for an appeal by Gridziuska, which was not recorded, the Minister said.
He added that the second failure happened when the offender, who committed further offences, was not brought before Judge John O'Hagan, who had granted bail on strict conditions, nor was the judge informed of those offences.
If the convictions had been brought to the judge's attention, Gridziuska would probably have been jailed.
Gridziuska, a Lithuanian national, left the scene of the fatal crash but the following day handed himself in to gardaí. He had more than 40 convictions at the time, including some in Northern Ireland.
Sinn Féin leader
Mary Lou McDonald
said there were credible allegations that he operated as a garda informant. The party's justice spokesman Matt Carthy said 'many people, myself included, believe that Zigimantas Gridziuska was an informer, that he was permitted to wreak havoc because gardaí prioritised the protection of their source above all else'.
Mr Carthy became emotional as he described Mr O'Farrell's mother Lucia as a force of nature whose efforts had resulted in this apology, adding that 'you've done Shane proud'.
Labour leader Ivana Bacik said the apology was 'welcome and overdue', adding that 'it is an important day'.
Fianna Fáil TD John McGuinness, a long-time campaigner on the case, paid tribute to the minister who 'despite obstacles', had shown 'leadership qualities that others should take note of', to 'ensure that justice is done'.
Social Democrats acting leader Cian O'Callaghan said the family's trauma, grief and heartache had been compounded by the State's response. He called for all reports on the Monaghan man's death to be published, as he noted that the Garda Síochána Ombudsman Commission had had the case for seven years.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Times
2 hours ago
- Irish Times
Man wins deportation appeal after evidence of being wanted by Nigerian police over same-sex activity
A Nigerian man has been allowed to apply for international protection despite having been deported from Ireland. The man, in his 30s, said he was forced to flee Nigeria in 2011 after being seen engaged in same-sex activities with another man. He appealed for asylum in Ireland on November 2nd, 2020, to the International Protection Office (IPO), but was turned down. The IPO decision was confirmed by the International Protection Appeals Tribunal (IPAT). READ MORE He was issued with a deportation order on June 18th last year and told to leave the State within a month. He was eventually deported last May. The man, whose name has not been given, submitted a claim that the police in Nigeria were looking for him last year, but IPAT did not consider it a credible piece of evidence. While in Lagos, he appealed again stating that as a gay man he could not live safely in Nigeria. Under that country's Same-Sex Marriage (Prohibition) Act 2014, those caught engaging in same-sex relationships can spend up to 14 years in jail. The man's legal counsel provided further evidence that the police were looking for him and gave corroborating evidence from other sources. The man was allowed to return to Ireland. The tribunal accepted a second police report from November 19th last year, confirming the man was being sought in connection with same-sex activities. The tribunal concluded that 'through no fault of his own' the man was unable to present the facts during his initial application. He could therefore apply again for international protection. The man works in a chicken farm in Co Monaghan and presented character references from his Irish employers. Speaking to RTÉ's Morning Ireland, on condition of anonymity, he described his experience of being deported. 'They did not take me to the deportation centre. They took me to the prison, so it was a very, very bad experience there,' he said. 'They asked me if I knew where I was going and I said no. They said I'm going to Lagos [Nigeria's largest city], so I said why, what is my offence? 'They said it's not their fault ... they're just doing their job, so they took us to the airport. 'The situation [in Nigeria] is very, very critical. If I want to go outside I have to wear a hoody and cover my face using a face mask. It's a very, very bad experience for me, honestly.'
