Survivors Call Out MSD For Redress Inaction, Travel Chaos, And Deep Harm – One Week Before National Wānanga (Part One)
Press Release – NZ Cast
This isnt an isolated failure. NZCAST says its part of a larger pattern: a redress system that isnt working, and an agency that claims to care about survivors but wont even show up.
With less than a week to go before a national wānanga for survivors of state abuse in Christchurch, the Ministry of Social Development (MSD) has still not confirmed consistent travel support for those trying to attend. Many have been left waiting, others have been declined outright, and some have received offers so low they feel like an insult.
'It's heartbreaking,' says Karl Tauri, spokesperson for NZCAST – the New Zealand Collective of Abused in State Care. 'We've had survivors calling us in tears, unsure if they'll be able to attend. Some have said they don't want to live anymore. And what's MSD's response? Silence, deferral, or ten dollars for a 5-hour round trip.'
This isn't an isolated failure. NZCAST says it's part of a larger pattern: a redress system that isn't working, and an agency that claims to care about survivors but won't even show up.
Travel support that harms more than it helps
Survivors attending the upcoming Whare Tapu Wānanga in Christchurch (23–25 May) have reported:
Receiving no confirmation of travel support
Being told they're ineligible because their 'claim is closed'
Being offered as little as $10–$20 for multi-hour journeys
Hearing different rules depending on the person who answers the phone.
'This is redress?' Tauri asks. 'Survivors are retraumatised just trying to attend an event that could help them heal.'
Deaf survivors excluded
The situation is no better for Deaf survivors. MSD has refused to fund New Zealand Sign Language (NZSL) interpreters for wānanga, redirecting organisers to Deaf Aotearoa who have no mandate or funding to cover redress-related events.
'This has left Deaf survivors completely shut out,' says Tauri. 'Or, again, the burden falls on us, a grassroots, unpaid organisation to try and find the money.'
Disability support that doesn't support
Survivors living with chronic pain, PTSD, or long-term illness are facing yet another barrier: the broken Disability Allowance system.
NZCAST reports survivors being forced to repeatedly prove their trauma by obtaining letters from GPs and specialists, a system over-stretched on its own, even when their conditions are permanent and well documented.
One mother cannot access basic allergy-safe food and unsubsidized medication for her and her children. They live with serious gluten and dairy allergies yet are denied support. 'She skips rent once a month just to feed her kids and buy her medication' says Tauri. 'What kind of system makes a woman choose between food and housing?'
Case management by postcode
In some parts of the country, Work and Income allows survivors to request dedicated case managers, a much needed and wanted advancement, so survivors don't have to relive their trauma with a new person every time.
In some regions, this request is refused. 'It's postcode-based discrimination,' says Tauri. 'The system you get depends entirely on where you live. That's not justice.'
No dignity in death
In one recent case, MSD refused to fund the headstone for a survivor's father, who was buried in an unmarked grave. He was a veteran of World War Two, and the only adult who supported and loved his daughter, before he passed away. Despite clear grounds for compassion and support, she has been left scrambling to piece together funding on a benefit.
'This was a man who stood by his daughter through everything,' says Tauri. 'And MSD told the whānau no. No help, no honour, no acknowledgment. That tells you exactly how broken this system is, when even the dead, a veteran at that don't get dignity.'
MSD: Present in some places, absent in others
Perhaps the most galling failure, NZCAST says, is MSD's refusal to attend the Christchurch wānanga, despite attending similar events in Wellington and Palmerston North.
'Christchurch has hundreds of MSD staff and multiple offices,' Tauri says. 'They claim it's due to 'conflicting commitments,' but the message survivors hear is: you're not important enough for us to show up. '
This matters, he says, because when MSD WINZ and Historic Claims does attend, it works. Survivors are able to connect with case managers, claims, ask questions, get real-time support, and rebuild trust with the public service.
NZCAST: Doing the work the Crown won't
NZCAST is running the entire three-day Christchurch gathering including food, accommodation, transport, wellness sessions, peer support, and facilitation entirely unfunded. The trust receives no Crown funding, and relies on community aroha, fundraising, and lived experience.
'We're holding people who are in crisis while MSD sends emails telling us to refer survivors to the website,' says Tauri. 'We are doing their job. Unpaid. And still doing it better.'
