Attorneys get more time to argue over contested copper mine on land sacred to Apaches
Judge Dominic Lanza in a ruling issued Monday denied motions that sought to halt the transfer pending the outcome of the case. However, he did preclude the U.S. Forest Service from proceeding with the land exchange until 60 days after the agency issues a required environmental review.
Lanza said that would give the parties more time to analyze the environmental report and file amended complaints. He said granting a preliminary injunction now would be premature since the review will differ in some ways from the one that spurred the legal challenge four years ago.
'It is unfortunate that the result of this order will be to force the parties to engage in another stressful, abbreviated round of briefing and litigation activity" when the new review is issued, he said, acknowledging the unusual circumstances.
Attorneys for the federal government and the mining company agreed during a recent hearing to the 60-day delay. That time frame also is specified in the legislation that Congress passed and then-President Barack Obama signed in 2014 authorizing the exchange.
The group Apache Stronghold, the San Carlos Apache Tribe and others welcomed more time to fight for Oak Flat, an area they consider as holy.
'In this critical moment, we call on the Trump administration and Congress to halt the transfer to a Chinese-owned mine, and honor what is sacred,' said Wendsler Nosie Sr., leader of Apache Stronghold. "As we continue to fight in court, know this: Nothing will turn us away from defending the spiritual essence of our people, the lifeblood that connects us to the creator and this land.'
A statement from Resolution Cooper said the ruling is consistent with prior decisions and gives the parties time to review the final environmental impact statement that will be issued later this month.
'We are confident the project satisfies all applicable legal requirements,' said Resolution president and general manager Vicky Peacey.
She added that years of consultation with tribes and communities resulted in changes to the mining plan to reduce potential effects.
The fight over Oak Flat dates back about 20 years, when legislation proposing the land exchange was first introduced. It failed repeatedly in Congress before being included in a must-pass national defense spending bill in 2014.
San Carlos Apache Chairman Terry Rambler said Monday that the bill was not in the best interest of the American people, Arizona or his tribe. He said concerns persist about the mine's use of groundwater and the pending obliteration of the culturally significant site.
Apache Stronghold and the tribe sued the U.S. government in 2021 to protect the place tribal members call Chi'chil Bildagoteel, which is dotted with ancient oak groves and traditional plants the Apaches consider essential to their religion. The U.S. Supreme Court recently rejected an appeal by the Apache group, letting lower court rulings stand.
The project has support in nearby Superior and other traditional mining towns in the area. The company — a subsidiary of international mining giants Rio Tinto and BHP — estimates the mine will generate $1 billion a year for Arizona's economy and create thousands of jobs.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
NBC News
a minute ago
- NBC News
White House reviewing Smithsonian exhibits to make sure they align with Trump's vision
The White House is conducting an expansive review of the Smithsonian's museum exhibitions, materials and operations ahead of America's 250th anniversary to ensure it aligns with President Donald Trump's views of history, an administration official confirmed to NBC News. The assessment, which was first reported by the Wall Street Journal, will include reviews of museum exhibitions, online content, internal curatorial processes, exhibition planning, the use of collections and artist grants, and wording related to museum exhibit messaging, the official said. The Smithsonian Institution includes 21 museums, 14 education and research centers and the National Zoo. The news of the review was outlined in a letter dated Tuesday and sent to Lonnie Bunch, the secretary of the Smithsonian Institution. White House senior associate Lindsey Halligan, Domestic Policy Council Director Vince Haley and White House Office of Management and Budget director Russ Vought signed the letter. 'This initiative aims to ensure alignment with the president's directive to celebrate American exceptionalism, remove divisive or partisan narratives, and restore confidence in our shared cultural institutions,' the administration official quoted the letter as saying. The official said the review is aimed at making sure the museums reflect the 'unity, progress, and enduring values that define the American story' and reflect the president's executive order calling for 'Restoring Truth and Sanity to American History.' That order, which was signed on March 27, calls for removing "improper ideology" from the Smithsonian museums and the National Zoo. 'This is about preserving trust in one of our most cherished institutions," Halligan said in a statement. "The Smithsonian museums and exhibits should be accurate, patriotic, and enlightening—ensuring they remain places of learning, wonder, and national pride for generations to come.' The impeachment exhibition at The Smithsonian Institution's National Museum of American History, on Aug. 1. Andrew Leyden / ZUMA Press Wire via Reuters NBC News reported in May that historical leaders and critics were questioning why exhibits at the Smithsonian's National Museum of African American History and Culture on the National Mall were rotating out. NBC News found at least 32 artifacts that were once on display had been removed. Among those items were Harriet Tubman's book of hymns filled with gospels that she is believed to have sung as she led enslaved people to freedom through the underground railroad, and the 'Narrative of the Life of Frederick Douglass,' the memoir by one of the most important leaders in the abolition movement. The Smithsonian's National Museum of American History also recently made headlines after it removed a placard referring to Trump from an impeachment exhibit, sparking concerns over his influence on the cultural institution. Mention of his two impeachments was later restored to the exhibit after criticism of the removal. In a statement, the Smithsonian said that the exhibit was temporarily removed because it"did not meet the museum's standards in appearance, location, timeline, and overall presentation. 