Former Irish Nationwide manager 'shocked' that Fingleton issued 'get-out-of-jail card' to borrower
A former senior commercial manager at failed lender Irish Nationwide has told the High Court he was left "absolutely shocked" that Michael Fingleton Sr, referred to as "the boss" at the bank, confirmed an alleged "get-out-of-jail card" to a borrower who could not repay a multi-million euro property loan.
Conal Regan, who joined the bank after Mr Fingleton left the society in April 2009, on Wednesday told the High Court that the defendant allegedly wrote a letter to a lender, Louis Scully, who borrowed almost €6 million to purchase land in Co Meath in October 2007, confirming that the sum loaned to him was a "non-recourse" one.
Advertisement
A non-recourse loan means that debt on a loan is secured by the collateral and cannot be pursued by the lender from the borrower.
The High Court civil case, which is in its third week, against the former Irish Nationwide Building Society (INBS) chief executive and managing director Mr Fingleton alleges that he negligently mismanaged the building society and engaged in property "gambles" with high-net-worth individuals in an informal and speculative manner in the mid-2000s, leading to fatal losses.
Mr Fingleton (87), who cannot give evidence due to ill health, joined the building lender in 1971 and retired in 2009. He held the roles of both managing director and chief executive in that time. At its height in 2007, INBS had reported assets of €16 billion but was a high-profile casualty of the financial crisis of 2008.
Liquidators for Irish Banking Resolution Corporation (IBRC) have taken the case against Mr Fingleton, who denies the allegation of negligent mismanagement.
Advertisement
The total losses at INBS had been estimated to be €6 billion. However, only €290 million in damages is being pursued by IBRC, relating to five specific loans, allegedly approved by Mr Fingleton.
The court has been told that Mr Fingleton was allegedly 'nodding through' top-ups and extensions to certain clients without the knowledge of the society's board.
At the High Court on Wednesday, former INBS manager Mr Regan, who joined the society in late October 2009, said he was dealing with "significantly" distressed credits at the lender.
When Mr Regan queried and tested loans issued to Mr Scully, he was told by letter from Mr Scully that the monies advanced to him were all "non-recourse" loans.
Advertisement
Lyndon MacCann SC, for IBRC's liquidators, was told by Mr Regan that a February 2009 letter from Mr Scully to Tom McMenamin, then-manager of commercial lending at Nationwide, referred to a list of borrowings by Mr Scully and other individuals that stated "nobody was getting any younger". Mr McMenamin wrote back saying that all loans to Mr Scully were made on a non-recourse basis.
Mr Regan said he could not find any reference "anywhere" in the paperwork about a non-recourse element in a loans to Mr Scully for Meath land – measured at 21,700 acres – at €598,7850, arising from a value of €275,000 per acre, which Mr Regan said seemed "exceptional, very, very high".
Mr Regan said he reacted by thinking "why in the name of God was a get-out-of-jail card given here, given the level of funding that had been provided?"
"I just could not understand that somebody could possibly believe that letter would trump agreements or legal documents signed and on a 'normal-recourse' basis. All of a sudden there is this and it just didn't make sense," Mr Regan told the court.
Advertisement
Mr Regan said he had looked at the files regarding Mr Scully's loans and that "non-recourse was mentioned nowhere. Nowhere".
Mr Regan told the court he asked Mr McMenamin "why in the name of god" was the letter of confirmation issued and claimed that Mr McMenamin told him: "I was only doing what the boss told me to do".
Mr MacCann asked who was being referred to as "the boss" to which Mr Regan said he was told by Mr McMenamin that this was a reference to Mr Fingleton Sr.
Later in December Mr Scully wrote to Mr Regan saying as far as he was concerned all of his business with the society was on an non-recourse basis and that this had been agreed by Mr Fingleton.
Advertisement
Mr Regan told Mr Justice Michael Quinn that it was a "shocking assertion" and that "individuals were not even putting hands in their pockets" if they had a "free bet" on getting planning or zoning for lands.
Ireland
Michael Fingleton engaged in 'solo run' trading wh...
Read More
"It was a get out of jail card. It was incredible. I have never, never come across it before," said Mr Regan.
