B.C. Appeals Court finds agency's decision to remove kids ‘tainted by stereotype'
VANCOUVER – The B.C. Court of Appeal says an Indigenous mother who had her four kids temporarily removed from her care by a child welfare agency was discriminated against because the agency's view of the woman was 'tainted by stereotype.'
The Appeals Court ruled Thursday that a $150,000 human-rights award should be restored after the B.C. Supreme Court overturned a decision of the B.C. Human Rights Tribunal in January.
The ruling says the Vancouver Aboriginal Child and Family Services Society removed the woman's four children in 2016, and they were returned to her care three years later.
The mother, identified only as R.R. in the ruling, filed a complaint with the B.C. Human Rights Tribunal, claiming the decision to remove her kids was based on 'protected characteristics' in the province's human-rights code 'rather than her children's best interests.'
The tribunal found she was discriminated against by the society and awarded her $150,000, but the B.C. Supreme Court set aside the tribunal's decision, finding it would create 'an operational conflict between' the human-rights code and the Child, Family and Community Services Act and 'undermine social workers' ability to intervene in the best interests of the child.'
The three-judge panel of the Appeals Court ruled that 'racial or other stereotypes have no place in decisions to intervene' by child welfare agencies, and though the society's employees acted in good faith, the impact of their conduct was discriminatory and 'discrimination in law is about impact, not intent.'
'Indigenous persons, and Peoples, understand better than most the potentially devastating consequences of having a child forcibly removed from a parent's care,' the ruling says.
'Good intentions, in the face of ingrained biases, stereotypes and prejudices, are not enough to justify discriminatory impact.'
The appellate panel's ruling says there's no 'conflict' between the human-rights code and the act, finding they 'operate harmoniously.'
'The (Child, Family and Community Services Act) protects children while the code ensures child protection services are delivered free of discrimination,' the panel ruled.
Winnipeg Jets Game Days
On Winnipeg Jets game days, hockey writers Mike McIntyre and Ken Wiebe send news, notes and quotes from the morning skate, as well as injury updates and lineup decisions. Arrives a few hours prior to puck drop.
B.C.'s Human Rights Commissioner Kasari Govender was an intervener in the case, and said in a statement Thursday that she welcomed the court's finding.
'It is essential that people experiencing discrimination in the child welfare system can rely on the Human Rights Tribunal to fully consider and address discriminatory conduct and enforce their Human Rights Code-protected rights,' she said.
'I am pleased to see this confirmation that stereotypes have no place in child protection decisions.'
The Vancouver Aboriginal Child and Family Services Society's lawyers were not immediately available for comment on the ruling.
This report by The Canadian Press was first published May 8, 2025.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Toronto Star
6 hours ago
- Toronto Star
Judge upholds obstruction conviction for B.C. Mountie in Dale Culver case
A provincial court judge has ruled that the guilty verdict stands for an RCMP officer convicted of obstruction of justice in the case of an Indigenous man who died in police custody in 2017, clearing the way for sentencing. A statement from the British Columbia Civil Liberties Association says Judge Adrian Brooks dismissed the attempt by RCMP Const. Arthur Dalman to have the proceedings stayed, rejecting Dalman's claim that his Charter rights were breached.
Winnipeg Free Press
6 hours ago
- Winnipeg Free Press
Judge upholds obstruction conviction for B.C. Mountie in Dale Culver case
A provincial court judge has ruled that the guilty verdict stands for an RCMP officer convicted of obstruction of justice in the case of an Indigenous man who died in police custody in 2017, clearing the way for sentencing. A statement from the British Columbia Civil Liberties Association says Judge Adrian Brooks dismissed the attempt by RCMP Const. Arthur Dalman to have the proceedings stayed, rejecting Dalman's claim that his Charter rights were breached. The B.C. Prosecution Service has confirmed the ruling, which communications counsel Damienne Darby says was released on May 29. Dalman was found guilty last July of obstruction of justice for ordering witnesses to delete video footage taken at the time Dale Culver was arrested in Prince George. The civil liberties association says officers used pepper spray during the 'violent' arrest and Culver died about 30 minutes later after complaining of breathing difficulties. The Independent Investigations Office of B.C. recommended charges in 2020 after finding reasonable grounds to believe two officers may have committed offences related to the use of force and three others may have obstructed justice. But the civil liberties association says manslaughter charges against two officers were stayed last year, one obstruction charge was stayed and another officer was acquitted of obstruction, leaving Dalman as the only officer convicted in the case. The reasons for Brooks' judgment have not been released, and Darby said in a statement on Monday that Dalman's next appearance is on June 19 to set a date for a sentencing hearing. Culver was from the Gitxsan and Wet'suwet'en Nations. He was 35 years old at the time of his death. An RCMP release from the time said police had received a report about a man casing vehicles and found a suspect who tried to flee on a bicycle. The civil liberties association, meanwhile, said after Culver's death that it was aware of reports from eyewitnesses that he 'was taken forcibly to the ground by RCMP members immediately after exiting a liquor store, apparently unprovoked.' The group shared a statement from Culver's daughter, Lily Speed-Namox, following the judge's decision to uphold Dalman's conviction this week. The family has waited 'eight long years' for accountability, Speed-Namox says. 'I have somehow managed to remain positive about my feelings that eventually someone would be held accountable. 'Even if it's because Dalman lied under oath to 'protect' his fellow officers. How many people have to die before people realize that the justice system is broken?' In the earlier decision finding Dalman guilty of obstruction of justice, the same provincial court judge, Adrian Brooks, found the officer deliberately lied and his evidence was 'so fraught with illogical missteps … and so contradictory when compared with reliable evidence, that it (was) not worthy of any belief.' Culver's cousin, Debbie Pierre, says in a statement that Brooks' latest decision upholding Dalman's conviction marks a step toward accountability. 'But true justice goes beyond one decision. My vision is for a system where Indigenous lives are protected — not silenced — and where police are trained to de-escalate, not destroy. 'This is not just about Dale; it's about transforming a justice system that continues to fail our people. We will not stop until that change is real.' This report by The Canadian Press was first published June 9, 2025.
CTV News
7 hours ago
- CTV News
Man killed in single-vehicle rollover north of Chaplin, Sask.
An RCMP cruiser can be seen in this file photo. The Saskatchewan RCMP says a man was killed early Saturday morning in a single-vehicle rollover north of Chaplin, Sask. Emergency crews were called to a rural road around 1:15 a.m. Saturday, an RCMP news release said. The sole occupant of the vehicle, a man who is not from Canada, was pronounced dead at the scene, the release said. RCMP said the man's family has been notified and that no additional details about him will be released. The incident remains under investigation. Chaplin, Sask. is about 154 kilometres west of Regina.
