Cement cartel case hearing to resume soon
Listen to article
The Competition Appellate Tribunal (CAT) has imposed a penalty of Rs10,000 on cement companies seeking adjournment in the hearing of a 2009 case.
CAT has now fixed April 24 for hearing appeals filed by cement manufacturers against a 2009 decision by the Competition Commission of Pakistan (CCP), which imposed a cumulative fine of Rs6.35 billion on 20 cement companies for alleged price fixing and cartelisation. As the tribunal has now become functional following recent appointments, the appeal hearing filed by the cement companies has resumed.
However, in a recent hearing, the senior counsel representing several manufacturers remained absent and the tribunal considered it as a deliberate attempt to delay the proceedings.
The original CCP order was issued in 2009 after an investigation into suspected collusion in the cement sector revealed that the manufacturers had engaged in cartel-like behaviour by fixing prices and monitoring cement dispatches to control market supply.
The evidence included a seven-month record of dispatches recovered from the premises of the All Pakistan Cement Manufacturers Association (APCMA), which pointed towards coordinated activities among the companies.
The CCP imposed fines on individual companies ranging from Rs12 million to Rs1.27 billion, including Rs1.27 billion on Lucky Cement and Rs933 million on DG Khan Cement. Others included Maple Leaf Cement Rs586 million, Bestway Cement Rs562 million, Pakistan Cement Rs405 million, Attock Cement Rs374 million, Pioneer Cement Rs366 million, Dewan (merged entity) Rs345 million, Fauji Cement and Cherat Cement Rs266 million each, Askari Cement (Wah) Rs233 million, Askari Cement (Nizampur) Rs187 million, Fecto Cement Rs174 million, Kohat Cement Rs103 million, Al Abbas Rs87 million, Mustehkam Cement Rs74 million, Dandot Cement Rs42 million, Gharibwal Cement Rs39 million, Dadabhoy Cement Rs28 million and Rs12 million on Flying Cement.
Following the imposition of these fines, several companies obtained stay orders from courts and some approached the Supreme Court directly.
In June 2017, the apex court ruled that the matter should first be adjudicated by CAT, in accordance with the law, which requires the tribunal to decide such cases within six months.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Express Tribune
13 hours ago
- Express Tribune
Sacrifice pool prices rise in line with animal costs
The cost of each share of collective or pool sacrifice has also increased with the hike in the price of the sacrificial animals. Bulls, cows and camels have seven shares in sacrifice for the Eidul Azha. While many households buy their own animals and distribute the share among family and friends, others choose to pool the sacrifice with local mosques or welfare organisations to fulfil the religious obligation. Due to the high cost of sacrificial animals, it is becoming difficult for many people to perform the Sunnah of Ibrahim on an individual level. That is why there has been an increase in the trend of collective sacrifice on Eidul Azha in Karachi this year. Imran-ul-Haq, the administrator of a welfare organisation that conducts collective sacrifices, informed The Express Tribune that sacrificial animals are being sold at exorbitantly high prices this year. He said that people who bought a heifer for less than Rs100,000 and a goat for around Rs30,000 last year, have found it difficult to sacrifice individually this Eidul Azha. That is why a large number of citizens are opting for collective sacrifice. He said that due to the high cost of animals, the share of collective sacrifice has also increased from Rs3,000 to Rs10,000. He said that various madaris, mosques and welfare organisations have introduced various packages of collective sacrifice. The share which was Rs20,000 to Rs25,000 or less last year has increased to Rs28,000 or more this year.
Express Tribune
14 hours ago
- Express Tribune
Zardari roots for broad national consensus
President Asif Ali Zardari has said the country urgently needs political stability and broad national consensus, stressing that all democratic forces must work together to ensure progress and prosperity. During a meeting with senior party leader Barrister Aamir Hasan in Lahore, President Zardari said public service should be kept uppermost, adding every individual and group will have to play their role to resolve public issues. The president urged youth to step forward for the country's progress. He called for a uniform strategy to make Pakistan economically vibrant. Zardari directed the PPP leaders to work hard for party's reorganization. Barrister Aamir Hasan proposed that competent and ideological workers be appointed on PPP's key organizational posts. Meanwhile, President Asif Ali Zardari also held a meeting with PPP central executive committee (CEC) member Chaudhry Manzoor Ahmed. They discussed the problems of labourers and government employees, and exchanged views on increasing the minimum wage by 50 per cent in the upcoming budget. Chaudhry Manzoor proposed that the minimum wage be increased to Rs50,000 and EOBI pensions by 100 per cent. Zardari expressed hope that the government will consider the welfare of labourers and workers as a top priority in the budget. He said society cannot progress without giving relief to labourers.
Business Recorder
16 hours ago
- Business Recorder
Pharmaceutical sector: CCP grants six exemptions to undertakings for FY2024–25
ISLAMABAD: In line with its mandate to promote fair competition and protect consumer welfare, the Competition Commission of Pakistan (CCP) has granted six exemptions to undertakings in the pharmaceutical sector for the fiscal year 2024–25, under Section 5 of the Competition Act, 2010. These exemptions relate to specific restrictive clauses in commercial agreements — such as territorial exclusivity and non-compete provisions that would ordinarily be considered anti-competitive under Section 4 (Prohibited Agreements) of the Act. However, after conducting rigorous due diligence, including a detailed assessment of market structures, sector-specific regulations, and the commercial terms of the agreements, CCP determined that the arrangements in question contribute to production efficiency, technological advancement, and enhanced consumer access to critical pharmaceutical products. The Commission noted that these exemptions are expected to improve service delivery, increase the availability of medicines in underserved regions, and lead to better public health outcomes. Consumers stand to benefit from access to advanced pharmaceutical technologies, more reliable product information, and higher standards of service. Each exemption was granted for a specific duration and is subject to conditions that ensure the pro-competitive benefits clearly outweigh any potential adverse effects on competition. Importantly, the undertakings are required to avoid any form of price-fixing or collusive conduct, and pricing arrangements remain outside the scope of these exemptions. The pharmaceutical sector remains a priority area for CCP's exemption regime, with the Commission maintaining close coordination with relevant health regulators to ensure that such decisions serve the broader public interest. Copyright Business Recorder, 2025