What NZCAST is calling for:
A consistent national travel support policy for all survivors, open claim or not
NZSL interpreter funding for all Crown-linked survivor events
A trauma-informed Disability Allowance process that stops punishing people
Equal access to case managers, no matter the postcode
A survivor-led inter-agency wellbeing and redress taskforce
Proper funding for survivor-led groups who are carrying the system's failures
Implentation of the recommendations provided by the Royal Commission.
'We're not asking for favours. We're asking for justice.'
At the heart of it, Tauri says, is a simple truth: redress is not money. Redress is showing up. It's access. It's care.
'MSD says it supports survivors, but survivors are not feeling supported. They're exhausted. They're retraumatized. And they're being left behind.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
RNZ News
a day ago
- RNZ News
MSD to monitor whether stricter rules for accommodation supplement push people into hardship
Social Development Minister Louise Upston. Photo: VNP / Phil Smith The Ministry of Social Development (MSD) will assess requests for hardship assistance to determine whether new, stricter rules for the accommodation supplement are pushing people to seek help elsewhere. From 2 March next year, payments from all boarders will be included in income assessments to determine whether people qualify for accommodation supplements or temporary additional support, and to calculate how much income-related rent people pay in public housing. At the moment, board payments are only included in this calculation when people have three or more boarders, or when it is their main source of income. Work and Income said that could mean people were paid less in housing subsidies or paid higher income-related rents. A spokesperson for MSD said because the policy change would mean a decrease in the rate of assistance received by some people, there could be an increase in applications for other hardship and housing supports. In earlier analysis, it had suggested that the $150 million the government expected to save over four years could be overstated because of this. "We cannot predict how many people will access hardship assistance and housing support products as a result of the change. As part of internal reporting for this initiative, MSD will monitor hardship assistance to see if it is increasing more than forecasted prior to this change. "If MSD identifies significant changes that may require further investigation (such as significant increases in hardship assistance, above what had been forecasted), MSD will investigate those further and provide advice to ministers." It has been estimated that about 13,200 households with boarders will be affected. Ricardo Mendendez-March, Green Party spokesperson for social development, said people who were receiving the accommodation supplement were already facing unaffordable rents. He said the government had not adequately communicated the impact of the bill. "Poverty is a political choice and this government has chosen to leave thousands of low-income families considerably worse off. The changes to the accommodation supplement are unjustified, particularly in a cost of living crisis. The government is trying to pay for their tax cuts by pushing low-income families into debt or to Work and Income to ask for hardship grants to survive. "Being $100 worse off each week may not mean much to wealthy government ministers, but for many families it's the difference between making ends meet or having to access a foodbank. We know that more families will end up needing to access hardship support because of this bill, putting pressure on families and other parts of the system that are already struggling to keep with the growing material hardship families are experiencing." Social Development Minister Louise Upston said there are various forms of assistance that are available to clients who need help with their housing and living costs and who meet the eligibility criteria. "This assistance will continue to be available to those people who are eligible, after 2 March 2026," she said. The minister acknowledges the changes could be unsettling but said they were necessary to make the system more consistent. Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero , a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.
NZ Herald
5 days ago
- NZ Herald
King's Birthday Honours 2025: The full list - knights, dames and all other recipients
Emeritus Distinguished Professor Alison Stewart, CNZM, for services to plant science and the arable sector Emeritus Distinguished Professor Alison Stewart has been made a dame companion of the New Zealand Order of Merit for services to plant science and the arable sector. Photo / File Catriona Ruth Williams, MNZM, for services to spinal cord injury research and equestrian sport Catriona Williams has been made a dame companion of the New Zealand Order of Merit for services to spinal cord injury research and equestrian sport. Photo / Lynda Feringa Knights Companion (KNZM) Mark Leslie Smith Cooper, KC, for services to the judiciary Now-retired Justice Mark Cooper has been made a knight companion of the New Zealand Order of Merit for services to the judiciary. Photo / Courts of NZ Brendan Jon Lindsay, MNZM, for services to business and