'It's disgusting': Queensland youth justice system under fire after court rules against recording convictions for violent teens
A crime victim advocate has urged the Queensland government to reform its youth justice system after a court decided two violent Queensland teenagers would not have their convictions recorded.
On Tuesday, Queensland's Court of Appeal determined that the two teenagers who, armed with knives, broke into the home of Wallabies rugby legend Toutai Kefu in 2021, injuring Kefu and three of his family members, should not have a conviction recorded against them.
The two teenagers, who were 15 years old at the time, slashed and stabbed Kefu and his wife, and injured their two adult children who came to their parents' aid.
The Attorney-General appealed the case after Justice Peter Davis sentenced the two teens to less than 10 years in June last year.
The appeal was dismissed on Tuesday by three Court of Appeal judges on the basis the Attorney-General had not established the sentences were 'manifestly inadequate' or, justified why convictions should be recorded against children.
The court reaffirmed that not recording convictions aids children in their rehabilitation.
"The proposition that a child is entitled to the benefit of not having a conviction recorded to assist with their rehabilitation … is supported by an established line of authority of this court which has not been overruled," the judgment read.
It is well established in Australia that convictions are often not recorded against a child; if they are, they are often wiped after a crime-free period to give them the best possible chance at a clean slate and a crime-free life.
Voice for Victims advocacy group founder Ben Cannon, who was also Kefu's neighbour at the time, said legislation around child convictions needs to be tightened.
'It's disgusting, the fact that these individuals, criminals, that cause such mayhem… these judges have got to start to set a precedent," he told Sky News.
'That they can just skip through life with no burden on their name and no questions being asked of their family as to why this happened is absolutely abhorrent.
'This has gone on for too long, too many victims (because) judges are making poor decisions that don't fall in line with what we expect."
Mr Cannon, who was also injured in the attack, called on Queensland Premier David Crisafulli's government to make major changes to the state's criminal justice system.
'They can start listening to victims - when you go through the legislation, the laws are all so heavily weighted towards benefiting the criminal.
'The framework of the justice system is created out of how they can best manage a criminal. Well, what we need to start doing is, how do we see better outcomes for victims?'
Section 183 and 184 of the Queensland Youth Justice Act dictate a conviction is not to be recorded against a child who is found guilty of an offence unless it is an offence that warrants life in prison.
The act also dictates a judge should consider how recording a conviction may affect the chances of finding employment when making their decision.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Sydney Morning Herald
5 days ago
- Sydney Morning Herald
Wallabies legend reveals why he turned down Lions invite
Former Wallabies skipper Michael Hooper admits time has caught up with him after turning down the opportunity of a final playing farewell against the British and Irish Lions. Hooper was invited to play for the combined Australian and New Zealand XV against the Lions in Adelaide, but told Stan Sport's Inside Line podcast he felt his body was no longer up to the rigours of facing the world's best players. This masthead reported earlier this week that Hooper would not feature in the game, after the former Wallabies captain finished his eight-game stint with Japanese side Toyota Verblitz last month. 'I've played the Lions before, I know that they're a week out from a three-game Test series, and it's getting pointy end of that tour, and you've got probably a fully-fit starting team who's going to play against the Wallabies a week later, champing at the bit, battle-hardened,' Hooper said. 'And I looked at myself and I thought, 'Well, I've had a good time in Japan, they pour a good Asahi [beer], they make a nice rice ball at the local conveni [convenience store]. 'I'm about eight weeks to 10 weeks out of being battle-hardened, not in a Test environment. So I'd have to come home now, train by myself, maybe try and get a run for Manly – which would have been cool as well – but come up against those [Lions] guys in a team that you pulled together for a week. 'As a young guy? Perhaps two years, four years, five years, six years ago – oh my God, how good. 'As an almost 34-year-old who made a fleeting comeback? No, it didn't sound like a game that would be a fairytale ending for me. Not that I was ever after a fairytale ending.'
