Trump urges Supreme Court to let him fire members of the Consumer Product Safety Commission
Trump dismissed the three Joe Biden-appointees in May, but a federal district court last month ordered their reinstatement. The administration is asking the Supreme Court to pause the lower court order, a move that would take the three commissioners off the board again.
The appeal is the latest to reach the high court dealing with the administration's power to fire board members at agencies Congress set up to have independence from the whims of the White House. The court has been receptive to Trump's arguments in earlier cases, giving his administration more control over those agencies – at least in the short term.
The litigation around the Consumer Product Safety Commission, has 'thrown the agency into chaos,' the Trump administration told the Supreme Court and has 'put agency staff in the untenable position of deciding which commissioners' directives to follow.'
The agency is charged with protecting consumers from dangerous products by issuing recalls and taking other enforcement steps.
Trump has had considerable success with similar claims over independent agencies at the Supreme Court. In May, the court, in an unsigned opinion, allowed Trump to fire officials at two independent federal labor agencies that enforce worker protections. The Department of Justice heavily cited that outcome in its appeal to the high court Wednesday.
'Because the Constitution vests the executive power in the president,' the court wrote in its opinion at the time, 'he may remove without cause executive officers who exercise that power on his behalf, subject to narrow exceptions recognized by our precedents.'
Writing for the dissenting justices, Justice Elena Kagan said the majority had effectively overruled a decades-old Supreme Court case, Humphrey's Executor v. US, that allowed Congress to require presidents to show cause – such as malfeasance – before dismissing board members overseeing independent agencies.
In the Consumer Product Safety Commission case now pending, the Richmond-based 4th US Circuit Court of Appeals unanimously rejected Trump's appeal – despite the outcome in the earlier case. In a concurring opinion, US Circuit Judge James Wynn noted that the Supreme Court had not yet technically overturned Humphrey's Executor.
'That precedent remains binding on this court unless and until the Supreme Court overrules it,' wrote Wynn, who was nominated to the bench by former President Barack Obama.
In its filing Wednesday, the Trump administration urged the Supreme Court to issue an immediate 'administrative stay' that would let Trump keep the members off the board for a few days while the court considers the case. The board members fired back rapidly with a brief Wednesday rejecting the need for that outcome.
Because the board members are 'currently serving and have been since June 13,' they told the court, 'an administrative stay would disrupt the status quo.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
7 minutes ago
- Yahoo
Trump says he 'had to' move nuclear submarines after 'threat'
STORY: :: Trump says he 'had to' move nuclear submarines after a 'threat' from Russian ex-leader Dmitry Medvedev :: August 1, 2025 :: Washington, D.C. Security analysts called Trump's move a rhetorical escalation with Moscow, but not necessarily a military one, given that the United States already has nuclear-powered submarines that are deployed and capable of striking Russia. Medvedev on Thursday said Trump should remember that Moscow possessed Soviet-era nuclear strike capabilities of last resort, after Trump had told Medvedev to "watch his words." He did not specify what he meant by "nuclear submarines." Submarines may be nuclear-powered, or armed with nuclear missiles. It is extremely rare for the U.S. military to discuss the deployment and location of U.S. submarines given their sensitive mission in nuclear deterrence. The U.S. Navy declined comment. The Pentagon did not immediately respond to a request for comment.
Yahoo
7 minutes ago
- Yahoo
44 Jaw-Dropping Historical Photos That Are 100x More Interesting Than Anything I Learned In History Class
honestly so cool to see these parents marching in a pride parade in it also makes me sad that it's been 50 years and queer people are still facing so much prejudice. that Theodore Roosevelt's first wife and mother died on the same day, which was just days after the birth of his eldest child (the indomitable Alice, who, if you have not read should). He wrote this in his journal shortly afterward, and it's genuinely heartbreaking. contrast, this letter from Teddy Roosevelt after he was called a drunk is kind of hilarious. Someone remind me what the medicinal purposes of brandy are? 1939 predictions about what fashion would look like in 2000 are also funny to see now. TBH, you probably could buy a version of those shoes in 2000, though I don't know how comfortable they'd be. photo of American soldiers playing video games at Saddam Hussein's former palace in 2003 — while troops were still looking for Hussein — is genuinely wild. also kind of mind-blowing to see what a first-class room looked like on the Titanic. Honestly? I expected nicer. Related: ad for a journey on the Titanic – back to the UK from NYC — is eerie to look at now. Obviously, it's a journey the ship would never complete. this letter from survivor Charlotte Collyer is super, super sad. 9.I bet you never learned about this in school — in 1964, Martin Luther King, Jr. received the following letter, along with a tape of his alleged sexual activity. It reads like blackmail from a prior supporter, but King believed it was from the FBI — and it was eventually revealed that it was. The full text of the letter, except for one redacted name, was released in 2014, and you can read it below. was the FBI so concerned about King, you