No legal basis to appeal paedophile GP sentence, PPS says
Concern had been expressed by some politicians following the sentencing last month of Alan Trevor Campbell, 40, of Silverbrook Park in Newbuildings, Co Derry.
Advertisement
He pleaded guilty to 11 offences around possessing indecent images of children on dates between October 2014 and January 2022.
He was sentenced to 75 hours of community service and was given a two-year probation order at Downpatrick Crown Court.
The PPS had previously said it was considering if there was a legal basis to refer the sentence to the Court of Appeal.
But in a statement on Thursday, a spokesperson said it had been 'unable to identify any legal error' in the sentencing process in the case.
Advertisement
The spokesperson said: 'The PPS recognises that there is rightly public concern when cases involving indecent images of children come before the courts, particularly where the defendant is in a position of trust.
'The courts also recognise that the abuse of young and vulnerable children in the production of indecent images is abhorrent.
'Those who access such material perpetuate the market for this abuse and are guilty by association with those who originally carried out despicable acts in creating the images in the first place.'
The spokesperson said the PPS had taken into consideration the judge's sentencing remarks and sentencing guidelines in the Campbell case.
Advertisement
The statement added: 'While there is understandable condemnation of anyone caught with any amount of indecent images, the independent judiciary have set clear guidelines that have to be followed when sentencing all offenders to ensure a consistency in approach.
'Having carefully considered the detailed sentencing remarks prepared by the judge, we have been unable to identify any legal error and do not consider that this is a case which could be successfully referred to the Court of Appeal on the basis that the sentence was unduly lenient.
'Therefore, there is no legal basis for the PPS to refer it for consideration.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Sun
an hour ago
- The Sun
Moment evil babysitter weeps as she's jailed for delivering disabled children to paedophile lover so he could rape them
THIS is the moment a depraved babysitter weeps during her sentencing as she is jailed for delivering disabled children to her sick lover so he could rape them. Brittney Mae Lyon, 31, advertised babysitting services online, with a so-called speciality in working with special needs children. 6 6 6 The twisted carer earned the trust of parents who left their kids under her supervision by boasting she had studied child development. But the San Diego woman was actually sexually abusing the girls - providing them to her boyfriend Samuel Cabrera, 31, so he could molest them. In some cases, he filmed the horrific abuse on victimss as young as three years old and as old as seven. The disabled children were autistic and non-verbal. Lyon pleaded guilty to two counts of a lewd act upon a child and two counts of a forcible lewd act upon a child in May. She also admitted additional allegations of kidnapping, residential burglary and sexually assaulting multiple victims. The chilling abuse came to light in 2016 when a seven-year-old girl told her mum she didn't want to go anywhere with Lyon. The babysitter was even a long term friend of the family and babysat her on multiple occasions. The child then told her mum about the abuse, who then immediately alerted cops, the San Diego Union-Tribune reported. A police probe resulted in the arrest of Cabrera, then 22 years old, and Lyon. Watch 'perv' teacher Christina Formella arrive at court with husband by her side…as she's accused of molesting teen boy Cabrera's car contained a double-locked box containing six computer hard drives with hundreds of videos of him abusing victims. Some of the children in the videos were drugged and the clips were often filmed with multiple cameras to capture different angles, prosecutors said. The sickening footage featured multiple unknown victims, sparking an investigation to track down other families who had hired Lyon as a babysitter. Parents of three of the victims said they met Lyon through a babysitting website. They claimed she had "touted her interest in working with special needs children," the San Diego County District Attorney's Office said. One mum even saw a news story about Lyon and Cabrera's heinous crimes, before reaching out to cops. The horrified parent then learned that her own three-year-old was among the victims filmed being abused by the twisted couple. Another one of the pair's victims was a seven-year-old with autism - who could not dress or bathe herself or speak. 