The Advertiser
5 days ago
- The Advertiser
Larkham wants proof Brumbies on track for Super title
Coach Stephen Larkham has no qualms about bringing Brumbies captain Allan Alaalatoa back from injury to face the Hurricanes despite the possibility of the Super Rugby Pacific qualifying final being a dead rubber. Alaalatoa missed their final-round loss to the Crusaders with a calf strain, but Larkham says his leadership is vital as the Brumbies look to see off the Hurricanes on Saturday night in Canberra. "He's had a good week so ticked everything off in terms of all the rehab markers with his strength, running, contact so he's ready to go," Larkham said of the Wallabies prop. "He's always been an outstanding rugby player but the leadership qualities that he brings to the team, the confidence that he gives the other players is certainly something that we're going to benefit from this weekend." In a quirk of the new six-team finals system and the scheduling of the finals, the third-placed Brumbies will know before kick-off whether they have a place in the semi-finals. There are three qualifying finals and all winners plus the top-ranked loser will advance. But Larkham said the Brumbies wanted to field their best team available and target a win regardless of the outcome of the other matches. "We are the last game this weekend but we've been pretty firm on making sure that we get a good performance out there on the field so irrespective of the other results we need to know that we're playing well," the coach said on Wednesday. "We can't get distracted by these other games and the other results. "The most important thing for us right now is to focus on our preparation so that we can have our best performance this weekend and either way we're going out there to try and win the game." In the only change to the starting side, Feao Fotuaika, who scored in the 33-31 loss to the Crusaders, will make way for Alaalatoa and return to the bench, bumping Rhys Van Nek out of the squad. Larkham said his team wanted a better first half after they trailed the Crusaders 14-25 at halftime while they were also down at the break in their last clash with the Hurricanes, which they also lost. He said with the Kiwi teams playing a similar fast and physical style, the Brumbies would be ready. "They're a physical side, the contests at the breakdown are very similar to Crusaders," Larkham said. "They're very good with the ball in hand, they've got dangerous threats around the ruck ... and they've got the ability to shift the ball quite well. "We've come across teams that play this way a few times this year and hopefully that's put us in a good position to play well this weekend." Brumbies: James Slipper, Billy Pollard, Allan Alaalatoa, Nick Frost, Tom Hooper, Rob Valetini, Rory Scott, Tuaina Taii Tualima, Ryan Lonergan, Noah Lolesio, Corey Toole, David Feliuai, Len Ikitau, Andy Muirhead, Tom Wright. Reserves: Lachlan Lonergan, Lington Ieli, Feao Fotuaika, Lachlan Shaw, Luke Reimer, Harrison Goddard, Declan Meredith, Ollie Sapsford. Hurricanes: Xavier Numia, Asafo Aumua, Tyrel Lomax, Zach Gallagher, Caleb Delany, Devan Flanders, Du'Plessis Kirifi, Peter Lakai, Cam Roigard, Brett Cameron, Fatafehi Fineanganofo, Peter Umaga-Jensen, Billy Proctor, Bailyn Sullivan, Ruben Love. Reserves: Raymond Tuputupu, Tevita Mafileo, Pasilio Tosi, Hugo Plummer, Brad Shields, Ereatara Enari, Ngatungane Punivai, Callum Harkin. Coach Stephen Larkham has no qualms about bringing Brumbies captain Allan Alaalatoa back from injury to face the Hurricanes despite the possibility of the Super Rugby Pacific qualifying final being a dead rubber. Alaalatoa missed their final-round loss to the Crusaders with a calf strain, but Larkham says his leadership is vital as the Brumbies look to see off the Hurricanes on Saturday night in Canberra. "He's had a good week so ticked everything off in terms of all the rehab markers with his strength, running, contact so he's ready to go," Larkham said of the Wallabies prop. "He's always been an outstanding rugby player but the leadership qualities that he brings to the team, the confidence that he gives the other players is certainly something that we're going to benefit from this weekend." In a quirk of the new six-team finals system and the scheduling of the finals, the third-placed Brumbies will know before kick-off whether they have a place in the semi-finals. There are