Charges filed against KiwiRail over Aratere grounding
The Aratere grounded just north of Picton on June 21 last year, with 47 people onboard at the time.
No one was injured and the vessel was refloated two days afterwards, with damage to its bow that required repair.
Maritime New Zealand's chief executive Kirstie Hewlett said the charges relate to failures by the operator to keep crew and passengers safe while onboard the ferry, under the Health and Safety at Work Act 2015.
"This was a complex incident and important investigation given it focused on KiwiRail bringing in new systems to older vessels and broader safety management.
ADVERTISEMENT
"It required us to look at systems, policies and procedures, culture, within KiwiRail in relation to the incident."
She said a "significant number of interviews were conducted" and a substantial amount of evidence collated.
Three investigations are looking at what happened to the vessel when it hit the coastline near Picton. (Source: 1News)
"The time taken to undertake this investigation, collate and review the evidence, and decide on compliance action is consistent with other complex and major incidents," she said.
"As we have now filed charges in court, we cannot talk about what our investigation found," Hewlett said.
In October last year, the Transport Accident Investigation Commission released an initial report into the incident, finding that less than three minutes passed between crew on the Aratere switching on autopilot and the ferry grounding.
TAIC will release a final report with further analysis and any possible recommendations at a later date.
ADVERTISEMENT
Earlier this year, the Government announced the ferry would be retired by August 30 to make way for required Picton port redevelopment in preparation for the two brand-new Cook Strait ferries arriving in 2029.
The grounding was just one of many incidents that have plagued the vessel in its 25 years of crossing the Cook Strait.
Interislander responds
In a statement, Interislander executive general manager Duncan Roy told 1News the company has "made improvements to our processes and systems to avoid an event like this happening again".
Roy said an internal investigation carried out in the immediate aftermath of the incident led to nine recommendations – the majority of which have been implemented.
"This includes a full review of training processes especially for critical equipment, and reviews of our contractor management and risk management procedures."
Since returning to passenger sailings, the Aratere has made more than 1100 crossings of Cook Strait, carrying over 133,000 passengers and 64,000 private and commercial vehicles, Roy said. The vessel's reliability is at 98% this financial year.
ADVERTISEMENT
In 2024, Interislander brought in independent overseas assessors DNV to review its three ships and their maintenance. Roy said DNV found the ships were in good condition for their age and with the company's stringent maintenance regime, there was no systemic reason why they cannot continue sailing safely until 2029.
The charges
Charge 1: s48 charge - in that it had a duty as a PCBU, namely to ensure, so far as reasonably practicable, the health and safety of those passengers and crew who would sail aboard the Aratere and that failure exposed crew members and passengers to the risk of death or serious injury. Maximum penalty $1.5m
Charge 2: s49 charge under HSWA - in that it had a duty as a PCBU, failed to ensure, so far as is reasonably practicable, the health and safety of those passengers and crew who would sail aboard the Aratere. Maximum penalty: $500,000
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Scoop
6 hours ago
- Scoop
Govt Gets It Wrong With Cancelled Ferries
The cost of cancelling the iRex ferries shows the wastefulness and short-term thinking of the Coalition Government. 'We could have had new ferries by next year and millions of dollars left over to spend on critical infrastructure if it weren't for this irresponsible Government,' says the Green Party's spokesperson for Transport, Julie Anne Genter. 'This decision to cancel the contract for new ferries has cost us $671 million. This is a missed opportunity and a massive mark against this Government's credibility. 'For context, that amount of money could have funded the electrification of the main rail line from Waikanae to Palmerston North, or built thousands of much-needed homes. 'New Zealanders should have been taking those new ferries this and next year - instead we've had the Aratere taken out of commission, and more trucks on the road as a result of retiring our only rail-enabled ferry. 'The Hyundai order for two new rail-enabled ferries for $550m was one of the best deals the country ever signed up to. This Coalition Government tore it up and will likely be forced into signing a deal that leaves us worse off in the short and long term. 'The Government must stop cutting corners and commit to funding a transport network that works for people and planet,' says Julie Anne Genter.
Scoop
2 days ago
- Scoop
Eye-Watering Break Fee For Botched Ferries
It has been revealed that the Government is paying a staggering $144 million to cancel the previous contract for the new Interislander ferries. 'Nicola Willis' terrible decision-making has now cost taxpayers more than half a billion dollars in total – $671 million – with no new ferries to show for it,' Labour transport spokesperson Tangi Utikere said. 'The $144 million break fee is on top of money already paid to Hyundai, which takes the amount of taxpayer money National has poured down the drain to $222 million. The rest is project management, landside infrastructure and paying to wind down the project – totalling more than half a billion. 'This proves Christopher Luxon and Nicola Willis have absolutely no clue what they're doing and are just making things worse. 'The amount of taxpayer money they've wasted with absolutely nothing to show for it makes a mockery of every time they've said they can't afford something. 'They can find more than half a billion dollars to botch a ferry project, but can't find any money to build homes, create jobs or fund the health system properly. 'People are struggling with the cost of living while Nicola Willis and Christopher Luxon's economic decisions run aground and sink,' Tangi Utikere said. Notes: Original estimates of $1.16 billion referenced in the Beehive PR includes the originally budgeted $300 million for the break fee plus the cost of ongoing maintenance of the current ferries. The contract was originally going to deliver the ferries next year, in 2026. The current projection for new ferries is at least three years later.
