Is there a genocide in Gaza? Why legal experts are split
The debate had already been simmering for several months, but with a single sentence, President Emmanuel Macron brought it out into the open in the French public debate. On the evening of May 13, during an interview on broadcaster TF1, journalist Gilles Bouleau abruptly asked the head of state: "Does what is currently happening in Gaza constitute genocide?" Clearly prepared and looking solemn, the president answered without hesitation: "It is not for a political leader to use those terms; that is up to historians, in due time."
The president neither endorsed nor condemned the use of the word "genocide." However, by deferring responsibility to historians and the passage of time, he appeared to overlook the fact that several legal proceedings are already underway, both before French courts and before relevant international bodies – the International Court of Justice (ICJ) and the International Criminal Court (ICC), both based in The Hague, Netherlands.
Genocide brought up soon after October 7, 2023
The question of genocide and Gaza is not just a matter for historians to address through archival research. Above all, it is the domain of law experts – prosecutors, investigating judges, and lawyers – who are working directly on complaints, lawsuits, and appeals that have already been filed. For instance, the French National Anti-Terrorism Prosecutor's Office, which is responsible for investigating cases of torture, war crimes, crimes against humanity, and genocide, requested in May that a probe be opened following a complaint for "complicity in genocide" and "direct incitement to genocide." This complaint had been filed against French-Israeli activists who obstructed the delivery of humanitarian aid to Gaza in 2023, 2024, and 2025. Only the investigation will determine whether there was complicity, and therefore a genocide, but this process could take several years.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Euronews
10 minutes ago
- Euronews
EU considers suspending Israeli access to Research fund over Gaza war
The European Commission is considering suspending Israel's access to the EU's Horizon Europe research and innovation programme in response to Israel's ongoing actions in Gaza, according to several EU sources familiar with the issue. EU Commissioners are meeting today to discuss the move in response to the failure of Israel to implement a negotiated agreement to "substantially" improve access to food and medical supplies to Palestinians in Gaza. "The partial suspension of Horizon will be discussed in the College of Commissioners today," a high-level EU source confirmed to Euronews. Until recently, EU Commissioners have refused to support any action against Israel. If agreed by the Commission, the proposal will be discussed and potentially voted on by member states as early as Tuesday when EU ambassadors from all 27 member states will convene. Suspending Israel from the Horizon programme was one of ten options the European Commission and member states were presented with on foot of a report confirming Israel was in breach of international law due to the dire situation for civilians across the Palestinian Territories. Partially suspending Horizon would not require unanimous support across all 27 countries, and countries such as Austria, Germany, Hungary and the Czech Republic are still unlikely to support taking action against Israel. It is a Commission proposal for member states "to partially suspend the agreement between the EU and Israel on the participation of Israel in the EU's Horizon Europe", the source affirmed. "Clearly the situation in the last few days in Gaza is still awful, and although more aid is getting in, distribution has been deadly," the source said. On 10 July the EU negotiated a "significant" improvement of humanitarian aid access into Gaza, including an increase of food trucks, and an agreement to "protect the lives of aid workers", after the EU High Representative for Foreign Affairs Kaja Kallas dispatched a delegation to Tel Aviv, including Christophe Bigot, the EU's Special Envoy to the Middle East. The UN estimates over 1000 people have been killed at food distribution sites alone, and dozens have died of starvation in recent days. "I hope they're discussing actual measures and not just the situation in Gaza, we need action, not more declarations of how terrible it is," said another EU diplomat close to the matter. "Focusing on one option forces member states to make a decision, I'm not sure how economically this will impact Israel, but it shows political pressure is really mounting" on Israel, said this diplomat, adding that he considered the Commission "has washed its hands of the matter" up to this point.
