Councillors split over decision to push ahead with demolition of historic hotel
The Golf Hotel in North Berwick closed commercially in 2006 and was used by its owners as staff accommodation until it was bought by its current owners during the pandemic.
Caledonian Heritable bought the building in 2021 and applied for permission to demolish it and build 14 luxury flats on the site on Dirleton Avenue.
However, the proposals were recommended for refusal by planning officers who said it had not been proven that the hotel could not continue to operate as a commercial venture.
Historic Environment Scotland (HES) objected to its demolition after describing the building as having historic and architectural significance in the town.
During a planning committee meeting on July 25, the controversial proposal was voted on.
Councillors were split evenly: four approved the proposal, and four rejected it.
Council leader Norman Hampshire had the deciding vote and opted to approve the plans, citing that the current building is 'nothing like' what it was.
The Labour councillor said: 'The building is in really poor condition and it has been for some considerable time.
'I don't think it has any enhancement to the conservation area, and I'm really surprised that Historic Environment Scotland seem to only come in to applications when certain influential people come in to notify them of things.
'There is no consistency in how they respond to this planning authority.'
However, the representative for the North Berwick coastal ward, SNP councillor Liz Allan, believes the plans to demolish the building are an act of 'cultural vandalism.'
She said: 'We are replacing something that is quite beautiful and could be changed into something, that I wouldn't say is hideous, but it is certainly dull.
'I think it is really going to be a blight on the landscape, so I don't think I can make myself any clearer, I am definitely against this.'
In a letter to the local authority, Scottish ministers have confirmed they will consider the application themselves and issue a decision.
It comes after the Architectural Heritage Society of Scotland (AHSS) also called for Government intervention. The AHSS described the unlisted building as 'architecturally distinguished' and added that it occupies a 'key position in the North Berwick conservation area.'
Objectors to the demolition said the building should be given listed status and was an important part of the town's conservation area.
A spokesperson for Historic Environment Scotland (HES), said: 'We were consulted by East Lothian Council on an application for the total demolition of 34 Dirleton Avenue, a former Golf Hotel in North Berwick, which is within the North Berwick Conservation Area.
'We objected to the application in October 2024 as the building contributes to the character of the Conservation Area and the application did not justify the loss of this building against relevant national policy and guidance.'
Get all the latest news from around the country Follow STV News
Scan the QR code on your mobile device for all the latest news from around the country
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Scottish Sun
an hour ago
- Scottish Sun
Scots civil servants offered £100k ‘cushy jobs' abroad while Holyrood faces ‘significant financial pressure'
'These cushy gigs are little more than taxpayer-funded platforms..." Click to share on X/Twitter (Opens in new window) Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window) CIVIL servants are being offered 'cushy' £100,000 pay packages to run Scottish Government offices in Denmark, Canada and China, we can reveal. The jobs are being advertised weeks after it emerged diplomats at the SNP ministers' international bases — dubbed 'pretend embassies' — have spent nearly £1million throwing 300 boozy parties. Sign up for Scottish Sun newsletter Sign up 2 Tories economy spokesman Murdo Fraser has hit out Credit: Alamy 2 Job adverts for 'Head of Scottish Government Office' roles are being advertised Credit: Getty Adverts for the 'Head of Scottish Government Office' roles promise successful applicants will have 'frequent contact' with ministers, business chiefs and cultural bigwigs. They even mention the cash crisis facing Holyrood — admitting it is a 'time of significant financial pressure for the Scottish Government'. Tories economy spokesman Murdo Fraser hit out: 'These cushy gigs are little more than taxpayer-funded platforms to bang the drum for independence abroad while Scotland's public services crumble. 'Scots want action on the state of the roads, NHS backlogs and failing schools — not more nationalist nonsense overseas. 'Hard-pressed Scots will be outraged the SNP is giving lucrative pay packages to pretend diplomats.' The jobs, in Copenhagen, Ottawa and Beijing, boast salaries of £74,480 to £85,964 with 28.9 per cent employer pension contributions boosting packages to around £100,000. Events held by the network of nine international offices include a ceilidh at a Brussels roundabout and a cheese and whisky celebration with the Swiss. External Affairs Secretary Angus Robertson said: 'We will never apologise for overseas offices that help showcase Scotland as a country open for business. "Scotland is consistently ranked best place in the UK outside of London for overseas investment.' Major Scottish Construction Firm Faces Liquidation in Dalgety Bay We previously reported how an independent review of the Scottish disability payment has called for the benefit to be simplified and made more accessible. Applying for the 'compassionate' benefit has been branded as 'soul-destroying' as part of a review commissioned by the Scottish Government. A report said the Scottish Adult Disability Payment (ADP) process was described as 'much kinder' than the UK Personal Independence Payment (PIP). But claimants still found it 'inaccessible, complex and burdensome, causing some clients significant stress and anxiety'. Led by charity leader Edel Harris, the review calls for automatic entitlement to the benefit in some cases. The Conservatives said the system 'is satisfying no one' and the SNP's persistent claim that they can run things better than Westminister 'continue to ring hollow'.
