Photo group says it has 'suspended attribution' of historic Vietnam picture because of doubts
An organisation that honoured The Associated Press' Nick Ut with its 'photo of the year' in 1973 for a picture of a girl running from a napalm attack in the Vietnam War says it has 'suspended its attribution' to Ut because of doubts over who actually took it.
World Press Photo's report on Friday (May 16) adds to the muddle over an issue that has split the photographic community since a movie earlier this year, The Stringer, questioned Ut's authorship. The photo of a naked and terrified Kim Phuc became an iconic symbol of the war's tragedy.
After two investigations, The Associated Press said it found no definitive evidence to warrant stripping Ut's photo credit. The AP said it was possible Ut took the picture, but the passage of time made it impossible to fully prove, and could find no evidence to prove anyone else did.
World Press Photo said its probe found that two other photographers - Nguyen Thanh Nghe, the man mentioned in The Stringer and Huynh Cong Phuc -'may have been better positioned' to take the shot.
'We conclude that the level of doubt is too significant to maintain the existing attribution,' said Joumana El Zein Khoury, executive director of World Press Photo. 'At the same time, lacking conclusive evidence pointing definitively to another photographer, we cannot reassign authorship, either.'
World Press Photo, an organisation whose awards are considered influential in photography, won't attempt to recover the cash award given to Ut, a spokeswoman said.
Ut's lawyer, James Hornstein, said his client hadn't spoken to World Press Photo after some initial contact before The Stringer was released. 'It seems they had already made up their mind to punish Nick Ut from the start,' he said.
Gary Knight, a producer of The Stringer, is a four-time judge of the World Press Photo awards and was once a consultant to the World Press Photo Foundation.
The AP said Friday that its standards 'require proof and certainty to remove a credit and we have found that it is impossible to prove exactly what happened that day on the road or in the (AP) bureau over 50 years ago'.
'We understand World Press Photo has taken different action based on the same available information, and that is their prerogative,' the statement said. 'There is no question over AP's ownership of the photo.'
Meanwhile, the Pulitzer Prize that Ut won for the photo appears safe. The Pulitzers depend on news agencies that enter the awards to determine authorship, and administrator Marjorie Miller - a former AP senior editor - pointed to the AP's study showing insufficient proof to withdraw credit. 'The board does not anticipate future action at this time,' she said on Friday.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Independent Singapore
5 hours ago
- Independent Singapore
Kunlavut Vitidsarn and Chen Yu Fei successfully took home titles at the 2025 Singapore Badminton Open
SINGAPORE: Kunlavut Vitidsarn of Thailand and Chen Yu Fei of China took home victories at the end of the 2025 KFF Singapore Badminton Open at the Singapore Indoor Stadium. Vitidsarn won his fourth title this year in front of 7,700 spectators, and Chen clinched his first title here in Singapore, one year after she placed second. Kunlavut Vitidsarn's reign The Thai athlete, who is on track to become the world's No. 1 men's singles player, has won his second BWF Super 750 title in 2025. Vitidsarn defeated Lu Guang Zu of China in 37 minutes, with a final scoreline of 21-6, 21-10. 'To play against a Chinese athlete, it's never easy. It's always tough, but I just tried my best to do whatever I could to win the match… It's a good thing that I'm now the world No. 1. Of course, there's always pressure. But it's a good kind of pressure. I've already said in the beginning that I want to win all tournaments, and that's what I'm focused on now,' Vitidsarn expressed. Vitidsarn demonstrated his dominance through his speed and strong defence, accompanied by impressive shots, which left his opponent frustrated during the match. Moreover, due to this achievement, he will become the first Thai male athlete to reach the number one spot. Indeed, he has cemented his name as one of the best players this year. Chen Yu Fei's redemption On the women's side, Chen Yu Fei played a dedicated game to beat her fellow Chinese athlete, Wang Zhi, with a final score line of 21-11, 21-11. She finally won the KFF Singapore Badminton Open after finishing second last year. The former world No. 1 had a great week so far, having a big win against