EXCLUSIVE: Raac homeowners in Dundee facing 'enormous anxiety' admits John Swinney
Speaking exclusively to The Courier, Mr Swinney said discussions were underway with both Westminster and local authorities over the issue.
Dundee has the most Raac-affected residential properties in Scotland with nearly 900 homes containing the defective concrete.
Dozens more have been confirmed in Monifieth.
Mr Swinney believes all levels of government will need to work together on a solution.
The Courier is asking people to sign this petition to help give homeowners and tenants a voice.
'I've got every sympathy with people who find themselves in this situation where they're dealing with Raac issues in the property,' said the first minister.
'It will obviously cause enormous anxiety for them.'
When asked if his Westminster colleagues would be raising the issue, Mr Swinney said talks were already underway.
He told The Courier: 'There have been discussions with the UK Government.
'There's obviously discussions with local authorities underway as well.
'So I'm certainly very happy to commit the Scottish Government to engaging in those discussions with other public authorities and with homeowners who are affected.
'I think it's important that all arms of government work together collaboratively to try to find solutions.'
Housing Minister Paul McLennan recently confirmed he will meet residents in Dundee, though no date has been set.
A major concern for homeowners is that any solution found at council level will not include them.
Dundee City Council says private owners must deal with the situation themselves.
Monifieth residents are waiting to hear if they will be included in any Angus Council efforts.
Mr Swinney said: 'There's obviously complex issues to be wrestled with here because there's interactions with individual home ownership and that needs to be carefully worked through and managed.
'The best way to do that is by having an active dialogue between all different levels of government and discussing those issues with members of the public who are affected.'
Last week, The Courier's Trapped By Raac campaign enlisted the help of local businesses who displayed posters directing people to the petition website.
Campaigners need 10,000 signatures by June 17 to get a voice at Westminster.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The National
2 hours ago
- The National
‘I should be living independently – but I can't afford it'
The full-time worker's inability to buy or rent her own place is highlighted as it was claimed that planning permission for build to rent and student accommodation outstrips affordable housing by over 20 to one in the city. Liz Davidson is just one of the many people affected by Glasgow's housing emergency. She has lived in Partick since she was five years old but says there is no way she could afford the new housing currently being built in the area. 'There are two developments going on near where I live, neither of which is at all affordable to me,' she said. READ MORE: Scottish Government minister joins march in support of Palestine 'I work a full-time job and they would want about 75% of my wages for a one-bedroom flat. Because of this, I've had to make the hard decision to stay living with my gran in her flat, which is a social home. 'At 37, I should be living independently and starting a family but I can't afford to. That's not my shame, it's Glasgow City Council's. They seem to think they're above the rules when it comes to building affordable housing.' The National Planning Framework 4's requirement is that all developments include 25% affordable homes or provide 'commuted sums' to help pay for infrastructure. However purpose built student accommodation is exempt from the rule, making it more attractive to investors. Campaign group Living Rent claim developments of purpose built student accommodation (PBSA) and build to rent in Glasgow outstrip affordable housing by 23 to one. They say only 447 units of affordable housing (mid-market rent and social housing) were approved between February 1 2023, and March 1 2025, while 53.7% of all applications granted planning permission are for PBSA developments in Glasgow. The majority of build-to-rent and PBSA developments are in the city centre, without any affordable housing units. The figures show that the council could be doing much more to alleviate the housing crisis, Living Rent claims. Only two developments by private corporations had an affordable housing contribution, one of 15% and the other of 13%, the Living Rent study says. In addition, the researchers could find no evidence of Glasgow City Council agreeing commuted sums for build-to-rent or private developments that failed to provide the 25% affordable housing component. The council declared a housing emergency in November 2023 citing an 'overwhelming increase' in homelessness. READ MORE: I went to the 'first legal wedding' at the Edinburgh Fringe – here's what it was like As of September 2024, there were more than 7000 people living in temporary accommodation, of which 3100 are children. This is costing the city £36 million a year for B&B spend, a 40% increase over the last three years. Glasgow has also seen a 22% increase in homelessness applications in the year from September 2023 to 4241. This is not helped by the rise in private rental prices. Since 2010, rent has increased 81.8% for a two bedroom property, over 30% above inflation (50%). Bianca Lopez, a Living Rent's spokesperson, said Glasgow was quickly becoming a city that prioritised the interests of developers over the wellbeing of its residents. 'Glaswegians don't need more student accommodation or expensive build-to-rent,' she said. 'We need social and affordable housing. 'Across Glasgow, people are being forced out of their communities, pushed into poverty and, in some cases, made homeless by the shortage of affordable places to live. 'Our report exposes the hypocrisy of Glasgow City Council and their failures to take action on affordable housing, despite announcing a housing emergency. 'It's unbelievable that the council has chosen to prioritise private developers' profits over the homes that Glasgow so badly needs.' Lopez said the council needed to prioritise affordable homes in its planning system and shift the balance away from unaffordable tenures such as PBSA and build to rent. 'It needs to implement the 25% requirement in NPF4 across the board. Only then will it be able to deliver the social and affordable housing that Glasgow deserves,' she said. What is the council saying? A Glasgow City Council spokesperson said: 'We do not recognise these figures. Around a half of all homes built in Glasgow every year are affordable/social, and comparing student rooms to new homes with a number of bedrooms is not comparing like for like. In Glasgow, there is a very high proportion of social homes built compared with the figures for any other Scottish or UK local authority.' The spokesperson added that planning applications did not lead to a development. 'If a housing association puts in a planning application for a development of social/affordable homes, then it will have support for funding and will in all likelihood be built out,' he said. 'This is not always the case for PBSA or build to rent.' However Living Rent said this was ignoring the 'fundamental point' of their research. 'The council is trying to pull the wool over our eyes by citing past data and ignoring the fundamental point of what our research says: their planning approvals are favouring unaffordable housing which will push up rents and push us out of the city centre,' said a spokesperson. 'Unless action is taken now, Glaswegians who have lived here their whole lives will be forced out by high rents and a lack of social housing. Glasgow needs social and affordable housing developments to be prioritised not PBSA and build-to-rent developments. 'If the developments that have received planning approval go ahead or developments seeking approval are granted permission, Glasgow and particularly the city centre would become increasingly gentrified. 'Our city centre will be a playground for the rich, all the while enabling foreign investment funds huge returns.' With regards to comparing student accommodation with other housing developments, Living Rent said it would be wrong to count a student development as one unit when it contained hundreds of beds. 'Many social housing developments did not specify the number of beds, so the 'unit' metric is imperfect but the closest way to compare what is being approved,' said the spokesperson. 'Even if we assume that a social home is on average 2.5 beds, approved purpose-built student accommodation and build-to-rent developments still vastly outstrip social and affordable housing by eight to one.'
