Ludhiana: Consumer panel directs car dealer to pay ₹1 lakh
The complainant, Kavita Tyagi, proprietor of Everest Sports Academy, had approached Lally Motors in August 2022 to purchase a Volkswagen Taigun Highline in Wild Cherry Red colour. Due to the colour's unavailability, the dealership arranged a vehicle from their Chandigarh outlet and delivered it on August 22, 2022.
However, in March 2023, the complainant was surprised to see a 'service due' message on the car's dashboard. Upon inquiry, she was told the car was actually billed in March 2022—five months before delivery. This raised suspicion that she had been sold an older vehicle, despite being assured it was brand new.
Repeated calls and emails to the dealership went unanswered. A legal notice sent in May 2023 received a vague reply, in which the company admitted the earlier billing, calling it an 'internal matter' to hold a special colour variant.
Tyagi alleged that she suffered mental agony, harassment, and financial loss due to the misleading sale. She also raised concerns over the car's reduced warranty period and resale value. In response, Lally Motors offered to extend the vehicle's warranty by 10 months but did not accept any wrongdoing.
The car was serviced three times under warranty after she raised issues, including a malfunctioning airbag light and power window switches. However, the Commission found that while there was no manufacturing defect, the non-disclosure of the car's initial billing date and misleading information about its 'new' status amounted to unfair trade practice.
In its order, the Commission dismissed the complaint against the manufacturer, Skoda Auto Volkswagen India Pvt. Ltd., but held Lally Motors responsible for misleading the buyer. The firm has been directed to pay ₹1 lakh as compensation within 30 days, failing which it will attract 8% annual interest until full payment is made.
The order was passed by commission president Sanjeev Batra and member Monika Bhagat.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
India Today
10 hours ago
- India Today
No blacklisted vendors: Exam body responds to mismanagement charge
Amid nationwide protests by candidates over alleged large-scale mismanagement during the Staff Selection Commission (SSC) Phase 13 examinations, the Commission's Chairman responded, assuring that steps are being taken to address concerns and asserting transparency in the agency selection to India Today TV, Commission Chairman S Gopalakrishnan dismissed claims made by students and teachers that a blacklisted vendor was awarded the tender to conduct the exams. He also clarified that the change in exam centres for some candidates was due to limited availability and security considerations, and assured that the Commission is working to prevent such disruptions in the is the first time we have changed agencies, and hence some students faced issues. Some had to travel far because larger centres are not available in every city, while some cities only have smaller centres. We will resolve this in future exams. Secondly, in two locations, the exam was cancelled due to a security lapse. However, we re-conducted the test at those locations on the same day," the SSC chief said. The computer-based Phase 13 examination, held between July 24 and August 1, was allegedly plagued by abrupt cancellations, software crashes, biometric verification failures, and erroneous exam centre allotments."In some places, the systems stopped working. For instance, the computer mouse was unresponsive. In such cases, we instructed the centres to reboot the system, and the candidate was given another chance. We conduct a log analysis for all exams across all centres. While we acknowledge that disruptions occurred, our goal is to eliminate them entirely in the future," he to allegations that the exam tender was awarded to a blacklisted agency, Eduquity Career Technologies, he said the new agency was selected through a transparent process, and any blacklisted firm would have been disqualified at the tendering stage.'We are dependent on agencies to conduct exams, and they are selected through an open tender process. Some agencies monitor the exams, some provide content and questions, and one offers IT support. The previous agency's term ended in 2024. After that, a new agency was selected through a transparent process. If any agency had been blacklisted, it would have been disqualified at the tendering stage. So, the process is transparent,' he SSC chairman added that with C-DAC, a government entity, now monitoring the exam process, they can see what is happening behind the to the previous tender Tata Consultance Services (TCS), Gopalakrishnan said that "TCS adopted a different style of examination. A supreme court order mandates we cannot give all exam conducting processes to one agency only. Hence, we have changed and deployed many agencies. Finally, the tests should be fair and transparent."On concerns about exam centres being allotted at distant locations, the SSC