Front-line organizations sound alarm after Quebec moves to limit safe consumption sites
By
Organizations on the front lines of the overdose crisis sounded alarm bells Thursday over a bill that would ban safe consumption sites within 150 metres of schools and daycares — and could potentially extend those same restrictions to any centre offering services to unhoused Quebecers.
A letter signed by 25 local and national organizations, including the Association des intervenants en dépendance du Québec (AIDQ) and Doctors of the World Canada, says the bill 'could hinder access to essential services' for those who consume drugs or are unhoused.
Tabled by Social Services Minister Lionel Carmant Tuesday, Bill 103 follows controversy over the 2024 opening of Maison Benoît Labre, a supervised drug consumption and transitional housing centre close to Victor-Rousselot elementary school in St-Henri. If passed, the legislation would ban safe consumption sites within a 150-metre radius of a school or daycare and give the minister authority to extend that ban to centres serving unhoused populations, such as shelters. It would also grant the minister veto power over proposed facilities, regardless of proximity to a school or daycare.
A similar ban on supervised consumption sites near schools and daycares was passed by the Ontario legislature in 2024. In March, an Ontario judge suspended its implementation pending a charter challenge.
The Coalition Avenir Québec government's bill comes at a time when overdose deaths in the province are at a high. The Institut national de santé publique du Québec reports that overdoses killed 645 people in 2024, a 20 per cent increase from 2023.
'Our initial reaction was to be stunned,' said AIDQ chair Louis Letellier de St-Just. 'This bill makes no sense and follows no logic.'
'We've weakened the work of safe consumption services, the work of organizations caring for unhoused people,' he said. 'At 150 metres, we don't have much room to manoeuvre in a city like Montreal.'
With the door left open to the ban extending to any services for unhoused people and an option for the minister to veto any proposed safe consumption site, front-line organizations are unsure of how the bill would be applied, he said.
'Personally, I'm deeply irritated,' said de St-Just, who co-founded the harm reduction organization Cactus Montreal and has worked in front-line social services for over 36 years. Carmant didn't consult with any of the 25 organizations that signed the letter, he said.
He said he understands concerns about safe consumption sites operating near schools and daycares, but that the bill is the wrong approach.
'These organizations aren't ignorant, they're not insensitive to the difficulties that their clientele can introduce to an environment,' de St-Just said. But 'they need to go where services are required.'
Ultimately, 'these are health services' that are being threatened, he said. Those providing services that respond to homelessness and the overdose crisis 'are not responsible for those crises. On the contrary, we mitigate their effects.'
Maison Benoît Labre opened in an area where homelessness already existed, de St-Just said, and took dozens of people off the streets.
'Of course there are improvements to be made. But instead of passing a bill, we could have established directives, had discussions that could have facilitated social cohesion.'
Front-line workers are bearing the brunt of the blame, he said, 'but it's thanks to them that we're able to diminish loss of life.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Global News
5 hours ago
- Global News
Quebec could break its poor air quality record as smoke sits over the province
Quebecers are being urged to take precautions as a special air quality statement is in effect Friday, with smoke from wildfires in the Canadian Prairies drifting into the province. Environment and Climate Change Canada (ECCC) says in a statement that the smoke is causing poor air quality for the entire Greater Montreal area and is reducing visibility, with conditions potentially persisting into Saturday. According to IQAir, a site that tracks air quality around the globe, Montreal ranked third in the world for worst air quality Friday, with Toronto and Santiago, Chile, coming in second and first, respectively. Detroit and Delhi ranked fourth and fifth. Get breaking National news For news impacting Canada and around the world, sign up for breaking news alerts delivered directly to you when they happen. Sign up for breaking National newsletter Sign Up By providing your email address, you have read and agree to Global News' Terms and Conditions and Privacy Policy Health officials are warning that as smoke levels rise, so do health risks — particularly for vulnerable populations. This includes seniors, pregnant individuals, infants, young children, those with chronic illnesses and outdoor workers. Story continues below advertisement 'People in these groups should avoid strenuous activities outdoors and seek medical attention if symptoms occur,' the advisory states. Common symptoms from smoke exposure may include eye, nose and throat irritation, headaches and mild coughing. More severe symptoms like wheezing, chest pain or a persistent cough should be treated as potentially serious and may require immediate medical attention. Residents are advised to stay indoors, keeping windows and doors closed, and to use a high-quality air filter or portable air cleaner if possible. For those who must go outside, a well-fitted N95 respirator can help reduce exposure to fine particles, although it doesn't eliminate all health risks. Officials also urge people to reschedule or reduce outdoor activities and events, and to check in on neighbours or loved ones who may be more susceptible to air pollution. If an extreme heat warning is issued alongside the air quality alert, authorities stress the importance of staying cool while also minimizing smoke exposure. Residents are encouraged to monitor updates from local health and environmental authorities as conditions can change quickly.