In response to a request for any documentary evidence as to the agreement between Mr Scully and Mr Fingleton, Mr Scully writes back on March 25th, 2010, enclosing a letter of confirmation of the non-recourse loans from Mr Fingleton and writes "I trust this brings matters to a conclusion".
Mr Regan said he was left "absolutely shocked" by the letter from Mr Fingleton.
The case continues at the High Court.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
BreakingNews.ie
38 minutes ago
- BreakingNews.ie
Jury dismisses allegations against Garda into alleged 'sorting out' of insurance offences
A serving Garda was found not guilty by a jury of charges of attempting to pervert the course of justice after allegations he 'sorted out' motoring offences for drivers. Garda Tom Flavin was acquitted of a total of 22 counts of allegedly attempting to pervert the course of justice by a jury at Limerick Circuit Criminal Court following an eight-day trial. Advertisement On Friday, the jury returned unanimous not guilty verdicts on 17 of the charges. Earlier the jury was directed by the trial judge, Colin Daly, to return not guilty verdicts in respect of five counts against Garda Flavin. The long serving and respected Co Limerick Garda, who had consistently denied all of the charges, was supported in court throughout the trial by a large gathering of family friends and colleagues. On Thursday, Garda Flavin's barrister, senior counsel Mark Nicholas, instructed by solicitor Dan O'Gorman, urged the jury to acquit the garda of all of the charges, and said there was no evidence of wrongdoing by the accused. Advertisement Garda Flavin was arrested and charged following an investigation by the Garda National Bureau of Criminal Investigation (GNBCI) and ultimately accused of knowingly entering false motor insurance details on the Garda Pulse computer records system, in an attempt to frustrate potential prosecutions against persons for driving without insurance. His trial heard that the drivers involved were stopped at routine Garda checkpoints around the country and asked by the garda present to produce their insurance and licence details at a nominated Garda station within ten days of the traffic stop. All of the drivers involved nominated Rathkeale garda station, and, later, when the investigating garda in each of the traffic stops carried out follow up checks of Pulse they were satisfied the details entered indicated that the driver in each case was insured. However, the court heard some of the drivers were actually not insured and had actually been prosecuted in court after pleading guilty to driving without insurance. Advertisement Mr Nicholas told the jury Mr Flavin was an exemplary garda who had served with dedication in Croom and Rathkeale, Co Limerick, for many years. The defence barrister had urged the jury to acquit and not fall into the trap of speculation, remarking to the jury that there was radically insufficient evidence to support a conviction against Garda Flavin. 'He (Mr Flavin) served his community without blemish and without any disciplinary blots - you know that from the evidence. "When other gardaí came to give evidence, his superiors, they spoke of him very fondly and well - It wasn't far off gushing and they spoke with knowledge,' Mr Nicholas told the jury in his closing speech, Thursday. Advertisement Mr Nicholas spoke of the 'unique challenges' gardaí face in Rathkeale as opposed to other jurisdictions: 'People who live down here know it has an enormous population, transient, in and out at various times of the year. "One policeman said (the population) quadruples and with that comes its own set of problems and own sets of vehicles - UK car registrations, UK insurance, some not insured, some not being entirely truthful.' 'We know that a certain number of times that people who were pulled up and stopped and asked for their documentation, produced bogus insurance certificates.' Mr Nicholas said the charge of attempting to pervert the course of justice, is an extraordinarily, serious allegation to make against a serving garda and that the State had 'nothing close' to proving its case. Advertisement The court heard evidence that persons had provided certain documents at Rathkeale garda station, where Garda Flavin was based at the time, however it was unclear who produced the documents nor was it clear what documents they produced. Fiona Murphy SC, prosecuting, had alleged that the evidence would show that Gda Flavin had 'sorted out' the uninsured drivers by inputting data into Pulse to try to frustrate prosecutions against them. However, Ms Murphy had told the jury that the prosecution case was 'a circumstantial case' with 'no direct evidence'. 'Instead, the prosecution relies on indirect evidence,' Ms Murphy said. Ireland Coroner returns verdict of accidental death after... Read More Ms Murphy had explained to the jury that a statute of limitation of 'six months' generally applied in respect of prosecuting offences of driving without insurance. She had argued that all of the relevant data entries into Pulse 'were entered under the ID of Thomas Flavin' and she had alleged that 'Tom Flavin knew they (the drivers) were not covered (by insurance) and that he entered the details onto PULSE to ensure they (appeared) covered'. 'Mr Flavin knew what he was doing, and he did so to ensure those persons were insured (on PULSE) when they were not, in order to ensure there was no prosecution,' Ms Murphy had alleged in court. However, after deliberating for three hours and 21 minutes, the jury disagreed and unanimously dismissed all of the allegations that had been made against Gda Flavin, following an expensive and top-level GNBCI (Garda National Bureau of Criminal Investigation) probe.