ask? Because they were worried he would endorse communism. Right-wing groups thus put up billboards like this during the Selma march as propaganda meant to make him lose supporters. is the gun used to kill Abraham Lincoln. In case you forgot, Lincoln was watching a performance of the comedy Our American Cousin at Ford's Theater with his wife, an officer, and the officer's fiancé. You may not know, however, that the plan was to wipe out the vice president, Andrew Johnson, and the secretary of state, William Henry Seward, as well. Seward actually had his throat slashed, but survived. kind of wild that this copy of the Magna Carta from 1305 still exists. not as mind-blowing as these 1800-year-old Roman leather sandals. news headline from 1933 did NOT age well. did this 1939 newspaper caption. Related: this 1914 article. To refresh your memory, the archduke's assassination is largely regarded as the event that jump-started WWI. and here's a photo of good ol' Franz and his wife just moments before they were assassinated. wonder when the first-ever selfie was? It's way further back than I thought — Robert Cornelius took one in 1839. leaflet for Black American soldiers during the Korean War is wildly fascinating to read — and made great points, tbh. handbook from WWI, translating important wartime phrases like "Run for your life!" or "we are losing," to me. about the first cat who went into space. Her name was Félicette, and she was a French stray who was flown in the rocket Veronique in 1964. She made it back safely and to this day is the only cat to have gone to space. fun fact? In Sweden, cars used to drive on the left side of the road. But in 1967, they switched to the right — leading to absolute chaos, as you can see below. York to Paris is a common flight now, but back in the early 1900s, it was unheard of — until Charles Lindbergh made the (solo!) journey in 1927. His airplane looked just a *bit* different than the ones we use today. Related: of Charles Lindbergh, his son was kidnapped and later found dead in 1932, and the case is fascinating to read about. The kidnapper exchanged multiple notes with the Lindberghs and their liaison, John Condon, who even apparently met with the kidnapper in a graveyard. Here's one of the notes. speaking of planes, check out this flight price from 1946. Of course, this would be $241.38 in today's dollars. what British passports used to look like, in case you wanted to pop over to another country in 1858. WWII, British people all had to carry these National Registration Identity Cards at all times — even children. If they were separated during bombing or for any other reason, this could assist with reunification. It would also assist with rationing food. here's what a WWII ration book looked like. psych wards are a far cry from what were called "lunatic asylums" back in the day. People could be admitted for a ton of different reasons, many of them completely unrelated to psychological conditions — you can read some of them, from the late 1800s, below. what the NYC subway looked like in 1961 — honestly, it doesn't look as different as I would've expected! here's what it looked like in 1987. is what a Japanese tram looked like after the atomic bomb was dropped on Hiroshima — next to a restored version. here's a larger-scale photo of the bomb's destruction in Hiroshima. Colonel Paul Tibbets, who flew Enola Gay, which dropped the bomb. Related: doesn't seem all that long ago when you look at graffiti left by soldiers. of WWII, check out these propaganda posters reminding Americans of their allies in the feels ironic, considering how the US would feel about Russia and China very shortly afterward. letter sent home from a soldier in Vietnam just made me really, really sad. 38.I definitely do not remember learning about the Mormon War from 1857 in school. Basically, then-President James Buchanan sent troops to quell rebellion in Utah, where tensions were already high between Mormons and both Protestants and the government. The Mormons took up arms and fought back in their own namely, involved killing around 120 people traveling via wagons to move out west. They attacked the migrants, then offered them safe passage out, only to execute everyone over the age of seven and blame it on the nearby Native Americans. This was called the Mountain Meadows Massacre. Militia Leader John D. Lee was eventually excommunicated and executed for his actions — here you can see him sitting on his coffin just before being killed. 39.I'm always fascinated by old beauty trends, and it turns out that there were some wildly dangerous beauty trends back in the day. For example, people used to use products with arsenic in them. were also makeup and hair products that contained radium and other radioactive elements. medicine also used to be pretty darn dangerous. For example, heroin was used as a cough suppressant. people could be prescribed cocaine. of medicine and health, X-rays have been around a lot longer than I realized — since 1896. Here's what it looked like to get one back in 1914. finally, this sign is a fascinating reminder of just how far we've come. Back in the day, people had to be instructed how to use electricity — and assured it was safe. Also in Internet Finds: Also in Internet Finds: Also in Internet Finds:
Wall Street Journal
9 minutes ago
- Wall Street Journal
Hegseth's Latest Battle: Infighting Inside the Pentagon
Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth's string of missteps has spurred infighting inside the Pentagon and raised concerns among some Republicans on Capitol Hill about his ability to run the department. The problems are rooted in Hegseth's lack of managerial experience in overseeing an entity anywhere near as large as the Pentagon, which employs around 3.4 million people on a budget now approaching $1 trillion, according to current and former officials.
