Cardross development to go ahead after Government overrules council
Planning permission in principle for the site at Kirkton Farm, outside Cardross, was granted in 2017, but a change of the condition was blocked due to concerns over flooding.
Council officials had recommended granting planning permission, but a decision to refuse won a roll call vote by five votes to four.
A Scottish Government officer has now overruled the decision and upheld the appeal by Cala. The housing company now hopes to start work at the site later this year.
READ MORE: Controversial Loch Lomond Flamingo Land plans recalled
The report will go before the PPSL committee at its meeting on Wednesday, June 18. It is only for noting by councillors, so no discussion will take place.
The Scottish Government officer said: 'The council's and representees' concerns relate to the implications of the proposed drainage arrangements on land west of Darleith Road, specifically on the Mill Dam pond and on flood risk along the Geilston Burn including at the property 'The Glen'. The focus is therefore on part (iii) of condition 11.
'Development-related water flows into this land would come from three sources. Firstly, runoff from land to the north of the development site that currently flows overland across the site and finds its way into the Geilston Burn (a small proportion may currently drain towards Barrs Road). It is proposed that this water be captured by a cutoff ditch and discharged into a tributary of the Geilston Burn (which apparently flows into the Mill Dam pond).
'The second source would be surface water originating from the development site itself. This water is to be directed to a SUDS detention basin from which the outflow is to be limited to the one in two year greenfield release rate.
'The detention basin is said to have sufficient capacity to cater for a one in 200 year rainfall event plus a 41 per cent allowance for climate change.
'The third source would be surface water originating from the existing Kilmahew Avenue/ Drive/ Court development to the east of the appeal site. It appears that surface water drainage from this area was incorrectly connected to the combined sewer in Barrs Road. This may be contributing to flooding issues downstream in Cardross.
'It is proposed to divert the surface water from Kilmahew Avenue into a new Scottish Water pipe (the 'third pipe') across the southern part of the appeal site. Together with the outflow from the SUDS basin, it is proposed that this water would then discharge to the west of Darleith Road in the vicinity of the Mill Pond.
'I note that this element of the water discharge would effectively implement the arrangement that should have been put in place originally in the agreed plans for the Kilmahew Avenue estate, albeit the discharge into the Geilston Burn is now proposed at a more upstream location.
'I am satisfied that the surface water discharges from the first two sources (the cutoff ditch and the SUDS basin) would be broadly equivalent to the agricultural runoff experienced pre-development. The flows originating from Kilmahew Avenue would be additional.'
READ MORE: 'First in Scotland': New 'free' store opens in Glasgow shopping centre
The official added: 'I find that the submissions demonstrate to my satisfaction that the development will not increase the risk of off-site surface water flooding.
'I do not consider that this policy requires the appellant to manage the water arising from the existing Kilmahew Avenue estate. The council's professional advisors on flooding matters are content that the appellant's submissions meet the required technical standards.
'The professional evidence before me therefore firmly favours the appellant's position. Overall, I conclude that the requirements of condition 11 have been satisfied.'
A statement by Cala said: 'Cala are delighted with this positive decision, and we continue our work with Argyll and Bute Council to secure the remaining necessary consents to facilitate this much needed housing development.
'We are currently targeting the start of the enabling works in autumn 2025, with first residents welcomed late 2026/early 2027.'
