Underage hires in Sindh police raise serious legal questions
A newly released seniority list of grade-16 police inspectors in Sindh has exposed serious irregularities in the recruitment process, including the appointment of officers below the legal minimum age of 18.
The findings have cast fresh doubt on the transparency of hiring within Sindh Police, with some officers reportedly inducted at ages as young as 16.
Under Pakistan's 'Civil Servants (Appointment, Promotion and Transfer) Rules, 1973', the minimum age for public service is 18.
However, according to the list issued by Inspector General of Sindh Police Ghulam Nabi Memon, several serving officers were recruited well before meeting this legal age.
One officer, Mehboob Ali Mithani, was reportedly hired at 16 years, 10 months, and 11 days old. Another, Babar Ali Sheikh, joined at just 16 years and 3 months. Other names, including Imtiaz Ali Thebo, Zahoor Ahmed Lashari, and Shah Jehan Lashari, also appeared in the list with ages under 17 at the time of hiring.
Read: Seniority list of DSPs raises eyebrows
Meanwhile, the same department recently declared three applicants ineligible for recruitment solely for exceeding the upper age limit by a few days or months.
Among them, Shehzad Khan missed eligibility by five days, Farhan Ali Ahmed by three months and 12 days, and Noor Muhammad by just one month.
The inconsistency has triggered criticism over a clear double standard in enforcing age regulations. While some were disqualified for minor overage, others with significant age shortfalls were recruited and later promoted to senior ranks.
The list also includes officers who barely met the age threshold, such as Mumtaz Rahoo (18 years, 2 days) and Qamaruzzaman (18 years, 6 days). Observers say that if past recruitments are properly scrutinised, the list of violations would include hundreds rather than dozens of names.
Questions have also been raised about the recruitment boards and appointment committees involved in approving such cases. If these irregularities stem from documentation errors, critics say, those responsible must be held accountable.
Express News previously reported similar issues in a separate seniority list of 500 deputy superintendents of police (DSPs), revealing discrepancies in age, appointment dates, and alleged out-of-turn promotions.
Many of these individuals are now in powerful positions, enjoying salaries, government vehicles, and other benefits — despite questionable eligibility at the time of their appointment.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Express Tribune
11-08-2025
- Express Tribune
Two young siblings killed in accident
Two young siblings were killed and their father was critically injured in a road accident on Rashid Minhas Road near Lucky One Mall around 4am on Sunday. The incident occurred when a speeding dumper rammed into a motorcycle, killing 22-year-old Mah Noor and her 14-year-old brother Ahmed Raza on the spot. Their father, Shakir, a clothes vendor and father of seven, sustained severe head injuries. According to the CCTV footage of the incident, the dumper driver struck the bike from the rear and drove his mammoth vehicle over the victims. Police said the dumper was heading from Gulshan Chowrangi towards Sohrab Goth and the victims were returning home from a family gathering in Malir Rifaa Aam Society. The incident sparked widespread outrage, with residents catching the dumper driver, Firdous Khan, and subjecting him to a severe beating before police intervention. The mob then began pelting passing dumpers with stones, forcing several drivers to flee. Protesters later set fire to seven dumpers, causing traffic chaos in the city. Law enforcement agencies, including police and Rangers, reached the site and brought the situation under control. Ten suspects involved in the arson were taken into custody, with further arrests to be made based on CCTV footage. The victims' uncle, Zakir, appealed to the government to take action against dumpers, warning that more families would suffer similar losses if measures were not taken. The incident has highlighted growing concerns over the unregulated movement of heavy vehicles in Karachi and the need for effective measures to prevent further loss of life. Dumper owners stage protest Dumper Association leader Liaquat Mehsud said he was earnestly aggrieved over the loss of lives, but torching dumpers without any investigation was totally uncalled far. Speaking to the Express News at the protest sit he said the accident was caused by a water tanker but dumpers were deliberately targeted. Mehsud said that Sindh government has banned the movement of dumpers in the city from morning till 10pm, "in current situation, the government should completely ban dumpers in the city." Protesters led by Mehsud blocked the Super Highway at Sohrab Goth and the National Highway near Thatta, erecting barricades and halting traffic. The blockade caused long queues of vehicles and severely disrupted intercity travel, leaving thousands of commuters stranded. Simmering tempers The funeral prayers for the brother and sister who lost their lives after being hit by a dumper truck in Federal B Area were offered at a mosque near their residence after Asr prayers. The prayers were attended by their injured father, relatives, neighbours, a large number of local residents, Jamaat-e-Islami Karachi Ameer Munim Zafar, Sindh Assembly member Abdul Wasim, and other political and social leaders. The scene at the funeral was deeply emotional. The injured father, with visible wounds on his head and body, attended despite his critical condition. Speaking to the media, Munim Zafar said PPP had failed in every sector, noting that in the past seven months, 5,252 road accidents had occurred, with dumpers and trailers claiming numerous lives. Referring to arrests made after torching of seven dumpers, Zafar said 10 young men sitting at a roadside café were arrested without cause. He further said that Rashid Minhas Road remained blocked for hours without any police presence. While the grief of the bereaved family cannot be undone, he stressed, those responsible must be held accountable. Zafar further stated that the government's claim of installing cameras on dump trucks and trailers had also failed in practice. Sharjeel defuses tensions The talks between the Sindh government and the transporters were successful, after which the transporters decided to end their protest, said an official handout issued on Sunday. A delegation of transporters, led by Haji Yousaf and Jan Alam, leaders of the Dumper Association, called on Minister for Transport and Mass Transit Sharjeel Inam Memon at the Commissioner House in Karachi. Karachi Commissioner Syed Hassan Naqvi, Secretary Transport Asad Zamin, Karachi Police Chief Javed Alam Odho, and other officials were also present at the meeting. Memon expressed grief over the loss of lives in the recent accident but also condemned the violent incidents that followed. The minister directed dumper owners to ensure that cameras, trackers, insurance, and driver's licenses are mandatory in all dumpers. Additionally, a committee is being formed to assess the losses suffered by the transporters.