'It was not consistent with other sections in the exhibit and moreover blocked the view of the objects inside its case. For these reasons, we removed the placard," the statement added. Trump's executive order called for changes at the museum system, charging that the 'Smithsonian Institution has, in recent years, come under the influence of a divisive, race-centered ideology. This shift has promoted narratives that portray American and Western values as inherently harmful and oppressive.' '[W]e will restore the Smithsonian Institution to its rightful place as a symbol of inspiration and American greatness –- igniting the imagination of young minds, honoring the richness of American history and innovation, and instilling pride in the hearts of all Americans,' the order said. Trump has also gotten more involved at another federally controlled D.C. institution, the John F. Kennedy Center for the Performing Arts. He has named himself the Kennedy Center chairman and fired the previous bipartisan board of trustees after vowing there would be no "anti-American propaganda" at the venue. 'We don't need woke at the Kennedy Center,' he said in February. House Republicans have moved to rename the center the 'Donald J. Trump Center for Performing Arts,' but the law creating the center prohibits any of the facilities from being renamed. Trump seemed to acknowledge the House effort in a post on Truth Social Tuesday. "GREAT Nominees for the TRUMP/KENNEDY CENTER, whoops, I mean, KENNEDY CENTER, AWARDS. They will be announced Wednesday," he wrote.
UPI
a minute ago
- UPI
Trump's Fed nominee Stephen Miran critical of China monetary policies
1 of 2 | Stephen Miran, President Trump's nominee for the Federal Reserve Board, walks outside the White House on Tuesday. Photo by Francis Chung/UPI | License Photo Aug. 12 (UPI) -- Stephen Miran is President Donald Trump's nominee to become the Federal Reserve's next governor, but his name is largely unknown to the American public. Miran, 41, visited the White House on Tuesday for reasons unknown, but his candidacy to temporarily fill a vacancy on the Federal Reserve Board of Governors likely will make Miran's name more familiar with those who pay attention to the Federal Reserve's lending rate. Miran is a Harvard-educated tariffs advocate with a doctorate in economics who views China as rigging the global monetary system to ensure it has a competitive edge over the United States, according to a recent Fortune profile of Miran. Miran told Fortune that, while working as a currency-focused economist on Wall Street in his late 20s, he noticed China's monetary policies devalued its renminbi currency while boosting the value of the U.S. dollar. "The currency markets are a bit of the wild wild West," he told Fortune. "All sorts of things happen that shouldn't happen in an economics textbook." Miran said nations such as China heavily manage their respective currencies, which makes global markets "behave in weird ways." China's monetary policies cause the U.S. dollar to be overvalued while undervaluing its renminbi, he explained. The result, he said, is a U.S. trade deficit with China due to increased exports from China to the United States while greatly reducing the flow of U.S.-made goods to China. China ranks as the world's second-largest economy, while the United States remains the world's economic leader. China has erected market barriers for U.S.-made goods by imposing tariff rates that are higher than the U.S. tariffs on Chinese-made goods, stealing Internet technologies and utilizing other "non-market barriers," Miran said. "Watching the accumulation of Chinese currency reserves in dollars accruing from exports was absolutely eye-opening," he told Fortune. China's monetary and trade policies robbed the United States of jobs while punishing it for being the world's largest economy, Miran said. Miran chairs the Council of Economic Advisers and likely will become the Federal Reserve's next governor for a temporary term through January. "He has been with me from the beginning of my second term," Trump said when announcing Miran's nomination. "His expertise in the world of economics is unparalleled," Trump added. "He will do an outstanding job." If confirmed by the Senate, Miran will replace former Federal Reserve Gov. Adriana Kugler, who was nominated by President Joe Biden in 2023 and was to serve until January. Kugler resigned her position as one of seven Fed governors without saying why and ended her governorship on Friday. Trump suggested Kugler resigned because she dissented from the Federal Reserve's recent announcement that it would maintain its current lending rate of between 4.25% and 4.5% instead of lowering it. Miran would serve the remainder of the term for Kugler's vacant seat and would be eligible for a subsequent 14-year term, which is the standard term for a member of the Federal Reserve's Board of Governors. The Senate is in recess but will reconvene in early September and would vote on Miran's nomination prior to the Federal Reserve's Open Market Committee meeting that is scheduled Sept. 16-17. Trump said he likely will nominate someone else to permanently replace Kugler. The president also will seek a replacement for Federal Reserve Chairman Jerome Powell, whose term ends in May. Trump has contemplated firing Powell due to the Federal Reserve not reducing its current lending rate since shortly before the Nov. 5 general election. Federal officers, National Guard patrol Washington President Donald Trump announced he is placing the D.C. Metropolitan Police Department under federal control and deploy the National Guard to the district to assist in crime prevention. Photo by Bonnie Cash/UPI | License Photo
a minute ago
Who is E.J. Antoni, Trump's pick to lead the BLS?
