JSC endorses tribunal findings of gross misconduct against judge Makhubele
The commission has resolved to refer the matter to the speaker of the National Assembly to recommend removal proceedings for the judge in terms of the constitution.
The commission, without the MPs, met in July to consider the contents of the report of the tribunal, which had inquired into allegations of judicial misconduct against Makhubele after a complaint by #UniteBehind, a coalition of movements comprising various nonprofit organisations.
The complaint was made as Part A and Part B.
Part A concerned Makhubele's acceptance of appointment and provision of services as a chairperson of the interim board of the Passenger Rail Agency of South Africa (Prasa) after she was appointed a judge with effect from January 1 2018.
Part B related to Makhubele's conduct during her tenure as chairperson of Prasa, that she failed to act honourably and avoid the appearance of impropriety and acted in a manner unbecoming of judicial office.
TimesLIVE reported that the complainant said during her time as chair, she pushed through the settlement of claims worth about R59m for companies in the Siyaya group, owned by Makhensa Mabunda, and on terms very favourable to the group.
Mabunda was politically connected to former Prasa CEO Lucky Montana, who the state capture commission's report has recommended for prosecution arising out of tenders he awarded at Prasa.
The settlement of the claims went against legal advice from her own legal affairs division, which she sidelined, #UniteBehind alleged. In its decision, the tribunal said there was no record of the board taking a resolution to settle these claims.
The tribunal found Makhubele guilty of gross misconduct in parts A and B of the complaint.
Before considering the matter, the commission — constituted without the MPs — called for written representations from Makhubele and #UniteBehind — and both parties filed representations.
Makhubele denied the allegations in the complaint and alleged that Gauteng judge president Dunstan Mlambo had consented to her starting her appointment as a judge in April 2018 rather than her official appointment date of January 1 2018.
The tribunal had found that Makhubele's version that Mlambo had agreed she would not commence her duties as a judge on January 1 2018 was most unlikely.
'In the commission's view, the facts set out in the tribunal's report clearly support the conclusion that judge Makhubele is guilty of gross misconduct in respect of the allegations set out in Part A,' the commission said in its report on Friday.
The commission also found the evidence on which Makhubele was found guilty in terms of Part B clearly established gross misconduct in the form of dishonesty.
TimesLIVE
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Mail & Guardian
an hour ago
- Mail & Guardian
Nicaragua Celebrates 46 Years of Sandinista Revolution in Pretoria
The Embassy of Nicaragua in South Africa hosted a vibrant commemoration of the 46th anniversary of the Sandinista Popular Revolution at its Waterkloof premises. The event, attended by dignitaries including ambassadors and diplomats from Cuba, Venezuela, Russia, Iran, Sahrawi Republic and Vietnam, as well as representatives from the ANC, SACP, and South African youth organisations, marked a historic reflection on Nicaragua's transformative journey since 19 July 1979. H.E. Ambassador Danilo Chang Cash opened the event with a stirring address, emphasising the revolution's enduring legacy of justice, freedom, and dignity. He highlighted Nicaragua's strides in social equity, noting the revolution's role in fostering hope and self-determination. 'The Sandinista Revolution reshaped Nicaragua, empowering communities and affirming our commitment to inclusive progress,' he stated. The keynote address by H.E. John Hodgson Deerings, Presidential Advisor for Nicaragua's Southern Caribbean Coast and parliamentarian, provided a detailed recounting of the revolution's history and its profound impact. He underscored the autonomy granted to the Caribbean Coast's Indigenous and Afro-descendant communities, including the Miskitu, Mayagna, Rama, Ulwa, Garífuna, and Creole peoples. 'The Statute of Autonomy has preserved ancestral cultures and empowered these communities to shape their future,' Deerings said. He cited significant achievements: over 30% of Nicaragua's territory is now legally recognized as communal property, ensuring sustainable resource use and cultural preservation. Deerings also detailed Nicaragua's developmental strides under the National Plan to Fight Poverty. Primary education coverage exceeds 97%, illiteracy has dropped to 4.5%, and life expectancy has risen to 75 years. Maternal mortality has decreased by 58% since 2006, and 99% of the population enjoys electricity access, with 80% from renewable sources. Women's leadership thrives, with over 50% parliamentary representation, ranking Nicaragua fourth globally. The event concluded with refreshments and renewed calls for solidarity with South Africa, Cuba, Venezuela, Palestine, and Iran, reinforcing Nicaragua's commitment to global justice and cooperation.
