NHS Fife nurse at centre of controversial trans tribunal suing her own trade union
The Kirkcaldy nurse suing NHS Fife over her suspension following a trans changing room row has launched legal action against her own trade union.
Sandie Peggie is already embroiled in a tribunal with her employer after she told trans doctor Beth Upton she felt uncomfortable at the two sharing a women's locker room.
Now she is suing the Royal College of Nursing (RCN) over claims the medical union has failed to help in her lengthy legal battle against NHS Fife.
The decision comes just days after Ms Peggie's lawyer wrote to the RCN asking if bosses had written to Fife health board about the importance of single-sex spaces.
The letter states Ms Peggie had felt 'disappointment' at the trade union's apparent lack of support.
It's understood the Victoria Hospital A&E nurse first requested support from the RCN in early 2024, shortly after the changing room altercation.
Sex Matters, a gender critical charity, claimed trade unions across Britain had done little to help female members fighting for single-sex spaces.
Helen Joyce, the charity's director, said: 'Unions right across the economy have shamelessly abandoned members who've been penalised for asserting their right to single-sex spaces at work.
'Sandie Peggie's decision to sue RCN should be a wake-up call for every union representing employees who need single sex facilities for their basic privacy and dignity.'
Ms Peggie and Dr Upton both gave evidence to the Dundee employment tribunal during the first two weeks of hearings in February.
The hugely controversial case has sparked national headlines and caught the attention of celebrities like Harry Potter author JK Rowling.
The tribunal is set to reconvene in July.
The next round of hearings will come against the backdrop of the UK Supreme Court's ruling that the terms 'woman' and 'sex' in the equality act refer to biological women.
NHS Fife was told to admit defeat in the tribunal following the court's judgement.
Earlier this month we reported that the health board had failed in its bid to ban the public from watching the hearing online.
The RCN has been contacted for comment.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Guardian
a day ago
- The Guardian
Dame June Clark obituary
When June Clark was elected to the governing council of the Royal College of Nursing (RCN) in 1969, becoming its youngest ever member at 28, it was still a genteel body. Many of her fellows wore hats and gloves to meetings. Clark was soon quietly taken aside and asked to stop breastfeeding her baby in the council chamber. Although she reluctantly complied on that occasion, Clark, who has died aged 83, would go on to make a career of prodding the nursing establishment to modernise, and especially to shake off its traditional deference to doctors. She was a key figure in the campaign to make all UK nurse training degree-based, which was finally agreed in 2009, and was an early exponent of digital care records, which are slowly coming to pass. Serving for 24 years on the RCN council, with only one short break, she was the college's president from 1990 to 1994. Never shy of challenging authority, she addressed her 1991 presidential speech directly to the then Conservative health secretary, William Waldegrave, who had introduced a quasi-market NHS system just weeks previously, telling him to his face: 'The reality is that the rough discipline of the market is producing unforeseen consequences which are already causing suffering to patients, chaos in the service and great anxiety.' Clark's forthrightness made her a key player in the world of health management, as well as a government adviser and a global authority on nurse education and practice. With her grounding in classics, she was a passionate and persuasive orator. Admirably punctilious, she would habitually take to the podium in debates at RCN congress by saying that she was going to make 'just three points' – and would do just that. Compromise did not come naturally, however, and supporters and friends would sometimes part company with her over the practicality of her policy ambitions or her impatience for faster change. She could also appear dismissive of some policy areas, such as learning disability nursing, which interested her less. Born in Sheffield to Marion (nee Walters), a homemaker, and Ernest Hickery, a steel industry trade union official, she was christened Margaret but was always known by her middle name, June. Her parents came from south Wales but her father had been temporarily relocated to Sheffield during the second world war. The family soon returned to Risca, near Newport, a community reliant on steel and coal. June excelled at Pontywaun grammar school, and became committed to pursuing a nursing career once she had begun volunteering as a teenager with St John Ambulance and then, every Saturday, at St Woolos hospital in nearby Newport. She would have preferred to have gone straight from school into nurse training, but after much argument with her parents they eventually corralled her into accepting a place at University College London (UCL), from which she emerged in 1962 with a degree in classics