6 6 Lyon and Cabrera met in high school, and he initially convinced her to secretly record women getting changed in dressing rooms and gym locker rooms, prosecutors said. The pedophile then asked Lyon to bring children in her care to his home. Lyon participated in some of the abuse herself, according to prosecutors. Cabrera went on trial in 2019 charged with 35 felonies, including multiple counts involving child molestation, kidnapping, burglary and conspiracy. He was convicted on all charges, with the jury taking just two hours to deliberate. The sick abuser was sentenced to eight life sentences without the possibility of parole and 300 additional years. The babysitter's defence attorney read a statement on her behalf. It read: "For nine years, I've thought about what I would say today. "I've come to the conclusion that there are no words that would make any of the harm and trauma I've caused any better. "The words 'I'm sorry' are far too simple for the amount of trauma I've caused and the amount of regret that I feel." A mum of one of the victims said Lyon "used her credentials to lull us into a state of comfort so we didn't feel like we had to ask a lot of questions about what Brittany did with our daughter when they were together". Although Cabrera is not eligible for parole, Lyon is. She was sentenced to 100 years behind bars, but it is possible she could be released after serving just a third of her sentence. 6
The Sun
an hour ago
- The Sun
Bizarre moment smiling £26m drug lord jumps for joy as he's arrested – before being jailed for 43 years
THIS is the bizarre moment a grinning drug lord jumps for joy as he's arrested – although he's not laughing now as he's been banged up for 43 years. Jamie Rothwell, 38, from Salford, was filmed while being arrested by Spanish cops after he was identified as running a £26million drugs empire in Greater Manchester. 5 5 In the short footage, a handcuffed Rothwell is pictured smiling and talking to the arresting officers. When he is led away, wearing shorts and a black t-shirt, he does a little dance and then kicks his legs in the air. Rothwell, has now been sentenced at Manchester Crown Court, along with nine other associates, who were sentenced to a total of 163 years and 11 months. The drug lord pleaded guilty in February to one count of conspiracy to possess firearms with intent to endanger life; one count of conspiracy to possess ammunition with intent to endanger life; conspiracy to supply a controlled drug of Class A, namely cocaine; two counts of conspiracy to cause grievous bodily harm with intent and a single count of conspiracy to supply a controlled drug of Class B, namely ketamine. International law enforcement agencies were able to infiltrate the once encrypted messaging service EncroChat, in April 2020 and detectives from Greater Manchester Police's Serious Organised Crime Group launched a covert investigation into the gang. When the encrypted platform was compromised in April 2020, Rothwell was living in Spain and continuing to organise the importation and distribution of drugs, firearms, and criminal cash from abroad. Despite his attempts to evade justice, detectives were able to monitor his encrypted communications in real time, exposing his command over a sprawling criminal enterprise and his involvement in the trafficking of high-powered weapons, including AK-47 rifles. His drug empire was estimated to have a street value of around £26million – he was deported back to the UK in 2021 to face trial. Senior Investigating Officer Detective Sergeant Colin Shackleton said: 'The supply of Class A drugs in this investigation were on an industrial scale, with the criminal gang making eye-watering profits. "They believed they were above the law, and having access to their messages gave us real insight into their arrogant, egotistical, and apathetic nature. Moment parrot helps cops bring down huge drug gang with criminal squawking 'This has been a complex and long-standing investigation which has spanned years and international borders. "These sentences today are testament to years of hard work by Greater Manchester Police SOCG team, Cheshire SOCU, the Crown Prosecution Service, Prosecution Barristers, the NCA and our partner agencies. 'It is not uncommon for suspects to flee the country in a bid to avoid facing the consequences of their crimes, but this case epitomises our dedication of bringing offenders to justice, regardless of where they try and hide. 'International collaboration was crucial to this case, and here we worked closely with the National Crime Agency and the Spanish authorities, and we continue to do so to locate fugitives who are currently at large. 'We share the common goal to see these people behind bars and we will do all we can to achieve this.' 5 5
Daily Mail
3 hours ago
- Daily Mail
Babysitter weeps as she's given enormous sentence for delivering disabled children to pedophile boyfriend so he could rape them
