Coalition demands rewrite of laws to re-detain NZYQ members
The federal government rushed "preventative detention" laws through in late 2023 with the Coalition's support, after a High Court ruling caused the release of dozens of people with serious criminal convictions who had served their time but remained in immigration detention.
The laws enabled the government to apply to have high-risk members of roughly 300 people released from the NZYQ ruling placed back in detention, if they were deemed to pose a threat to community safety.
After an ex-immigration detainee allegedly murdered a 62-year-old man at Footscray mall while on bail and wearing an ankle monitor, scrutiny has again returned to how the government is handling the NZYQ cohort.
Shadow Immigration Minister Paul Scarr said the government had failed to use powers it had been given 16 months ago.
"We were told that the work was underway, evidence was being collected … and then we have the shocking admission 16 months later that it wasn't practical to make applications," Senator Scarr said.
"We should be looking at how to amend the legislation."
The Coalition supported the government's 2023 Community Safety Orders, and moved its own amendments to that legislation.
Senator Scarr acknowledged that, and did not offer proposals for how the scheme could be rewritten.
But he said until the weekend, the government had been assuring it was in the process of applying to re-detain the cohort.
Home Affairs Minister Tony Burke said on Sunday that the legislation had set a high bar for people to be placed back in detention and none of the cohort had yet met it.
"The reality is the legal thresholds we are stuck with because of some of the decisions of the High Court are more difficult to reach than I wanted them to be," he said.
The minister said he had not given up on that effort, but his preference now was to see the group deported.
The government is wary of a further loss in the courts that could again restrict its legislative ability — the ruling in NZYQ that overturned two decades of precedent was that indefinite ongoing detention was punitive in nature, and therefore unlawful.
There is a risk for government that detaining people who have not committed an offence, or applying overly harsh punishments to offences such as a breach of curfew or monitoring conditions, could also be thrown out in a High Court challenge.
The Law Council of Australia said at the time of the laws being passed that preventative detention should only be allowed in exceptional circumstances and imposed after a fair hearing by a court.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
ABC News
31 minutes ago
- ABC News
Tasmanian Liberals retain power
A no-confidence motion in Tasmania's Liberal government has failed to pass. It marks the final note in the Tasmanian election, with Labor defeated, and the Liberal government retaining power in minority.
West Australian
35 minutes ago
- West Australian
RTS: Harris warns Aussie mining supremacy is under threat, while Minister King fires up on nuclear
Sandfire Resources chief executive Brendan Harris said parts of Africa and Europe are nipping at the heels of Australia as the world's premier mining jurisdiction. Meanwhile, Federal Resources Minister Madeleine King hammered another nail in the nuclear energy coffin and brushed off suggestions artificial intelligence could devastate jobs in the resources industry. Mr Harris, speaking at a Resources Technology Showcase panel, said Sandfire had avoided much of the cost inflation and regulatory approval logjams plaguing Australian mining operations in recent years. West Perth-based Sandfire, which owned the high-grade DeGrussa mine in WA until it was exhausted in 2023, has found renewed success with mines in Spain and Botswana. 'We haven't had anywhere near the level of inflationary pressure in our industry in those two locations (Spain and Botswana) over the last two to three years (compared to Australia),' Mr Harris said. 'In fact, our costs remain relatively steady. Our approvals are generally more easily obtained with the same rigor, I might add. 'But the last one, the thing I feel people need to be really aware of, is in Spain we buy 100 per cent of our power off the grid, 100 per cent carbon emissions-free. 'We haven't had to develop any of that capacity. So when we think about this as a race, somewhat, I think we just need to be careful to assume that we (Australia) are at the front of the pack.' With the panel's discussion revolving around artificial intelligence and its heavy energy requirements in the context of a decarbonising world, a fired-up Minister King emphatically ruled out nuclear energy becoming part of Australia's energy mix. The Coalition made nuclear energy a key tenet of its energy policy leading up to the May Federal election. 'It didn't get them (the Coalition) very far . . . the election was not that long ago, and we talked about it a lot. So at the moment, that's not up for re-consideration.' Minister King said it was 'reasonable' people in the mining industry were fearful of being replaced by AI but she believes the technology would enable a new tranche of 'better, safer jobs' in the industry. Caterpillar vice president of technology and global sales Corey Wurtzbacher and Hancock Iron Ore executive general manager of technology Kate Flanagan were in agreement that AI presented more opportunities than threats. '(AI is) definitely not a threat, it creates more opportunities, a higher level of performance. I'm not a technologist, but I look after a technology team — there's plenty of room in technology for everyone,' Ms Flanagan said. She said a 'Skynet' scenario reminiscent of the 1980s blockbuster film Terminator, where AI machines overpower their human creators and take control of the globe, was an 'unlikely scenario.' Mr Wurtzbacher said Caterpillar was investing big in AI and technology more broadly to enhance its offerings to mining clients across the globe. 'Caterpillar really wants to be positioned with WesTrac as to how do we really provide value to the customer, and lean in heavily with research and development to support that initiative'.
ABC News
35 minutes ago
- ABC News
Two men involved in fatal helicopter accident charged over stealing crocodile eggs from Kakadu National Park
Two men, including the pilot who survived a fatal helicopter accident in 2022, have been charged over stealing saltwater crocodile eggs from the Northern Territory's iconic Kakadu National Park. Sebastian Robinson and Timothy Luck, both aged in their early 30s, are facing Commonwealth charges alleging "unauthorised taking" of eggs from the park in February 2024. Mr Robinson and Mr Luck were both involved in a crocodile egg collecting mission in February 2022 which resulted in the death of television personality Chris "Willow" Wilson. Mr Robinson was piloting the helicopter involved in the accident and suffered lifelong injuries as a result, including paraplegia and a traumatic brain injury. The ABC is not alleging any wrongdoing on behalf of either man in relation to the 2022 crash. The Office of the Director of Public Prosecutions (CDPP), Australia's federal prosecution service, confirmed its involvement. "[The CDPP] is prosecuting this matter after a joint investigation by Parks Australia, the Australian Federal Police and the Northern Territory Parks and Wildlife Commission,' a spokesperson said. Parks Australia said proceedings started in the Darwin Local Court on Tuesday. "Parks Australia will not be providing further comment as this matter is before the court," a spokesperson said. Both cases were adjourned until September 30. Crocodile egg collecting is a recognised practice in the NT. It is done for various reasons, including conservation and commercial business operations. It often involves a helicopter pilot lowering a collector into nests from the air to avoid having to walk distances in crocodile-inhabited waters. The practice is legal. However, it does requires approvals from environmental authorities and traditional owners in certain areas. Kakadu, located about 150 kilometres east of Darwin, covers almost 20,000 square kilometres, including estuaries, floodplains and billabongs. The park, which is also a UNESCO world heritage listed site, is known for its large crocodile population with roughly 10 per cent of the Northern Territory's crocodile population estimated to live in Kakadu.