Sunday Post
an hour ago
- Sunday Post
Minister bankrolls Bosnian factory after public grant for Scottish jobs
Get a weekly round-up of stories from The Sunday Post: Thank you for signing up to our Sunday Post newsletter. Something went wrong - please try again later. Sign Up SNP minister Ivan McKee's engineering company took taxpayers' money to create jobs in Scotland – then, according to records, lent out £100,000 which helped bankroll an 'ultra-low cost' factory in Bosnia. The millionaire politician has refused to discuss his financial affairs after The Sunday Post exposed his links to engineering plants in the Balkans that are boosting his family's income. Before becoming an MSP, McKee was a director of Greenfold Systems Ltd (GSL) when it was awarded up to £400,000 by Scottish Enterprise in 2013 to fund 65 new jobs in Fife – most of which didn't materialise and the firm received just £35,000. But documents suggest GSL then gave a £100,000 loan to another of his companies, Excel Assemblies Ltd (EAL), which was setting up the factory in the former Yugoslavia. Both firms make hardware for bus constructors – but while EAL's business is booming by paying low wages in the Balkans, Greenfold has just gone bust. It collapsed because iconic Stirlingshire coachbuilder Alexander Dennis Ltd (ADL) lost out on Scottish Government grants, undercut by foreign companies paying workers a pittance. Hundreds of engineering jobs are now at risk as ADL considers shutting its Scottish operations altogether. On Friday, ADL put one of its two factory sites in Falkirk up for sale despite talks continuing to try and save the 400 jobs at risk. McKee quit commerce to become a politician in 2016 and is now public finance minister, in charge of making sure taxpayers' cash is used properly. Meanwhile, though, his wife owns 5% of Excel's [ESL] parent company, to which she has lent money, earning interest payments on it. Records suggest he, too, has an outstanding loan to the firm. McKee has repeatedly ignored questions about their finances. © Alamy Stock Photo Last night critics demanded to know whether Scottish Enterprise grants have ended up creating low-paid jobs abroad. Scottish Conservative shadow employment minister Stephen Kerr said: 'Ivan McKee and the SNP must provide a full and frank explanation. It will be a major scandal if taxpayers' money was spent bankrolling jobs in the Balkans and, to add insult to injury, it led to a Scottish firm going bust and workers being flung on the dole. 'If Ivan McKee had a direct financial interest, it would be even more appalling. SNP ministers warn of the dangers of foreign workers undermining Scottish firms but do nothing to support our domestic industries. 'If, as these claims suggest, their policies actively contribute to that problem while enriching SNP politicians, it's inexcusable.' McKee was one of three businessmen who rescued engineering company Simclar Ltd, renaming it Greenfold Systems. In 2013, quango Scottish Enterprise awarded it up to £400,000 to create new jobs. GSL vowed to increase its workforce from 84 to around 150, but employed just 90 when it went bust. It received £35,000 in 2014, but then 'the company's plans changed', according to a source. Around the same time, McKee and his business partners set up EAL, buying a factory in Croatia. They hatched a plan to create an 'ultra-low cost' new base in Bosnia, which would do roughly the same work as GSL. Excel's 2014/15 accounts state that it received a £100,000 loan from Greenfold Systems – at a time when building the Bosnia plant 'has been a challenging and expensive project'. Since then, the fortunes of the two companies have diverged. GSL plunged into administration last month. Meanwhile, EAL's headcount in Bosnia and Croatia has grown to 742, receiving an average salary of only £9,600 a year. It banked profits of £1.2m last year thanks to new contracts with bus builders. The SNP government's Scottish Zero Emission Bus Challenge Fund (ScotZEB) has offered £120m of grants to operators to buy electric coaches. But bids were marked on criteria that made Scottish jobs and paying decent wages to workers less important than cheap price tags. It means fewer than a third of the buses ordered have been made in Scotland. Last year, ADL accused ministers of creating 'an uneven playing field' favouring 'competitors from lower-cost economies'. McKee has failed to respond when asked if the Balkans factories have profited from ScotZEB grants – while the government says it doesn't know. Ahead of the 2014 referendum, the entrepreneur helped lead lobby group Business For Scotland, which raised £143,000 for the Yes campaign. And GSL's Dunfermline