logo
Movie Review: A Weird ‘Superman' Is Better Than a Boring One

Movie Review: A Weird ‘Superman' Is Better Than a Boring One

Yomiuri Shimbun09-07-2025
It's a bird, it's a plane, it's a … a purple and orange shape-shifting chemical compound?
Writer-director James Gunn's 'Superman' was always going to be a strange chemistry of filmmaker and material. Gunn, the mind behind 'Guardians of the Galaxy' and 'The Suicide Squad,' has reliably drifted toward a B-movie superhero realm populated (usually over-populated) with the lesser-known freaks, oddities and grotesquerie of back-issue comics.
But you don't get more mainstream than Superman. And let's face it, unless Christopher Reeve is in the suit, the rock-jawed Man of Steel can be a bit of a bore. Much of the fun and frustration of Gunn's movie is seeing how he stretches and strains to make Superman, you know, interesting.
In the latest revamp for the archetypal superhero, Gunn does a lot to give Superman (played with an easy charm by David Corenswet ) a lift. He scraps the origin story. He gives Superman a dog. And he ropes in not just expected regulars like Lois Lane (Rachel Brosnahan) and Lex Luthor (Nicholas Hoult) but some less conventional choices — none more so than that colorful jumble of elements, Metamorpho (Anthony Carrigan).
Metamorpho, a melancholy, mutilated man whose powers were born out of tragedy, is just one of many side shows in 'Superman.' But he's the most representative of what Gunn is going for. Gunn might favor a traditional-looking hero at the center, like Chris Pratt's Star-Lord in 'Guardians of the Galaxy.' And Corenswet, complete with hair curl, looks the part, too. But Gunn's heart is with the weirdos who soldier on.
The heavy lift of 'Superman' is making the case that the perfect superhuman being with 'S' on his chest is strange, too. He's a do-gooder at a time when no one does good anymore.
Not everything works in 'Superman.' For those who like their Superman classically drawn, Gunn's film will probably seem too irreverent and messy. But for anyone who found Zack Snyder's previous administration painfully ponderous, this 'Superman,' at least, has a pulse.
It would be hard to find a more drastic 180 in franchise stewardship. Where Snyder's films were super-serious mythical clashes of colossuses, Gunn's 'Superman' is lightly earthbound, quirky and sentimental. When this Superman flies, he even keeps his arms back, like an Olympic skeleton rider.
We begin not on Krypton or Kansas but in Antarctica, near the Fortress of Solitude. The opening titles set-up the medias res beginning. Three centuries ago, metahumans first appeared on Earth. Three minutes ago, Superman lost a battle for the first time. Lying bloodied in the snow, he whistles and his faithful super dog, Krypto, comes running.
Like some of Gunn's other novelty gags (I'm looking at you Groot), Krypto is both a highlight and overused gag throughout. Superman is in the midst of a battle by proxy with Luthor. From atop his Luthor Corp. skyscraper headquarters, Luther gives instructions to a team sitting before computer screens while, on a headset, barking out coded battle directions to drone-assisted henchmen. '13-B!' he shouts, like a Bingo caller.
Whether this is an ideal localizing of main characters in conflict is a debate that recedes a bit when, back in Metropolis, Clark Kent returns to the Daily Planet. There's Wendell Pierce as the editor-in-chief, Perry White, and Skyler Gisondo as Jimmy Olsen. But the character of real interest here is, of course, Lois.
She and Kent are already an item in 'Superman.' When alone, Lois chides him over the journalistic ethics of interviewing himself after some derring-do, and questions his flying into countries without their leaders' approval. Brosnahan slides so comfortably into the role that I wonder if 'Superman' ought to have been 'Lois,' instead. Her scenes with Corenswet are the best in the film, and the movie loses its snap when she's not around.
That's unfortunately for a substantial amount of time. Luthor traps Superman in a pocket universe (enter Metamorpho, among others) and the eccentric members of the Justice Gang — Nathan Fillion's Green Lantern, Edi Gathegi's Mister Terrific and Isabela Merced's Hawkgirl — are called upon to lend a hand. They come begrudgingly. But if there's anyone else that comes close to stealing the movie, it's Gathegi, who meets increasingly absurd cataclysm with wry deadpan.
The fate of the world, naturally, again turns iffy. There's a rift in the universe, not to mention some vaguely defined trouble in Boravia and Jarhanpur. In such scenes, Gunn's juggling act is especially uneasy and you can feel the movie lurching from one thing to another. Usually, that's Krypto's cue to fly back into the movie and run amok.
Gunn, who now presides over DC Studios with producer Peter Safran, is better with internal strife than he is international politics. Superman is often called 'the Kryptonian' or 'the alien' by humans, and Gunn leans into his outsider status. Not for the first time, Superman's opponents try to paint him as an untrustworthy foreigner. With a modicum of timeliness, 'Superman' is an immigrant story.
Mileage will inevitably vary when it comes to Gunn's idiosyncratic touch. He can be outlandish and sweet, often at once. In a conversation between metahumans, he will insert a donut into the scene for no real reason, and cut from a body falling through the air to an Alka-Seltzer tablet dropping into a glass. Some might call such moments glib, a not-unfair label for Gunn. But I'd say they make this pleasantly imperfect 'Superman' something quite rare in the assembly line-style of superhero moviemaking today: human.
'Superman,' a Warner Bros. release is rated PG by the Motion Picture Association for violence, action and language. Running time: 129 minutes. Three stars out of four.
Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