three qualifying finals and all winners plus the top-ranked loser will advance. But Larkham said the Brumbies wanted to field their best team available and target a win regardless of the outcome of the other matches. "We are the last game this weekend but we've been pretty firm on making sure that we get a good performance out there on the field so irrespective of the other results we need to know that we're playing well," the coach said on Wednesday. "We can't get distracted by these other games and the other results. "The most important thing for us right now is to focus on our preparation so that we can have our best performance this weekend and either way we're going out there to try and win the game." In the only change to the starting side, Feao Fotuaika, who scored in the 33-31 loss to the Crusaders, will make way for Alaalatoa and return to the bench, bumping Rhys Van Nek out of the squad. Larkham said his team wanted a better first half after they trailed the Crusaders 14-25 at halftime while they were also down at the break in their last clash with the Hurricanes, which they also lost. He said with the Kiwi teams playing a similar fast and physical style, the Brumbies would be ready. "They're a physical side, the contests at the breakdown are very similar to Crusaders," Larkham said. "They're very good with the ball in hand, they've got dangerous threats around the ruck ... and they've got the ability to shift the ball quite well. "We've come across teams that play this way a few times this year and hopefully that's put us in a good position to play well this weekend." Brumbies: James Slipper, Billy Pollard, Allan Alaalatoa, Nick Frost, Tom Hooper, Rob Valetini, Rory Scott, Tuaina Taii Tualima, Ryan Lonergan, Noah Lolesio, Corey Toole, David Feliuai, Len Ikitau, Andy Muirhead, Tom Wright. Reserves: Lachlan Lonergan, Lington Ieli, Feao Fotuaika, Lachlan Shaw, Luke Reimer, Harrison Goddard, Declan Meredith, Ollie Sapsford. Hurricanes: Xavier Numia, Asafo Aumua, Tyrel Lomax, Zach Gallagher, Caleb Delany, Devan Flanders, Du'Plessis Kirifi, Peter Lakai, Cam Roigard, Brett Cameron, Fatafehi Fineanganofo, Peter Umaga-Jensen, Billy Proctor, Bailyn Sullivan, Ruben Love. Reserves: Raymond Tuputupu, Tevita Mafileo, Pasilio Tosi, Hugo Plummer, Brad Shields, Ereatara Enari, Ngatungane Punivai, Callum Harkin. Coach Stephen Larkham has no qualms about bringing Brumbies captain Allan Alaalatoa back from injury to face the Hurricanes despite the possibility of the Super Rugby Pacific qualifying final being a dead rubber. Alaalatoa missed their final-round loss to the Crusaders with a calf strain, but Larkham says his leadership is vital as the Brumbies look to see off the Hurricanes on Saturday night in Canberra. "He's had a good week so ticked everything off in terms of all the rehab markers with his strength, running, contact so he's ready to go," Larkham said of the Wallabies prop. "He's always been an outstanding rugby player but the leadership qualities that he brings to the team, the confidence that he gives the other players is certainly something that we're going to benefit from this weekend." In a quirk of the new six-team finals system and the scheduling of the finals, the third-placed Brumbies will know before kick-off whether they have a place in the semi-finals. There are three qualifying finals and all winners plus the top-ranked loser will advance. But Larkham said the Brumbies wanted to field their best team available and target a win regardless of the outcome of the other matches. "We are the last game this weekend but we've been pretty firm on making sure that we get a good performance out there on the field so irrespective of the other results we need to know that we're playing well," the coach said on Wednesday. "We can't get distracted by these other games and the other results. "The most important thing for us right now is to focus on our preparation so that we can have our best performance this weekend and either way we're going out there to try and win the game." In the only change to the starting side, Feao Fotuaika, who scored in the 33-31 loss to the Crusaders, will make way for Alaalatoa and return to the bench, bumping Rhys Van Nek out of the squad. Larkham said his team wanted a better first half after they trailed the Crusaders 14-25 at halftime while they were also down at the break in their last clash with the