philanthropy Brendan Lindsay has been made a knight companion of the New Zealand Order of Merit for services to business and philanthropy. Photo / Jason Oxenham Ewan Francis Smith, CNZM, for services to Cook Islands business and tourism Ewan Smith has been made a knight companion of the New Zealand Order of Merit for services to Cook Islands business and tourism. Photo / LinkedIn Companions (CNZM) Catherine Joy Andersen, for services to the music industry Wayne Robert Boyd, for services to business, philanthropy and sport Professor George Charles Clifton, for services to structural engineering Anthony Edwin Falkenstein, ONZM, for services to philanthropy and business education Steven Leonard Joyce, for services as a Member of Parliament Steven Joyce has been made a companion of the New Zealand Order of Merit. Photo / Nick Reed Donald Angus Mackinnon, for services to sports governance Professor Emeritus Ian George Mayhew, for services to the veterinary profession, especially equine medicine Dr David Edwin McKee, for services to New Zealand Sign Language and the Deaf community William Charles Nathan, OBE, ED, for services to Māori Dr Lesley Kay Rameka, for services to Māori and early childhood education Ruth Margaret Richardson, for services as a Member of Parliament and to governance Dr Ai Ling Tan, for services to gynaecology Dr Mark Greenslade Thomas, for services to people living with HIV/Aids and antibiotic research Officers (ONZM) Emeritus Professor George David Baxter, for services to physiotherapy and health Gillian Lorraine Bohm, for services to health Associate Professor Philip Michel Jose Brinded, for services to psychiatry Fergus Graham Brown, for services to the tourism industry Graham Vincent Brown, for services to the venison industry David Paul Burton, for services to food writing Peter Hardy Ballantyne Carty, for services to fly-fishing Suzanne Noreen Cato, for services to music, television and education Hohepa Conrad, for services to Māori, particularly kaupapa waka Peter Michael de Blois, for services to music Dr Celia Jane Devenish Giddings, for services to women's health and education Sophie Frances Monique Devine, for services to cricket Judith Mary Dobson, for services to the community, broadcasting and historical preservation Jude Dobson has been made an officer of the New Zealand Order of Merit for services to the community, broadcasting and historical preservation. Photo / Supplied Professor Bernadette Kathleen Drummond, for services to dentistry and education Daryl Kelvin Eason, for services to wildlife conservation Susan Elizabeth Elliott, for services to the arts and governance Rear Admiral James Leslie Gilmour, (Rtd), for services to the New Zealand Defence Force Kirk Brian Hardy, for services to drug abuse prevention and education Dafydd (Dai) Morgan Henwood, for services to the entertainment industry and charitable fundraising Professor Patria Anne Hume, for services to sports science and injury prevention Gary Rodney Lane, for services to conservation and philanthropy Julia May Marshall, for services to children's literature Peter David Martin, JP, for services to the community, particularly Pacific and LGBTQ+ communities Murray Graham Mexted, for services to rugby David Ross Morgan, for services to aviation Panchanatham Narayanan, QSM, JP, for services to multicultural communities Peter Arnold Nation, for services to the agricultural industry and governance Gillian Christine Naylor, for services to rural communities, particularly women John Daniel O'Sullivan, for services to business and philanthropy Dr Fiona Dorothy Pardington, MNZM, for services to photography Dr Susan Parry, for services to gastroenterology David Robert Percy, for services to fire safety technologies, business and the community Eric Clive Power, for services to swimming Timothy Grant Southee, for services to cricket Gail Patricia Spence, for services to language education Distinguished Professor Emeritus Paul Spoonley, for services to sociology John Bradley Struthers, for services to cycling, the cycling industry and business Mark William Joseph Vela, for services to mental health care and education Jennifer Mary Wake, for services to theatre and television Neil William Walker, JP, for services to primary industries and the community Sarah Louise Walker, for services to BMX and sports governance Dr Richard John Wild, for services to animal welfare and the veterinary sector Portia Louise Woodman-Wickliffe, for services to rugby Wayne Wright, for services to education and philanthropy Members (MNZM) Anae Lupematasila Lima Arthur John Anae, for services to the Samoan community Ellesse Mote Andrews, for services to cycling Richard Balcombe-Langridge, for services to business Catherine Juliet Bell, for services to food education Dr Santosh Prasad Bhandari, JP, for services to the Nepalese community Darryl Bishop, for services to mental health Victor Kenneth Boyd, for services to survivors of abuse in care Anna Catherine Cottrell, for services to documentary filmmaking and migrant communities Simon Eric Denny, for services to art Welmoed (Chris) Duggan, for services to science education Ronald Bruce Ealam, for services to Search and Rescue Robert Tuahuru Edwards, for services to the community and governance Susan Ann Elley, for services to education Terri Jayne