
Can a French citizen's petition reverse the reintroduction of a banned pesticide?
But some farmers, environmentalists and medical experts have criticised many of the law's proposals – particularly one provision that proposes to reintroduce the insecticide acetamiprid, a chemical known to be toxic to pollinators such as bees and to ecosystems – which was banned in France in 2018.
The contentious provisions spurred 23-year-old masters student Eleonore Pattery to launch a petition against the law on July 10, which brought the bill to the public's attention. The petition's author, who describes herself as "a future environmental health professional", called the new law a "scientific, ethical, environmental and public health aberration".
"It represents a frontal attack on public health, biodiversity, the coherence of climate policies, food security, and common sense," she said.
At the time of writing, the petition had collected more than 1.5 million signatures – higher than any other petition published on France's official National Assembly site so far.
The reintroduction of acetamiprid – an insecticide that belongs to a class of synthetic chemicals similar to nicotine called neonicotinoids, often shortened to "neonics" – is the most divisive provision of the law.
Neonics were developed in the 1980s to target the central nervous system of insects and disrupt nerve function. These insecticides are extremely effective against a wide range of pests like aphids and grubs, and have been used globally since the 1990s. In France, they are widely used by beetroot and hazelnut growers.
However, they come with a list of caveats that harm biodiversity and human health, according to experts.
Unlike contact pesticides that coat the surface of a plant, neonics are absorbed by the plant and distributed through its leaves, flowers, pollen, and nectar.
While this makes them very effective against pests, they also cause impaired navigation, reduced learning, weakened colony health and death among bees. Various beekeeping organisations have urged citizens to fight against the law for this very reason and have branded the chemical "a bee killer".
Scientists also say that neonicotinoids tend to remain inside the soil and hurt non-target species i.e., insects and animals that don't hurt crop yield but play an essential role in maintaining ecological balance.
However, the invertebrates aren't the only ones at risk. A growing body of research shows that neonicotinoids impact human nervous systems too. Hundreds of doctors and researchers have signed an open letter published by French healthcare organisation Médecins du Monde that says the law fails to address the collapse of biodiversity and the impact on farmers' health. The letter specifically mentions three chemicals: acetamiprid, flupyradifurone and sulfoxaflor.
'The primary consequence of these dysfunctions is an increased risk for farmers of non-Hodgkin's lymphoma (NHL), myeloma, prostate cancer, Parkinson's disease, and neurodevelopmental disorders, to take just a few examples, while the precautionary principle (and the European regulation) requires that no marketing authorisation be issued in the event of a risk to human health or biodiversity,' it says. The letter has been backed by The French League Against Cancer and the European Federation of Neurological Associations.
01:34
Environmentalists are also concerned by some of the other provisions of the law.
The law claims it will promote the expansion of industrial agriculture by easing permits for large livestock facilities and water reservoirs. Critics say this move will harm smaller family-run operations and is likely to increase greenhouse gas emissions and environmental degradation.
The Duplomb law will also implement several long-standing demands from France's largest farm union FNSEA, which has historically supported pesticide use.
"We need to maintain our means of production, and I believe there's a lot of exaggeration in the comments being made," the head of FNSEA, Arnaud Rousseau, told franceinfo radio.
Growers also argue that acetamiprid, allowed in other EU countries, is vital to fight yellows disease, which cut yields by 30% in 2020 and slashed sugar output.
Can a citizen's petition change the law?
The number of signatures on Pattery's petition continue to climb, and increasing pressure on the government to revisit the law.
The French government has defended the bill, but has been obliged to acknowledge the outcry, amid the rapidly rising number of signatures.
In France, petitions with over half a million signatures can prompt a parliamentary debate, but do not require a new vote.
National Assembly chairwoman Yael Braun Privet said the government "had to listen to the people. We will hold a debate but this debate will not – it cannot – change the text that was just voted." Former Prime Minister Gabriel Attal has also said he would back a debate.
Benjamin Morel, a constitutional expert and lecturer at the University of Paris-Panthéon-Assas agrees, saying that while the petition might lead to a debate, it will not ultimately lead to any change in the text of the law itself: "For the Duplomb law not to be enforced, a new bill would have to be introduced, or the president of the Republic would have to get involved."
" Emmanuel Macron could request a new deliberation by Parliament, in accordance with Article 10 of the Constitution," Morel adds. But he believes that the result of the vote would be identical.
For now, France's left – the four parties formerly allied under the banner of the New Popular Front – have promised to continue to battle to repeal the Duplomb law. "The fight has only just begun," warned Green Party MP Sandrine Rousseau on franceinfo radio on Monday.
Hashtags

