Jury told they must remain unbiased in trial against former Hobart teacher Keith Bates-Willie
WARNING: This story includes descriptions of alleged child sexual abuse, which some readers may find distressing.
The trial for Keith Athol Bates-Willie is continuing in the Supreme Court in Hobart.
Mr Bates has pleaded not guilty to 14 criminal charges, including rape, indecent assault and the persistent sexual abuse of a child.
The charges relate to incidents at three separate Hobart schools between the late 1970s and the early 2000s.
Mr Bates' lawyer, Jessie Sawyer, reminded the jury in her closing submissions on Tuesday that in making their decision of finding Mr Bates guilty or not guilty, they must remain unbiased.
"The state [prosecution] invited you to feel sorry for these witnesses. They said no one listened to them when they tried to complain.
"Regardless of how you feel about any of them, you need to push that to the side.
"Mr Bates is also a person and he said he did not commit these crimes."
Crown prosecutor Jack Shapiro told the jury on Monday, the volume of evidence in the case was "overwhelming".
He urged the jury to consider all of the evidence.
Mr Shapiro alleged Mr Bates put students in skimpy clothing during theatre performances, touched them in dressing rooms and would often grab their genitals.
It is also the crown's case that Mr Bates invited students over to his house for dinner parties, gave them alcohol and asked them to sleep over, where he would indecently touch them.
"There's an overwhelming volume of evidence to prove the accused touched many male students indecently," Mr Shapiro told the court.
"There were 16 different men who came into this court and told you they were touched indecently. It's just an overwhelming number … these witnesses are real people.
"Why would they come into open court and tell you what happened unless it did happen … 16 different men telling you in graphic detail, and becoming upset about being touched."
"Mr Bates had a tendency to touch male students, to groom them … to establish a close relationship," Mr Shapiro told the court.
To this allegation, Ms Sawyer reminded the jury her client has denied any wrongdoing and argued a lot of the evidence heard "couldn't have happened".
"The state has painted Mr Bates as a villain … and says he has a tendency to touch students. This is just denied," she said.
"You can't just apply today's standards to something that happened 40 years ago.
The trial, before Justice Stephen Estcourt, continues.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
ABC News
27 minutes ago
- ABC News
Central Coast councillor, husband charged with assault over Wamberal Beach dispute
A Central Coast councillor and her husband have been charged with assault following an alleged confrontation with a home owner undertaking unauthorised works on Wamberal Beach to protect his property from coastal erosion. Councillor Corinne Lamont and Mark Lamont, who lead the community group Wamberal Beach Save our Sand, are facing one count each of assault occasioning actual bodily harm and affray. The pair vocally opposes a proposal from beachfront residents for the construction of a seawall to address coastal erosion. It is alleged they clashed with Warren Hughes, a beachfront home owner, on Tuesday afternoon, while filming construction work he had ordered to reinforce his property. They were charged and granted conditional bail on Wednesday and are due to face court next month. In a statement, the Lamonts said, "We look forward to our day in court. "We are innocent victims of a prolonged violent assault on the beach by a group of men. "Violence has no place in Wamberal. No violence, no seawall." Mr Hughes declined to comment to the ABC. Acting Central Coast Mayor Doug Eaton described the situation as "distressing and quite concerning". "My personal view is she [Corinne Lamont] should stand aside pending the outcome of the charges," he said. Cr Eaton has asked the council to refer the matter to the Office of Local Government to determine whether there has been a breach of the councillor code of conduct. He said he understood residents were frustrated by the lack of action to deliver a solution for Wamberal Beach. "We've had too much talk and no action," Cr Eaton said. "It is bureaucratic inertia. It's a bureaucratic nightmare. "The Reconstruction Authority has taken over as the authority for authorising any works and in my opinion, they haven't adequately discharged that duty." Last month, Recovery Minister Janelle Saffin signed off on interim protection works to address erosion at another Central Coast beach, The Entrance North. She said she was waiting for Central Coast Council to submit a scope of works to clear the way for the same permission at Wamberal. "What I did as Minister for Recovery was give the community, through the council, a way through to protect their properties at The Entrance North and it's exactly the same with Wamberal when council puts that scope of works up to us," Ms Saffin said. However, in a statement, Central Coast Council said: "Only a terminal protective structure correctly designed in accordance with council's engineering design requirements can provide an acceptable level of further risk reduction." The ABC understands residents have been told they will not receive the same permission granted to their neighbours at The Entrance North. Central Coast Council has issued two stop work orders after unauthorised works were undertaken on Tuesday, Wednesday and Thursday. Council officers are applying for an injunction in the Land and Environment Court to stop further unauthorised works occurring on Wamberal Beach.
