£10m commitment to Edinburgh Seafield sewage stench delayed
'From May and June the number of reports made through the community council website are much higher than this period last year,' he said. 'They [Scottish Water] will put that down to climate change and dry periods, but the fact that's annoying us is that they've had this £10m and nothing has been done.
'It's maybe going to cost double that now, just with rising inflation and building costs since Covid.'
Mr Scanlon said that in a recent meeting with Scottish Water bosses he was told, 'they were just going to tender,' adding: 'My question to them was that if you're just tendering at the moment the process could take two or three months. In which case you'd be looking at October, November. So it's drifting into 2026.
'We find that totally unacceptable.'
Scottish Water was unable to say when work would start, but it is expected to issue an update with a project timeline and a new cost estimate once a contractor is assigned to the job.
The water body told The Herald it remained 'committed to investing in Seafield'.
Eileen Simpson is a long-time resident of Pirniefield, one of the neighbourhoods worst affected by the 'Seafield stench'.
Describing what it's like living near the plant she said: 'It's dreadful, we can't use the garden at times, we're not as bad as down near Seafield but there are pockets where it's particularly bad and sometimes it spreads away up Easter Road.
'With this commitment of £10m I think there's a bit of complacency setting in and we were just trusting them [Scottish Water].
'People's lives are being really badly impacted by it.'
Read more:
Scottish Water spending had 'shortcomings' minister admits
Mr Scanlon said: 'People can't go into their gardens, they have to shut their windows - it basically means when they invite friends round it's embarrassing because it just stinks and it affects people's mental health and well-being.'
Ms Simpson, who also sits on the community council, said she felt there wasn't 'a practice of openness and transparency' from the public body 'in the way they should be'.
She called for an emergency meeting with stakeholders to find out more about 'what's happening about the £10m' a 'transparent discussion' with the community council, Scottish Government and city council 'about the plans for the next period'.
Scotland's largest waste water treatment facility, Seafield serves Edinburgh and the wider Lothians, playing a key role in the country's water infrastructure. Since 1999, it has been operated by French company Veolia under a PFI (Private Finance Initiative) contract which expires in 2029.
Odour issues have persisted for decades, though are said to have eased following a £25m odour improvement plan in 2010. However complaints have continued since.
The problem is worse after warm, dry spells when there is a lack of water to treat sewage and is septic by the time it arrives in the settlement tanks on the banks of the Firth of Forth.
A further £10m was announced following an odour review at Seafield in 2018 and will be used to 'add additional capacity to the treatment process and ensure that odorous sewage waste is moved as quickly as possible from open areas to covered, odour extracted areas,' according to Scottish Water.
Ben Macpherson, Edinburgh Northern and Leith MSP, said the delays to the project were 'disappointing' but could be attributed to 'external market challenges'.
Mr Macpherson chairs the Seafield Stakeholders Group which brings together Scottish Water, Veolia, Edinburgh Council, SEPA and community representatives to discuss the operation of the plant, odour incidences and future investment.
Seafield has been run by French company Veolia since 1999 under a PFI contract expiring in 2029 (Image: Scottish Water) He said: 'It's unfair that local residents have experienced unpleasant odours at times during recent weeks and months.
'While it is appreciated that this was mostly due to the exceptionally dry weather we had recently, the amount of complaints during the last months does also underline the importance of the planned investment by Scottish Water into the plant, to make sure the odour risk is meaningfully reduced as much and as soon as possible, in the near future.'
The backbench SNP MSP asked the government for an update on the investment in the Scottish Parliament last month.
Acting climate action minister, Alasdair Allan, told Mr Macpherson contractual obligations for the delivery of the £10m investment by Scottish Water lie with Veolia until 2029.
The minister said: 'Scottish Water remains committed to delivering improvements for customers and will keep community representatives updated through the Seafield stakeholder group.
'Scottish Water is at an early stage in developing its plans to ensure a smooth transition of operational responsibility once the PFI contract expires.'
Scottish Water has committed to building a new 'state-of-the-art facility' to replace Seafield after 2030 once it takes back control of the plant 'to meet the expected changing demands, population growth, replacement of equipment and new emerging technologies in wastewater treatment'.
Mr Scanlon and Ms Simpson recalled a representative from the water body saying in a 2020 meeting around £100m would be spent on this project, however this figure was not confirmed by the organisation.
More from our Edinburgh correspondent:
'They said £100m, it wasn't just me that heard that,' Mr Scanlon said. 'There were various other people that had heard that but when we got the minutes recently of that meeting there was no mention of it. It's disappeared.'
Ms Simpson said: 'They're not being specific anymore - it was £100m, we've never seen it publicly in writing although three of four of us heard it. Everybody at the meeting heard it.'
However she added it didn't matter how much was spent as long as it was 'enough to meet the needs for a state-of-the art plant for the whole of this area,' which she noted was set to grow with 2,700 new homes planned for the waterfront at Seafield, directly beside the sewage treatment facility.
A Scottish Water spokesperson said: 'We are committed to investing in Seafield so that it will continue to serve as the primary treatment facility, with significant upgrades and improvements required to meet future demand and serve our customers into the next decades of this century.'