Montreal Gazette
a day ago
- Montreal Gazette
Relocating safe-consumption sites could worsen situation, Drouin tells hearing
By Montreal's public health director says the Quebec government should increase its support of a controversial safe-consumption site in St-Henri, not force it to move through new legislation. During consultations on the matter this week, Mylène Drouin spoke in support of Maison Benoît Labre, suggesting money should be put toward increasing its operating hours instead of relocating it. 'In the context of Maison Benoît Labre, if we relocate the supervised consumption services, in my opinion, we will worsen the situation,' Drouin told elected officials. 'Instead of investing in its relocation, I would add hours on weekends and evenings to ensure consumption can truly take place in a safe, dedicated location,' she added. Held over two days in Quebec City this week, the consultations explored Bill 103, the Quebec government's recent attempt to regulate where safe-consumption sites can operate in the province. Tabled by Social Services Minister Lionel Carmant in May, the bill seeks to bar the sites from operating within 150 metres of a school or daycare. It would also give the government the authority to extend certain restrictions to shelters for unhoused people. Under the bill, any sites operating within 150 metres of schools or daycares would be forced to relocate within four years. Maison Benoît Labre, which also offers transitional housing and drop-in services, told the consultations this week that relocating its safe-consumption services would cost at least $6 million. Throughout her testimony, Drouin stressed how the sites effectively prevent overdoses, limit infections and ease cohabitation tensions by reducing public drug use. She urged the government to reconsider any regulations that would make it harder for them to operate, noting they already follow strict oversight rules. She also suggested implementing a grandfather clause for those that already exist. 'We do not want to slow down their implementation,' Drouin said. 'Or undermine the agility we have in developing services to respond to this evolving crisis.' In response, Carmant asked Drouin if she has any concerns about how the sites near schools or daycares might add undue stress on parents or affect children's development. He specifically asked about the suggestion not to relocate the services at Maison Benoît Labre. 'What should we tell the parents,' he asked. 'We continue to involve them and raise awareness,' Drouin answered, noting that while local parents have expressed concerns, they've also shown empathy toward the situation. Although Montreal has five of the 12 safe-consumption sites in Quebec, when asked, Drouin noted that the provincial government did not consult the city's public health department while drafting the bill. In an email response on Thursday, a spokesperson for Carmant's office said the bill was drafted in collaboration with Quebec's public health department. Regional public health departments, she added, were allowed to submit briefs and were heard during the consultations. 'We have reviewed the briefs and they are currently being analyzed by our teams.' While Bill 103 mainly focuses on safe-consumption sites, it also allows for the provincial government to enforce stricter regulations on shelters and services for unhoused people. In a brief prepared for the consultations, the city of Montreal warned the province against legislating a single approach to address both the unhoused and drug overdose crises. 'Conflating these two types of services, or these two crises, can lead to inappropriate policies,' the city says in the document. According to the city, over the last five years, the five safe-consumption sites on its territory — not counting similar mobile services — have served more than 28,000 people. While much has been said about Maison Benoît Labre, the city noted how most of the sites have been operating in Montreal since 2017 without issue. 'The majority of these resources are well integrated into the urban fabric,' it said. Overall, given the density and high number of schools and daycares in Montreal, the city argues that the province's 150-metre rule would make it nearly impossible for new sites to open. It concluded that the bill would not only risk worsening the overdose crisis but may also lead to more public drug use, heightening social tensions and health risks. 'By conflating issues related to supervised consumption and homelessness, and by imposing uniform and centralized constraints,' the document says, 'this bill could exacerbate the problems it seeks to solve.'
Global News
a day ago
- Global News
Quebec announces $36M to improve pre-hospital services
The Legault government is releasing $35.8 million to improve access to pre-hospital emergency services, notably by increasing ambulance coverage. Health Minister Christian Dubé made the announcement Thursday, stating that the government's objective is to offer 'the best possible pre-hospital coverage to Quebecers in all regions.' Quebec will therefore add, starting this year, 35,000 hours of ambulance coverage service 'according to regional realities and observed needs.' Part of the money will also be used to convert shift schedules, during which paramedics must remain available 24 hours a day to respond to emergency calls, to hourly schedules. Get weekly health news Receive the latest medical news and health information delivered to you every Sunday. Sign up for weekly health newsletter Sign Up By providing your email address, you have read and agree to Global News' Terms and Conditions and Privacy Policy Furthermore, Quebec is tripling funding for the first responder program, increasing it from $11 million to $32.7 million for all regions. This announcement comes two weeks after the tabling of a report by interim Auditor General Alain Fortin, which highlighted that half of Quebecers live in a municipality without first responder services. Story continues below advertisement In these areas, 45 per cent of 'very urgent' calls are answered in more than 10 minutes. In rural areas, this proportion rises to 59%, noted Mr. Fortin. In his report, the interim auditor general reiterated the importance for a municipality to have a first responder service, since, in 73% of cases, they arrive before the paramedics to provide basic care. The Ministry of Health and Social Services hopes to increase population coverage from 50 to 80 percent by 2028. It notes that some fifty municipalities have expressed interest in establishing a new first responder service. 'This major announcement, which will ultimately triple investment in first responder services, demonstrates that we continue to invest massively to improve pre-hospital emergency services across Quebec,' Minister Dubé said in a press release. As announced earlier this year, the government is also maintaining its commitment to install 450 new defibrillators over the next year.
