Debate on Isle of Man state pension changes separated from budget
Politicians have agreed to have "a proper debate" about proposed changes to state pensions and the future of the National Insurance Fund. Treasury Minister Alex Allinson had intended to move plans to replace the "triple lock" commitment for those who retired after April 2019 as part of the 2025-26 budget.But MHKs backed Julie Edge's call for a "full independent national debate" on the issue separate from the delivery of the annual financial plan in Tynwald next Tuesday.Allinson said he would support holding a separate discussion about the plans to introduce a "double lock guarantee" as a way to preserve the National Insurance (NI) Fund.
The treasury minister faced criticism from some members, who said he had not followed through with a commitment made in his 2024 budget speech to engage with politicians and the public prior to any changes.A report published in October forecast the island's £1.09bn NI Fund would run out by the 2047-48 financial year. Earlier in the weekly sitting of the House of Keys, Allinson defended the plans to introduce a system that would see pensions rise by either 2% or inflation, arguing it was not discriminatory under the island equality laws.The proposals would see the scrapping of the "triple lock", which currently ensures increases based on the higher of UK CPI inflation, average earnings, or 2.5%, for anyone who retired after 5 April 2025 and qualifies for the Manx state pension.
'Unacceptable and deeply unfair'
But during a House of Keys debate that lasted more than an hour, Onchan MHK Edge said the policy could "put UK state pensioners living on our island in a better position than Manx-born pensioners who have lived and worked here all their lives"."That is both unacceptable and deeply unfair and I refuse to allow this proposal to be buried in the small print of the budget," she said."A separate motion is the only way to ensure proper scrutiny and debate."Glenfaba and Peel member Kate Lord-Brennan agreed a debate was needed, and argued that the Treasury moving ahead without wider scrutiny was a "flagrant disregard for Tynwald and the residents of the Isle of Man".She said the original plan to have the changes debated and voted on as part of the budget was "bizarre" and not how major policy should be shaped.The treasury minister told members he would ask for the proposals to be listed as a separate motion for debate and approval at the February sitting of TynwaldHowever a bid by Lord-Brennan to have that pensions debate pushed back to a later sitting was narrowly voted down by MHKs.
Read more stories from the Isle of Man on the BBC, watch BBC North West Tonight on BBC iPlayer and follow BBC Isle of Man on Facebook and X.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The National
27 minutes ago
- The National
'Fed up' Brian Cox hits out at Keir Starmer on BBC Debate Night
The Succession star was speaking as he appeared on the BBC Scotland Debate Night programme on Wednesday evening. Cox called for more unity of purpose from Scottish politicians and the public more widely. READ MORE: Wee Ginger Dug: John Swinney needs to rethink his strategy over Scottish independence 'I'm not just talking about parties, I'm talking about the country,' he said. 'I'm talking about this country, which I love, and I'm very proud that I come from this country, but I've seen it time and time again where there's this endless debate: debate this, that, this, that, this. 'I just feel that we need unity, we need unity of purpose, and we haven't got unity of purpose. I'm sorry, but we simply don't. 'We have so much dissension, and we've lost the way really big time, and I feel that we should resume that, we should get it back.' Cox said he did not know which political party could unite Scotland, but suggested it was 'certainly' not Labour under Starmer. The actor went on: 'I'm not pleased with Mr Starmer and his attitude towards Scotland, because everything for him is England. 'He talks about England, he talks about English football.' After applause from the audience, the Dundee-born star added: 'I'm at heart a socialist, so I get, I do really get annoyed when it's not about socialism, it's about something else, and that's what I feel is lacking. 'I'm just, I'm sick of it really, I'm fed up. READ MORE: These key economic truths show how independent Scotland and Wales can succeed 'I come back to this country. I love this country and I see dissension after dissension after dissension, the inability to come together, and it's an appalling situation.' Asked if pro-independence parties should unite, Cox said: 'Absolutely they should, because it's in everybody's interests.' Talking about the Labour Government, he added: 'They're not interested in us. I know for a start that Starmer is certainly not interested and doesn't want an independent Scotland. 'He only sees it as a sort of encumbrance to what he is, so I'm not happy about that situation.' Brian Cox is known for his role as Logan Roy in the smash hit SuccessionElsewhere, Cox, a former Labour supporter, said that the UK Government's attitude to Scotland was 'nebulous'. 'I worry about a lot of things that go on, and I'm particularly worried about the attitude towards Scotland,' he said of the impact of the Spending Review, which Rachel Reeves announced on Wednesday. Cox went on: 'There certainly should be more detail, but they also should certainly understand what the need of this country is – and that's what gets me. 'It's a bit bland, it's a bit off, you know, just off the cuff, and I really want to see really what they think about Scotland, and I find it a little bit nebulous.'