‘Fantastic Four: First Steps' scores Marvel's first $100 million box office opening of 2025
‘Fantastic Four: First Steps' scores Marvel's first $100 million box office opening of 2025

Japan Today

time23 minutes ago

  • Japan Today

‘Fantastic Four: First Steps' scores Marvel's first $100 million box office opening of 2025

This image released by Disney shows Pedro Pascal in a scene from "The Fantastic Four: First Steps." (Marvel/Disney via AP) By LINDSEY BAHR and ITZEL LUNA Marvel's first family has finally found box office gold. 'The Fantastic Four: First Steps,' the first film about the superheroes made under the guidance of Kevin Feige and the Walt Disney Co., earned $118 million in its first weekend in 4,125 North American theaters, according to studio estimates Sunday. That makes it the fourth biggest opening of the year, behind 'A Minecraft Movie,' 'Lilo & Stitch' and 'Superman,' and the biggest Marvel opening since 'Deadpool & Wolverine' grossed $211 million out of the gate last summer. Internationally, 'Fantastic Four' made $100 million from 52 territories, adding up to a $218 million worldwide debut. The numbers were within the range the studio was expecting. The film arrived in the wake of another big superhero reboot, James Gunn's 'Superman,' which opened three weekends ago and has already crossed $500 million globally. That film, from the other main player in comic book films, DC Studios, took second place with $24.9 million domestically. The box office success of 'First Steps' and 'Superman' means 'the whole notion of superhero fatigue, which has been talked about a lot, can I think be put to rest. I always say it's bad movie fatigue, not superhero fatigue,' said Paul Dergarabedian, senior media analyst for data firm Comscore. 'First Steps' is the latest attempt at bringing the superhuman family to the big screen, following lackluster performances for other versions. The film, based on the original Marvel comics, is set during the 1960s in a retro-futuristic world led by the Fantastic Four, a family of astronauts-turned-superhuman from exposure to cosmic rays during a space mission. The family is made up of Reed Richards (Pedro Pascal), who can stretch his body to incredible lengths; Sue Storm (Vanessa Kirby), who can render herself invisible; Johnny Storm (Joseph Quinn), who transforms into a fiery human torch; and Ben Grimm (Ebon Moss-Bachrach), who possesses tremendous superhuman strength with his stone-like flesh. The movie takes place four years after the family gained powers, during which Reed's inventions have transformed technology, and Sue's diplomacy has led to global peace. Both audiences and critics responded positively to the film, which currently has an 88% on Rotten Tomatoes and promising exit poll responses from opening weekend ticket buyers. An estimated 46% of audiences chose to see it on premium screens, including IMAX and other large formats. The once towering Marvel is working to rebuild audience enthusiasm for its films and characters. Its two previous offerings this year did not reach the cosmic box office heights of 'Deadpool & Wolverine," which made over $1.3 billion, or those of the 'Avengers'-era. But critically, the films have been on an upswing since the poorly reviewed 'Captain America: Brave New World,' which ultimately grossed $415 million worldwide. 'Thunderbolts," which jumpstarted the summer movie season, was better received critically but financially is capping out at just over $382 million globally. Like Deadpool and Wolverine, the Fantastic Four characters had been under the banner of 20th Century Fox for years. The studio produced two critically loathed, but decently profitable attempts in the mid-2000s with future Captain America Chris Evans as the Human Torch. In 2015, it tried again (unsuccessfully) with Michael B. Jordan and Miles Teller. They got another chance after Disney's $71 billion acquisition of Fox's entertainment assets in 2019. The 'Fantastic Four's' opening weekend results were a little less than some rival studio projections, Dergarabedian said. Nonetheless, the film is expected to carry movie theater earnings well into August. Holdovers dominated the top 10, but one other newcomer managed to make the chart. The dark romantic comedy 'Oh, Hi!' earned $1.1 million from 866 screens. 'Jurassic World Rebirth' landed in third place in its fourth weekend with $13 million, followed by 'F1' with $6.2 million. The Brad Pitt racing movie also passed $500 million globally. 'Smurfs' rounded out the top five with $5.4 million in its second weekend. The box office is currently up over 12% from last year. With final domestic figures being released Monday, this list factors in the estimated ticket sales for Friday through Sunday at U.S. and Canadian theaters, according to Comscore: 'The Fantastic Four: First Steps,' $118 million. 'Superman,' $24.9 million. 'Jurassic World Rebirth,' $13 million. 'F1: The Movie,' $6.2 million. 'Smurfs,' $5.4 million. 'I Know What You Did Last Summer,' $5.1 million. 'How to Train Your Dragon,' $2.8 million. 'Eddington,' $1.7 million. 'Saiyaara,' $1.3 million. 'Oh, Hi!,' $1.1 million. © Copyright 2025 The Associated Press. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed without permission.

