Senzo Meyiwa trial judge apologises for racial remarks
On Monday, Judge Ratha Mokgoatlheng apologised for making controversial racial remarks which sparked public and political criticism during the Senzo Meyiwa trial.
He admitted his conduct was unbecoming of his stature and expressed regret, reflecting on his remarks and addressing accusations of racism.
Mokgoatlheng offered to recuse himself if anyone doubted his fairness, honour, or integrity as a judge.
Judge Ratha Mokgoatlheng has publicly apologised for his controversial racial remarks he made during Thursday's session of the Senzo Meyiwa murder trial.
His comments came on the back of defence advocate Charles Mnisi's request to be excused from court on Monday because he was participating in the Comrades Marathon on Sunday and sparked widespread criticism.
The judge said at the time: 'When the JP [Judge President] asks why you were not sitting on Monday, [we'll have to say] 'no, we were waiting for advocate Mnisi to drive back to Joburg because he was running a marathon'. This is South Africa run by blacks; I can tell you now ... a white advocate would never have the gall to ask me that. Never.'
The remarks drew sharp criticism from various quarters, including political parties and legal commentators.
In his apology, Mokgoatlheng said: 'I have been on the bench for 26 years as an acting judge and a judge. I have never ever behaved the way I did on Friday. Before becoming a judge, I spent 30 years as an attorney. I spoke to the Judge President and he, together with the Deputy Judge President, rightfully excoriated me for my conduct, saying it was not befitting of a judge of my experience and stature. I agree wholeheartedly. My conduct was questionable and incorrect.'
On Thursday the GOOD Party strongly condemned Mokgoatlheng's comments, saying: 'It undermines the integrity of the judiciary and risks inflaming already fragile race relations in South Africa. Decorum in court is not just about the behaviour of lawyers and attendees; it begins with the conduct of the bench. Judges must embody the fairness and dignity they expect from others. These comments fall far short of that standard.'
Despite the backlash, Gauteng Judge President Dunstan Mlambo had offered a different perspective, telling News24: 'I can see no misconduct by the judge in the circumstances of the case, as viewed by many.'
In his apology, however, Mokgoatlheng added a personal dimension, revealing the impact these events had on his family and shedding light on his own personal reflections.
'My wife, who I thought was afraid of me, told me that I should apologise to the whole of South Africa because I am worse than the attorneys who are currently stealing money from clients in the Road Accident Fund (RAF) matter ... I wish to tender my sincerest apologies. It's contra my nature to act like that. I recently lost my son, who was an advocate — he died due to lymphatic cancer. I believe he would have been disappointed in my behaviour. That's why I wholeheartedly and unreservedly apologise to my colleagues here and to the gentlemen in front of me.'
Mokgoatlheng also sought to address suggestions of racism on his part, saying: 'I have also been accused of being a racist. I want to share one or two things about me as a person, beyond being a lawyer. I grew up in the house of Moses Skotane. Nelson Mandela used to visit our home, as did Walter Sisulu — even Robert Sobukwe before he broke away from the ANC. My father was an active member of the ANC and the Communist Party. He would be mortified to hear me being labelled a racist. My great-grandmother was German. I recall she used to cut her hair short so that people wouldn't realise she had white blood. So I know everything about racism.'
He concluded by offering to step down if anyone questioned his integrity.
'The gentlemen in front of me - if you believe that I, as a judge, am so useless, dumb, and incapable of giving you a fair trial, please tell me. I will recuse myself. I do not want to impose myself on individuals who doubt my integrity, honour, or dignity. If you truly believe I am racist, unfit for this role, and dismissive of the Constitution, just say it, and I will step away.'
The case continues.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
News24
an hour ago
- News24
ANC tightens its rules on selection of local government leaders
The ANC is implementing stricter selection processes for party leadership positions in preparation for the 2026 local government elections. These measures aim to improve the party's image and enhance service delivery by appointing qualified leaders who can properly manage municipalities. The new rules reflect the ANC's effort to 'clean its membership' and ensure those in leadership positions are adequately qualified for their roles. The African National Congress (ANC) is implementing stricter selection processes for party leadership positions in preparation for the 2026 local government elections. Secretary General Fikile Mbalula has instructed provincial structures to begin selecting quality members with proper qualifications and without tainted histories. His views were supported by the head of the party's electoral committee, Kgalema Motlanthe, who emphasised educational qualifications. Motlanthe also highlighted the importance of considering women first in all positions. The party has given the provincial structure a strict task of selecting quality members with no criminal record or facing an internal disciplinary hearing. With the 2026 local government around the corner, Mbalula has called on the party structure to commence with the selection processes of the leadership, including the mayors. In a letter sent to provincial secretaries and ANC deployees dated 22 May, Mbalula informed them about the candidates' selection process deadline. According to Mbalula, all the selection processes should be done by the end of July 2026. He said this was to enable the party to be ready for the 2026 local government elections, which are expected to take place at the end of 2026. He instructed the provincial leadership and the party deployees to urgently establish the provincial list committees (PLCs). 'Kindly find attached the letter to all provincial secretaries and NEC deployees on the deadlines for the candidate selection process. This is for the establishment of the PLCs as a matter of urgency. The Elections Committee will be making follow-up on each province in this regard,' read Mbalula's letter. Insiders say the party is tightening the rules of deploying qualified people in government who would help redeem its dignity and improve service delivery. The names that are going to be nominated are going to be subjected to rigorous vetting processes and thorough educational background checks. Source The source said strict rules aim to change the image of the party, which had been appointing people who cannot read or interpret the financial report. 