Fairhall (Terri Middleton), for services to the New Zealand Police and the community Allison Daphne Christina Franklin, for services to people with disabilities Okesene Uili Galo, for services to the Tokelau community Rez Gardi, for services to refugees and human rights advocacy Alan Charles Gilmore, for services to astronomy Francis Quinn Goldingham, for services to outdoor recreation and seniors Elizabeth Helen Graham, for services to Māori and education Patricia Pearl Gregory, for services to the fashion industry Aaron Mark Halstead, for services to Search and Rescue and the tourism industry Dr Nina Emilia Hood, for services to education Lesley Mary Huckins, for services to swimming Meleua Enda Ikiua, for services to Vagahau Niue language and education Martin Kaipo, for services to social services and the community Lalita Vanmali Kasanji, for services to the IT industry and the Indian community Brian Patrick Kelly, for services to broadcasting William James Kermode, for services to governance and philanthropy Pamela Margaret Kilmartin, for services to astronomy John Junior Kumitau, for services to the Pacific community Laurinne Marion Laing, for services to sports and people with intellectual disabilities Ross James Lawrence, for services to the ski industry Lisa Li, for services to the tourism industry James Eric Lilley, for services to conservation and the community Janet Crystal-Lee Lilo, for services to the arts Pauline-Jean Henrietta Luyten, for services to rugby and the Pacific community Reverend David Elliott Major, for services to the community and the State Ngatepaeru Marsters, for services to midwifery and Pacific communities Lloyd James McCallum, JP, for services to the dairy industry and the environment Suzanne Michelle McFadden, for services to sports journalism and women Ian Robert Flockhart McKelvie, for services to local government, governance and as a Member of Parliament Grant Allan McMillan, ED, for services to education and the community Victoria Mary Mee, for services to women and business Eugene Joseph Meredith, for services to American Football Allan George Mincher, for services to aviation engineering Margaret Mary Mitchell, for services to the Royal New Zealand Naval Women's Association Dr Alishia Rangiwhakawaitau Moeahu, for services to Māori culture Dr Malcolm George Davis Mulholland, for services to health and Māori Khoa Truong Nguyen, for services to New Zealand-Vietnam relations and the community Julia Louisa Pearse, for services to governance and the community Sunit Prakash, JP, for services to the IT industry and the Indian community Dr Maxine Mariri Ronald, for services to breast cancer treatment and research Gary James Herbert Rooney, for services to business and philanthropy Bruce Winston Ross, for services to cycling Charles Edward Ross, for services to the community Morrin Jackson Rout, for services to the arts, particularly literature Annie Burma Teina Tangata Esita Scoon, for services to softball and the Pacific community Diana Rosemary Shand, for services to the environment and the community Simon John Caufield Strombom, DSD, ED, for services to war commemoration and historical preservation Veronica Ngarutai Kaye Thompson, for services to basketball Diane Anita Turner, JP, for services to governance, seniors and Māori Hariata Ann Vercoe, for services to Māori, health, and the community Louise Annette Wallace, for services to the entertainment industry Andrew Norman Williamson, for services to agriculture Marilyn Kay Yeoman, for services to education and the community Honorary Member Viliami Teumohenga, for services to education and the Pacific community King's Service Order (KSO) Companions Dr Christopher Evan Longhurst, for services to survivors of abuse in care Tyrone Marks, for services to survivors of abuse in care Phillip Wayne Paikea, for services to the prevention of family violence and the community Dover Spencer Samuels, for services as a Member of Parliament Dover Samuels has been made a companion of the King's Service Order. Photo / Michael Cunningham Peter William Tipene, for services to Māori King's Service Medal (KSM) Heather Jayne Baldwin, for services to the community Tina May Barrett, JP, for services to the community Debra Ann Bell, for services to the community Narendra Bhana, for services to the Indian community Marius Jean Bron, for services to Search and Rescue and the community Judith Marion Browne, JP, for services to the community Julia Mary Castles, for services to language education and migrant communities John Albert Coleman, for services to the community and sport Lily Coleman, for services to the community and sport Ross Melville Cooper, for services to rugby Margaret Jean Cousins, for services to local government and the community Glenda Gaye Davies, for services to the community Aperira Ngahau Davis, for services to the community Deborah Grace Davis, for services to the community Gavin Lloyd Dennis, JP, for services to Fire and Emergency New Zealand and the community Edwin John Eeles, JP, for services to pipe bands Anthony William Norman Enderby, for services to conservation Jennifer Fay Enderby, for services to conservation Zora Estelle Feilo-Makapa, for services to the Niue community and the arts Penelope-Jane Frost, for services to children and social work Christine Ada Gilbertson, for