Umpire at centre of Wimbledon controversy ABSENT from match-list after chiefs were forced to apologise for blunder
German Nico Helwerth was in the chair for Sonay Kartal's Centre Court battle with Anastasia Pavlyuchenkova.
4
Nico Helwerth chats with Anastasia Pavlyuchenkova
Credit: Getty
4
Helwerth, 40, was in the chair during the controversy
Credit: PA
The match erupted into life with Pavlyuchenkova holding a game point while serving at 4-4 in the first set.
British favourite Kartal clearly missed a shot long, but the electronic line calling (ELC), run by tech company Hawk Eye, did not call it out.
As the tech system called "stop, stop" - Helwerth halted the point and told the crowd "there is a problem".
Bizarrely no video replay, which would have clearly shown the ball out, was available to Helwerth - and following a three-minute delay the 40-year-old followed protocol by replaying the point.
Pavlyuchenkova, who should have already won the game, went on to lose it - meaning that Kartal would go on to serve for the first set.
The Russian fumed at Helwerth during the next change of ends, even going as far as to accuse Wimbledon of home player bias.
The 34-year-old said: "I don't know if it's in or it's out. How do I know?
"How can you prove it? Because she is local, they can say whatever. You took the game away from me.'
Most read in Sport
BEST ONLINE CASINOS - TOP SITES IN THE UK
4
Pavlyuchenkova, 34, was understandably fuming with the decision
Credit: Getty
Pavlyuchenkova went on to break back and eventually win the first set, and the match.
But she did not row back on her comments much in her post-match press conference, again pointing to Kartal being a "local" player.
Britain's last hope in Wimbledon women's draw Sonay Kartal OUT after huge controversy as rival accuses umpire of bias
Hours after the incident, Wimbledon chiefs released the following statement: "Following the Pavlyuchenkova vs Kartal match, we have had the opportunity to undertake further investigation, including speaking to the players, chair umpire, Hawk-Eye operators and Review Official.
"It is now clear that the live ELC system, which was working optimally, was deactivated in error on part of the server's side of the court for one game by those operating the system.
"In that time there were three calls not picked up by live ELC on the affected part of the court. Two of these were called by the chair umpire, who was not made aware that the system had been deactivated.
"Following the third, the chair umpire stopped the match and consulted with the review official. It was determined that the point should be replayed. The chair umpire followed the established process.
"We have apologised to the players involved. We continue to have full confidence in the accuracy of the ball tracking technology. The live ELC system relies on the Hawk-Eye operators, the review official and the technology to work in harmony.
"This did not happen. In this instance there was a human error and as a consequence we have fully reviewed our processes and made the appropriate changes."
4
Wimbledon 2025 LIVE - follow all the latest scores and updates from a thrilling fortnight at SW19
All Engand Club chiefs have stressed that it is perfectly normal to rotate umpires throughout the tournament - and confirmed to SunSport that Helwerth would return to the chair tomorrow.
Wimbledon ditched line judges this year in favour of electronic line calling.
The ELC is run by the same company, Hawk Eye, that operated the challenge system that was previously available to players.
On Helwerth, Pavlyuchenkova said: "The chair umpire was so confused.
"I think they just need to… chair umpire needs to maybe have a clear plan if that happens, 'Okay, what am I going to do in this situation'.
"I think they are a little bit lost. They start calling everybody. They don't know what to do.
"Instead [they should be able to say]: 'if the system is down, then I'm going to take initiative and call this'.
Read more on the Irish Sun
"We probably should have this system like in football to review."
Pavlyuchenkova will return to action tomorrow, when she faces No13 seed Amanda Anisimova on No1 Court.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Daily Mirror
an hour ago
- Irish Daily Mirror
Heartbreak for Dimitrov as he retires when two sets up on world number one
Grigor Dimitrov suffered Wimbledon heartbreak when he was on the verge of knocking out world number one Jannik Sinner. The 34-year-old Bulgarian was two sets up and playing some inspired tennis when, at 2-2 in the third set, he clutched his chest after serving an ace. Sinner rushed around the net to check on his opponent as he sat, in some distress, on the court. The 19th seed was helped to his feet by two physios and went off to receive treatment, before returning a few minutes later to shake Sinner's hand. It was more dreadful luck for a popular player, who had to retire injured from matches in the last four grand slams, including against Daniil Medvedev here at the same stage last year. Sinner, who helped Dimitrov pack his rackets away and carried his bag off court, said: 'I don't know what to say. He is an incredible player, I think we all saw this today. 'He's been so unlucky in the past couple of years. An incredible player, a good friend also. Seeing him in this position, if there would be a chance he could play the next round he would deserve it. 'I hope he has a speedy recovery. I don't take this as a win at all. This is just a very unfortunate moment to witness for all of us. 'In the last grand slams he struggled a lot. Seeing him again having this kind of injury is very, very tough. It's very sad. We all wish him only the best, let's have applause for him.' It was a major reprieve for Sinner, the three-time grand slam winner who looked set to be on the end of a seismic shock in front of a stunned Centre Court. The Italian had slipped on the baseline in the opening game and took a medical timeout midway through the second set for treatment on his right wrist and elbow. But the physio was unable to alleviate the real pain for Sinner, which was Dimitrov serving up a grass-court clinic on a surface the 23-year-old has yet to get to grips with. However, after two hours and eight minutes of vintage Dimitrov, his body let him down again, so it is the top seed who will face American Ben Shelton in the quarter-finals.