Business Recorder
07-08-2025
- Business Recorder
Patchy security progress clouds confidence
Pakistan's volatile security environment, coupled with persistent political instability, has long acted as a drag on investment and business confidence, creating a climate of uncertainty that deters both local and foreign investors. Risks ranging from terrorism and militant attacks to street crime and politically charged demonstrations raise operational costs, elevate financial risk, and weaken long-term investment appetite. Recent findings from the OICCI Security Survey 2025, covering the period from June 2024 to May 2025, shed light on how changes in the security landscape are influencing business sentiment. The survey points to clear improvements in major economic hubs such as Karachi and Lahore, where businesses reported fewer operational disruptions and a more secure environment for company assets, employees, and customers. Declines in serious crimes, including armed robberies and kidnappings, particularly in Karachi, wider Sindh, and Punjab, have been a positive development, as has the notable drop in street crime in Karachi, Lahore, and Islamabad. Employee perceptions of safety during commutes have improved in these cities, suggesting that enhanced urban security directly supports workforce productivity and mobility. These positive changes have been underpinned by growing confidence in law enforcement agencies, with the Sindh Police, Sindh Rangers, Khyber Pakhtunkhwa Police, and the Citizens Police Liaison Committee (CPLC) Karachi receiving favourable assessments for their role in creating a safer business environment. However, the security outlook remains uneven. Regions like Balochistan, interior Sindh, and parts of Khyber Pakhtunkhwa have either stagnated or deteriorated, posing continued challenges for investors and businesses operating in or sourcing from these areas. In particular, Balochistan stands out as an emerging area of concern, with deteriorating law and order undermining perceptions of safety. Even in areas showing improvement, businesses continue to report issues such as illegal gratification, expatriate security risks, and disruptions caused by politically motivated strikes and demonstrations. These factors feed into broader governance challenges and perpetuate investor caution. The historical link between security and investment in Pakistan is clear. Episodes of heightened violence and political turmoil have repeatedly coincided with sharp declines in foreign direct investment. During 2008–2010, militant violence and political instability drove FDI down by more than 50%, from $5.41 billion in FY2008 to about $2.15 billion in FY2010. More recently, between 2022 and 2024, a combination of political turmoil, devastating floods, rising terrorism, and economic stress eroded investor appetite, stalling key projects and suppressing overall investment inflows. This pattern underscores the broader reality that improvements in macroeconomic indicators or temporary political consensus often fail to translate into sustained investor confidence without a secure and predictable operating environment. The OICCI Security Survey results suggest that while recent improvements in Karachi, Lahore, and other key business hubs offer a window of opportunity to strengthen investment prospects, this progress is fragile and regionally uneven. Long-term growth and the ability to attract sustainable foreign and domestic capital depend on addressing security risks comprehensively, tackling corruption, improving law enforcement in lagging regions, and reducing political disruptions. Without such systemic reforms, investor sentiment will remain cautious, and Pakistan's potential for leveraging its strategic location, young workforce, and emerging consumer market will continue to be constrained by the enduring perception of risk.
Business Recorder
05-08-2025
- Business Recorder
Youm-e-Shuhada Police: Message from Ghulam Nabi Memon Inspector General of Police, Sindh
On the occasion of Police Shuhada' Day, August 4, it is a matter of great pride for me to address the Sindh Police. This day is dedicated to paying tribute to and remembering our brave comrades who laid down their lives in the line of duty. Their courage, dedication, and unwavering commitment to the protection of the public stand as a testament to their extraordinary service and spirit. The memorials of our heroes represent the highest ideals of our profession. They faced dangers with unmatched bravery and selfless service to uphold justice and ensure the safety of our citizens. Their sacrifices are a solemn reminder of the heavy responsibilities we bear as police officers, and we must always strive to uphold the highest standards of integrity and courage. We extend our deepest condolences to the families of our Shuhada. The sacrifices of your loved ones will always be remembered. We share in your grief and remain committed to standing by your side as we honor the legacy of those who gave their lives in service to our province. To all the members of Sindh Police serving across the province, I commend your unwavering dedication, hard work, and commitment to duty. Despite the countless daily challenges and threats you face, your resolve to serve and protect remains unshaken. The efforts you put forth and the strength of our law enforcement system are sincerely appreciated and valued from the depths of our hearts. As we commemorate National Police Shuhada' Day, let us reaffirm our commitment to the principles and values upheld by our fallen heroes. Maintaining the highest standards of honesty, justice, and service is our collective responsibility. Let us also strive to ensure that our officers are equipped with the essential resources, training, and support needed to carry out their duties effectively and safely. On this solemn occasion, as we renew our dedication to this noble profession, we honor the memory of our Shuhada. May their sacrifices inspire us to work tirelessly toward a safer and more just society. Their legacy must be a guiding lightfor us all as we continue to serve with pride, commitment, and dignity. May Allah grant eternal peace to our Shuhada and patience to their families. Let us carry forward their legacy with pride and unwavering resolve, ensuring that their sacrifices are never forgotten. With deep respect and gratitude. Copyright Business Recorder, 2025