ABC News
27 minutes ago
- ABC News
Former Genius Childcare boss Darren Misquitta pleads guilty to dealing with suspected proceeds of crime
Fallen childcare magnate Darren Misquitta has pleaded guilty to receiving $120,000 in suspected proceeds of crime from a business associate. On Thursday, the former Genius Childcare boss was fined $4,000 at the Melbourne Magistrates' Court after admitting the money, which he received in 2019, came from a loan drawdown obtained through forgery. Magistrate Patrick Allen did not record a conviction. It comes amid investigations into Genius by administrators who have referred Mr Misquitta to the corporate watchdog over the collapse of the group, which owes creditors more than $80 million, and lawsuits alleging the childcare empire failed to pay workers properly. Court documents show Mr Misquitta received the $120,000 from Lubna Matta, who serves on the board of another large childcare operator where Mr Misquitta is a shareholder, the ASX-listed Mayfield Childcare. Ms Matta herself has admitted to the same offence of dealing with property reasonably suspected of being the proceeds of crime, in relation to the entire drawdown of $300,000. In August last year she received a diversion order from the court, sparing her jail time or a conviction. In a statement of facts agreed to by Mr Misquitta, police said the case revolved around a loan taken out in early 2019 by a business in which Ms Matta was involved in that was a client of Mr Misquitta's at the finance group he ran, Sprint Capital. The business made a legitimate loan application to the Bank of Melbourne for $410,000 to pay out an existing loan and refurbish their IGA supermarket in Fitzroy. But a man involved in the business had a heart attack in February 2019 and while he was in hospital, Ms Matta — his sister-in-law — agreed to manage the finances. Drawing down on the loan required five signatures from Ms Matta and five from her sister. On February 27, 2019, the bank received a drawdown request asking that $300,000 of the loan be sent to Ms Matta's account. The money was transferred and in April, Ms Matta went on to send $120,000 from her account to Mr Misquitta. But Ms Matta's sister's signatures on the form bore "no similarities to her actual signature and have since been identified as forgeries", police said in a statement. "Based on the allegedly false signature it is alleged that the $300,000 was paid into the account of Ms [Matta], of which the accused was paid $120,000, is reasonably suspected as being the proceeds of crime," police said. At hearings this week it was not alleged that either Mr Misquitta or Ms Matta forged the signatures used to obtain the money. But the police statement said he had "dealt with those funds by way of the funds being transferred to his account and the charge is made out". Ms Matta has been on and off the board of Mayfield Childcare, where Mr Misquitta has been locked in a bitter battle for control with other shareholders including Liberal Party figure Michael Kroger. She was appointed to the board in December 2021 as part of an agreement where Mayfield bought 14 childcare centres from Genius. She was a director of Mayfield, which runs 45 centres, until September 2023, when she resigned citing "external professional commitments". But in January this year she was appointed an executive director while the embattled company was between CEOs. She stepped down from that role in July but remains on the board. Mayfield chair Roseanne Healy told the ABC that Ms Matta's criminal case "had not been disclosed to the company". "As a result, the company have commenced an investigation into the matter," she said. She said Mayfield operated under strict governance frameworks and has transparent reporting and accountability measures in place. "As such, we do not condone criminal behaviour of any kind," she said. Mr Misquitta's main business for the past few years has been Genius. At its height, Genius ran more than two dozen childcare centres in Queensland, New South Wales, the ACT, Victoria and Western Australia, and was developing 17 more, while Mr Misquitta lived in a historic Toorak mansion. But in March two key companies in the group collapsed owing more than $80 million, handing control of 25 centres over to administrators. Mr Misquitta declared himself bankrupt late last month following the collapse of his childcare empire. On Monday, his