A San Diego babysitter broke down in tears in court as she was sentenced to 100 years to life in prison for delivering little girls to her pedophile boyfriend to molest. Brittney Mae Lyon, 31, advertised her babysitting services online - with a particular interest in working with special needs children - and earned the trust of parents who left their kids in her care. But, in reality, she was sexually abusing the little girls and providing them to her boyfriend Samuel Cabrera, 31, who would film himself molesting them. The victims were aged between three and seven years old and some were autistic and non-verbal. Lyon pleaded guilty to two counts of a lewd act upon a child and two counts of a forcible lewd act upon a child in May. She also admitted additional allegations of kidnapping, residential burglary and sexually assaulting multiple victims. The sick abuse came to light in 2016 when a seven-year-old girl told her mother she didn't want to go anywhere with Lyon - a long-term friend of the family who also babysat her - anymore. The little girl then told her mom about the abuse who went to the police, according to the San Diego Union-Tribune. An investigation led Carlsbad police to Cabrera, then 22, and both he and Lyon were arrested. A search of Cabrera's car uncovered a double-locked box containing six computer hard drives with hundreds of videos of him abusing victims. Some of the victims in the videos were drugged and the clips were often filmed with multiple cameras to capture different angles, prosecutors said. The horrifying tapes featured multiple unknown victims, prompting an investigation to track down other families who had hired Lyon as a babysitter. Parents of three of the victims had met Lyon through a babysitting website where she had 'touted her interest in working with special needs children,' according to the San Diego County District Attorney's Office. One mother saw a news story about Lyon and Cabrera's awful crimes and reached out to police, only to learn that her own three-year-old was among the victims filmed being abused by the twisted couple. Another victim was a developmentally-delayed seven-year-old with autism, who could not dress or bathe herself or speak. Lyon and Cabrera met in high school and he initially convinced her to secretly record women getting changed in dressing rooms and gym locker rooms, prosecutors said. Then, the pedophile asked Lyon to bring children in her care to his home - where she participated in some of the abuse, according to prosecutors. Cabrera went on trial in 2019 charged with 35 felonies, including multiple counts involving child molestation, kidnapping, burglary and conspiracy. It took a North County jury just two hours to convict him on all charges. He was sentenced to eight terms of life in prison without the possibility of parole and 300 additional years. Lyon's case was stalled by Covid courtroom closures and by changes of attorneys. She has been represented by three different defense attorneys over the past nine years: a public defender, then private counsel and then another public defender. At her sentencing inside the Vista Courthouse in San Diego Thursday, the babysitter's defense attorney read a statement on her behalf. 'For nine years, I've thought about what I would say today. I've come to the conclusion that there are no words that would make any of the harm and trauma I've caused any better,' the statement read. 'The words "I'm sorry" are far too simple for the amount of trauma I've caused and the amount of regret that I feel.' Parents of the victims also spoke in court on Thursday. One mother said Lyon 'used her credentials' - such as studying child development - 'to lull us into a state of comfort so we didn't feel like we had to ask a lot of questions about what Brittany did with our daughter when they were together'. What the mother thought was a special trip for their daughter to play places she later learned were 'molestation sessions,' she said. Cabrera is not eligible for parole, but Lyon - who was sentenced to 100 years to life - is. This means it is possible she could be released after serving just a third of her sentence. Some of the victims' parents slammed the possibility that she could be freed in future. 'It's a slap in the face to drag us through this field of broken glass for 10 years only to give Brittney a break,' one mother said. A California law change now allows for 'elder parole,' where inmates who have served at least 20 years of their sentence can petition for a parole hearing when they turn 50. While legislative efforts to exclude sex offenders from this rule have stalled, the San Diego County District Attorney's Office has continued to push for the change. 'The age of 50 is hardly "elderly," particularly in the realm of child molesters, who need only be in a position of trust and power to access and sexually abuse children,' District Attorney Summer Stephan said in a news release in reference to Lyon's sentencing.