'Superman' triumphs once again at North American box office
'Superman' triumphs once again at North American box office

Japan Today

time20-07-2025

  • Japan Today

'Superman' triumphs once again at North American box office

(L-R) Nicholas Hoult, Rachel Brosnahan and David Corenswet star in the new 'Superman' The Man of Steel has staying power: "Superman" topped the North American box office for a second week running and surpassed the $400 million mark worldwide, industry estimates showed Sunday. Riding largely positive reviews, the latest big-budget action film featuring the iconic superhero from Warner Bros. and DC Studios earned $57.3 million in the United States and Canada, Exhibitor Relations said. That puts its North American take at $235 million and its international sales at $171 million -- or $406 million globally. "Jurassic World: Rebirth" -- the latest installment in the blockbuster dinosaur saga -- also held its ground in second place at $23.4 million. Its worldwide total stands at $647.2 million. The Universal film, starring Scarlett Johansson, Jonathan Bailey and Mahershala Ali, takes viewers to an abandoned island research facility, where secrets -- and genetically mutated dinosaurs -- are lurking. "I Know What You Did Last Summer," a sequel to two 1990s slasher hits that bring back the franchise's original stars Freddie Prinze Jr and Jennifer Love Hewitt, opened in third place at a disappointing $13 million. "This is another horror series returning after a long layoff, in this case after 27 years," said industry analyst David A. Gross of Franchise Entertainment Research. "Generally, the layoffs don't bother these films; in fact, they get stronger... that's not happening here." "Smurfs," the latest film featuring the adorable blue creatures and starring Rihanna as Smurfette, opened in a lackluster fourth place with $11 million in North American ticket sales. "F1: The Movie," the Apple and Warner Bros. flick starring Brad Pitt as a washed-up Formula One driver who gets one last shot at redemption, finished in fifth place at $9.6 million. "The current lineup in theaters is strong, with a broad selection of big titles including superheroes, action, monsters, horror and animation," said Gross. "Superman" will soon get a new superhero rival when Marvel's hotly anticipated "The Fantastic Four: First Steps" starring Pedro Pascal hits theaters in the coming days. Rounding out the top 10 were: "How to Train Your Dragon" ($5.4 million) "Eddington" ($4.3 million) "Elio" ($2.0 million) "Lilo & Stitch" ($1.5 million) "28 Years Later" ($1.3 million) © 2025 AFP

Superman
Superman

Metropolis Japan

time15-07-2025

  • Metropolis Japan

Superman

By Don Morton Super reboot 'Truth, Justice and the American Way' may not exactly ring true these days, but Superman's motto served close to a century of comic books, TV shows and movies, and some hope we Yanks can regain the power and trust those words once implied. Maybe we need a… Look! Up in the sky! I was a fan from early on, starting with the DC comic books and then the B&W television show in the '60s starring George Reeves. So of course I ate up Richard Donner's seminal movie in 1978 Starring Christopher Reeve. Looking back, however, how were we to know that this entertaining flick would arguably kick off the endless tsunami of superhero sequels, prequels, origin stories, remakes and reimaginings that has come to define Hollywood's lack of originality? I stopped bothering with the genre a few years ago, at about the time when Coppola and Scorsese redefined superhero flicks as theme parks rather than actual movies. I simply had nothing to say about the endless combinations and permutations that lazy filmmakers came up with to lure pre-teen butts into theater seats. But I went to see James Gunn's reportedly new take on the Man of Steel. It was getting some good press for its fresh approach and was supposed to be pretty funny. Plus there's nothing else opening this weekend. Refreshingly non-macho Cast-wise, the new Superman, David Corenswet, does what needs to be done without getting all macho about it. Refreshing, that. A delight is Mrs. Maisel herself, Rachel Brosnahan, as Lois Lane, managing the right blend of glamor, grit and wit. The weakness is Nicholas Hoult as Lex Luthor. The man's a gifted actor but simply lacks the weight for the part. He's no Gene Hackman. The good stuff: Since this is Gunn's re-launch of the DC universe, there's little need to catch up on dozens of origin movies; no homework. Then there's the emphasis on fun. The movie concentrates on the lighter side of being able to leap tall buildings at a single bound. Despite its tentpole status, it even dips into satire of its own genre with the introduction of the 'Justice Gang,' the comically vain members of which can't even agree on their name. Great stuff. It's human scale, whimsical, silly, positive and intentionally cornball. The whole thing feels like a comic book but, you know, in the best way. Oh, and there's a superpowered flying dog. Have fun. (129 min)

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store