and a steady boyfriend, Roger Clark, also a classics scholar. Once she had finished at UCL, her long-awaited nurse training began at University College hospital in London. There, in 1963, she became the first delegate of the then Student Nurses' Association (later absorbed by the RCN) to the annual National Union of Students' conference, moving a resolution condemning 'the archaic principles governing the lives of student nurses'. It was passed unanimously. She qualified in 1965 and married Roger the following year, moving to Berkshire, where he had begun a career in administration at Reading University. Rather than settling for a hospital job on qualification, she undertook further training to become a health visitor, beginning her work in that role in 1967 in Mortimer, near Reading, where she set up a family planning clinic and a health education programme in local schools. From then onwards, Clark was a fierce proponent of the value of health visiting, which, unlike many others, she considered to be an integral part of nursing. She particularly lamented the narrowing of the health visitor's remit from the 1970s onwards, and later, in 1985, as part of a doctorate at South Bank Polytechnic, she wrote an influential thesis on health visiting that set out a theoretical framework she believed it lacked. She also established an annual research workshop for health visitors. Similarly, Clark believed that personal care delivered by social care workers was also nursing, and called it a 'travesty' that such work was assessed and commissioned by social workers, not nurses. She was a member of the 1997 royal commission on long-term care that called for free personal care in the UK – a recommendation accepted only in Scotland. After her start as a health visitor, Clark had a varied career in the health service. She filled clinical nursing posts during the 70s before combining teaching and research with bringing up a family, and then resuming her work as a health visitor in Berkshire in 1981. From the mid-80s she held senior health authority positions in London, including as a special projects coordinator at Lewisham and North Southwark, director of community nursing services at West Lambeth and chief nursing adviser at Harrow – all the while writing regularly in the nursing press and even serving as agony aunt in Mother & Baby magazine. In 1990 she moved into academia as professor of nursing and head of the new school of health studies at Middlesex Polytechnic (now Middlesex University). She later described this as her toughest job and, burned out, she took early retirement after five years. But she set Middlesex on course to be a leading centre of health education. After leaving Middlesex, Clark spent large parts of the next two years studying and advising in Europe and the US. Much of what she saw reaffirmed her faith in the NHS: she would often recall arriving at a nursing conference in Los Angeles to be asked by her hotel porter if she might look at a lump in his mouth as he could not afford to go to a doctor. Clark was made a dame in 1995 for her services to nursing and health visiting, and in 1997 was tempted back to academia and to Wales, becoming professor of community nursing at Swansea University. Thereafter she focused increasingly on Welsh health affairs, including leading reviews for the Welsh government and campaigning successfully for legislation on safe staffing levels. She grew disenchanted with the direction of the RCN, believing it was giving too much emphasis to its trade union function at the expense of its role as a professional body. However, she remained an active member and sat on the college's Wales board as recently as 2022. In retirement she also led the RCN's involvement in the National Pensioners Convention. Clark stepped down from her Swansea post in 2003, on the same day that Roger retired from Reading University. They had by then gradually relocated from Berkshire to Mumbles, near Swansea, where she died while picking flowers in their garden. She is survived by Roger, their children, Andrew and Gill, five grandchildren and her sister, Kay. Margaret June Clark, nursing leader, born 31 May 1941; died 14 May 2025
Daily Mirror
4 days ago
- Daily Mirror
Harry Potter-obsessed teen given magical surprise of her life at Warner Bros
Saffron Crickley from Blackpool was whisked on a magical trip to London for her first ever holiday A Harry Potter-obsessed teenager who lives with a rare genetic condition got the surprise of her life when she was whisked to the Warner Bros Studios in Watford to see how her beloved films were made. Saffron Crickley, who was born with the incredibly rare chromosomal disorder Mosaic Turner Syndrome, lives with hearing and vision loss, scoliosis and ADHD. Despite her challenges, the 14-year-old from Blackpool remains upbeat and full of life, says mum Lianne. 'She's a miracle baby,' says Lianne. 