Mistrial for ex-Grand Rapids officer Christopher Schurr, who fatally shot Patrick Lyoya
Christopher Schurr, 34, was charged with one count of second-degree murder stemming from the April 2022 shooting of Patrick Lyoya, a 26-year-old Congolese immigrant. Schurr shot Lyoya in the back of the head after tackling him after Lyoya tried to flee a traffic stop in southeast Grand Rapids.
Schurr's attorneys had argued the former officer was acting in self defense, after Lyoya attempted to grab Schurr's Taser during the physical struggle. Prosecutors had argued Schurr used excessive force.
The jury deliberated for about 20 hours before informing 17th Circuit Judge Christina Mims it could not reach a verdict. Mims declared a mistrial.
Inside the courtroom, Schurr did not have a discernible reaction when Mims announced the mistrial. There were not visible reactions from members of the Lyoya or Schurr families, either.
Throughout the trial, the 12-person jury was able to see footage of the shooting played numerous times, and from different angles, from the moment Schurr exited his patrol car to the moments after he shot Lyoya. Jurors also heard from a series of witnesses, the bulk of whom were qualified as policing experts, but also from eyewitnesses, investigators, police officers who responded to the scene of the shooting and Schurr himself.
Much of the testimony focused on the Taser — defense lawyers argued Lyoya had gained possession of it from Schurr. Once Schurr believed Lyoya had control of the Taser, he was within his rights to use deadly force and shoot Lyoya, policing experts called by the defense testified.
The prosecution focused large parts of its case around Schurr's training with the Grand Rapids Police Department (GRPD), where he had joined as a recruit in 2015. Policing expert witnesses called by the prosecution said Schurr acted improperly by chasing Lyoya on foot after he tried to flee the traffic stop.
The shooting, and the subsequent release of footage of the incident, sparked protests in Grand Rapids in 2022, when demonstrators called for police accountability.
During the trial, demonstrators gathered outside the courthouse in downtown Grand Rapids to await a verdict. Some stood in support of Schurr, waving 'thin blue line' flags that have emerged as a support symbol for law enforcement. Others chanted 'Justice for Patrick,' with one demonstrator waving a flag with the letters 'BLM' painted on, an apparent reference to the Black Lives Matter movement.
This is a breaking news story and will be updated.
Contact Arpan Lobo: alobo@freepress.com
This article originally appeared on Detroit Free Press: Christopher Schurr trial: Mistrial declared for ex-Grand Rapids officer
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Boston Globe
3 hours ago
- Boston Globe
After Trump-backed peace deal, survivors recount rebel massacre in Congo
The Washington Post interviewed three witnesses to the initial massacre, as well as six residents of the nearest town, and reviewed photographs and videos from the aftermath. Locals described farmers being gunned down indiscriminately by M23 fighters as they worked the fields and survivors hiding for days among the dead. They spoke on the condition of anonymity, communicating by voice notes on borrowed phones, out of fear for their safety. Advertisement Rwanda has always denied backing M23 — despite overwhelming evidence to the contrary from UN experts — and the rebels were not signatories to the US-backed peace deal. M23 representatives and the government of Congo signed an agreement on July 19 pledging to establish a ceasefire as part of a separate peace process mediated by Qatar, though M23 told the BBC on Monday it was pulling out of the Doha-based talks, saying Kinshasa had reneged on the deal. Advertisement It was not immediately clear how the killings would affect the US-backed peace deal. Earlier this month, the US Treasury Department announced new sanctions on an armed group opposed to M23, as well as Chinese and Congolese mining companies, which it said were fueling the region's illicit mineral trade. The announcement noted that the 'Rwanda-backed' M23 group 'has rapidly expanded its territorial control in eastern DRC and is responsible for human rights abuses.' US officials, however, have made no public comment about the recent killings, and the president claimed again on Monday to have 'settled six wars in six months,' a count that includes the conflict in Congo. 'It's well past time that President Trump was awarded the Nobel Peace Prize,' White House press secretary Karoline Leavitt said last month. Massad Boulos, Trump's Senior Africa Advisor, said in a statement to The Post that 'we will continue to work through any challenges to ensure that 30 years of war come to an end, and people can live in peace.' The White House press office said Trump had secured a 'historic agreement' between Rwanda and Congo and that his administration would ensure that all sides 'honor their commitments.' In an Aug. 7 post on X, Congo's ministry of information said M23 had killed more than 300 civilians in the North Kivu region; M23 swiftly denied any role in the killings and dismissed what it called 'false accusations.' Advertisement In an interview with The Post, Congolese Information Minister Patrick Muyaya called for an international investigation: 'Any kind of violence must be condemned by the US,' he said, urging American officials to 'continue to put pressure so we can fully implement the Washington accord and get Rwandan troops out of DRC.' Rwanda's government spokeswoman, Yolande Makolo, said the country's forces had 'absolutely nothing to do' with the latest violence, adding that M23 is not 'Rwandan-controlled.' Lawrence Kanyuka, the M23 spokesman targeted with sanctions by the US government in February, did not respond to a request for comment. Kigali accuses Congo of supporting the remnants of ethnic Hutu militias responsible for the 1994 Rwandan genocide; Congo accuses Rwanda of using proxy forces, including M23, to terrorize Hutu communities and loot the country's vast but underdeveloped mineral reserves. In January, M23 fighters seized control of the regional capital of Goma in a lightning offensive and have taken more Congolese territory in recent months, including the area where the July killings took place. Support from the Rwandan Defense Forces 'played a critical role in the territorial expansion of [M23] and its occupation of new territories,' a report by a UN panel of experts found last month. The latest massacres happened near Binza, about 65 miles north of Goma, in mid-July, but information has been slow to trickle out because phone networks are unreliable and locals fear further reprisals from M23. Residents and survivors told The Post that the violence originated with clashes between M23, which controls the town, and the Wazalendo, a loose array of local militias often supported by the Congolese government. After losing a skirmish, M23 fighters turned against civilians working in the fields of Binza on July 13, three survivors said. Advertisement A man told The Post he began to run as soon as he heard the first shots, tripping on a body as he fled. Many victims came from different villages, he said, and his brother was still missing. 'I saw many dead people on the way home,' he said. He estimated that at least 50 people were killed that day. The Post could not independently verify the toll. Terrified residents told him 'the M23 were killing anyone they found,' the man said. A woman who escaped the initial massacre said she spent three days hiding among corpses with no food or water. When she finally made her way back to the town of Nyamilima, she said, she walked past at least 20 bodies. 'It was the M23,' she told The Post. 'People were massacred … and until now they have not been buried.'