the current top-ranked An Se Young in the quarterfinals. With her win, Chen declared: 'I'm really, really happy. The match schedule was tough, and every round was a challenge. I just tried to take it one game at a time and not stress too much. I felt more relaxed this time, and that helped me play better.' See also Will the tide turn for Loh Kean Yew at Singapore Badminton Open? Updates on doubles Malaysia's world No. 3 doubles Aaron Chia and Soh Wooi Yik defeated South Korea's Kim Won Ho and Seo Seung Jae. After losing the first game, they had a comeback and won the next two matches to clinch the victory in 65 minutes, with a final scoreline of 15-21, 21-18, 21-18. This win is their third title of the year, alongside their victories at the Badminton Asia Championships and Thailand Open. In the women's double, South Korea's Kim Hye Jeong and Kong Hee Young also won their third title of the year. They defeated Rin Iwanaga and Kie Nakanishi of Japan with scores of 21-26, 21-14. The athletes also won earlier this year at the Orleans Masters and the Indonesia Masters. Furthermore, Thailand's Dechapol Puavaranukroh and Supissara Paewsampran finished strong and won the mixed doubles title after winning against Hong Kong's Tang Chun Man and Tse Ying Suet in straight games. The match's final scoreline is 21-16, 21-9. This was a memorable win for the pair as they lost to the same pair in the Thailand Open quarterfinals. Just like the previous pairs, this is also their third title of the year, following wins at the Malaysia Open and Thailand Masters. The 2025 KFF Singapore Badminton Open happened from May 21 to Jun 1, 2025, at Singapore Indoor Stadium. This event is part of the BWF World Tour Super 750 series and offered a total prize money of US$1 million.
CNA
6 hours ago
- CNA
Trial begins for Stars Engrg director, manager involved in 2021 Tuas explosion that killed three
SINGAPORE: The trial for the company behind an explosion at Tuas in 2021 that killed three workers and injured seven others opened in the State Courts on Tuesday (Jun 3). Stars Engrg, whose core business was the installation of fire protection systems, was the occupier of the premises at 32E Tuas Avenue 11, where the blast occurred on Feb 24, 2021. The company, its sole director Chua Xing Da and production manager Lwin Moe Tun are all contesting charges under the Workplace Safety and Health Act for safety lapses. Chua, a 41-year-old Singaporean, and Lwin Moe Tun, a 35-year-old Myanmar national, also face obstruction of justice charges relating to what they did after the accident. All three are represented by lawyer Chia Boon Teck, while Lwin Moe Tun is additionally represented by lawyer Foo Cheow Ming. An inquiry committee convened to look into the accident concluded in March 2022 that the explosion was mainly brought about by the company's failure to ensure the safe use of a mixer machine. Stars Engrg workers were preparing the machine to mix potato starch powder with heated water at their workshop in Tuas when the explosion happened. They were manufacturing 'fire clay' for use in an insulation wrap which goes around piping and ducting systems. The committee found that the initial rapture of an oil jacket resulted in the initial blast. This ignited potato starch powder that had accumulated in the air, causing subsequent flash fires. Court documents – agreed by both the prosecution and defence – set out the timeline of events leading to the explosion, including how employees had found the machine smoking and leaking on several occasions. Twelve days before the incident, a fire occurred at the machine and was put out by two employees. Another small fire occurred on the morning of the incident, hours before the explosion at 11.22am on Feb 24, 2021. The explosion was followed by three flash fires. The inferno was extinguished at 11.46am by the Singapore Civil Defence Force. PROSECUTION'S CASE Opening its case on Tuesday, the prosecution said that Chua bought the mixer machine in August 2019 from a company in China via the Alibaba online platform. The machine was installed on Jun 12, 2020. Stars Engrg and Chua used the mixer machine improperly and continued to use it despite "clear indications that it was unsafe to use", the prosecution said. "This created an environment of risk to the health and safety (of) every person at the worksite," Deputy Public Prosecutors Timotheus Koh, Grace Chua, Mohamed Riasudeen and Goh Qi Shuen said. They said that they will be leading evidence from Stars Engrg employees and experts to show that the company and Chua: Used insufficient thermic oil