President Donald Trump nominated E.J. Antoni, chief economist at the conservative Heritage Foundation, as the next commissioner of the U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics (BLS), the president said in a social media post late Monday. Antoni, a longtime critic of the BLS and a contributor to the conservative policy blueprint Project 2025, received the nod less than two weeks after Trump fired the agency's previous commissioner, Erika McEntarfer. Antoni's nomination will require Senate confirmation. Hours after the release of a weak jobs report on Aug. 1, Trump accused McEntarfer of providing 'faked' statistics, without providing evidence to support his contention. The report also featured significant downward revisions of employment numbers from May and June. Such data revisions, either adding or subtracting jobs, are not uncommon. 'Our Economy is booming, and E.J. will ensure that the Numbers released are HONEST and ACCURATE,' Trump said of Antoni in a social media post. Antoni did not immediately respond to an ABC News request for comment. Both gross domestic product and hiring have slowed this year. The BLS, an independent agency under the U.S. Department of Labor, provides regular reports on key economic indicators that are relied upon by Congress, federal and state agencies, and businesses. Here's what to know about Antoni and what his selection could mean for the BLS: Economic philosophy Antoni, who holds a Ph.D. in economics from Northern Illinois University, has spent recent years working with conservative organizations. Since joining the Heritage Foundation in 2022, he has ascended to the top economic post at the conservative think tank, which has close ties to the Trump administration. He is also a senior fellow at the Committee to Unleash Prosperity, a research organization co-founded by longtime Trump advisor Stephen Moore. Antoni has appeared as a guest on Steve Bannon's 'War Room' podcast and also contributed opinion pieces to Fox News. In a statement to ABC News, Kevin Roberts, president of the Heritage Foundation, said Antoni's leadership 'has been instrumental in advancing our mission to protect American families and rebuild a resilient economy rooted in free enterprise.' Critic of the BLS Antoni has criticized the BLS in recent years, focusing in part on issues tied to data collection and revisions. 'There are better ways to collect, process, and disseminate data – that is the task for the next BLS commissioner, and only consistent delivery of accurate data in a timely manner will rebuild the trust that has been lost over the last several years,' Antoni said in a post on X last week. In an interview with Fox Business last week, before his nomination, Antoni said the BLS should stop issuing monthly jobs reports and instead switch to quarterly reports until the agency improves its data collection process. Quarterly reports would allow additional time for greater accuracy, Antoni said. Survey response rates have declined since the onset of the pandemic, BLS data shows. Lower response rates in turn make it more difficult for the agency to gather information about the U.S. economy, which is a complex task even under ideal conditions. The BLS releases a preliminary estimate of its jobs report based on an initial tranche of data but the agency often revises the figure in subsequent months as households and businesses return additional data. Additionally, in an appearance on Bannon's podcast earlier this month, Antoni described now-former BLS Commissioner McEntarfer as 'incompetent,' and voiced support for the notion that Trump should appoint an ally to the position. McEntarfer, a Biden appointee who was confirmed by the Senate in 2024, had served in the federal government for two decades prior to her firing. "It has been the honor of my life to serve as Commissioner of BLS alongside the many dedicated civil servants tasked with measuring a vast and dynamic economy," McEntarfer said in a social media post after her dismissal. "It is vital and important work and I thank them for their service to this nation." William Beach, a former commissioner of the Bureau of Labor Statistics, who was appointed by Trump, condemned the firing of McEntarfer. "The totally groundless firing of Dr. Erika McEntarfer, my successor as Commissioner of Labor Statistics at BLS, sets a dangerous precedent and undermines the statistical mission of the Bureau,' Beach posted on X. McEntarfer did not respond to an earlier ABC News request for comment. Antoni's nomination draws mixed reaction from economists Some economists warned that Antoni's appointment could spark concerns about partisanship at the BLS and foster distrust of the agency's data. They also pointed to what they consider to be Antoni's lack of experience with data collection. 'Trump's nominee for BLS commissioner, EJ Antoni, is disastrously terrible,' Justin Wolfers, a professor of public policy and economics at the University of Michigan, said in a post on X on Monday. 'He has demonstrated no commitment to truth.' Jason Furman, an economist at Harvard University and a former economic advisor to President Barack Obama, echoed the sentiment, posting on X that Antoni is an 'extreme partisan and does not have any relevant expertise. He would be a break from decades of nonpartisan technocrats.' Moore, of the Committee to Unleash Prosperity, praised Antoni as the right fit to improve the BLS.