Yahoo
4 hours ago
- Yahoo
Xavier Hernandez death: El Paso DA gets investigation, likely to go to grand jury
An investigation into the death of Xavier Guadalupe Hernandez during an arrest on the side of a freeway is now in the hands of the El Paso District Attorney's Office. It will likely go to a grand jury to determine if criminal charges will be filed against police officers. Hernandez, 30, died in a controversial case recorded on an El Paso Police Department body camera video that raised criticism over how police handled what started as a call about a pedestrian on Interstate 10 and ended with Hernandez's death on July 13. More: El Paso medical examiner rules man who died in police struggle as a homicide El Paso District Attorney James Montoya, in an emailed statement on Wednesday, Aug. 20, said his office has now received the investigation conducted by El Paso police. "While the case is pending, we cannot offer any other comment about it specifically," Montoya stated. "However, it is the policy of the DA's Office to present all in-custody deaths and officer-involved shootings to a grand jury of El Pasoans for their review and determination of potential criminal liability." EPPD body camera video released this week showed Hernandez in an agitated state on the shoulder of the busy freeway in a situation that quickly escalated into a struggle as an officer repeatedly shocked him with a Taser. "Officer, what's your badge number?" Hernandez repeatedly yells in the video, which shows Hernandez stop breathing while handcuffed behind his back and held facedown on the asphalt by officers. An autopsy by the county medical examiner's office deemed Hernandez's death a homicide caused by "asphyxia due to chest compression during law enforcement subdual and restrain" with cocaine toxicity as a "significant" factor. DA: Grand jury to look at police deadly force cases Montoya, a Democrat, took office in January after defeating former Republican DA Bill Hicks in the November 2024 election. Montoya previously had an unsuccessful run for DA, losing to Yvonne Rosales in the 2020 Democratic primary. Rosales later ended up resigning from office amid accusations of incompetence and Hicks was appointed by Gov. Greg Abbott to fill in the remainder of her term. During the 2020 campaign, police brutality was a hot topic amid the George Floyd protests, Black Lives Matter movement and the COVID-19 pandemic. In 2020, Montoya said in an El Paso Times interview that incidents in which police use deadly force should be automatically investigated. "Whether that is a discharge of a firearm, some kind of chokehold, any type of deadly force, including a Taser, which I believe is deadly force, will be presented to an El Paso grand jury for their review for potential criminal charges," Montoya said in 2020. Daniel Borunda may be reached at dborunda@ and @BorundaDaniel on X. This article originally appeared on El Paso Times: El Paso police bodycam video death case likely to go to grand jury
Los Angeles Times
10 hours ago
- Los Angeles Times
Rwanda-backed rebels killed over 140 civilians in eastern Congo, rights group says
DAKAR, Senegal — Rwanda-backed rebels killed at least 140 people in farming communities in eastern Congo in July, a human rights group said in a report Wednesday, describing the killings as 'summary executions.' Human Rights Watch said 141 people, predominantly Hutus, were feared dead or missing after the attacks near Virunga National Park in North Kivu province, citing local experts and witness accounts. It said the killings appeared to be part of a military campaign by the M23 group, the most prominent of more than 100 armed groups fighting for control in eastern Congo, against the Democratic Forces for the Liberation of Rwanda, a mostly Hutu armed group. Nearly 2 million Hutus from Rwanda fled to Congo after the 1994 Rwandan genocide that killed 800,000 Tutsi, moderate Hutus and others. Rwandan authorities accused the Hutus who fled of participating in the genocide, alleging that the Congolese army protected them. 'The M23 armed group, which has Rwandan government backing, attacked over a dozen villages and farming areas in July and committed dozens of summary executions of primarily Hutu civilians,' said Clementine de Montjoye, senior researcher at Human Rights Watch. Witnesses said M23 soldiers, accompanied by Rwandan soldiers who were identified by their accents, told them to 'immediately bury the bodies in the fields or leave them unburied, preventing families from organizing funerals,' the report said. One woman described being marched in a group to a riverbank near the town of Kafuru. The group of around 70 people was lined up before the soldiers began shooting at them. 47 people, including children, who were killed were identified, the report added. Willy Ngoma, military spokesperson for M23, called the report 'military propaganda.' The report said the Rwandan military and the Rwanda Defense Force were involved in the M23 operations, citing U.N. and military sources and witness accounts. There was no immediate comment from the Rwandan government. The reported killings could escalate tensions in Congo's mineral-rich east where different partners have been racing to achieve a permanent ceasefire since fighting between the M23 and Congolese forces escalated in January. The U.N. has called the conflict 'one of the most protracted, complex, serious humanitarian crises on Earth.' M23 was previously accused of extrajudicial killings during their seizure of major cities in the eastern part of the country in May. Mcmakin writes for the Associated Press.
