Federal appeals court rules against Trump's birthright citizenship executive order
The 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals in San Francisco affirmed a lower court's decision blocking the nationwide enforcement of the EO, which would deny citizenship to babies born to people illegally or temporarily in the U.S.
A three-judge panel ruled against Trump's plan in a 2-1 vote, keeping a decision first made by U.S. District Judge John C. Coughenour in Seattle in place.
"The district court correctly concluded that the Executive Order's proposed interpretation, denying citizenship to many persons born in the United States, is unconstitutional. We fully agree," the majority wrote.
Though the Supreme Court has since restricted lower courts from issuing nationwide injunctions, the majority in the 9th Circuit ruled against the EO after discovering the case fell under an exception left open by SCOTUS justices.
States filed the case against the Trump administration after arguing that a nationwide order is needed to block the EO in order to prevent problems that would arise from birthright citizenship being outlawed in some states.
"We conclude that the district court did not abuse its discretion in issuing a universal injunction in order to give the States complete relief," wrote Judges Michael Hawkins and Ronald Gould, both of whom were appointed by former President Bill Clinton.
Judge Patrick Bumatay, a Trump appointee, dissented after deciding that states don't have the legal right or standing to sue the Trump administration over this.
He did not weigh in on the constitutionality of ending birthright citizenship.
The Citizenship Clause of the 14th Amendment states that people born or naturalized in the U.S., or "subject to United States jurisdiction," are American citizens, but Department of Justice attorneys argue that does not mean children are automatically American citizens based solely on birth location.
Trump's EO would deny American citizenship to a child born to a mother without legal or permanent status in the U.S., and whose father does not hold legal or permanent status.
The Trump administration is facing at least nine lawsuits across the country challenging the EO.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
2 minutes ago
- Yahoo
Trump seeks sway over Los Angeles Olympics with new task force
Donald Trump on Tuesday established a task force that he will lead on the 2028 Olympic Games in Los Angeles, a Democrat-run city that has frequently clashed with the Republican US president. The group will engage the federal government to "ensure the Games are safe, seamless and historically successful," potentially offering Trump and his allies greater influence over the sporting event. Trump will serve as chairman and Vice President JD Vance will be vice-chair of the task force, which will encompass several other leaders in his administration. Signing an order to establish the group Tuesday, Trump said "we'll do anything necessary to keep the Olympics safe" -- including potentially deploying "our National Guard or military." He enraged Los Angeles and state officials in June with his highly unusual decision to deploy California's National Guard against the wishes of Governor Gavin Newsom. Trump claimed the deployment was necessary to quell protests that had flared up against federal immigration raids in Los Angeles, which has a huge migrant population. On Tuesday he doubled down on his feud with Karen Bass, the city's Democratic mayor, by labeling her "not very competent." Trump has previously criticized her response to wildfires that impacted Los Angeles in January. However, Casey Wasserman, the chairman of the 2028 LA Olympics organizing committee, gave no hints of animosity as he joined Trump for the task force announcement at the White House. "You've been supportive and helpful every step of the way. And we wouldn't be here without you," Wasserman said. Los Angeles was awarded the 2028 Olympic and Paralympic Games in September 2017, during Trump's first term. Wasserman also flattered the president with examples of gold, silver and bronze medals that were given to athletes the last time Los Angeles hosted the Games in 1984. And he offered Trump a chance to carry the Olympic flame -- something he has already done in New York ahead of the Athens Games in 2004. "For the first time in history, we are going to take the Olympic torch relay to all 50 states," Wasserman said. "And sir, if you'd like to run on Park Avenue again to revisit history, you're more than welcome," he told Trump. Trump's second term will coincide with the 2026 FIFA World Cup and the 2028 Olympics -- two major global sporting events taking place in the United States. He has previously targeted transgender individuals, particularly athletes, and further stated on Tuesday that the "United States will not let men steal trophies from women at the 2028 Olympics." Asked about genetic testing for participating athletes, Trump said: "There will be a very, very strong form of testing and if the test doesn't come out appropriately, they won't be in the Olympics." aue/bjt/sla