'We look forward to working constructively with the local community and stakeholders to address concerns and share progress.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Daily Mirror
an hour ago
- Daily Mirror
Prune lavender one specific time to avoid 'woody' plant next year, according to Monty Don
Lavender is a popular plant among gardeners, but it requires a fair bit of maintenance to keep it looking its best Lavender flourishes in bright sunshine and needs well-draining soil to prosper. The plants battle in shadowy spots or cold conditions, which means they can face challenges in Britain's unpredictable climate. According to the Royal Horticultural Society (RHS), many lavender specimens can turn "woody" without proper care, though regular trimming can prevent this issue. Cutting back lavender properly is essential for reviving your plants, but certain important guidelines must be followed, reports the Express. Monty Don explained on his blog how to stop lavender bushes becoming "woody" and "leggy", saying: "To avoid woody, leggy plants, lavender should be pruned every year. The best time to do this is as soon as the flowers start to fade." Monty explained this timing could range from mid-summer through to late August, depending on which lavender variety you're growing. The horticultural guru continued: "Do not wait for the seed heads to form or the flowers to turn brown, as you want to allow the maximum amount of time for regrowth before winter." For a nicely proportioned plant, gardeners should trim boldly while ensuring some young growth stays on every branch. He cautioned that lavender plants generally won't regenerate from old bare wood, making it crucial to preserve these fresh shoots. Monty explained: "These new shoots will grow fast and provide an attractive and healthy cover to protect the plant in winter and provide the basis of next year's display." Should your lavender appear particularly weary despite proper pruning, it might be wise to substitute the plant entirely. If you happen to miss the ideal pruning window for your lavender, it's advised to hold off until the subsequent spring. This is particularly crucial for less robust varieties such as French, Spanish and Italian types. July also presents a splendid opportunity to take cuttings from lavender for crafting dried flower gifts. While waiting to prune your lavender, there are other plants that can be pruned in July, including wisteria and certain fruit trees. Rambling and climbing roses, along with some perennials like hardy geraniums, might also benefit from a trim at this time. When pruning, always make angled cuts to ward off disease and ensure your secateurs are sharp.
Daily Record
2 hours ago
- Daily Record
French toast will be 'tastier and fluffier' if you ditch frying pan and cook this way instead
Ditching the pan will improve the texture of your favourite breakfast. French toast is a popular breakfast, enjoyed by many foodies for across the world. In theory it should be easy to perfect as it only involves a couple of ingredients, however mastering the correct texture can be tough. Frying french bread in a pan might seem like an obvious way to cook it, but actually it can make it ruin it. The oil in the frying pan can make your bread turn greasy. It can also make it burn on the outside, yet still be soggy on the inside as it doesn't get a chance to fully cook. Kristin Hoffman, a trained chef who goes by Baker Bettie, believes ditching the pan and following her cooking method will produce french toast which is 'perfectly crispy on the outside with a fluffy custard-y inside'. She said the recipe is easy to make as long as you bake it in the oven instead. Kristin said: 'The key to perfect pan-baked French toast is a pan heated in the oven. You want to get a sheet pan roaring hot in your heating oven while you prep your other ingredients, reports the Express. 'This will cause the bottom side of the bread to sear immediately when you put it on the pan.' Cooking French toast in the oven means every side of the bread receives the same amount of heat, so it will have a much better texture and be less greasy. Using the oven is also less effort, as you do not have to flip it or constantly hover around it like you do a frying pan. This is a simpler way to make professional French toast without much hassle, which makes it great for feeding lots of people at once if you are cooking for your family. However, if you want the French toast seared without a frying pan, you will need to either broil the bread or heat a baking tray before cooking it in the oven. How to make tastier French bread without a frying pan You will need (for eight servings) Eight pieces of bread Two eggs 120ml of milk Half a teaspoon of vanilla extract Cooking spray or butter or some oil Join the Daily Record WhatsApp community! Get the latest news sent straight to your messages by joining our WhatsApp community today. You'll receive daily updates on breaking news as well as the top headlines across Scotland. No one will be able to see who is signed up and no one can send messages except the Daily Record team. All you have to do is click here if you're on mobile, select 'Join Community' and you're in! If you're on a desktop, simply scan the QR code above with your phone and click 'Join Community'. We also treat our community members to special offers, promotions, and adverts from us and our partners. If you don't like our community, you can check out any time you like. To leave our community click on the name at the top of your screen and choose 'exit group'. If you're curious, you can read our Privacy Notice. To begin, place the shelf rack in the centre of the oven and then a baking tray on the rack. Preheat the oven to 230C (210C for a fan oven) for at least 20 minutes. Meanwhile, prepare your French toast by placing the eggs, milk, and vanilla extract in a bowl and whisking them together. You can add cinnamon at this stage if you wish, or if you prefer, you can add the vanilla extract. Wait for the oven to be properly preheated. Have your pieces of bread and egg mixture nearby. Use an oven mitt to remove the baking tray from the oven, then add a generous amount of cooking spray. If you wish, you can add oil or butter to the baking tray instead. Dip each piece of bread in the egg mixture, coat both sides, and then add to the baking tray. Try to do this quickly so the bread sears when it hits the hot tray. Once all the bread has been added to the baking tray, place it back in the oven. Your French toast should be cooked between five and eight minutes. When you take your French toast out of the oven, it will be golden brown with perfectly crisp edges while still being soft and pillowy on the inside.
Evening Standard
3 hours ago
- Evening Standard
David Ellis reviews Canal: Flow your own way along familiar culinary waters
The kitchen turns out what might be called London Mediterranean, mostly in an Italian pose, though Spanish, French and British influences wriggle in. There is a sense of unity throughout the menu that makes a bad order tricky: if you have the plate of pickles — various beetroots, very gently done, the oil and beet juice together like the interior of a lava lamp — you can happily have the cheerful crab doughnut, with its light dough and pink innards. Stracciatella, sitting in a pool of olive oil — liking olive oil is a requirement for liking here — might follow, with its gently blackened turrets of courgette. But bream crudo would have suited too. Was mangalitza sausage a little out of place, with its likeness to the frankfurters I had every Saturday lunch after swimming classes? Pickled chillies held it in keeping.
