Braid: After big national meeting, not much hope for Premier Smith's pipeline dreams
They're called Manitoba and British Columbia.
Article content
Article content
The hard reality was obvious during the national premiers' meetings this week with Prime Minister Mark Carney.
Article content
Both provinces are run by NDP premiers who find themselves surrounded by conservative premiers.
Article content
We like to imagine, or hope, that partisanship is being set aside in the drive to get projects done. Its a wonderful dream.
Article content
Article content
But after all the meetings and declarations, the omens are not positive for pipelines.
Article content
Article content
On Monday, a memorandum of understanding on pipelines and energy development was signed by Alberta Premier Danielle Smith, Ontario's Doug Ford and Scott Moe of Saskatchewan.
Article content
The three conservative premiers enthusiastically support pipelines to B.C.'s north coast and James Bay in Northern Ontario.
Article content
Asked if he'd been invited to sign on with the conservative premiers, B.C. Premier David Eby said brusquely: 'No.'
Article content
Further questioned on whether he would have signed if asked, he said 'I haven't read it.'
Article content
Eby did say, reluctantly, that he'll consider such a pipeline if a private proponent comes on the scene.
Article content
Smith didn't challenge Eby. Rather, she emphasized her support for LNG exports and various joint economic projects now being discussed with B.C.
Article content
Article content
She seemed to agree that talks won't happen until a private pipeline proponent comes forward.
Article content
Both premiers know that no backer is likely to emerge until Ottawa lifts the north coast tanker ban implemented by ex-Prime Minister Justin Trudeau in 2019.
Article content
Otherwise, how do you ship bitumen – by fishing boat?
Article content
Premier Smith keeps asking Prime Minister Carney to rescind the ban. He becomes very vague.
Article content
Even if the ban were to end, the B.C. NDP is likely to be as obstructive as they were when the late Premier John Horgan used 'every tool in the toolbox' – his words – to block the Trans Mountain expansion.
Article content
Eby now talks about how wickedly expensive the Trans Mountain line was ($34 billion) and how Ottawas was forced to buy it.
Article content
Article content
But a huge part of that cost was directly caused by B.C. obstruction at every step of the way.
Article content
The province, various municipalities and activists dusted off every possible regulation, legal challenge and blockade to slow or halt progress.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
National Observer
42 minutes ago
- National Observer
Katrina Chen's kids' book discusses gender-based violence. It's a story she knows well
Former British Columbia legislator Katrina Chen sits on a couch in her Burnaby home, reading aloud from the children's book she's co-written. "'Maybe,' Mommy tells me, 'It's time for a stronger house. We leave everything behind. And we go.'" The mother and son in the story, "A Stronger Home," co-written with Elaine Su, turn their backs on a scene of domestic turmoil: a broken vase, furniture overturned, sofa cushions in disarray. "I wrote this book as a survivor of gender-based violence with personal experiences about how violence has touched and impacted my whole life," said Chen, BC's former minister of state for child care. She considers the scene by artist Delphie Coté-Lacroix, showing the mother and son's exit, to be among the most powerful in the book — having the courage and strength to leave a violent situation is not easy, she said. Chen, who also has a young son, sees the problem as an urgent one, pointing to a recent spate of alleged intimate partner violence in BC. This month alone, there has been the killing of an 80-year-old Abbotsford woman and the death of her husband in what police consider a murder-suicide; the killing in a Richmond apartment of a 51-year-old woman whose partner has been charged with second-degree murder; and the death of Bailey McCourt, allegedly beaten to death in a Kelowna parking lot by her estranged husband, James Plover, also charged with second-degree murder. Chen said it was "totally heartbreaking and unacceptable" to hear of such tragedies, and society needed to see the violence as an emergency. She and other advocates want changes to the legal and social justice systems to prevent it from continuing. "Gender-based violence is a form of violence that's the most pervasive and most persistent," said Chen. "It's the longest human rights violation throughout human history." Chen, who represented the riding of Burnaby-Lougheed until last year, was best known in BC as an advocate for the NDP government's $10-a-day childcare program, as well as co-chairing Premier David Eby 's campaign to lead the party. But in 2022, Chen announced she was taking herself out of contention for a new ministerial position, revealing she wanted "time and space to heal" from the trauma of gender-based violence. "I have long-term trauma that has yet to be fully unpacked," she said at the time. Chen said in a recent interview that she was a victim of gender-based violence during her childhood, but she never talked about the trauma until she was hurt again in her late 30s. "I started realizing that the impact of violence can really impact a whole person's career, your life choices," said Chen. She said it was important to break the cycle of violence from generation to generation. But opening up isn't easy — revealing emotional scars came with misunderstanding, judgment, and stigma, said Chen. "I was very little when I was first touched by gender-based violence, and as I was growing up and realizing what was happening to me, I questioned myself, I judged myself," said Chen. 