factory hosted photo ops for SNP top brass. Then Finance Secretary John Swinney said on his 2013 visit: 'I am pleased… the Government [and] Scottish Enterprise… are working hard to support manufacturing jobs in Scotland.' McKee was then picked to contest the Glasgow Provan seat for the SNP at the 2016 election and offloaded his business interests. But the day before he became an MSP, his wife Ewa took his vacant seat on the board of Excel Assemblies Holdings Ltd, with shares in her name too. She is also being paid 4% interest a year on an unspecified loan. Scottish Enterprise said it hands over grants retrospectively once criteria have been met. The Scottish Government said: 'Our focus is on securing a future for Alexander Dennis and its workforce. This work is being led by the Deputy First Minister with input from the Cabinet Secretaries for Transport and Finance, as appropriate. Ivan McKee is not involved in any discussions on this issue.' McKee and the SNP were approached for comment. It's understood that GSL created only six new Scottish jobs with the Scottish Enterprise investment.
Daily Record
2 hours ago
- Daily Record
Tony Bloom tells Celtic and Rangers their domination is over as Hearts money man reveals what disruption looks like
The Brighton owner and Jambos shareholder insists he's not messing about and warned the big two he's hear to bring them down Tony Bloom has told Celtic and Rangers that their days of dominating Scottish football are OVER. The Hearts money man vows he's here to upset the Scottish football applecart after ploughing £10million into the Tynecastle club. The Jambos were already using Jamestown Analytics to turbo charge their summer recruitment - the same data analytics company Bloom uses at Brighton and Union Saint-Gilloise - before he bought a 29 per cent stake in the capital club. And the gambling mastermind sent a bullish warning to the big two now that he's on the scene in Edinburgh, and it's that they should be ready for another runner to gate crash the two-horse race for the title. "It's really important for Scottish football for it not to be a one or two club show," Bloom told fans at a Q&A event for Foundation of Hearts pledgers. "And it's not going to be from now on., I assure everyone of that. "I welcome the investment from other clubs outside of the Old Firm. I think that's really good for Scottish football. "It's not good at all that historically, Scottish clubs haven't been doing well in Europe, so it lowers the Scottish coefficient. That means even if you win the league like Celtic, they've got to win two knock-out games to actually get into the group games of the Champions League. "I'm very confident that coefficient over the next few years will change, which would be really good for Scottish football. I really hope it will be really good news for Hearts. "I'm really excited about the challenge and the days of it being a two runner race have gone." Bloom is dead set on disrupting Scottish football and spelled out exactly what that means. He added: "It means that the fans and the media are not talking about it being a two-runner race. As I said, that will not be the case from now on. "Every game that Heart of Midlothian plays in, we will play to win. Every tournament that Hearts are in, we think we can win it and we're aiming to win it. "I accept the fact that when we get in the Champions League, that may be a little bit difficult! "But we have to have belief. We have to have belief in who we are, what we are, our head coach and our players and everyone at the football club. "I certainly do, and I think that the squad of players that Graeme (Jones, sporting director) has helped put together under Derek McInnes, will continue to get stronger year on year, on year. "It sounds like a success to me if Rangers and Celtic are knocking on Graeme's door wanting to buy our players. "But they might not be able to buy our player as they may have bigger clubs to go to. "I don't like to make predictions on one game or one season as there are so many variables. "But what I would say is that Hearts have got an exceptionally good squad this season and I think there's every chance that we will have success this season. "Not being in Europe this season gives Hearts an excellent chance in the league and perhaps in the cups as well. "Hearts fans have every right to have big expectations and historically I don't think those expectations have been big enough. "I know it's difficult and that the Old Firm have a huge advantage in terms of turnover, commercial deals and fan base, but that's all changing because we are going to have a squad to compete with the very best teams in Scotland."
