Attorneys get more time to argue over contested copper mine on land sacred to Apaches
Judge Dominic Lanza in a ruling issued Monday denied motions that sought to halt the transfer pending the outcome of the case. However, he did preclude the U.S. Forest Service from proceeding with the land exchange until 60 days after the agency issues a required environmental review.
Lanza said that would give the parties more time to analyze the environmental report and file amended complaints. He said granting a preliminary injunction now would be premature since the review will differ in some ways from the one that spurred the legal challenge four years ago.
'It is unfortunate that the result of this order will be to force the parties to engage in another stressful, abbreviated round of briefing and litigation activity' when the new review is issued, he said, acknowledging the unusual circumstances.
Attorneys for the federal government and the mining company agreed during a recent hearing to the 60-day delay. That time frame also is specified in the legislation that Congress passed and then-President Barack Obama signed in 2014 authorizing the exchange.
The group Apache Stronghold, the San Carlos Apache Tribe and others welcomed more time to fight for Oak Flat, an area they consider as holy.
'In this critical moment, we call on the Trump administration and Congress to halt the transfer to a Chinese-owned mine, and honor what is sacred,' said Wendsler Nosie Sr., leader of Apache Stronghold. 'As we continue to fight in court, know this: Nothing will turn us away from defending the spiritual essence of our people, the lifeblood that connects us to the creator and this land.'
A statement from Resolution Cooper said the ruling is consistent with prior decisions and gives the parties time to review the final environmental impact statement that will be issued later this month.
'We are confident the project satisfies all applicable legal requirements,' said Resolution president and general manager Vicky Peacey.
She added that years of consultation with tribes and communities resulted in changes to the mining plan to reduce potential effects.
The fight over Oak Flat dates back about 20 years, when legislation proposing the land exchange was first introduced. It failed repeatedly in Congress before being included in a must-pass national defense spending bill in 2014.
San Carlos Apache Chairman Terry Rambler said Monday that the bill was not in the best interest of the American people, Arizona or his tribe. He said concerns persist about the mine's use of groundwater and the pending obliteration of the culturally significant site.
Apache Stronghold and the tribe sued the U.S. government in 2021 to protect the place tribal members call Chi'chil Bildagoteel, which is dotted with ancient oak groves and traditional plants the Apaches consider essential to their religion. The U.S. Supreme Court recently rejected an appeal by the Apache group, letting lower court rulings stand.
The project has support in nearby Superior and other traditional mining towns in the area. The company — a subsidiary of international mining giants Rio Tinto and BHP — estimates the mine will generate $1 billion a year for Arizona's economy and create thousands of jobs.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Vancouver Sun
an hour ago
- Vancouver Sun
About 40% of Canadians, Americans believe lasting peace can be reached in Ukraine war: poll
Almost half of Canadians believe the federal government is providing the right amount of support to Ukraine in the war against Russia, while 14 per cent think Canada is not supportive enough, according to a new poll. The poll, which was conducted by Leger for the Metropolis Institute and the Association for Canadian Studies, compared Canadian and American opinions about the war, which started in 2014, but reached a new height in 2022 when Russia invaded Ukraine. The poll found that Americans were more likely to think their country isn't doing enough to support Ukraine. Just under one third (29 per cent) said the United States isn't doing enough, while 26 per cent said support was about right and 19 per cent said the U.S. has been too supportive. In Canada, 17 per cent of respondents thought their country was doing too much. Start your day with a roundup of B.C.-focused news and opinion. By signing up you consent to receive the above newsletter from Postmedia Network Inc. A welcome email is on its way. If you don't see it, please check your junk folder. The next issue of Sunrise will soon be in your inbox. Please try again Interested in more newsletters? Browse here. Almost half of Canadians said they've been following the conflict very closely (12 per cent) or somewhat closely (36 per cent), while 32 per cent said 'not very closely' and 16 per cent said they haven't been following the war at all. Americans have been paying about the same amount of attention, with 15 per cent following it very closely, 28 per cent somewhat closely, 27 per cent not very closely and a quarter of respondents in the U.S. saying they haven't been following the war at all. Among the 12 per cent of Canadians who are following the events in Ukraine closely, 47 per cent of them believe Canada supports Ukraine the right amount, while 38 per cent believe that Canada is not supportive enough. Jack Jedwab, president and CEO of the Association for Canadian Studies and the Metropolis Institute, said Canadians don't feel like they have much control over the outcome of the war. 'At this particular time, Canadians do not feel that their support is providing for a significant impact in that regard,' he said, adding that Canadians were more supportive of Ukraine at the start of the war. 'We're not seeing the same type of mobilization that we saw at the front of the conflict. You're not seeing a lot of Ukrainian flags or symbols out there,' he said. Fewer than half of Canadian respondents (47 per cent) said they have a fairly good understanding of the conflict, while 11 per cent said they have barely any understanding at all. Canadians over 35 years old feel like they have a better understanding of the conflict compared to those under 35, the poll found. 'Those people who are in those older cohorts feel they have a better understanding of the conflict than the younger cohorts do,' said Jedwab. 'That doesn't mean they're right or not right, but that's how they feel.' About half (49 per cent) of Canadians between 24 and 34 years old said that they have a good understanding, while 39 per cent of Canadians between 18 and 24 years old feel like they don't have the best understanding of the issue. Americans and Canadians have a similar view about whether or not lasting peace can be reached. A plurality (42 per cent of Canadians and 40 per cent of Americans) think it can, while 28 per cent of Canadians and 26 per cent of Americans think lasting peace cannot be reached. In both countries, about a third said they don't know. 'When you are in North America, we think all conflicts can be resolved. But unfortunately, in some parts of the world there's no quick fix,' said Jedwab. Men seem to be more optimistic than women, with 51 per cent and 34 per cent respectively believing lasting peace can be found between Russia and Ukraine. According to the British Ministry of Defence, more than one million Russian troops have been killed or injured in the past three years, and more than 400,000 Ukrainians have been killed or injured. The online survey of 1,511 Canadians and 1,011 Americans was conducted by Leger between June 6 and 8, 2025. A margin of error cannot be associated with a non-probability sample in a panel survey. A probability sample of 1,511 respondents in Canada would have a margin of error of plus or minus plus or minus 2.5 per cent, 19 times out of 20. Our website is the place for the latest breaking news, exclusive scoops, longreads and provocative commentary. Please bookmark and sign up for our daily newsletter, Posted, here .