'A SAFER WAY TO LIVE' It's a feeling that Sarah Sherman has struggled with, too. In 2004, her husband, Jeff Bethell, attacked her in her Nanaimo, BC, home, tied her up, and tried to kill her. She freed herself and alerted police, but when Bethell saw a police car, he crashed his own vehicle, killing himself and a four-year-old boy in a car he struck. Sherman said she lived with "shame and guilt for many years," relocating to New Brunswick to escape the past and be "invisible" again. "Some people were critically injured. They lost their child. How do I ever make up for that?" said a tearful Sherman, "I can't, I can't, and that is the most heartbreaking part." Sherman is the founder of charity We're Here for You, which provides comfort kits to survivors of intimate partner violence. She believes sharing can empower other victims. "When we share truthfully and authentically, we give other people hope, possibly inspire them to find a better way or a safer way to live." On the legal front, there has been some progress. Last year, BC Attorney General Niki Sharma appointed lawyer Kim Stanton to conduct an independent review of the BC legal system's treatment of intimate partner violence and sexual violence. Stanton said she found numerous barriers to action and made nine recommendations to help survivors, including an increased focus on prevention, reform in the courts, and legal aid funding for family law services. Chen called it a good start. She also said the reform process could not involve a better person than Sharma, who supported her personally while she was struggling with violence. "But we need actions," said Chen. She would like to see all the proposals in Stanton's report enacted, she said. Sharma said "the work is underway," and a team within ministries, including hers, was looking at how to implement the recommendations. "I've seen that there are gaps in the justice system that we need to change," she said. Sharma said she pressed for changes to the Criminal Code to improve risk assessments when she attended last month's first minister's meeting in place of Eby, who was overseas. "In particular, what I'm asking to see changed is changing it so after the person's convicted, the bail conditions are looked at so they are held based on the risk that they pose, instead of them being released until sentencing," said Sharma, adding that this period is usually "the riskiest time" for the victim. The killing of McCourt in Kelowna had occurred a few hours after Plover was convicted of a separate assault; there was no discussion of keeping him in custody, a recording of the hearing revealed. Eby said last week that he had delivered a letter from McCourt's family to Prime Minister Mark Carney, who had committed to bail reform "on multiple occasions." Sharma said she plans to meet with Justice Minister Sean Fraser soon to continue such conversations. "I think that anybody who has known somebody who's been the victim of intimate partner violence, or anybody who's been a victim themselves, understands that the system doesn't take the crime as seriously as it should," said Sharma. "And that makes me angry." Chen, who is now president of An Xin Community Savings Credit Union in Richmond, said her recovery journey isn't easy, but she is grateful for community support. "It took me a while to understand how important it is to find my own sense of self and reflect on what I truly want in life — rather than simply reacting to what has happened to me, like constantly feel angry, hurt or sad." she said. "With the support of family, friends, counselling and coaching — and knowing I am not alone — I began to focus on my own well-being." This report by The Canadian Press was first published July 29, 2025.
Edmonton Journal
5 hours ago
- Edmonton Journal
Tuesday's letters: Alberta government helps MAGA singer but not disabled
Just so we are clear on Alberta government priorities. Staff at Alberta Infrastructure are helping U.S. anti-diversity, anti-2SLGBTQ+ and anti-women's rights MAGA musician Sean Feucht complete his incompletely submitted event permit form. The rest of the country has cancelled on him. Alberta government resources are being put towards helping to provide him a venue at our Alberta legislature grounds. Article content Article content Article content Article content The Liberals are three votes short of a majority. Historically they have negotiated with the NDP for those votes and not the Conservatives. A win for Pierre Poilievre changes nothing, but an independent conservative can impact federal policy during a minority government, forcing the Liberals to make compromises to get legislation passed. The NDP did this last time, and now it could be our turn. The Conservatives will never wheel and deal with the Liberals. Article content Article content I do not know much about Bonnie aside from that she says she is local, has conservative views, and will represent the will of the people in Battle River-Crowfoot. That combination is exactly what we need to make Alberta's needs heard. That said, feel free to look into her yourself. Poilievre may be born in Alberta, but he has lived in and represented a riding in Ottawa for decades. I see him as a parachute candidate. He is an Eastern carpetbagger. Article content
The Province
11 hours ago
- The Province
B.C. premier calls for overhaul of government drug approval process after 10 resignations from rare disease committee
