'People are angry with you': Seymour admits regulations contribute to ‘enormous rate rises'
Deputy Prime Minister David Seymour says there is no policy for local government reform - yet.
In his speech to local government leaders in Christchurch today, Mr Seymour took a softer approach than expected, acknowledging pressures placed on local councils by central government.
Council leaders told Local Democracy Reporting they felt more upbeat after his speech at the two-day Local Government New Zealand conference.
It was a contrast to yesterday, when councillors said they felt like "the whipping boys" after a short video address from Prime Minister Christopher Luxon and then Resource Management Act Reform Minister Chris Bishop putting a halt to council planning to stop "wasteful spending".
In Mr Seymour's speech, he said the government has "no policy of changing the structure of local government" - contrary to recent political statements.
But he acknowledged change could come out of the Resource Management Act reforms.
Mr Seymour said he recognised regulations imposed by central government were helping to push up rates.
"It is true that people are angry with you [councils] because of enormous rate rises, but many of the challenges councils face are enforced by statutory rules."
He encouraged people to contact the "red tape tip-line" with any "unnecessary regulations".
"I want to float the idea that we all want the same thing - and that is affordable and efficient government."
Responding to a question from Gore Mayor Ben Bell, Mr Seymour admitted to "kicking the can down the road" to share goods and services tax (GST) on new builds with councils - a promise made by ACT during the 2023 general election.
"We aren't going to lose sleep about it, because times are tough."
But it remained on the agenda, he said.
Councils have been asking the government for the GST to be shared in a bid to create more revenue to help with rising costs.
Mr Seymour said city and regional deals would lead to better co-ordination between central and local government, creating more efficiencies and cost savings.
Hauraki Mayor Toby Adams said he felt councils were being rapped over the knuckles by central government at the conference.
"This year the tone has changed, where you are realising the pressure that local government is under financially from the statutory obligations of central government.
"You're saying it to us here, but you are not saying it to the public."
Mr Adams called on central government to share the message to the public that rising costs are pushing up rates.
"We are working hard, we are trying ... that's not out there in the public."
After the speech, Mr Seymour told LDR he wasn't taking a soft or hard approach to councils.
"We should be collaborative," he said.
- By David Hill, Local Democracy Reporter
• LDR is local body journalism co-funded by RNZ and NZ On Air.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Otago Daily Times
10 hours ago
- Otago Daily Times
Mayoral hopeful berates council chief executive
Wendy Baker. PHOTO: ODT FILES A Southland mayoral hopeful has taken shots at a council chief executive during a fiery public speech. On Wednesday, Wendy Baker presented to district councillors about the council's dog control policy and bylaw review. But her presentation began on an unrelated note when she read out a letter she had received from the minister of sports and recreation about her sporting accomplishments. "I wanted to bring that up because it's a positive letter of praise. And unfortunately, just recently, your CEO — who is extremely well paid — sent me a letter which was very upsetting to me," Ms Baker said. "This letter as you all know has gone to the ombudsman. A leader needs to build people up, and I will not be bullied when I do amazing amounts of volunteer work, which your council ignores formally, I feel." Ms Baker would not divulge the contents of the chief executive's letter, but confirmed to Local Democracy Reporting it was not related to the minister's letter. The letter was out of the blue, unnecessary and untimely, she said. "They should be praising the work I do and not sending a letter that upsets me." In response to questions, council chief executive Cameron McIntosh was tight-lipped. "We have raised some matters with Ms Baker. They are between council and Ms Baker," he said. "We will leave it with Ms Baker to decide if she wishes to share the contents of the letter with media." Ms Baker's presentation also took aim at the council over a perceived lack of dog control. She said a dog had come on to her property twice in three weeks — once on the eve of Anzac Day attacking a possum and once attacking a back fence at 4am. "I pay $4099.50 in rates to SDC ... and what do I get for it? Stuff all." The mayoral hopeful is one of three candidates in the running for the top job this October. At the 2022 election, she finished last out of six candidates with 211 votes. ■ LDR is local body journalism co-funded by RNZ and NZ On Air.
