Payer can recover GST loss from supplier who failed to remit tax, rules Madras HC
The judge noted that the petitioner believed he was absolved of his liabilities since he had paid the tax to the supplier, and thus, if there was any failure on the part of the supplier, it was only for the GST Department to initiate appropriate legal action and recover the GST amount.
But the GST Department could not be treated as an agent for collecting the tax from the supplier. Instead, the petitioner could have followed it up with the supplier to ensure proper remittance.
The judge held that the right course of action available for the petitioner was to initiate recovery proceedings against the supplier.
'Of course, the petitioner can initiate proceedings against the supplier to the extent of loss incurred by him due to the reversal of the ITC by the department on the ground of non-remittance of GST by the supplier, by taking appropriate legal action for recovery of the amount,' the judge said.
He noted that once the amount was remitted, the provisional credit available with the ECL of the petitioner would become absolute and made available for him to avail the ITC.
Further, the judge observed that the petitioner could inform the first respondent (GST authorities) about the non-remittance of the tax amount by the supplier. However, it would be up to the authorities to initiate proceedings under Section 76 of the GST Act.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
&w=3840&q=100)
Business Standard
an hour ago
- Business Standard
Two-slab 'Next Gen GST' to pay way for single tax rate by 2047: Centre
Describing the proposed GST tax reforms as Next Gen GST', senior government officials on Saturday said that the two-slab tax regime will eventually pave the way for a single sales/services tax rate, hopefully by 2047. They said the proposed new GST regime, which slashes tax rates and assigns just two slabs of 5 per cent and 18 per cent, will boost the economy and also serve to mitigate tariff threats. The proposed two-slab regime, if approved by the GST Council, will replace the current four slabs in the goods and services tax (GST) regime, doing away with the 12 per cent and 28 per cent slabs. Calling it the "next Gen GST', one government official said "it is a game changer reform. In the pantheon of economic reforms seen in India, it's right up there." The officials spoke on condition of anonymity. They said the new structure would mean that almost all of the common use items will move to the lower tax bracket, leading to price cuts, which in turn would boost consumption. "Lower taxes means it will put more money in people's pockets. It will obviously lead to more consumption," the official said. The Centre's proposal for a 5 and 18 per cent tax rate on merit and standard goods and a 40 per cent tax for sin goods, has been a large canvas exercise to ensure stability in tax rates, the officials said, explaining the rationale behind the exercise. The changes that have come about after nearly six months of deliberations and dozens of meetings, have been conceived in a way so as to ensure that demand for tax tweaks do not come and also input tax credit (ITC) do not get accumulated in the system. Once the Centre's proposal is accepted by the Group of Ministers (GoM) and is approved by the GST Council, it will end the flux of tax rates and ensure stability, the officials said. What we have suggested is a Next Gen GST' keeping the needs of the middle class, poor, farmers, and MSMEs in mind. Also, it has been ensured that tax on daily use items are low, the official told PTI. "Once the system is put in place and India becomes a developed nation, we can think about a single rate GST," said the official, adding that a single rate structure is suitable for developed countries where income and spending capacities are uniform. The ultimate aim is to move to a single slab structure, the official said, adding that the time, however, is not right at present. The official said that during the process of overhaul, every due process is being followed. The Centre has taken the steering role but is protecting constitutional obligations by sharing it with the Group of Ministers (GoM) on rate rationalisation. "We have looked at every item, item by item and in some cases we have gone back and forth 3-4 times. Whether it is pesticide for use by farmers or pencils for students or some raw material or intermediaries for MSMEs, every item has been discussed threadbare and categorised in the merit or standard slab, the official added. As many as 99 per cent of the items in the 12 per cent category such as butter, fruit juices and dry fruits would move to 5 per cent tax rate. Similarly, electronic items like ACs, TVs, fridges, and washing machines as well as other goods like cement will be among the 90 per cent of the items that would move from 28 per cent to lower 18 per cent slab. The move comes after US President Donald Trump slapped a 25 per cent tariff on all goods India exports to the US, and planned doubling of the levy to 50 per cent from August 27 to punish New Delhi for its oil purchases from Russia. The tariffs are likely to impact USD 40-billion of non-exempt Indian exports such as that of gems and jewellery, textiles and footwear. Prime Minister Narendra Modi in his Independence Day address to the nation on Friday emphasised that India should become self-reliant and consume what is made in India. The tax slabs that the Union Finance Ministry has proposed will go to a group of ministers from different states and after their concurrence will be placed before the all-powerful GST Council, which is headed by Union Finance Minister and comprises representatives of all states and UTs. The Council is expected to meet next month to deliberate on the tax reform proposal. About 20 per cent of items, including packaged food and beverages, apparel and hotel accommodation currently are taxed at 12 per cent GST and accounts for 5-10 per cent of consumption and 5-6 per cent GST revenue. Moving them to a lower 5 per cent slab may lead to loss of revenue but the Central government is hopeful that a boost in consumption would be able to make up for the deficit in the next few months. (Only the headline and picture of this report may have been reworked by the Business Standard staff; the rest of the content is auto-generated from a syndicated feed.)