Edmonton Journal
an hour ago
- Edmonton Journal
About 40% of Canadians, Americans believe lasting peace can be reached in Ukraine war: poll
Article content Almost half of Canadians believe the federal government is providing the right amount of support to Ukraine in the war against Russia, while 14 per cent think Canada is not supportive enough, according to a new poll. Article content The poll, which was conducted by Leger for the Metropolis Institute and the Association for Canadian Studies, compared Canadian and American opinions about the war, which started in 2014, but reached a new height in 2022 when Russia invaded Ukraine. Article content Article content Article content The poll found that Americans were more likely to think their country isn't doing enough to support Ukraine. Just under one third (29 per cent) said the United States isn't doing enough, while 26 per cent said support was about right and 19 per cent said the U.S. has been too supportive. In Canada, 17 per cent of respondents thought their country was doing too much. Article content Article content Almost half of Canadians said they've been following the conflict very closely (12 per cent) or somewhat closely (36 per cent), while 32 per cent said 'not very closely' and 16 per cent said they haven't been following the war at all. Americans have been paying about the same amount of attention, with 15 per cent following it very closely, 28 per cent somewhat closely, 27 per cent not very closely and a quarter of respondents in the U.S. saying they haven't been following the war at all. Article content Article content Among the 12 per cent of Canadians who are following the events in Ukraine closely, 47 per cent of them believe Canada supports Ukraine the right amount, while 38 per cent believe that Canada is not supportive enough. Article content Article content Jack Jedwab, president and CEO of the Association for Canadian Studies and the Metropolis Institute, said Canadians don't feel like they have much control over the outcome of the war. 'At this particular time, Canadians do not feel that their support is providing for a significant impact in that regard,' he said, adding that Canadians were more supportive of Ukraine at the start of the war. Article content 'We're not seeing the same type of mobilization that we saw at the front of the conflict. You're not seeing a lot of Ukrainian flags or symbols out there,' he said. Article content Fewer than half of Canadian respondents (47 per cent) said they have a fairly good understanding of the conflict, while 11 per cent said they have barely any understanding at all.
Calgary Herald
an hour ago
- Calgary Herald
About 40% of Canadians, Americans believe lasting peace can be reached in Ukraine war: poll
Almost half of Canadians believe the federal government is providing the right amount of support to Ukraine in the war against Russia, while 14 per cent think Canada is not supportive enough, according to a new poll. Article content The poll, which was conducted by Leger for the Metropolis Institute and the Association for Canadian Studies, compared Canadian and American opinions about the war, which started in 2014, but reached a new height in 2022 when Russia invaded Ukraine. Article content Article content Article content The poll found that Americans were more likely to think their country isn't doing enough to support Ukraine. Just under one third (29 per cent) said the United States isn't doing enough, while 26 per cent said support was about right and 19 per cent said the U.S. has been too supportive. In Canada, 17 per cent of respondents thought their country was doing too much. Article content Article content Almost half of Canadians said they've been following the conflict very closely (12 per cent) or somewhat closely (36 per cent), while 32 per cent said 'not very closely' and 16 per cent said they haven't been following the war at all. Americans have been paying about the same amount of attention, with 15 per cent following it very closely, 28 per cent somewhat closely, 27 per cent not very closely and a quarter of respondents in the U.S. saying they haven't been following the war at all. Article content Article content Among the 12 per cent of Canadians who are following the events in Ukraine closely, 47 per cent of them believe Canada supports Ukraine the right amount, while 38 per cent believe that Canada is not supportive enough. Article content Article content Jack Jedwab, president and CEO of the Association for Canadian Studies and the Metropolis Institute, said Canadians don't feel like they have much control over the outcome of the war. 'At this particular time, Canadians do not feel that their support is providing for a significant impact in that regard,' he said, adding that Canadians were more supportive of Ukraine at the start of the war. Article content 'We're not seeing the same type of mobilization that we saw at the front of the conflict. You're not seeing a lot of Ukrainian flags or symbols out there,' he said. Article content Fewer than half of Canadian respondents (47 per cent) said they have a fairly good understanding of the conflict, while 11 per cent said they have barely any understanding at all.