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Herald Scotland
30 minutes ago
- The Herald Scotland
So Nicola Sturgeon achieved nothing? What a load of nonsense
I have not read the memoir - time has not permitted. And the noisy reaction from some quarters has been of no real interest – it has not triggered any impulse to delve deeper to find out what the fuss is about. All of this sound and fury is to be expected, and much of it has come from people with political views very different to those of the former first minister or from those at odds with Ms Sturgeon on particular issues. The publication of the memoir has, however, also led to assessments of what Ms Sturgeon achieved during her long time as first minister, from November 2014 to March 2023. And this, from a personal perspective, is a more interesting aspect. It has seemed that many people have been almost falling over themselves to flag their withering opinions on this front, with a black-and-white view that 'nothing' or close to nothing was achieved. From a business and economic perspective, and from a societal point of view, that seems like a most unfair conclusion. Thankfully, some assessments have been more positive, but these seem to have been drowned out somewhat. Ms Sturgeon's relationship with the business community, certainly from the perspective of the latter, seemed to deteriorate significantly amid the coronavirus pandemic. What is often forgotten is the period before that, when you could have taken the view that business was surprisingly positive about Ms Sturgeon. After all, many company leaders were and are vehemently opposed to independence, not infrequently because of personal political or ideological views but also for some because of fears about the effects of constitutional change. Touching briefly on the pandemic, you might have thought Ms Sturgeon's approach would have been appreciated by more business leaders. There was a steadiness about it, in contrast to the toing and froing and all the drama from former prime minister Boris Johnson. Read more We should also remember Ms Sturgeon argued eloquently and convincingly during this period against the hard Brexit delivered by Mr Johnson, which continues to cost businesses the length and breadth of the UK so dearly and to hammer the country's beleaguered economy. And there were surely few if any moments, for all the hue and cry from some in the business community, when it could have been argued that Ms Sturgeon and the Scottish Government were being far too cautious with the pandemic restrictions and lockdowns. That said, a narrative nevertheless developed during that period that the Scottish Government was not on the side of business. Leaving the politicking and emotion fuelled by Ms Sturgeon's memoir to one side and taking a detached look at her time as first minister, without having read the book, it is not at all difficult to immediately identify other major positives. Ms Sturgeon was first minister when the Scottish child payment was introduced in 2021. This continues to be an extremely important source of support for low-income families in Scotland, now amounting to a weekly payment of £27.15 for every child under 16 years of age. And it is all the more crucial given the savage welfare cuts at a UK level that began when the Tories came to power in 2010. Given the Scottish Government's very limited powers in this area, the Scottish child payment is a huge deal. And it is simple arithmetic that giving money to people who have to spend all or the vast bulk of their income to live feeds through directly to aggregate demand, thereby boosting the economy. Former Conservative prime minister David Cameron and erstwhile chancellor George Osborne highlighted the importance of welfare spending to growth when they cut it savagely and hammered the UK economy. Read more Claiming we were 'all in this together', they implemented a corporation tax cuts bonanza, which failed miserably to boost investment and the economy as they claimed it would, as company bosses hung on to the windfall or distributed it to shareholders while the population at large was made to pay the price for the global financial crisis. Ms Sturgeon also, during her time as first minister, stuck steadfastly in straitened financial times and amid grim budget squeezes coming from Westminster with the SNP's commitment to free university tuition for students ordinarily resident in Scotland and doing their first degree. This is so important in ensuring the talent pool is not diminished by restricting access to higher education to those able to pay for it or willing to take on huge amounts of debt. If we are serious about having a highly skilled workforce, free university tuition is essential. It was lamentable to see Prime Minister Sir Keir Starmer go back on a previous pledge on free university tuition in England. Under 'social justice', one of Sir Keir's 10 pledges in 2020 when he was standing for Labour leader, the politician promised to 'support the abolition of tuition fees and invest in lifelong learning'. However, asked about this pledge in spring 2023 on BBC Radio 4's Today programme, Sir Keir replied: 'We are likely to move on from that commitment, because we do find ourselves in a different financial situation." The trebling of tuition fees in England under the Cameron administration looked at the time like a politically driven move to narrow access to higher education, and it continues to do so. Of course, Ms Sturgeon could probably have done some things better on the business and economic front. It was unnecessary for her to pass an opinion that the proposed giant Cambo oil field off Shetland should not get the green light. The decision rested in any case with the UK Government. And the North Sea is still such an important provider of employment, directly and through the supply chain, and still makes a huge contribution to the Scottish economy. Having said that, there were far more positives than negatives from a business and economic perspective when Ms Sturgeon was first minister, even if the pluses seem very under-appreciated now. Perhaps the best overall assessment of Ms Sturgeon's time in charge is to be gleaned from examining the foreign direct investment (FDI) numbers over the period in which she was first minister. This, after all, gives a cold, objective view of the merits of Scotland as a place to do business in a global context. Companies look at many factors, including workforce skills and the stability of government and policymaking. In 2022, the last full year in which Ms Sturgeon was first minister, a then record 126 FDI projects were secured by Scotland, figures from accountancy firm EY revealed. This was up from 122 in 2021, and the 3.3% increase in the number of projects secured by Scotland in 2022 contrasted with a 6.4% decline in the UK as a whole that year. EY's Ally Scott said at the time: 'Scotland put in another powerful performance on FDI in 2022, securing record inward investment projects and UK market share.' The accountancy firm, publishing figures for 2024 this summer, highlighted the fact Scotland has been second only to London in terms of the number of FDI projects won in every year since 2015. That is mightily impressive. And those who would claim Ms Sturgeon achieved nothing, or was somehow detrimental to business and the economy, should reflect on this, once the emotion subsides a bit.