1News
2 days ago
- 1News
How much it cost to cancel iRex ferry contract: $671 million
KiwiRail has reached a settlement agreement with South Korean shipyard Hyundai Mipo Dockyard (HMD) following the coalition Government's cancellation of the iReX ferry project. Chief financial officer Jason Dale said the state-owned enterprise effected an agreement with Hyundai for a full and final settlement to exit the contracts for two rail-enabled ferries that were signed in 2021. "After constructive negotiations we have concluded a settlement agreement with HMD for a final amount of $144 million. Including previous payments, this brings the total paid to HMD to $222 million and the final cost for the entire iReX project to $671 million." Project iReX was launched to replace KiwiRail's ageing Interislander fleet with two large, rail-enabled ferries. The plan also included major upgrades to port infrastructure at Wellington and Picton. The ships were due to cost $551 million, with the delivery of the two ferries set to occur in 2025 and 2026. ADVERTISEMENT Approved in 2021, the contract was cancelled with Hyundai in December 2023 shortly after the coalition Government came into power, citing Treasury warnings of costs associated with the ferries and required port upgrades ballooning. Minister for Rail Winston Peters said the $144 million final settlement payment was to cover the costs incurred by Hyundai and its global suppliers. "That is only fair as the decision to cancel Project iReX was never a reflection on Hyundai." Around $300 million was originally provisioned to cover the potential cost of exiting the iReX commitments, Peters said, adding that more funding was now available for other Government projects as a result of the lower settlement cost. He also hit out at media reports and the Opposition for suggesting the final settlement could be more than $300 million. "Doomsayers said cancelling the contract would cost the taxpayer the full $551 million contract value, but these are some of the same people who accepted Project iReX ballooning from $1.45 billion when approved in 2021 to Treasury warning it was on course to $4 billion in 2023 thanks to eyes-bigger-than-their-mouths ambitions and absentee management." ADVERTISEMENT Finance Minister Nicola Willis said the settlement ended "yet another sorry chapter in the story of the previous government's mismanagement of the Crown's books". "It signed up to purchase two big new ferries without giving sufficient consideration to the port infrastructure needed to support ships of a much bigger size." She said the cost of the project "had almost quadrupled" by the time of its cancellation in December 2023. "No Government should be advised of billion-dollar blowouts in a major infrastructure programme upon being elected, as was the case after the 2023 general election. "I am pleased that a more pragmatic solution is now in place that will ensure a safe, reliable Cook Strait service at an affordable price." The Government set up a company, Ferry Holdings Ltd, to lead the procurement process of two new ferries by 2029. It is currently in talks with several shipyards to find a preferred build partner for the new ships. The new ferries will be approximately 200m long and 28m wide, with capacity for 1500 passengers and 2.4km of lanes for cars, trucks, and 40 rail wagons each. ADVERTISEMENT The final sailing for the Aratere, which is leaving service to allow for work on port infrastructure upgrades, is on Monday. Labour transport spokesperson Tangi Utikere. (Source: 1News) Cancellation of iReX 'terrible decision-making' - Labour Labour's transport spokesperson Tangi Utikere said the cancellation of the previous contract for the Interislander ferries was "terrible-decision-making" by Finance Minister Nicola Willis. "The $144 million break fee is on top of money already paid to Hyundai, which takes the amount of taxpayer money National has poured down the drain to $222 million. The rest is project management, landside infrastructure and paying to wind down the project – totalling more than half a billion." He accused the Prime Minister and Willis of having "absolutely no clue what they're doing and "just making things worse". "The amount of taxpayer money they've wasted with absolutely nothing to show for it makes a mockery of every time they've said they can't afford something. People are struggling with the cost of living while Nicola Willis and Christopher Luxon's economic decisions run aground and sink." ADVERTISEMENT Green Party co-leader transport spokesperson Julie Anne Genter said the exit from the Hyundai ferry contract showed "wastefulness and short-term thinking" by the coalition Government. "We could have had new ferries by next year and millions of dollars left over to spend on critical infrastructure if it weren't for this irresponsible Government. This is a missed opportunity and a massive mark against this Government's credibility." Genter said the $550 million deal for the two new rail-enabled ferries was one of the best the country had ever signed up to. "This Coalition Government tore it up and will likely be forced into signing a deal that leaves us worse off in the short and long term. The Government must stop cutting corners and commit to funding a transport network that works for people and planet."