chief said the Commission was not forcing anyone to travel, adding that some students may have selected far-off centres instance, students from North Indian states were sent to the Andaman and Nicobar Islands to take the tests. I must say there are only two possible reasons for this: either the student lives in the Andaman and Nicobar Islands and opted for that centre, or someone from another region chose that centre themselves.'We have never assigned a centre to anyone forcefully. There was an initial shortage in centre allotments, and our priority was to start the tests on time. Most students will not need to travel more than 200-250 kilometres. However, there will be some disruptions due to the lack of centres in many cities. We are going to publish on the portal how many students were allotted their first, second, and third choice of centres. That data will be made public,' he also affirmed that the agency is working to eliminate impersonation in examinations, calling it the "biggest threat", along with tackling issues related to hacking and cyber it was pointed out that students are concerned about the conduct of the Combined Graduate Level (CGL) exam, scheduled to begin on August 13 with over 30 lakh candidates expected to appear, the commission said it will conduct the examination after analysing the improvements made in the have seen some improvement, and only after we see further progress will we conduct the exam. Over the past week, there has been significant improvement. However, this level of disruption is intolerable and will not be tolerated," he said.- Ends
Hindustan Times
16 hours ago
- Hindustan Times
Tomato rates cross ₹100-mark amid erratic supply from hills
Tomato prices have shot up 100% at the apni mandis in just a week– from ₹50 per kg on July 26 to ₹100 per kg on August 2 – due to erratic supply. Retail shops are selling it at ₹120/kg. Last year, tomato prices had reached ₹ 120 per kg at apni mandis. But the highest-ever was seen in 2023 when tomatoes were selling for ₹ 250 per kg during the flashfloods in Himachal. (HT File) Komal Sharma, incharge of Apni Mandi, Punjab Mandi Board, in Chandigarh, said, 'The production of Punjab-grown tomatoes gets adversely affected due to increase in temperature and untimely rains. Generally, our local production stops by mid-July. When this happens, we import tomatoes from the hills. But due to incessant rains and landslides in Himachal, the supply has taken a hit, leading to a steep spike in rates.' She added that the rates are changing every day but it might drop to ₹50 to ₹60 per kg once the weather clears up. 'If the rains continue, we may see erratic supply from other states too,' Sharma added. Last year, tomato prices had reached ₹120 per kg at apni mandis. But the highest-ever was seen in 2023 when tomatoes were selling for ₹250 per kg during the flashfloods in Himachal. While the rates of staples such as potatoes and onions have remained unchanged, the rates of capsicum and brinjal, which are sourced from the hills, have also seen a spike (see box).
Hindustan Times
17 hours ago
- Hindustan Times
Waste firm flags tender criteria in Manesar, MCM rejects plea
A Gurugram-based waste management firm has raised objections to the eligibility conditions set in the Municipal Corporation of Manesar's (MCM) latest tender for door-to-door solid waste collection and segregation, urging that the criteria be revised to include secondary waste collection and transportation as qualifying experience. Garbage dumped on roads in Manesar. (HT Archive) In a letter submitted to the Municipal Commissioner on August 1, the company pointed out that while the Request for Proposal (RFP) acknowledges advanced waste processing techniques, including bio-methanation, waste-to-energy, landfill mining, and remediation, it overlooks the role of firms engaged in transporting waste from secondary collection points to processing sites. 'The work of secondary waste collection from secondary points and transportation to dumpsites wasn't mentioned in the list of similar projects, whereas more specialised and disposal-related activities like bio-mining and CBG production are considered,' the firm stated. 'We respectfully request that secondary waste collection and transportation also be included under eligible Solid Waste Management works.' The company argued that such work is an essential part of door-to-door systems and that its inclusion would broaden participation by allowing experienced local firms to bid. However, MCM issued an official clarification on August 1, rejecting the request. 'The technical evaluation shall be conducted strictly in accordance with the terms and conditions specified in the RFP,' the civic body stated. Gurugram-based environmental activist Vaishali Rana said excluding secondary collection may disqualify operators with key experience in fast-growing towns like Manesar. The tender remains open, and the list of technically qualified bidders will be announced in the coming weeks.