The Independent
5 hours ago
- The Independent
Economic uncertainty blamed for ‘lacklustre' retail performance last month
Analysists have blamed rising economic uncertainty for a 'lacklustre' July that saw Scottish retail sales fall in real terms compared with the same month last year. According to figures from the Scottish Retail Consortium (SRC) and KPMG, total sales in Scotland rose 0.1% last month compared with July 2024, when they had decreased by 0.9%. However when adjusted for inflation this represents a year-on-year fall of 0.5%. Food sales in Scotland were down 1.4% compared with July 2024, when they had decreased by just 0.3%. This was despite a strong opening to the month when hot weather led to a 'boost' in spending on barbecues and summer meals. Non-food sales on the other hand rose by 1.4% compared with the same period last year, with analysists saying phones and some furniture and toy ranges performed well. Adjusted for the effects of online sales, non-food sales increased 1.6% on July 2024, when they had decreased by 1.5%. Ewan MacDonald-Russell, deputy head of the SRC, said: 'July was a lacklustre month for Scottish retailers as sales again disappointed. 'When adjusted for inflation retail sales in Scotland fell by 0.5%. That's a slight improvement on June's figures, but demonstrates shoppers continue to cut back on shopping as economic uncertainty continues to rise. 'Within the general disappointment there were some bright spots. Food sales shone in the opening half of the month as Scots took advantage of the warm weather to cook barbeque and summer meals. 'Phone sales did well, as did some toys and furniture ranges. Against that televisions continue to disappoint, with few households investing in high-end entertainment despite the summer plethora of sporting events. 'Fashion ranges performed poorly, albeit the likelihood is shoppers did their summer wardrobe shopping earlier in the year when the sunshine emerged. 'The harsh truth is Scots are holding back spending as worries about the economy grow. 'That is leaving shops in the lurch – facing higher costs as a consequence of last year's UK Government budget without the growth needed to pay those bills. 'With little sight the economic weather will brighten, many retailers, especially those on the high street, face increasingly unpalatable choices in the coming months.' Linda Ellett, UK head of consumer, retail and leisure at KPMG, described the current trading environment as 'challenging' for retailers. 'The UK's fifth warmest July on Met Office record brought a boost to home appliance and food and drink sales,' she said. 'But rising inflation was also a driver of the latter and monthly non-food sales are only growing at around 1% on average at present. 'With employment costs having risen and inflation both a business and consumer side pressure, it remains a challenging trading environment for many retailers. 'While the majority of consumers that KPMG surveys are confident in their ability to balance their monthly household budgets, big ticket purchases are more considered in the context of rising essential costs and ongoing caution about the economy and labour market. 'Holidays are the priority for many this summer but those heading away have had to account for a higher cost of travel. 'Consequently, spending in some areas of the retail sector remains subdued and competition for consumer spend will remain fierce.' The figures were published in the SRC-KPMG Retail Sales Monitor for July.
Daily Record
5 hours ago
- Daily Record
Former Paisley MP Willie Gallacher's death marked by bookshop display tribute
Abbey Books in the town produced the showcase in memory of one of Paisley's most famous politicians. A Paisley bookshop has honoured the passing of one of Paisley's most famous MPs by creating a display. Abbey Books, in Wellmeadow Street, marked the 60th anniversary of the death of Willie Gallacher by designing a window display dedicated to the Buddie. Taking up room in the shop, the display on Thursday not only contained copies of the politician's own books but a whole raft of left-wing reads including works by Lenin and Stalin. Gallacher was believed to be the first Paisley author to be published by Penguin – a multi-national publishing company – with a book titled 'The Case for Communism', published in 1949. The book was so well received, it became the first in a series produced by Gallacher. A second book, 'Rise Like Lions', was published by Lawrence and Wishart in 1951. And not only has Abbey Books got hold of copies of both books, they are both signed by Gallacher; a rare distinction at a time when book signing was far from the norm. Brian Hannan, manager of the Paisley book store, told the Paisley Daily Express: 'It's something of an honour to even hold these books in my hand. He is one of the most famous figures to emerge from Paisley and a significant politician in his time. 'I realised no one else was remembering a man that was one of the most famous people to come out of Paisley. He was instrumental in pushing for the 40-hour week and wanted to improve the working life for people. 'Initially, I was just going to put books in the window but I thought a bigger display was more fitting given the historical figure of the politician.' Born in Paisley on Christmas Day, 1881, he was the son of a baker. After his father died when he was seven, it was left to his washerwoman mother to keep the family together. In the 1920s, Gallacher became an influential figure when he became known a Scottish trade unionist, activist and communist. He was one of the leading figures of the shop stewards' movement in wartime Glasgow, as well as being a founding member of the Communist Party of Great Britain. In 1925, he was imprisoned for his political beliefs after being convicted under the Incitement to Mutiny Act 1797. He lived in a two-room council house in 68 Rowan Street and, famously, never had a phone. Gallacher was regularly contacted via the nearest public telephone booth bearing the number THO 3255 – with calls said to have come from all over the world. He died in August 12, 1965 aged 83.