Deccan Herald
an hour ago
- Deccan Herald
'Next Gen GST' precursor to eventual single tax slab GST: Sources
Senior government officials said the proposed new GST regime, which slashes tax rates and assigns just two slabs of 5 per cent and 18 per cent, will boost the economy and also serve to mitigate tariff threats.
News18
an hour ago
- News18
Congress Claims Credit For GST Reforms Plans, BJP Questions Opposition's ‘Audacity'
Congress and BJP engaged in war of words over PM Modi's announcement of next-gen GST reforms and the Opposition claimed credit for the Prime Minister's move. A war of words broke out between the BJP and the Opposition over the latter's rush to take credit for Prime Minister Narendra Modi's Independence Day promise to bring next-generation GST reforms. The BJP slammed Congress for claiming credit for the proposed two-slab tax regime, down from the existing four, and reminded the party that its leader Rahul Gandhi dubbed GST as 'Gabbar Singh Tax". BJP leader Amit Malviya said that the Congress 'realises" that PM Modi's GST reforms are 'bound to succeed", therefore the party wants to 'rebrand their sabotage as support". Govt Vs Opposition Over GST 2.0 Plans This comes after government sources said that the Centre has proposed to do away with the 12% and 28% GST slabs and proposes to keep 5% and 18% tax rates. Shortly after this, Congress leaders credited Rahul Gandhi for his old tweets and videos in which he sought GST reforms, limiting the rate to 18%. 'Now these people are under so much pressure that they will now agree to everything @RahulGandhi says," Congress spokesperson Pawan Khera said. अब यह लोग इतने दबाव में आ गए हैं कि अब यह @RahulGandhi की हर बात मानेंगे। — Pawan Khera 🇮🇳 (@Pawankhera) August 15, 2025 Hitting back at the Congress party, Malviya said, 'When the Modi government delivered the constitutional amendment, Congress boycotted the historic GST midnight launch in Parliament. They couldn't bear to see Modi succeed where they had failed for a decade. Rahul Gandhi chose to degrade it as 'Gabbar Singh Tax." And now Congress has the audacity to claim credit for GST reform proposals by the Modi government." If @INCIndia is so full of 'GST ideas," why did the UPA (2004–14) fail to implement GST for years?When the Modi government delivered the constitutional amendment, Congress boycotted the historic GST midnight launch in Parliament. They couldn't bear to see Modi succeed where… — Amit Malviya (@amitmalviya) August 16, 2025 'The real truth is GST succeeded despite Congress opposition, not because of it. The proposed two-slab structure represents continuous improvement by a government that actually delivers. Congress realises the PM's next-generation reform proposals are popular and bound to succeed, so now they want to rebrand their sabotage as support," he added. Congress Demands Discussion Paper On GST 2.0 Congress MP Jairam Ramesh earlier said that the party had been demanding 'GST 2.0" for over a year and a half and had included it in its 2024 Lok Sabha poll manifesto. 'Over the last seven years, the spirit of GST has been vitiated by an increased number of rates and the granting of multiple exemptions. The structure also seems to have facilitated evasion. There must be a drastic reduction in the number of rates," he said. He also demanded a discussion paper on GST 2.0. 'The Indian National Congress demands an official discussion paper on GST 2.0 very soon so that there can be an informed and wider debate on this vital and pressing national issue," he said. view comments Location : New Delhi, India, India First Published: August 16, 2025, 21:13 IST News politics Congress Claims Credit For GST Reforms Plans, BJP Questions Opposition's 'Audacity' Disclaimer: Comments reflect users' views, not News18's. Please keep discussions respectful and constructive. Abusive, defamatory, or illegal comments will be removed. News18 may disable any comment at its discretion. By posting, you agree to our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.