His comments come after 10 experts resigned from the Expensive Drugs for Rare Diseases Committee over NDP's reversal in Charleigh Pollock case Langford's Jori Fales with daughter Charleigh Pollock, 10, who resumed infusions of the drug Brineura at Victoria General Hospital recently. Photo by Family Handout The NDP may be on the verge of blowing up B.C.'s process for drug approvals after 10 experts resigned from the province's committee for expensive drugs after the government rejected its recommendation to stop covering treatment for a 10-year-old dealing with a rare illness. This advertisement has not loaded yet, but your article continues below. THIS CONTENT IS RESERVED FOR SUBSCRIBERS ONLY Subscribe now to read the latest news in your city and across Canada. Exclusive articles by top sports columnists Patrick Johnston, Ben Kuzma, J.J. Abrams and others. Plus, Canucks Report, Sports and Headline News newsletters and events. Unlimited online access to The Province and 15 news sites with one account. The Province ePaper, an electronic replica of the print edition to view on any device, share and comment on. Daily puzzles and comics, including the New York Times Crossword. Support local journalism. SUBSCRIBE TO UNLOCK MORE ARTICLES Subscribe now to read the latest news in your city and across Canada. Exclusive articles by top sports columnists Patrick Johnston, Ben Kuzma, J.J. Abrams and others. Plus, Canucks Report, Sports and Headline News newsletters and events. Unlimited online access to The Province and 15 news sites with one account. The Province ePaper, an electronic replica of the print edition to view on any device, share and comment on. Daily puzzles and comics, including the New York Times Crossword. Support local journalism. REGISTER / SIGN IN TO UNLOCK MORE ARTICLES Create an account or sign in to continue with your reading experience. Access articles from across Canada with one account. Share your thoughts and join the conversation in the comments. Enjoy additional articles per month. Get email updates from your favourite authors. THIS ARTICLE IS FREE TO READ REGISTER TO UNLOCK. Create an account or sign in to continue with your reading experience. Access articles from across Canada with one account Share your thoughts and join the conversation in the comments Enjoy additional articles per month Get email updates from your favourite authors Premier David Eby told reporters during an unrelated announcement on Monday in Vancouver that it is obvious the system isn't working and that there needs to be some changes to improve transparency and to better serve the public when it comes to the expensive drugs for rare diseases committee. He said he understands people's frustration that there is an independent body that makes recommendations on drug coverage but that doesn't have to defend its recommendations to the public. 'The current structure of a committee that doesn't speak to the media, doesn't speak to the public, makes decisions privately, only speaks to the treating physician, even then only through the Ministry of Health, resulted in a scenario where it appeared as though what was happening was the exact opposite of what anybody wants, which is that politicians were making decisions about access to medicine,' said Eby. Essential reading for hockey fans who eat, sleep, Canucks, repeat. By signing up you consent to receive the above newsletter from Postmedia Network Inc. Please try again This advertisement has not loaded yet, but your article continues below. 'We have to figure out a way that works for the doctors and experts advising on whether or not a particular patient should receive a particular treatment, and we need to make sure that it works in a way that it's the experts that are making those decisions, and that that is taking place in a way that's transparent and understandable to the public.' Experts on the 58-member expensive drugs for rare diseases committee had recommended the government cut off funding for Brineura, the drug prescribed to Charleigh Pollock, a 10 year-old Vancouver Island girl who is the only person in the province diagnosed with the rare degenerative brain condition known as Batten disease. In their recommendation, the subcommittee dealing with Pollock's case pointed to the review of Brineura by Canada's Drug Agency, which found evidence that the drug is effective in extending the lives of patients and in reducing symptoms such as seizures was inconclusive. This advertisement has not loaded yet, but your article continues below. It also argued that Pollock was in an advanced stage of Batten disease and Brineura would no longer help her. An advisory board made up of all the chairs of the subcommittees, as well as outside specialists in health ethics, health economics and other fields, backed up the subcommittee's recommendation and the government officially announced it was revoking coverage last month. Jori Fales, Pollock's mother, disputed the finding, stating that she had seen with her own eyes how Brineura helped improve her daughter's quality of life and that, without it, she was worried Charleigh's condition would rapidly decline. After a public outcry, advocacy from Fales and a letter from 13 American experts, Health Minister Josie Osborne reversed the decision and restored funding of the drug for Pollock on July 17. This advertisement has not loaded yet, but your article continues below. The Ministry of Health confirmed 10 members of the expensive drugs for rare diseases committee have now resigned. That's a doubling since last week when the ministry stated there had been five resignations. Dr. Sandra Sirrs, who resigned as chair of the subcommittee that made the decision in Pollock's case, told Postmedia last week that the committee process had been undermined by the NDP's political calculations and that she isn't sure if it will survive the resignations. 'To see this process dragged through the mud, I don't even know whether the process will survive this,' she said. Sirrs would not comment on Eby's latest comments. In a statement, Osborne said she has asked the ministry to review the expensive drugs for rare diseases process to 'identify opportunities for improvement.' 'We also recognize the need to increase public understanding of how the … process works. Greater transparency can help build trust and ensure that patients and families feel heard and informed as decisions are made,' said the minister. alazenby@ Read More Vancouver Canucks Vancouver Whitecaps Golf Sports News