Irish Times
4 hours ago
- Irish Times
The Irish Times view on the presidential election: the race now looks very different
The presidential election now looks very different after the shock withdrawal of the Fine Gael candidate Mairead McGuinness. The front-runner among the candidates declared so far, McGuinness said in a statement yesterday that she was dropping out of the race for health reasons. Her departure leaves just one candidate, Independent TD Catherine Connolly, who has enough support to be sure of a place on the ballot paper. She has the backing of the Social Democrats, Labour and People Before Profit. A number of potential Independent candidates are circling, though it is unclear how many could achieve a nomination. The race for the presidency was already slow getting under way, with Fianna Fáil and Sinn Féin still considering their options. Now Fine Gael needs to think again, too. Potential Independent candidates will also be mulling the changed outlook for the poll. The big parties need to realise that choice is important for the voters. McGuinness, with a long and high-profile career in public life – most recently as a European commissioner – had shown up well in initial opinion polls. Of course, the field has not yet been declared and past experience shows that the campaign can change everything, in what has often been a brutal process. Nonetheless, Fine Gael would have been confident of a strong showing and for voters the presence of McGuinness and Connolly would have provided two contrasting options. READ MORE Fine Gael, which always seemed well-placed to put forward a candidate, will now need to look to its 'bench' and figures like Seán Kelly and Frances Fitzgerald may come back into the frame. Observers have felt all along that Fianna Fáil would, eventually, put up a nominee. With a left-wing candidate already in the field, Sinn Féin's intentions will also be closely watched. Any nominee from one of the big three parties starts with a support base – and would thus have to be taken seriously. As they are able to guarantee a nomination, the big parties, while not in complete control of the process, have a strong hand to play. And they can also – between them – block Independents from entering the race, if they choose to do so. This does not mean Independents will not feature – nor that one or two might not do well. But they first have to jump the high bar of getting on the ballot. Voters will need to consider what they want from the president and what qualities they value. And it is important that the process delivers them a good choice. The job requires a mix of political nous, judgment and an ability to reflect the national mood. Michael D Higgins has been popular in part because of his willingness to speak out. With the departure of McGuinness, the race to succeed him has now got even more unpredictable.
Irish Times
4 hours ago
- Irish Times
Schoolteacher who defrauded colleagues of €2,000 barred from teaching for at least five years
A primary schoolteacher who defrauded three of her work colleagues of more than €2,000 and who owes almost €1,000 to the school where she worked has been removed from the register of teachers for at least five years. The teacher may not apply for readmission for five years, and the panel 'cannot say when, if ever' she would be readmitted, said chairman Paul Moroney. The inquiry concerned allegations that the teacher dishonestly induced a teaching colleague and two Special Needs Assistants (SNAs) at the school to give her more than €2,000 in September and October 2021 for Apple goods which were not subsequently delivered. The teacher received, via Revolut, €1,102 from her teaching colleague and €375 and €545 from the two SNAs, respectively. READ MORE The inquiry also heard allegations that the teacher received two payments of €500 each at the beginning of September 2021, by way of a loan from the school board of management. Only €50 has been repaid. At a previous hearing in May of this year, the inquiry heard that these payments were made as the teacher had recently started at the school and by then had not received any wages from the Department of Education. The inquiry also heard that for a prolonged period, the teacher had falsely represented that she had put in place a system to repay the money owed to the board of management. At the hearing in May, the panel found that the allegations were proven in fact and that they amounted to professional misconduct and breaches of the Code of Conduct for Teachers. Mr Moroney said that the behaviour of the teacher in the first three allegations related to the Apple money was 'disgraceful [and] dishonourable'. Regarding the money owed to the board of management, Mr Moroney said that the teacher was trusted to repay these funds, the non-repayment of which served to deprive the students of the school of this sum. Mr Moroney further noted that the teacher appeared to have a lack of empathy for her victims and that she provided 'little or no expert report' regarding the mental health ground advanced as a mitigating factor. Consequently, the panel was not persuaded that there was any health issue regarding mitigation. The inquiry had heard that at the time the allegations occurred the teacher was suffering from a gambling addiction and that she had been affected by several personal tragedies, including the loss of family members and relations and a burglary at her apartment carried out by two criminals. While the panel in its reasoning for its decision also noted that the teacher had made a limited apology, Mr Moroney said that even now, the teacher demonstrated no meaningful insight. The panel acknowledged, as an additional mitigating factor, that the teacher repaid her three work colleagues. The teacher, school and witnesses could not be identified, by order of the panel. The director of the Teaching Council, who was represented by Fieldfisher Solicitors, made the complaint against the teacher, who did not attend today's proceedings and was not represented. The teacher has already appeared in court concerning the allegations of deceiving her colleagues, for which she did not receive a conviction. After a plea of mitigation, the Probation Act was applied. The teacher has resigned from her position at the school.