'Everything she goes through she faces with a smile. She just wants to be part of the world, to belong, to laugh, to experience everything.' Saffron was taken on a once-in-a-lifetime trip by charity Dreams Come True, which organised for her to travel with her family to London for a three-day holiday - the first time Saffron had ever left her home town. She and her family - brothers Kyron, 15, and Greyson, 11; dad Lee, grandma Gail, 18-month-old foster brother Noah and mum Lianne - were treated to a slap-up meal at Frankie & Benny's, where they feasted on Saffron's favourite: burgers, without the bun! The next morning they were taken to the world-famous toy store Hamley's in central London, which pulled out all the stops with entertainers, high tea and a private tour of the seven floors of toys, games and fun. And that wasn't the only surprise in store for the youngster, who has loved Harry Potter since watching the very first film when she was four. Saffron found herself standing outside The Making of Harry Potter, home to hundreds of thousands of props, sets and costumes that were all used during the filming of every Potter film. And just to top it all off, two of her heroes - David Ricardo-Pearce and Thomas Aldridge, who are currently playing Harry and Ron Weasley in the stage production of Harry Potter and the Cursed Child - had recorded a special video message just for her. 'She's absolutely Harry Potter obsessed, this is something she's talked about for years,' says Lianne. 'To finally go to London, and not only visit The Making of Harry Potter but also to receive a personalised message from the stars of the stage, Harry and Ron themselves, is beyond anything we could have imagined. It's truly magical.' Her favourite film is The Chamber of Secrets, and her favourite character is Harry's best friend Hermione, 'because she's brave and bossy - just like me with my brothers,' laughs Saffron. Her mum agrees. 'Hermione keeps the boys in line and under her thumb, and so does Saffron,' smiles Lianne. One of her highlights of the trip was trying Butterbeer, which in JK Rowling's magical universe is a slightly alcoholic butterscotch-tasting drink. In Muggle land, however, it's not boozy at all. 'I had it all over my face,' Saffron laughs. 'It was like a moustache!' But the ultimate highlight was walking into the room containing the 50-foot model of Hogwarts Castle, which was painstakingly built and painted by the art department for the first film, Harry Potter and the Philosopher's Stone. 'It took Saffron's breath away,' says Lianne. 'She couldn't believe her eyes. It was the real Hogwarts, right in front of us.' The one scary moment came when Saffron found herself face-to-face with a roaring dragon, which in the Harry Potter series lives deep underground the wizarding bank Gringotts - until it is freed by Harry, Ron and Hermione. 'It was so loud I had to turn off my hearing aids,' says Saffron. But she left happily in possession of Hermione's very own wand, all the better for keeping her brothers in line. It comes as research finds more than half of families with children who have disabilities live beneath the poverty line. Dreams Come True is a wish-granting charity focused exclusively on children living in the highest areas of deprivation with serious medical needs or disabilities, and chief exec Lisa King OBE says: 'This is what it's all about: creating unforgettable experiences for children who deserve the world. For Saffron and her family, this is more than a holiday. It's hope, joy, and magic brought to life.'
Scottish Sun
6 days ago
- Scottish Sun
Elderly patient's drinking water infested with ants during stay at Scots hospital
ANT SHOCK Elderly patient's drinking water infested with ants during stay at Scots hospital A HOSPITAL has been slammed after horrified loved ones spotted ants crawling in an elderly patient's drinking water. And they reckon the Parkinson's disease sufferer, 78, may have been left sipping insect-infested liquid for days. Advertisement 4 Shocking photos show the sickening scenes at Stratheden Hospital, in Cupar, Fife 4 Ant's were found in drinking water at the hospital. 4 Alastair Tarbett fears his elderly mother sipping insect-infested liquid. Credit Steve Welsh Credit: Steve Welsh The OAP's son, Alastair Tarbett, 44, shared shocking photos and videos with The Scottish Sun of the sickening scenes at Stratheden Hospital, in Cupar, Fife. He told how his dad, who we're not naming, had been admitted to the community unit for assessment. Alastair, of nearby Balmullo, said: 'When we visited, ants were crawling round the rim of his glass. It was disgusting. 'When I went there on another day, I saw three or four ants inside his plastic cup. Then I opened his sealed water bottle — and there were ants in there too. Advertisement 'My poor dad had been drinking from that bottle for two days, sucking up ants through his straw.' Alastair raised the alarm with staff on the hospital's Muirview Ward, who admitted the infestation was 'deplorable'. But he said he was still stamping on ants during visits two weeks later. He added: 'As soon as ants are crawling around patients' food and drink, a team should be out dealing with it immediately. It's just not good enough.' Advertisement An NHS Fife spokesman said: 'We apologise for any concern caused. Immediate action was taken to address the presence of ants. 'This issue affected only part of Muirview Ward and is likely linked to building works in the area.'