BreakingNews.ie
2 hours ago
- BreakingNews.ie
Man (23) appears in court in connection with shooting incident at Ennis halting site
A 23-year-old Dublin man has appeared in court concerning three shots allegedly fired at a caravan in an Ennis halting site last week. At Ennis District Court on Friday, Johnny Donovan of Bay 3, Rathmichael, Shankill, Co Dublin appeared in connection with four charges arising from the shooting incident at Ballaghboy halting site, Quin Rd, Ennis on Thursday, May 29th last. Advertisement At a contested bail hearing, Det Garda Aoife O'Malley told the court that there had been unrest all week due to tensions between certain families at Ballaghboy halting site with gardai responding to multiple incidents. Det Garda O'Malley said that additional gardaí have been deployed to police the situation and she said that the shooting incident took place only 10 minutes after the Garda Armed Support Unit (ASU) had left the scene. Det Garda O'Malley said that the alleged shooting showed blatant disregard for An Garda Síochána. She said that the fire-arm has not yet been recovered. Advertisement Det Garda O'Malley said that it will be alleged that on May 29th last, 'Johnny Donovan while travelling in a grey BMW jeep entered Ballaghboy halting site, Quin Rd, Ennis and accompanied by a second male produced a hand-gun and fired three indiscriminate shots at a caravan in the first bay'. No person was shot but Det Garda O'Malley said that two people were present in the bay at the time of the shooting. She said that one of the two took a video which captures her running to a vehicle to take cover and captures three gunshots. Det Garda O'Malley said that no persons are identified in the video. Advertisement She said that a Garda Scenes of Crime Unit examined the scene and found one caravan had three bullet holes while one spent bullet was found inside the caravan. Det Garda O'Malley said that Mr Donovan is facing three charges of criminal damage of property at Ballaghboy and a fourth under the Firearms and Weapons act concerning use of a hurley or a stick. Det Garda O'Malley said there is a possibility that more serious charges are to follow and Judge Alec Gabbett described the charges before the court as holding charges. The detective said that evidence gathered confirmed that a shooting incident did occur. Advertisement She said that the video of the alleged shootings showed that a viable firearm capable of causing death of serious harm was used. Det Garda O'Malley said that Garda seized the jeep allegedly used in the shooting and found a hurley, a pitch fork, an axe and small bottles filled with accelerants. Ireland Coroner returns verdict of accidental death after... Read More She said that Mr Donovan - who, she said, has family links to Co Clare - is first cousins of the partners of the injured parties in this case. 'They are all very well known to each other and until recently would have been very friendly with each other," she said. Solicitor for Mr Donovan, John Casey applied for bail stating that Mr Donovan was willing not to enter Clare as part of his bail conditions. However, Judge Gabbett refused bail and remanded Mr Donovan in custody to Limerick prison to appear in court next Wednesday via video link.
