Residents survey reveals ‘distrust'
"Stinging" and "sombre" were some of the adjectives they used at a council workshop yesterday to describe the results of the survey, which was released last week.
Conducted by an independent market research company earlier this year, the survey delivered some confronting results, such as only 17% of respondents thinking the council made decisions in the best interests of the district.
Council policy data analyst Nathan Brown said the results reflected a "general distrust and unhappiness" with the council, and a perception by residents they were not being listened to.
Deputy mayor Quentin Smith said trust in the council had taken a hit over the Wānaka Airport lease issue, and the trend had only worsened in the years since.
Cr Niki Gladding said staff tended to "manipulate" community engagement, either "conscious or subconsciously".
Staff bias had crept into consultation on such issues such as Project Manawa, Lakeview and outdoor dining fees.
Councillors were "constantly being denied information we need to make decisions", Cr Gladding said.
Cr Esther Whitehead said that the council needed to be more transparent and improve its communications.
She often read online comments by people who clearly did not know much about the issue they were concerned about.
Cr Cody Tucker said it was "frustrating" to read online comments by people he had known for many years, but who never contacted him directly about their concerns.
Cr Lisa Guy said some online criticism was "made up and personal", but there was plenty to improve on.
She gave the council's website an example of an "amateur hour" level of service.
"I hate searching our website — I can't find things."
Cr Gavin Bartlett said some of the community's frustration was due to a lack of understanding of how local government worked.
Some people thought it was easy to get things done and fix problems, and believed councillors were intent on pursuing personal agendas.
"Anyone who sits in a council meeting knows that's not the case."
Mayor Glyn Lewers said the council was dealing with an "all-encompassing" level of growth, but he would rather be mayor of a town that was growing than one that was not.
The survey results were a "baseline", and the council would take the next few months to absorb the lessons.
"I don't think we should be too hard on ourselves".
guy.williams@odt.co.nz
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Otago Daily Times
3 days ago
- Otago Daily Times
Backing urged for holiday park housing
A Dunedin city councillor is putting Aaron Lodge back on the agenda, urging the government to reconsider its stance and back the former holiday park for use as community accommodation. Cr Mandy Mayhem says the former Aaron Lodge Holiday Park, in Kaikorai Valley, would be "ideal" to provide housing for the city's homeless population. Last year, Dunedin Mayor Jules Radich pitched the disused site, owned by Kāinga Ora but up for sale, as a possible temporary housing complex for homeless people. Housing Minister Chris Bishop rejected the idea as the building lacked services required for those complex needs, although the council was welcome to continue assessment work, at its own cost. At Tuesday's council meeting, elected officials will consider Cr Mayhem's motion which requests the mayor write to Mr Bishop asking the government to reconsider the decision and "allow" the property to be used for accommodation. On-site yesterday, Cr Mayhem, who is running for mayor and council this election, said sending a letter to the government was the least the council could do. "We have an obligation to all of our residents to make sure they're safe, they're warm and they've got a roof over their heads," she said. "The government has that obligation to the whole nation." Mr Radich's proposal was a good idea; the lodge needed a "bit of paint and a tidy-up" and it was a shame the minister did not see a need for the accommodation in Dunedin, she said. "I certainly remember a time in my life as a young mum on the [Domestic Purposes Benefit] when I was one bill payment away from homelessness," Cr Mayhem said. "It could be anybody right now in this current cost-of-living crisis." Cr Mayhem said she lodged her motion after members of a housing hui held on Monday decided to write to Mr Bishop in support of accommodation at Aaron Lodge. Otago Housing Alliance leader and former Dunedin mayor Aaron Hawkins said it was important the government be reminded of Dunedin's needs, as it clearly was not a priority. However, the council also had a role to play — its decision earlier this year not to move ahead with planned expansion of Dunedin's community housing programme did not help matters, Mr Hawkins said. "There is clearly growing support in our community for their representatives to do more to help — that means more advocacy, yes, but also more action." Mr Radich said the council had "nothing to lose" by writing the letter and he would support the motion. "At the core of the issue" was government policy which did not appear to support emergency housing, he said. "It's a matter of having a partnership with government to do it," Mr Radich said. "It's not as simple as it might appear, but there's no harm in trying and I'm happy to have another go." The property was bought by Kāinga Ora for more than $4 million about four years ago. It has been on the market since January.