barrister, Sam Tovey, told the court Mr Misquitta does not have a job, his marriage has broken down and he has moved to the Gold Coast. "At the present time he's able to support himself," Mr Tovey told the court. "He's got outstanding issues with his businesses that are going to have to be dealt with." In a July 25 report to creditors of two Genius companies, Vertical 4 and Abacus 49, administrators accused Mr Misquitta of fraud and said they would refer him to the corporate watchdog for prosecution over allegations he breached his duties as a company director. They said their initial investigations had also identified more than $375,000 in potentially unreasonable payments made by the companies to Mr Misquitta, as well as more than $1.7m paid to law firms at his direction that needed to be looked into further. Genius had been trading while insolvent since at least July 1, 2020, they said. The administrators said they were continuing to trade 11 of the centres while they try to sell them. In the Federal Circuit Court, 57 former employees are currently suing Mr Misquitta and Genius alleging late payment of wages and deliberate and systematic failure to pay super. Mr Misquitta has yet to file a defence.
News.com.au
an hour ago
- News.com.au
Norwegian diving duo jailed over foiled 80kg cocaine smuggling plot
Two Norwegian nationals have been jailed after attempting to smuggle 80kg of cocaine into Australia, by plunging it deep under the water in Newcastle harbour. On January 23 2023, NSW Police received a tip that a bulk carrier ship from Brazil – which was destined to arrive at the Port of Newcastle – was carrying illicit drugs. The same day, a passer-by witnessed two men with diving equipment and seabobs at Swansea, and reported to Crime Stoppers. They said the seabobs had a black tow harness with shackles and weights on either side. NSW Police, the AFP and Australian Border Force (ABF) visited the bulk carrier the following day, with divers retrieving six waterproof duffel bags hidden inside a section of the hull. Inside, they found 82 packages of cocaine, weighing about 80 kgs and with a street value of $26m. On January 25, witnesses on a ferry saw two men in the water at the harbour and notified police. Later that day. officers arrested the two men – aged 53 and 35 and Norwegian nationals – and returned them to shore. There, they found a black climbing belt, diving googles with torches, a black flipper, diving bag, bolt cutters, diving gloves, pliers and a pocket knife. Police also seized diving equipment, electronic devices, receipts and passports from their car. The men were found to have separately flown in to Brisbane from Bali on January 17 and 18, a few days before the bulk carrier arrived in Newcastle. The men drove from Brisbane to the Gold Coast, where they purchased two seabobs worth $56,000, before purchasing a scuba set in Nelson Bay in NSW and tools from a hardware shop in Newcastle. The two men were each charged with one count of attempting to possess a large commercial quantity of a border controlled drug. Both men pleaded guilty. On March 13, 2025, the 35-year-old Norwegian man was sentenced to 10 years and two months imprisonment, with a non-parole period of five years and nine months. Last week on August 13 2025, the 53-year-old Norwegian man was sentenced to nine years and 11 months imprisonment, with a non-parole period of four years and 11 months. AFP Detective Superintendent Peter Fogarty said alleged offenders often mistake Australia as a 'lucrative market to sell illicit drugs' and would 'go to great lengths, even risking their own safety, to make a quick buck'. 'Divers hired by criminal syndicates are a cog in the wheel of organised crime, and they will be pursued and apprehended, no matter where they sit in a syndicate's hierarchy,' he said. 'This result is testament to our ongoing collaboration with our partners, both then and now. 'Criminals are relentless at targeting our community for illicit ventures, which is why our close working relationships with partners such as NSW Police Force and ABF are so important,' he said. ABF Superintendent Geoff Quinn said the 'outcome serves as a warning to criminals that we're acutely aware of what you're up to'. 'The ABF's work with partner agencies helps identify, target and disrupt the nefarious activities of serious organised crime groups irrespective of how clever they think they are,' he said.