Yahoo
2 minutes ago
- Yahoo
Abbott Asks Texas Supreme Court To Remove Democratic Leader From Office
In a significant escalation of his spat with Texas Democrats who left the state to stop a controversial redistricting vote, Gov. Greg Abbott (R) has asked the Texas Supreme Court to remove Rep. Gene Wu, chair of the House Democratic Caucus, from office. A statement from Abbott's office identifies Wu as the 'ringleader' in Texas House Democrats' strategic effort to block a GOP-friendly redistricting vote by having dozens of them leave the state, denying the Republican-controlled House a quorum. 'Representative Wu and the other Texas House Democrats have shown a willful refusal to return, and their absence for an indefinite period of time deprives the House of the quorum needed to meet and conduct business on behalf of Texans,' Abbott said. 'Texas House Democrats abandoned their duty to Texans, and there must be consequences.' The emergency petition describes the Democrats' departure as a 'hijacking of Texas government' and accuses them of impeding democracy. 'If representatives are free not to show up whenever they choose, then Texans simply do not have a representative government,' the petition states. 'In fact, they don't have a functioning government at all.' Wu's office did not immediately return a request for comment on the matter. It's unclear whether Abbott's petition has any legal standing, but the Texas Supreme Court is comprised entirely of Republicans, and Chief Justice Jimmy Blacklock was formerly Abbott's general counsel, The Texas Tribune noted. Wu traveled to Illinois on Sunday ahead of Monday's vote on the proposed redistricting, which would create five new GOP-leaning districts. President Donald Trump, who seeks to maintain Republican control of the House in next year's midterms, has said the GOP is 'entitled' to the redistricting. 'We're doing this because we don't have a choice,' Wu, who will remain out of state until further notice, said in a social media video Sunday. 'This is the last tool we have to stop Trump and to stop the destruction of our communities. This is not a fight for just Democrats, or even Texans. This is a fight for all Americans, because if this spreads everywhere, if politicians can simply stop listening to their people, it's over.' Abbott's effort to expel Wu comes the same day Texas Sen. John Cornyn (R) asked the FBI to help track down and arrest all the Democrats who left the state, saying they've 'committed potential criminal acts in their rush to avoid their constitutional responsibilities.' Related... Sen. Cornyn Asks FBI To Help Track Down, Arrest Texas Democrats Trump's Redistricting Fight Could Broaden And Last A While With Texas And California As Epicenters Texas Dems Prevent Trump-Backed Redistricting Vote Despite Abbott's Threats
Yahoo
2 minutes ago
- Yahoo
Russian oligarch's superyacht to be auctioned in US
A luxurious superyacht seized by the US authorities from sanctioned Russian billionaire Suleiman Kerimov is headed to the auction block. The 348-foot (106-metre) Amadea has a helipad, pool, jacuzzi, gym, spa, beauty salon and eight staterooms that can accommodate 16 guests, according to The yacht, which has been valued at more than $300 million, was seized from the Russian oligarch in Fiji in April 2022 and is currently berthed in San Diego, California. The auction is being held by National Maritime Services, a Fort Lauderdale, Florida, company. Sealed bids are being accepted until September 10 and require a $10 million initial bid deposit. The yacht is headed to the auction block after a US judge in March dismissed a competing claim to ownership of the vessel. Another wealthy Russian, Eduard Khudainatov, the former head of Russian state oil and gas company Rosneft, claimed in a New York court to be the rightful owner of the Amadea but his claim was dismissed by District Judge Dale Ho. According to prosecutors, Khudainatov was a "straw owner" of the Amadea and the true owner was Kerimov, a close ally of Russian President Vladimir Putin who was sanctioned by the United States in 2018 and again in 2022 after the Russian invasion of Ukraine. Following the invasion, the Justice Department under then-president Joe Biden began seizing the assets of Russian oligarchs close to Putin, an operation known as Task Force KleptoCapture. President Donald Trump disbanded the task force after taking office. The US Congress passed legislation last year that allows for the sale of seized Russian assets, with the proceeds going to provide humanitarian assistance to Ukraine. cl/st