Otago Daily Times
4 days ago
- Otago Daily Times
Butter price drops 3.8% in global dairy trade auction
New Zealand's shopping public will be relieved soaring butter prices had some of their steam removed at Fonterra's global dairy trade (GDT) auction. An overall back-to-back rise will be music to dairy farmers' ears, but family shoppers will be honing in on butter prices dropping 3.8% to $12,220 a tonne. Overall prices increased marginally 0.7% for about 37,000 tonnes of dairy products sold overnight on Tuesday, including a 2.1% gain for the main staple of whole milk powder to nearly $6800. The average price across the range was nearly $7200 a tonne, up on a 1.1% gain at the last auction on July 15. Record butter prices have raised the ire of family shoppers, resulting in Fonterra chief executive Miles Hurrell stepping in to explain they had increased about 50% over the past year because of high global dairy prices. A GDT drop will increase expectations for this to show up in the domestic marketplace. However, the Fonterra leader indicated high prices for a butter block could stick around for longer as strong demand was still being seen internationally, particularly in China and Asia. Buttermilk powder fell 2% to $5166, while cheddar slipped 0.6% to $7750 and mozzarella 0.1% to $7945. On top of the advance for whole milk powder, anhydrous milk fat increased 1.2% to $11,995 and skim milk powder was up 0.4% to $4751. No lactose was offered. The result follows four consecutive auctions in negative territory, including a 4.1% overall drop in early July.
Scoop
6 days ago
- Scoop
Extensive Infrastructure Upgrades To Futureproof Upper Clutha's Wastewater Needs
Upgrades to Hāwea, Wānaka, and Albert Town's wastewater infrastructure are set to begin in early September 2025, responding to and futureproofing Upper Clutha's wastewater needs, providing additional capacity across the network, and helping to further protect the natural environment too. Queenstown Lakes District Council (QLDC) General Manager Property & Infrastructure, Tony Avery said the project would see an extensive range of work undertaken to improve local infrastructure and provide for current and future housing in the area. 'Existing infrastructure in Wānaka and Albert Town is fast approaching its capacity to effectively convey wastewater out to Project Pure Wastewater Treatment Plant (WWTP), and as many in Hāwea will be aware, the township's treatment plant has reached capacity too,' said Mr Avery. To address these constraints, the Upper Clutha Wastewater Conveyance Scheme project will see a range of improvements made to the area's wastewater network, including: A new wastewater pump station (WWPS) at Domain Road in Hāwea 12.5km of new wastewater pipeline connecting Domain Road to existing infrastructure at the Albert Town WWPS Upgrades to the existing Riverbank Road WWPS 7.4km of new wastewater pipeline connecting Riverbank Road WWPS and Albert Town WWPS to Project Pure. 'These upgrades will see wastewater from the Hāwea township being treated and disposed of at Project Pure, enable future connection of Hāwea Flats and Hāwea Campground, and allow for flows from Wānaka and Albert Town to be managed by two pump stations,' added Mr Avery. 'Ultimately, the network will be able to handle Upper Clutha's wastewater needs well into the future, treatment and disposal will be improved, and the network will be more resilient in the event of any unforeseen issues.' Physical work on the Upper Clutha Wastewater Conveyance Scheme is expected to begin in September 2025, with construction anticipated to be completed by early 2027, nearly a year earlier than initially anticipated. Hāwea's existing wastewater treatment plant will be decommissioned once the township's new pump station and pipeline are operating. As with any large construction project some disruption is likely once work on these upgrades begins, and will include noise, vibration, traffic management, and increased construction machinery movements around various work sites between Hāwea, Albert Town, and Project Pure near Wānaka Airport. Large parts of the new pipeline running from Hāwea to Project Pure will be installed on the side of State Highway 6 (SH6) or within rural road corridors, meaning most of the project's impacts will be limited to sections of temporary traffic management. Other key impacts will include disruption on both Camphill Road Bridge and Albert Town Bridge when installation of the new pipeline occurs in these locations. A detailed delivery plan is currently being worked on by the Contractor, and more information about these works and what to expect will be shared once this is completed.