The Irish Sun
an hour ago
- The Irish Sun
‘My pec, my pec' – Grigor Dimitrov breaks down in tears after horror Wimbledon injury and forced to retire vs Sinner
CROCKED Grigor Dimitrov broke down in tears as he retired from a FIFTH successive Grand Slam after injuring himself with a serve. The Bulgarian, 34, was two sets up against world No.1 Jannik Sinner and looking to reach the Wimbledon quarter-finals for the first time since 2014. 8 Grigor Dimitrov retired against Jannik Sinner after hurting himself while serving Credit: BBC 8 He was seen screaming 'my pec, my pec' in agony Credit: AP 8 Dimitrov was in tears as he had to pull out in horrible scenes Credit: BBC 8 Roger Federer watched on concerned from the Royal Box Credit: BBC Yet as he closed out game four of the third set, to draw level at 2-2, with a 96mph ace, he pulled something in his right arm and shoulder. Dimitrov collapsed to the floor in pain, clutching his right armpit and appeared to say "my pec, my pec" in reference to his pectoral muscle. The No19 seed then went backstage for medical treatment before deciding he could not continue. When he returned to the court to get his bags, he could barely lift his arm to shake the umpire's hand but he received a standing ovation for his efforts. Roger Federer, the eight-time men's champion, looked aghast from the Royal Box as the drama unfolded in an arena where he has had so much success and joy. It means Dimitrov's last five appearances at the majors – twice at Wimbledon, the US Open, Australian and French Open – he has had to quit mid-match. What makes it equally disappointing is that Sinner was there for the taking because he had hurt his elbow in set two and was on the physical brink. Sinner, 23, fell to the ground in game six of the second set when his right foot slipped on the slippery baseline. Most read in Tennis Instinctively, he put his right arm out to break his fall but hurt his elbow in the process of landing awkwardly. The Italian took a medical timeout, at 3-2 to Dimitrov, and a trainer tried to massage the area around his sore elbow. The reigning Australian and US Open champion was clearly in pain and at one point, uncharacteristically, he completely missed the ball with a swing of his racquet. It was his good fortune that he did not have to attempt, against the pain, a five-set comeback as Dimitrov got crocked in unexpected fashion. Sinner said: 'I don't know what to say because he's an incredible player. We all saw this today. 'He's been so unlucky in the past couple of years. An incredible player. A good friend of mine also. We understand each other very well off the court. 'Seeing him in this position, honestly if there would be a chance he could play the next round he would deserve it. 'But now mostly I hope he has a speedy recovery. 'Very, very unlucky from his side. I don't take this as a win at all. This is a very unfortunate moment to witness for all of us. 'I think in the last Grand Slams he has struggled a lot with injuries. To see him now having this kind of injury it's very, very tough. 8 Wimbledon 2025 LIVE - follow all the latest scores and updates from a thrilling fortnight at SW19 'We all saw this with his reaction, how much he cares about the sport, he is one of the most hard-working players on Tour. 'It's very unfortunate. Thank you for coming but this is not the end we wanted to see. It's very sad. We wish him all the best.' Before set three, officials decided to shut the retractable roof in anticipation of bad light. This decision was taken at around 8.20pm – as Sinner went backstage for some rest and treatment on his sore elbow. The call did not go down well with two-time singles champion Andy Murray, who felt there was more than an hour to go before the light really deteriorated. Murray said on X: 'So ridiculous to close the roof at this stage of the match. 'At least an hour of light left. Well over a set of tennis can still be played. It's an outdoor tournament!' American Brad Gilbert – a former coach of Murray, Andre Agassi and Andy Roddick – voiced his disapproval over the closure. He said: 'This is day 8 of Wimbledon and the seventh time this tournament will finish under roof. Not for rain. Because of long matches. Never seen this happen before.' Read more on the Irish Sun THIS IS A DEVELOPING STORY.. The Sun is your go to destination for the best football, boxing and MMA news, real-life stories, jaw-dropping pictures and must-see video . Like us on Facebook at 8 Dimitrov sobbed into a towel as he walked off court Credit: BBC 8 Dimitrov underwent a medical time-out but there was nothing that could be done 8 Sinner had treatment on a troublesome elbow after a fall Credit: EPA
The Irish Sun
an hour ago
- The Irish Sun
Football star reveals he has become a vegan after joining eco-friendly non-league club as manager
TOUGH-tackling footballer Robbie Savage has become a vegan after joining a non-league team as manager. The ex-Wales midfielder, who once held the Premier League record for yellow cards, is the new boss of eco-friendly Forest Green Rovers. 2 Former football hardman Robbie Savage has gone vegan - aligning with the values of his new club, Forest Green Rovers Credit: Getty 2 Eco-warrior and green energy boss Dale Vince, is owner of the non-league club Credit: Getty The club serves only vegan food in the players' canteen and to fans on match days. And The ex- He added of the Cotswolds: 'It's a beautiful place, though I have a little French bulldog and I'm not sure her legs will get over the hills, I'll have to carry her.' READ MORE FOOTBALL NEWS Meanwhile, the club's owner, eco-warrior Dale Vince, has been told he needs permission to fly a giant Palestinian flag hoisted on his firm's HQ - as it is not recognised as a country. The Ecotricity boss was ordered to get planning consent for the banner, which has been hung from his offices in Stroud, Glos. Vince, who owns "The council got in touch and said 'Oh, you can't actually fly that flag without planning permission because Palestine is not recognised by the British government'." Most read in Football What is up with you-' - Robbie Savage's harsh halftime dressing room team-talk that inspired Macclesfield to title win Unlock even more award-winning articles as The Sun launches brand new membership programme - Sun Club.