Hurricanes, which they also lost. He said with the Kiwi teams playing a similar fast and physical style, the Brumbies would be ready. "They're a physical side, the contests at the breakdown are very similar to Crusaders," Larkham said. "They're very good with the ball in hand, they've got dangerous threats around the ruck ... and they've got the ability to shift the ball quite well. "We've come across teams that play this way a few times this year and hopefully that's put us in a good position to play well this weekend." Brumbies: James Slipper, Billy Pollard, Allan Alaalatoa, Nick Frost, Tom Hooper, Rob Valetini, Rory Scott, Tuaina Taii Tualima, Ryan Lonergan, Noah Lolesio, Corey Toole, David Feliuai, Len Ikitau, Andy Muirhead, Tom Wright. Reserves: Lachlan Lonergan, Lington Ieli, Feao Fotuaika, Lachlan Shaw, Luke Reimer, Harrison Goddard, Declan Meredith, Ollie Sapsford. Hurricanes: Xavier Numia, Asafo Aumua, Tyrel Lomax, Zach Gallagher, Caleb Delany, Devan Flanders, Du'Plessis Kirifi, Peter Lakai, Cam Roigard, Brett Cameron, Fatafehi Fineanganofo, Peter Umaga-Jensen, Billy Proctor, Bailyn Sullivan, Ruben Love. Reserves: Raymond Tuputupu, Tevita Mafileo, Pasilio Tosi, Hugo Plummer, Brad Shields, Ereatara Enari, Ngatungane Punivai, Callum Harkin.
Sky News AU
5 days ago
- Sky News AU
'It's disgusting': Queensland youth justice system under fire after court rules against recording convictions for violent teens
A crime victim advocate has urged the Queensland government to reform its youth justice system after a court decided two violent Queensland teenagers would not have their convictions recorded. On Tuesday, Queensland's Court of Appeal determined that the two teenagers who, armed with knives, broke into the home of Wallabies rugby legend Toutai Kefu in 2021, injuring Kefu and three of his family members, should not have a conviction recorded against them. The two teenagers, who were 15 years old at the time, slashed and stabbed Kefu and his wife, and injured their two adult children who came to their parents' aid. The Attorney-General appealed the case after Justice Peter Davis sentenced the two teens to less than 10 years in June last year. The appeal was dismissed on Tuesday by three Court of Appeal judges on the basis the Attorney-General had not established the sentences were 'manifestly inadequate' or, justified why convictions should be recorded against children. The court reaffirmed that not recording convictions aids children in their rehabilitation. "The proposition that a child is entitled to the benefit of not having a conviction recorded to assist with their rehabilitation … is supported by an established line of authority of this court which has not been overruled," the judgment read. It is well established in Australia that convictions are often not recorded against a child; if they are, they are often wiped after a crime-free period to give them the best possible chance at a clean slate and a crime-free life. Voice for Victims advocacy group founder Ben Cannon, who was also Kefu's neighbour at the time, said legislation around child convictions needs to be tightened. 'It's disgusting, the fact that these individuals, criminals, that cause such mayhem… these judges have got to start to set a precedent," he told Sky News. 'That they can just skip through life with no burden on their name and no questions being asked of their family as to why this happened is absolutely abhorrent. 'This has gone on for too long, too many victims (because) judges are making poor decisions that don't fall in line with what we expect." Mr Cannon, who was also injured in the attack, called on Queensland Premier David Crisafulli's government to make major changes to the state's criminal justice system. 'They can start listening to victims - when you go through the legislation, the laws are all so heavily weighted towards benefiting the criminal. 'The framework of the justice system is created out of how they can best manage a criminal. Well, what we need to start doing is, how do we see better outcomes for victims?' Section 183 and 184 of the Queensland Youth Justice Act dictate a conviction is not to be recorded against a child who is found guilty of an offence unless it is an offence that warrants life in prison. The act also dictates a judge should consider how recording a conviction may affect the chances of finding employment when making their decision.