The National
3 hours ago
- The National
Scottish Government minister marches in support of Palestine
In a post online, Housing Secretary Mairi McAllan shared an image of her marching in Scotland's "national demonstration" from Glasgow Green to the city centre, organised by the Scottish Palestine Solidarity Campaign. The MSP is pictured holding a sign which states: "Peace for Palestine now." She is also wearing a Medical Aid for Palestinians T-shirt. McAllan previously took part in a Stride for Palestinians, in aid of raising money for the charity. Alongside her constituency team, McAllan completed 107km on foot, representing the distance from Occupied East Jerusalem to Gaza. READ MORE: Israel in talks to resettle Palestinians in South Sudan, sources say Today I marched in Glasgow for every child and innocent Palestinian civilian being bombed, displaced and starved by the Israeli government," McAllan wrote on Instagram. "The atrocities must end! We must stand up and raise our voices against a genocide unfolding before our eyes. War crimes cannot be committed with impunity. "Leaders must act. Palestinians must be free." McAllan's words come after First Minister John Swinney said he is looking at a 'whole range of measures' to take against Israel amid its genocide in Gaza. The Scottish Government has come under mounting scrutiny over the public money it has continuously provided for these companies. The government agency Scottish Enterprise (SE) has given £8 million to 13 companies involved in weapons manufacturing since 2019 – although the SNP Government maintains that the funding doesn't go directly to the production of munitions and that 'due diligence' checks are thorough. However, that has been called into question given that, of the 199 human rights checks between 2021 and 2023, no firm ever failed. Pressure has also built around arms firms' links to Israel. Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu has said Israel plans to widen its coming military offensive with the mobilisation of forces expected to take weeks. Families of hostages fear the coming offensive further endangers the 50 hostages remaining in Gaza, just 20 of them thought to be alive. The United Nations is also warning that levels of starvation and malnutrition in Gaza are at their highest since the war began. Palestinians are drinking contaminated water as diseases spread, while some Israeli leaders continue to talk openly about the mass relocation of people from Gaza. Another 11 malnutrition-related deaths occurred in Gaza over the past 24 hours, the territory's health ministry said on Saturday, with one child among them. That brings malnutrition-related deaths during the war to 251. The UN and partners say getting aid into the territory of more than two million people, and then on to distribution points, remains highly challenging with Israeli restrictions and pressure from crowds of hungry Palestinians. The UN human rights office says at least 1760 people were killed while seeking aid between May 27 and Wednesday. In a statement, organisers of the Glasgow march stated: "The horror genocide continues. Having mass-bombed the Palestinians and their infrastructure, we now see the systematic starvation of a desperate, displaced population. READ MORE: European leaders speak with Donald Trump after Ukraine ceasefire talks "Skeletal babies are dying in front of the world's eyes, deprived of the most basic nutrition. Doctors and aid workers are collapsing from hunger and exhaustion, unable to help the injured and save lives. "Like scenes from a 'hunger games' movie, people approaching the regime's death trap 'aid' facilities are being shot as they scramble for a paltry bag of flour. "The whole dystopian spectacle is being watched by the regime's Western patrons, refusing to impose economic sanctions and an arms embargo. Starmer, Lammy and their cohorts belong in The Hague for their direct part in the apocalypse."
Daily Mail
3 hours ago
- Daily Mail
Why 'Albo the activist' has more in common with Liberal hero John Howard than he'd care to admit - and what it says about the future of Australia: PVO
Anthony Albanese is edging towards a paradox: a Labor PM who could end up echoing John Howard. Not in ideology, but in method. The shape of what's unfolding is familiar: govern from the centre, bank incremental gains and let time in office do the heavy lifting. But nobody could accuse either PM of failing to pursue passion projects, and not always successfully.