services to midwifery Kaiaho (Butch) Kereama Green, for services to music Heidi Elizabeth Griffin, for services to the arts and the community Allyson Teresa Hamblett, for services to people with disabilities and the transgender community The Venerable Sohim Hay, for services to the Cambodian community Katerina Hauhaua Hepi, for services to Māori language education Nicola Linda Hickey (Nicky Rawlings), for services to Victim Support Luen Nanette Hoani, for services to Māori language education Parminder Kaur, JP, for services to multicultural communities Kevin Francis Loe, JP, for services to the community and agriculture Timothy Peter Marshall, for services to the community and waka ama Audrey Myra Mattinson, for services to Scottish Country Dancing and the community Annie Elizabeth McCracken, for services to the community Reverend Rosemary McMillan, for services to the community Clem Burnard Mellish, for services to Māori art and music Graham Frederick Charles Milligan, MStJ, for services to the Royal New Zealand Returned and Services Association Fergus Charles Denis More, for services to the community and the law Graham (Kereama) Douglas Nathan, for services to Māori Terence John O'Regan, for services to nursing and the community Alison Isabel Perrin, JP, for services to the community and music Narayanan Kutty Pulloothpadath, for services to ethnic communities Berry Jane Rangi, for services to the community, particularly Pacific peoples Karen Elizabeth Richards, for services to textiles history and conservation Papali'i Seiuli Johnny Siaosi, for services to health and the Pacific community Rosemary Jan Sloman, JP, for services to the community Roberta Jane Smallfield, JP, for services to historical research and the community Alan (Curly) Rex Troon, for services to Fire and Emergency New Zealand Jacqueline June Watson, for services to the community and the arts Glenys Margaret Weir, for services to health Merrilyn Joy Withers, for services to youth and the Baptist movement Yuanyong Yang, for services to bonsai and the Chinese community Honorary KSM Eteuati Fa'avae, for services to the Pacific community Siesina Ofahelotu Latu, for services to the Pacific community
Scoop
29-05-2025
- Scoop
Govt's Budget Balanced On The Backs Of Low-Income Families
Press Release – Green Party Poverty is a political choice this coalition is repeatedly choosing. Once again, we see the wellbeing of thousands sacrificed in the name of superficial savings and cowardly games of political hot potato, says Ricardo Menndez March. The Government is quietly leaving some of our poorest families hundreds of dollars worse off, ignoring warnings that changes to the accommodation supplement and public housing subsidies will disproportionately target disabled, older, Māori, Pasifika, and young people. 'This is a stealth cut, pushed through with no acknowledgement of the harm it will cause,' says the Green Party's spokesperson for Housing, Ricardo Menéndez March. 'Housing is a human right. We can build an Aotearoa in which everyone has what they need, and nobody is left behind. 'Instead, the Government hoped we wouldn't notice that, hidden under headlines about KiwiSaver and Best Start changes, lies a major policy shift that will leave 13,200 families worse off by $100, even up to $200 per week*. 'Changes to how the Accommodation Supplement is calculated means that income from boarders–which previously were partially exempt because the Ministry of Social Development (MSD) understood these boarders were often family members–now fully counts against eligibility. 'MSD flagged early on that increased hardship was expected to be experienced by disabled people, young people, older New Zealanders and Māori and Pasifika peoples. 'People who receive the accommodation supplement, by definition, already have unaffordable rents. $100 or $200 a week may not feel much for a Prime Minister out of touch with reality, but for thousands of families it's a lifeline that allows them to keep a roof over their head, put food on the table and pay their bills. 'MSD also noted that any 'savings' were likely overstated**, as costs were simply going to be shifted to emergency housing and hardship grants. 'Poverty is a political choice this coalition is repeatedly choosing. Once again, we see the wellbeing of thousands sacrificed in the name of superficial savings and cowardly games of political hot potato,' says Ricardo Menéndez March. Notes: *An estimated 13,200 households will be affected (7,000 on accommodation supplement, 6,200 on public housing subsidies). On average, the 7,000 households with boarders receiving the Accommodation Supplement will be $100/week worse off, and people with 3 boarders would be $202/week worse off. Affected households receiving public housing subsidies would see an average increase of $132/week to the cost of their rent. (Page 21 of the report) **The Government is saving $150m over four years by stripping support (Accommodation Supplement + Income Related Rent Subsidy) from around 13,200 households who have boarders. MSD has told the Government that the savings are likely to be overestimated (page 7 and bottom of page 15 of the report). This is due to people needing hardship assistance, emergency housing, etc as a result of these changes creating costs for other parts of the system.