LeMonde
39 minutes ago
- LeMonde
French prosecutors seek new Assad arrest warrant
French prosecutors said Monday, July 28, they have requested a new arrest warrant against Syria's former president Bashar al-Assad over a deadly 2013 chemical attack after a previous one was cancelled. It is now up to investigating magistrates to decide whether to issue the new warrant. French investigators have since 2021 been looking into a suspected Syrian government sarin gas attack that killed more than 1,000 people, according to US intelligence, on August 4-5, 2013, in the areas of Adra and Douma outside Damascus. The Court of Cassation, France's highest court, on Friday ruled there were no exceptions to presidential immunity, even for alleged war crimes and crimes against humanity, annulling a French warrant against Assad issued in 2023 when he was still leader. It however added that, as Assad, who was toppled in December, was no longer president, new warrants could be issued and the French investigation could continue. The National Anti-Terror Prosecutor's Office (PNAT) said they on Friday requested "the issuing and international dissemination of an arrest warrant against Bashar al-Assad for alleged complicity in crimes against humanity and complicity in war crimes" in the chemical attack case. Assad and his family fled to Russia, according to Russian authorities, after Islamist-led fighters seized power on December 8. Another French warrant is already out for Assad's arrest, issued in January for suspected complicity in war crimes for a bombing in the Syrian city of Deraa in 2017 that killed a French-Syrian civilian.
LeMonde
39 minutes ago
- LeMonde
Gazan city of Khan Yunis is almost completely leveled, satellite images show
Khan Yunis is now nothing but ruins. Satellite photos taken in recent days revealed that the Israeli army has nearly completely razed the second-largest city in the Gaza Strip, located in the enclave's south, as well as the surrounding municipalities. Its area spans more than 100 square kilometers. The city had a population of 400,000 residents before the war. November 24, 2023 July 18, 2025 November 24, 2023 July 18, 2025 November 24, 2023 In April 2024, the newspaper Libération reported that "after the Israeli troops' withdrawal, thousands of residents of the southern Gaza city discovered the apocalyptic landscape left by months of fierce fighting between the [Israeli army] and Hamas." At the time, the city's civil defense organization issued a call to the United Nations for equipment to extract dead bodies, most of which, according to them, were stuck under the debris, in an advanced state of decomposition. The most significant destruction has occurred in the neighboring towns of Bani Suheila and Abasan al-Kabira, where most buildings have been destroyed, according to the Israeli newspaper Haaretz. Another town, Khuza'a, has been completely leveled. July 15, 2025 November 21, 2024 July 19, 2025 October 5, 2024 "It appears that most of the destruction was done by bulldozers and the like," Haaretz wrote, adding that, in recent months, the Israeli "military has greatly accelerated the pace of destruction in southern Gaza, using private contractors that earn a profit of thousands of shekels per building razed." In recent weeks, the demolitions of homes, along with aerial bombardments, have been "the only operational activity that has been carried out systematically" by the Israeli army in Gaza, according to Haaretz. "Hundreds of bulldozers, excavators, and armored Israeli Caterpillar D9 bulldozers continue their efforts to make Gaza uninhabitable for years to come." According to Haaretz, the Israeli army has offered to pay bulldozer and excavator operators 2,500 shekels (about $750) to demolish a building up to three stories high and 5,000 shekels for taller structures. "Many people are being recruited. (...) Fortunately, there is still plenty of work," an entrepreneur told the Israeli economic newspaper TheMarker. The Palestinian enclave has been completely devastated by Israel's military campaign since the Hamas attack on October 7, 2023. According to an estimate from UNOSAT, the UN's satellite center, around 70% of the total structures in Gaza had been destroyed or damaged as of April 2025, or "258,201 estimated damaged housing units." Israeli far-right leaders held a public meeting at the Knesset, Israel's parliament, in Jerusalem on Tuesday, July 22, to discuss a plan to transform the Gaza Strip into a "riviera," at a time when the territory's residents are facing famine. Among those present were Finance Minister Bezalel Smotrich and Jewish supremacist Daniella Weiss, a staunch advocate for Jewish settlements in Gaza. The detailed plan presented at the meeting provides for the construction of housing units for 1.2 million Israelis, as well as the development of industrial and agricultural zones and tourist complexes on the coast. In February, Donald Trump proposed that the United States take control of the Gaza Strip, which has largely been destroyed by Israeli bombings, in order to turn it into "the Riviera of the Middle East," after first displacing the Palestinians to Egypt or Jordan. Such remarks could constitute "direct incitement to commit a crime against humanity," according to experts.