BreakingNews.ie
2 hours ago
- BreakingNews.ie
Coroner returns verdict of accidental death after boy (12) fell off the Cliffs of Moher
A 12-year old boy lost his balance after slipping in a puddle close to the edge of the Cliffs of Moher before falling over the edge to his death, an inquest has heard. In eye-witness testimony at the Clare coroner's court into the accidental death of Zhihan Zhao at the Cliffs of Moher on July 23rd last, French tourist, Marion Tourgon described seeing Zhihan fall over the edge at around 1:45pm on the day. Advertisement Zhihan had set out on walking the Cliffs of Moher trail from Hag's Head on the Liscannor side or southern side of the Cliffs of Moher to the Cliffs of Moher visitor centre with his mother, Xianhong Huang and her friends. The two Chinese nationals had arrived in Ireland only 12 days previous on July 11th. Last year, 1:49m people visited the Cliffs of Moher making it Ireland's most popular natural attraction. In her deposition, Ms Huang said that Zhihan was walking ahead of her on the Cliffs of Moher trail and she lost sight of him. Speaking through an interpreter at the inquest in Kilrush, Co Clare, Ms Huang wiping away tears, asked: 'What exactly caused Zhihan to fall from the Cliffs?' Advertisement Clare County Coroner, Isobel O'Dea told the distraught Ms Huang that the evidence of Ms Tourgon would help answer that question. In her deposition Ms Tourgon said that she was at the edge of the Cliffs of Moher with her husband and two children at around 1:45pm. She said that they were taking a selfie when she saw a young Asian boy, who was alone, come into view. She said: 'I saw him slipping in the puddle that appears in the photo that my husband sent to the police." Advertisement Ms Tourgon said: 'His right foot slipped into the puddle with him trying to stop himself from falling with his left foot but his left foot ended up in the air.' She said: 'It was very quick - he found himself in an awkward position with his left foot in a void over the cliff and his right knee on the edge of the cliff.' Ms Tourgon said: 'His right knee eventually fell into the void over the cliff and he was trying to grasp the grass with his hands to pull himself up. He didn't shout and there was no noise.' She said that 'it is the only the few of us who saw him falling' and the Tourgons alerted the emergency services by phone. Advertisement Speaking again through an interpreter, Ms Huang asked 'did he slip?' and in reply, Inspector Helen Costello told her: 'It appears from the witness that he slipped into the void having stumbled in the puddle.' In her deposition, Ms Huang said that she started out from Nagle's car park in Liscannor to walk to the Cliffs of Moher with Zhihan and friends of hers. She said: 'My son walked very fast and was ahead of us by 50 metres' She said: 'As there was only one path I thought we would meet him along the way. When I didn't I walked to the visitor centre and I checked the visitor centre." Advertisement When she couldn't find her son here, she walked back along the path to search for her son and after not finding him, she reported him missing. She said that she last saw Zhihan at 1pm that day. She said that Zhihan was a fluent English speaker and described the clothes that Zhihan was wearing that day including black shorts, Nike Air Jordans, an LA Lakers wristband and a kid's smart-watch. Sgt Claire McGuigan said that on the day, Ms Huang was able to provide a photo of Zhihan she had taken taken earlier on the Cliffs of Moher trail. Garda Colm Collins said that he received a call that day at 2pm to attend the Cliffs of Moher after a male was seen falling off the cliff edge. He said that the Irish Coastguard had spotted a body floating in the water at the base of the Cliffs of Moher. Through the interpreter, the mother asked was the location the same spot where scenes from a Harry Potter movie were shot and Insp Costello said that they were not. Garda Collins said that a lifeboat was launched but the craft was not able to access the site where the body was spotted due to the sea conditions. Zhihan's body would not be recovered from the sea for another five days and was recovered after fisherman, Matthew O'Halloran from Corofin, Co Clare spotted a body facedown and arms extended in the water between Doolin and the Aran Islands shortly after 10am on Sunday, July 28th. Mr O'Halloran alerted the Irish coastguard at Valentia and members of the Doolin unit of the Irish coastguard retrieved Zhihan's body from the waters and brought it ashore at Doolin. Ms O'Dea said that the post mortem found that Zhihan died from multiple traumatic injuries consistent with a fall from a height. Ms O'Dea said her verdict was one of 'accidental death'. She said: 'It is clear from evidence we heard that Zhihan slipped off the Cliffs rather than any other way. His death would have been very quick - instantaneous." Ms O'Dea told Ms Huang 'I can't imagine how upsetting this is for you' and the two embraced as Ms Huang left the coroner's court in Kilrush. Ms O'Dea also extended her sympathies to Zhihan's father who was not present at the inquest. Addressing Ms Huang, Insp Costello said: 'The pain must be immeasurable for you all.' Ms Huang declined to comment on the record when approached for comment after the inquest. On August 22nd of last year, the Clare Local Development Company closed off large sections of part of the Cliffs of Moher trail and it remains closed off today due to continuing safety concerns. At the time, the Clare Local Development Company confirmed that it was taking the action following the two recent fatal accidents on the Cliffs of Moher trail. In May 2024, a young woman died after she fell from the Cliffs of Moher. She was in her early 20s and a college student from Belgium who was studying in Scotland.