NZ Herald
21 hours ago
- NZ Herald
David Seymour resurrects idea of migrants signing NZ ‘values statement'
'These sorts of things are values that we need to stress. If you don't subscribe to that, don't come here,' he said. Asked about immigration concerns on Newstalk ZB this week, Seymour noted that in 2016 he had made the point that 'we should actually have a New Zealand values statement'. 'That's not the Government's policy. But I suspect it should be,' the Act leader said. He said that 'if you want to be part of New Zealand', people should 'sign up to' ideas such as 'men and women are equal', 'someone's sexuality or religion is a private matter', 'we have certain rights before the law' and 'we have free speech'. The Act Party's constitution makes mention of this idea as an example of a policy that reflects its principles. 'Any person seeking New Zealand citizenship or permanent residency should be required to affirm that they subscribe to the democratic and civil rights enunciated in sections 12-18 of the New Zealand Bill of Rights Act 1990.' These sections of the Bill of Rights Act relate to the likes of freedom of peaceful assembly, expression and association. Act's David Seymour has again raised the idea of a New Zealand values statement. Photo / Michael Craig A spokesman for Immigration Minister Erica Stanford said a values statement is not something the minister has raised with officials or been advised on. 'The minister's work programme has been focused on restoring stability and predictability to the immigration system – getting net migration under control, prioritising higher skilled migrants, reducing migrant exploitation, speeding up visa processing, supporting additional foreign investment for New Zealand, and fit for purpose settings across work, study and visitor visas.' Unlike New Zealand, Australia does have a values statement that most temporary, provisional or permanent visa applicants must sign or accept. This includes confirming they understand 'Australian society values', like 'respect for the freedom and dignity of the individual', 'freedom of religion (including the freedom not to follow a particular religion), freedom of speech, and freedom of association', and 'commitment to the rule of law'. The Australian Home Affairs Department says by accepting the statement, migrants are 'undertaking to conduct yourself in accordance with Australian values and to obey Australian laws during your stay in Australia'. In 2016, Peters, who is now in a coalition Government with Seymour, suggested the Act leader was stealing NZ First's policy. 'Being a secretive admirer of New Zealand First is no excuse for plagiarising that party's leader's statements,' the Herald reported Peters as saying at the time. He also described Seymour as a 'toy MP'. Peters said at the time that migrants should be interviewed at the border to ensure they respect New Zealand 'views'. Two years later, then-NZ First MP Clayton Mitchell proposed the Respecting New Zealand Values Bill, which would have required refugees and migrants to sign up to New Zealand values. These were identified as including respect for gender equality, religious freedom and New Zealand law. NZ First leader Winston Peters also believes migrants should subscribe to New Zealand values. Photo / Mark Mitchell While speaking with Newstalk ZB, Seymour also said there were some people who say, 'immigration is terrible, vote for me [and] I will get rid of it'. 'But they don't actually stop immigration when they get into power,' he said. Seymour said he believed the reason for that was because business owners know 'you can't succeed when you only have 5 million people to pick from when your competitors around the world are operating in labour markets of half a billion'. Peters last week told the Herald he was concerned with the number of migrants entering New Zealand and said it remained NZ First's view that immigration shouldn't be 'an excuse for our failure to train, skill and employ our own people'. His comments about the 'alarming development' overseas of 'careless immigration policies transforming cities' received criticism from Opposition parties. Prime Minister Christopher Luxon on Monday said Peters was entitled to have his own views. 'What I am focused on is making sure I advance New Zealand's national interests, economic and security. Immigration will always be on our terms and in the interest of New Zealand,' Luxon said. 'He is entitled as a political party leader to make comments about his observations of other countries. My job as Prime Minister of New Zealand is to say I am focused on making sure we have the right immigration settings for ourselves in order for us to grow our economy.' Jamie Ensor is a political reporter in the NZ Herald press gallery team based at Parliament. He was previously a TV reporter and digital producer in the Newshub press gallery office. In 2025, he was a finalist for Political Journalist of the Year at the Voyager Media Awards.
NZ Herald
a day ago
- NZ Herald
Horizons regional councillor David Cotton signing off after four terms
'That's what I'm quite proud of, really knowing our numbers, whether that was with sustainable land use or public transport.' Cotton opposed an additional $400,000 for Whanganui's public transport in 2025/26, saying last November that while the city's high-frequency bus service Te Ngaru The Tide had been a success, it was still running below capacity. Councillors voted 10-4 to keep the funding in Horizons' budget, with the annual plan signed off on June 24. Cotton said he had been out of step with other councillors this term on rates rises. In Whanganui, the average rates rise from the regional council was 12.8% for 2025/26. 'Thirty per cent of that was because we put a new bus system in,' Cotton said. 'I'd say that was a nice to have. Central Government would not fund 50% like they normally do.' Cotton said it was time to consider whether regional councils were needed or if there should be a unitary authority. 'Particularly here in Whanganui, with the ownership structure around the Whanganui River,' he said. 'With the changes in the RMA [Resource Management Act], and the amount of work regional councils won't be required to do, I think it's the opportune time to have that conversation. 'Personally, I'd like to see it go to referendum in the election of 2028.' Whanganui district councillors Jenny Duncan and Charlie Anderson, Whanganui Deputy Mayor Helen Craig, and Horizons chair Rachel Keedwell are also standing down at the end of the term. Cotton said anyone thinking of running for council needed to know standing orders and how meetings and systems worked. 'It's very different than a private business,' he said. 'You can come up with a great idea but find you don't have the funding in place because you haven't had it added to an annual or long-term plan.' He had thoroughly enjoyed working alongside fellow Whanganui-based councillor Alan Taylor, Cotton said. The pair disagreed on a few issues, including additional public transport funding, but that 'represented the view of the community'. 'Then, the members of council made a decision. That's good process. 'Tongue in cheek, I have to say I lost more than I won.' Cotton said being a councillor meant he was able to go to places he never would have otherwise. 'And I've met people from all walks of life. 'Being a councillor can be hugely satisfying and hugely frustrating, but it's really been a great journey.' Nominations for the 2025 local government elections close at noon on Friday, August 1. Mike Tweed is a multimedia journalist at the Whanganui Chronicle. Since starting in March 2020, he has dabbled in everything from sport to music. At present his focus is local government, primarily the Whanganui District Council.