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


France 24
4 hours ago
- France 24
Chinese, US officials meet for 2nd day of trade talks in Stockholm
AFP journalists saw officials from both sides, led respectively by Chinese Vice Premier He Lifeng and US Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent, enter the Swedish government building serving as the talks venue. Neither side has so far made public any information about what has gone on in the talks, which started on Monday. The negotiations are happening in the wake of a US-EU trade deal struck over the weekend that set US tariffs on most EU imports at 15 percent, but none on US goods going to the EU. The truce between China and the United States, the countries with the worlds two top economies, has temporarily set US duties on Chinese goods at 30 percent, and Chinese levies on US ones at 10 percent. That accord, reached in Geneva in May, brought down triple-digit tariffs each side had levelled at the other after a trade war sparked by US President Donald Trump spiralled into a tit-for-tat bilateral escalation. The 90-day truce is meant to end on August 12. But there are indications both delegations want to use the Stockholm talks to push the date back further. The South China Morning Post, citing sources on both sides, reported on Sunday that Washington and Beijing are expected to extend their tariff pause by a further 90 days. Trump's threats Trump has threatened to hit dozens of other countries with stiffer tariffs from Friday this week unless they agree to trade deals with Washington. Among them are Brazil and India, which he has warned could be targeted for 50-percent tariffs. The US leader has already announced deal outlines with five countries -- Britain, Vietnam, Japan, Indonesia and the Philippines -- as well as the one with the 27-nation EU. Beijing says it wants to see "reciprocity" in its trade with the United States. Foreign ministry spokesman Guo Jiakun said dialogue was need "to reduce misunderstandings". The previous round of of China-US talks was held in London. Analysts said many of the trade deals Trump has been publicising were leaning more on optics than on details. Stephen Innes, managing partner at SPI Asset Management, a firm that advises on currency exchange and commodities, said an extension of the 90-day truce between China and the United States could reinforce that view. "That truce could set the stage for a Trump – (President) Xi (Jinping) handshake later this year -- another risk-on carrot for markets to chew," he said.


France 24
4 hours ago
- France 24
Heavy rain causes flooding, evacuations and at least 38 deaths around Beijing region
01:49 29/07/2025 100-year-old Frenchman breaks skydive record with family 29/07/2025 Trump gives Putin deadline for Ukraine peace deal, prompting skepticism in Kyiv 29/07/2025 Gaza: Rights groups accuse Israel of genocide 29/07/2025 Trump warns of 'real starvation' in Gaza as aid deliveries pick up 29/07/2025 Israel begins to acknowledge Gaza's need for humanitarian aid under US pressure 29/07/2025 Trump issues new ultimatum calling on Putin to end Ukraine war in '10 or 12 days' 28/07/2025 'There is no alternative to the two-state solution to end the Israeli-Palestinian conflict' Middle East 28/07/2025 'EU has a lot to lose': US-EU trade deal with Trump counter to 'what EU should be standing for' Europe 28/07/2025 Rajab's Ramp: A skateboarder's call from a starving Gaza


France 24
5 hours ago
- France 24
Israel begins to acknowledge Gaza's need for humanitarian aid under US pressure
01:40 29/07/2025 Trump issues new ultimatum calling on Putin to end Ukraine war in '10 or 12 days' 28/07/2025 'There is no alternative to the two-state solution to end the Israeli-Palestinian conflict' Middle East 28/07/2025 'EU has a lot to lose': US-EU trade deal with Trump counter to 'what EU should be standing for' Europe 28/07/2025 Rajab's Ramp: A skateboarder's call from a starving Gaza 28/07/2025 Russia: Numerous flights cancelled after massive cyberattack 28/07/2025 Impact of US tariffs varies across European Union 28/07/2025 Trump says many are starving in Gaza, vows to set up food centres 28/07/2025 Thailand and Cambodia agree to ceasefire to end deadly border row 28/07/2025 Starmer–Trump meeting: US president sees signs of 'real starvation' in Gaza"