Mail & Guardian
an hour ago
- Mail & Guardian
Peru celebrates its 204th anniversary
Minister of Correctional Services Dr Pieter Groenewald, standing with Ambassador Jose Javier Augusto Shaw of Peru Peru celebrated its 204th anniversary of Independence as proclaimed by General Jose de San Martin in 1821, marking the end of the more than 300 years of colonial important milestone reminds Peruvian's of their commitment to freedom, sovereignty and democracy. Ambassador Mr Jose Javier Augusto Shaw thanked the Minister of Correctional Services Dr Pieter Groenewald for representing the government of South Africa and addressing the guests. Peru's history spans more than 5000 years, shaped by advanced pre-Incan cultures, the Inca Empire, and a rich blend of African, Spanish and Asian influences. The economy remains amongst the most dynamic in the region, with growth projections close to 4%. Peru continues advancing towards sustainable development, while addressing enduring challenges such as poverty, inequality, corruption and insecurity. Peru's foreign policy is rooted in dialogue, cooperation, and a rules-based international order. The country is committed to the 2030 Agenda and to policies that place people at the centre. ' In 2024, Peru held the presidency of APEC under the theme , ' Empower. Include. Grow' reaffirming our role as a reliable partner in the Asia-Pacific and our dedication to inclusive economic growth ' said H.E Mr Augusto Shaw Bilateral relations between Peru and South Africa are grounded in shared values of democracy, human rights and international cooperation. In 2023 the first round of political consultations were held in Pretoria and there is hope to host the second round this year in Lima, with the objective of broadening collaboration in trade, investment, tourism and education. ' by expanding our economic ties we can build a more robust partnership that can elevate and consolidate our bilateral relations in other areas of cooperation ' said Minister Groenewald. Guests raised glasses with pisco sours to toast to enduring friendship between South Africa and Peru.
Mail & Guardian
an hour ago
- Mail & Guardian
‘Some MK members jealous of Duduzile and my relationship with Zuma'
MK party spokesperson Nhlamulo Ndhlela. (@NhlamuloNdhlela/X) uMkhonto weSizwe ( The party's constitution stipulates that those in parliament cannot have full-time positions, but Ndhlela is also a legislator and a member of MK's 'high command'. Former party leader Jabulani Khumalo and former secretary general Ndhlela and Sambudla-Zuma have also been accused of being rude to other members and although Zuma has been happy in removing others accused of similar transgressions, the two have not been disciplined. Some party members have also accused them of behaving as if they are founding members of the MK party who cannot be told what to do. In an interview with the Mail & Guardian, Ndhlela said since the formation of the party on 16 December 2023, there had been a coordinated attack on him and Zuma-Sambudla. The two are believed to be the leaders of the so-called 16 December faction of the party, which claims to represent its founders rather than those who joined from other political movements after the This faction says these 'incompetent' newcomers have been elevated to senior positions, sidelining founding MK members. 'From day one, if you recall, there were three faces in the announcement of uMkhonto weSizwe. It was president Zuma, Dudu and I handling the media in terms of the questions and answer session.'. Before the 2024 elections there had been no internal party friction, Ndhlela said. 'So you can tell it's a coordinated attack on Dudu and Nhlamulo, after that they said we are in a relationship and now they are saying we are disruptive and that's a lie.' Ndhlela has also been accused by Shivambu of taking drugs. Without mentioning her name, Shivambu accused Zuma-Sambudla of posting on social media and insulting him while drunk. This was after she, in February, wrote on X that Shivambu was 'the worst thing that happened to MK', describing him as 'useless'. She also posted 'Fuck you Floyd', although she did not tag Shivambu in any of her posts. Zuma-Sambudla had to apologise and the party assured its members and the public that she would appear before the disciplinary committee, but this, according to insiders, has not been done. Ndhlela has also been accused by the party's MPs of being the author of a fake letter leaked to news channel eNCA, which claimed that the party's caucus in parliament was calling for its chief whip, Some insiders said Ndhela had done this to counter a letter the party's deputy president and parliamentary leader, Hlophe accused Ndhlela of repeated instances of being rude, arrogant and dismissive of communication toward parliamentary members and senior leaders, undermining the dignity and collaborative spirit needed in the whippery team. He also accused him of creating divisions among parliamentary members through perceived factional and counterproductive behaviour. Ndhlela said on television that he had not been removed as the party's whip of communication in parliament. He said Hlophe's letter was fake. Hlophe then held a briefing to clarify that the letter was authentic and Ndhlela had removed as a whip. Sources said Sambudla‑Zuma and Ndhela had also approached Zuma in a bid to influence him and to disparage Makhubele and Hlophe, but Zuma 'wouldn't hear anything of it'. Earlier this month, the M&G reported that the party was set to discussZuma-Sambudla and Ndhlela's conduct, but sources said this has not happened. Ndhlela told the M&G that Shivambu — who has since been axed as secretary general over an unsanctioned trip to Malawi — was among those who had coordinated the attack on Sambudla-Zuma and himself. 'At one point, she's taking drugs, then I'm taking drugs, you can just tell it's character assassination to try and drive a wedge between ourselves and the president so they can actually go for the kill,' he said. Asked if Ndhlela had appeared before him following the remarks by Hlophe, MK party disciplinary chair Ndhlela said: 'There's no need for a [hearing]. I resigned as a whip long after what was alleged to have happened. I was a whip of communication under [Mzwanele] Manyi, I stepped down under Manyi to give her [Makhubele] the whip of communication. I wanted to step away from the whippery and they requested that I stay in the whippery but deputise her, which I accepted.'