Operated the mixer machine as a "closed system" without pressure monitoring Failed to monitor the oil jacket temperature Continued using the mixer machine despite incidents that showed it was unsafe to use, and took inappropriate and insufficient steps to ensure that it was safe for continued use The company and Chua owed a duty of care to their employees but failed to ensure that they had adequate instruction, information, training and supervision to perform their work, the prosecution said. They also failed to ensure that safety measures were taken and failed to provide a safe environment for the employees. It added that Lwin Moe Tun negligently endangered the safety of Stars Engrg employees by allowing them to conduct repairs on the mixer machine's heater despite the risks involved. After the accident, Lwin Moe Tun allegedly asked Chua if he could delete a WhatsApp conversation between him and one of the deceased employees, Subbaiyan Marimuthu, on Feb 25, 2021. The conversation was eventually deleted. Both of them allegedly knew that deleting this communication could obstruct investigations into the incident, the prosecution said. VICTIMS AND INJURIES The three who died were employees working at the time of the incident. They are: Bangladeshi nationals Anisuzzaman Md, 29, Shohel Md, 23, and Indian national Subbaiyan Marimuthu, 38. Each sustained about 90 per cent or more total body surface area burns. Five other Stars Engrg employees - all Bangladeshi nationals - were hurt. They are Mr Ahmmed Lizon, Mr Hossain Jitu, Mr Mehedi, Mr Molla Md Yousuf, and Mr Rahad Asfaquzzaman. They sustained total body surface area burns of at least 35 per cent and have permanent disfiguration from their injuries. Another two men employed at a unit opposite the premises, Mr Miah Md Azam and Mr Zhao Jian Wang were also injured.
Independent Singapore
6 hours ago
- Independent Singapore
Steven Cheung, financially struggling, takes to Instagram asking for employment
HONG KONG: Even though singer Steven Cheung took on various jobs to make ends meet, he continues to face financial struggles and has publicly sought help, as reported by VnExpress. Photo: Instagram/Steven Cheung He took to Instagram and posted a Story, saying that he was in urgent need of a job opportunity and required HK$6,800 (S$1,116) today, and he said, 'Help me,' as reported by The Star . Difficult situation Cheung's wife, Au Yin Man, also took to Instagram to share a post about the couple's difficult situation. In a social media post, she shared her thoughts, saying that sometimes even a small amount of effort can turn things around in life, but then she also added that sometimes, even that's just not enough. Cheung and his wife are parents to four young boys, ranging in age from one to five years old. The couple has been struggling to make ends meet. Behind on their rent Things are tight for them right now. Au revealed that they're behind on their rent by a month and a half, and it costs them HK$15,000 monthly. She also mentioned that the landlord is threatening to kick them out if they don't pay the overdue rent by the end of the month. See also Netizens think that Cecilia Cheung is pregnant Cheung, 40, has held several jobs to support his family. He's done everything from setting up cable wires and working on construction sites to handing out flyers, delivering food, and even distributing condoms. Did not get many roles If you're wondering how Cheung got his start, it was in 2003 with a boy band. Before that, they were known as Boy'z but then switched to Sun Boy'z. They were quite popular in Hong Kong and even won several music awards. However, when the group disbanded in 2008, Cheung attempted to transition into acting, but his career didn't take off. He didn't get many good roles. Cheung tied the knot with Au, who's 34, back in 2019, but things have been tough for their family, especially after that cheating scandal in 2019, the one with four women, including actress April Leung. Following that, the singer was unable to secure a job, further worsening their financial difficulties. In 2003, Steven Cheung Chi-hang, 40, a singer from Hong Kong, made his debut as part of the boy group Boy'z. The duo, formed by Emperor Entertainment Group, also included Kenny Kwan. They were quite popular and received multiple music awards in Hong Kong. In 2005, Kwan left the group and was briefly replaced by Dennis Mak. Then, things shifted in 2006 when William Chan joined, and it was then that they decided to change their name to Sun Boy'z. However, in December 2008, the group officially called it quits.