The Sun
an hour ago
- The Sun
Reeves is waking up to grim reality check as GDP slumps – she revelled in spending splurge but it's downhill from here
Rachel Reeves revelled in a major spending splurge yesterday - but this morning she wakes up to a grim reality check. The Chancellor delighted in getting out the cheque book as billions of pounds were allocated to health and defence combined with shiny new infrastructure projects. 1 But today is a different story. The Chancellor says that the figures are "clearly disappointing" but it's a stark reminder of the fragility of the UK economy and how difficult it will be to turbo-charge growth. The effects of 'Awful April' - when a slew of added costs for business including that national insurance rise came in - has hit home. This Labour government has put that push for growth as their number one mission which will have the knock-on effect of driving up living standards. After a positive start to the year - where we saw growth up by 0.7 per cent - today we see it drop by 0.3 per cent for May. We shouldn't take one month's figures in isolation but the fear is conditions for business and entrepreneurs have hit them hard. The hike to national insurance contributions and minimum wage for firms kicked in at the start of April and this is how the economy has reacted. As the British Chambers of Commerce outline the NI rise has hit investment, recruitment and prices. The uncertainty of Donald Trump's tariffs is also a drag on the UK with the largest monthly fall on record in goods exports to the US. With dismal economic growth, the global trade war and stubborn inflation, the Chancellor will surely be left with little choice but to cut spending or raise taxes in the autumn. Ms Reeves has iron-clad fiscal rules she insists are non-negotiable so it feels inevitable something will have to give. A cruel summer of speculation is on the cards.
Daily Mail
2 hours ago
- Daily Mail
BREAKING NEWS Rachel Reeves' spending splurge plans are ALREADY in chaos after GDP fell 0.3% in April - fuelling fears she WILL have to hike taxes
' spending plans have already been thrown into chaos today after figures showed the economy tumbling into the red. GDP was down 0.3 per cent in April, worse than analysts had expected, and raising more questions about the realism of the Chancellor's splurge on services. Although UK plc has still grown over the past three months, evidence has been mounting of a slowdown. Ms Reeves admitted the data - which coincide with the huge national insurance tax raid on businesses taking effect - were 'disappointing'. ONS Director of Economic Statistics Liz McKeown said: 'The economy contracted in April, with services and manufacturing both falling. However, over the last three months as a whole GDP still grew, with signs that some activity may have been brought forward from April to earlier in the year. 'Both legal and real estate firms fared badly in April, following a sharp increase in house sales in March when buyers rushed to complete purchases ahead of changes to Stamp Duty. Car manufacturing also performed poorly after growing in the first quarter of the year. 'In contrast April was a strong month for construction, research and development and retail, with increases in these only partially offsetting falls elsewhere. 'After increasing for each of the four preceding months, April saw the largest monthly fall on record in goods exports to the United States with decreases seen across most types of goods, following the recent introduction of tariffs.' In the Spending Review yesterday, Ms Reeves set out plans to 'invest' a staggering £4trillion to fund 'the renewal of Britain'. She said the plans, which include another huge dollop of cash for the NHS, would end the 'destructive' austerity of the last government and boost economic growth. Labour strategists hope the costly gamble will pay off by cutting hospital waiting lists, improving the creaking infrastructure and pump-priming the economy. But experts warned the scale of the spending, coupled with the deteriorating public finances, would force another round of damaging tax rises this autumn. The Conservatives accused Ms Reeves of adopting a reckless 'spend now, tax later' approach. The Chancellor insisted her plans could be funded by the eye-watering tax rises she imposed last year. She refused to rule out tax rises this autumn, saying only that taxes 'won't have to go up to pay for what's in this Spending Review'. But the small print of yesterday's Treasury document already includes one significant new tax hike, with the Chancellor pencilling in council tax hikes that will add more than £350 to an average Band D bill by 2029 to help fund local services and the police. Asked to rule out further tax rises, Treasury minister Emma Reynolds said: 'I'm not ruling it in, I'm not ruling it out.'