'We have a lot of problems in municipalities because many leaders are failing the communities as a result of not understanding simple things,' said the source. Mbalula's letter was also sent to the party's electoral committee led by the party's former deputy president Kgalema Motlanthe. Motlanthe requested the provincial secretaries to submit the names of the recommended members of the provincial list committee, which shall manage and coordinate the 2026 local government elections candidates' selection process. The CVs and proof of qualifications for the recommended members must also be submitted, and failure to do so shall result in disqualification. The Electoral Committee shall submit recommendations for the appointment of PLC members for approval by the NEC, and names without CVs and qualifications will not be included in the submission Motlanthe Motlanthe said the PLC members must be respected and disciplined members of the ANC and Alliance who may not stand for any elected positions in the ANC and shall not be available for nomination and selection as public representatives. 'All PLC members must have a tertiary qualification coupled with political and/or government experience. All PLC members must have no pending criminal charges or ongoing ANC disciplinary proceedings against them,' read Motlanthe's letter dated 22 May. Insiders say this is part of the ANC's cleaning its membership campaign. 'The reason for starting early is to enable the party to screen all the people who would be running the structures and selecting those who will be leading or be deployed in local government, like mayors, speakers and chief whips,' said the source. To ensure that the people running the selection process do not have an interest in the party-political positions, Motlanthe requested the PECs to nominate three senior ANC members who no longer occupy elected positions in the NEC or PEC or REC, with no direct personal interest in the outcome of the candidate selection process. He also said two of those nominated three individuals must be women. Each of the leagues' provincial executives may also nominate one list committee member who meets the above criteria. Each of the Alliance partners plus Sanco may nominate one list committee member who meets the above criteria. Motlanthe According to the new rules, provincial secretaries and electoral committee members are not eligible to occupy leadership positions at the national, provincial or regional levels in their organisations. 'The Provincial Secretary will provide administrative support for the PLC and will ensure that all organisational structures implement the processes and abide by the rules determined by the Executive Committee (EC). The Provincial Secretary or Convenor shall not sit on the PLC. A provincial staff member or volunteer must be appointed as list administrator to assist the PLC by the provincial secretary and approved by the EC,' said Motlanthe. Motlanthe said all the structures must assume that the elections would be held before the end of November; all the processes need to be concluded by the end of July 2026.
Bloomberg
2 hours ago
- Bloomberg
Land Rovers, Houses and Whisky: Gold Rally Brings Riches to Rural Zimbabwe
In Filabusi, in south-eastern Zimbabwe the streets are packed with BMW X5s and Land Rover Defenders, modern houses paid for in cash are springing up and whisky is only sold by the bottle in the small town's bars. The three-year surge in gold prices, driven to a record this year as US President Donald Trump's trade war bolstered its allure as a safe-haven, is enriching the country's more than 700,000 informal, or artisanal, miners. They are flocking to gold mining belts and throwing a lifeline to an economy that's been in economic turmoil since the turn of the century.
News24
3 hours ago
- News24
Green hydrogen opportunities key to unlocking economic growth: Ramokgopa
@GovernmentZA / X Ramokgopa highlighted green hydrogen as a key driver for South Africa's economic growth, addressing structural challenges in energy and logistics while creating downstream value from mineral resources like platinum and vanadium. He emphasised green hydrogen's dual role in decarbonising hard-to-electrify sectors, such as transport and heavy industry, while boosting energy security and supporting the mining sector's revival through demand for transition minerals. Ramokgopa stressed the importance of continental policy alignment to unlock Sub-Saharan Africa's renewable energy potential, which could attract greater global investment and foster industrial development. At the media launch of the Africa Green Hydrogen Summit on Tuesday, electricity and energy minister Dr Kgosientsho Ramokgopa emphasised that South Africa's future energy mix must be strategically aligned to solve economic challenges, with green hydrogen positioned as a central lever. Speaking at Isondo Precious Metals in the OR Tambo Special Economic Zone, Kempton Park, Ramokgopa said the country's energy problems are not simply technical but economic at their core. 'We are resolving an economic problem with energy manifestations,' he said. South Africa cannot grow if electricity is unreliable or unaffordable. Kgosientsho Ramokgopa Ramokgopa spoke candidly about how the government is treating the energy crisis as a matter of national importance. Drawing from his engineering background, he argued that solving the crisis requires a deep understanding of the root problem, namely, that South Africa's economy has stagnated due to structural constraints, primarily in logistics and energy. 'The structural constraint to the South African economy can be identified as twofold: inefficiencies in logistics and challenges related to the electricity deficit,' Ramokgopa said, echoing views previously raised by President Cyril Ramaphosa and Finance Minister Enoch Godongwana. As part of the state's plan to respond to these constraints, green hydrogen has emerged as a potential contributor to both energy diversification and economic development. Ramokgopa pointed to the dual importance of this emerging industry: on one hand, green hydrogen could help decarbonise sectors like transport and heavy industry; on the other, it opens doors for South Africa to beneficiate its mineral resources and create downstream value. Cabinet has already approved a Critical Minerals Strategy, led by Mineral Resources and Energy Minister Gwede Mantashe, aimed at identifying and leveraging minerals essential to the global energy transition. The strategy identifies minerals such as platinum, vanadium, manganese and rare earth elements that are critical to producing green hydrogen and associated technologies like fuel cells. Ramokgopa described the potential as a 'resurgence of the battery and fuel cell economy', which he believes could revitalise the mining sector's contribution to GDP and employment. Mining has contracted in recent years, but the demand for energy transition minerals offers a chance to reposition it. Kgosientsho Ramokgopa On the sidelines of the launch, Ramokgopa expanded on these themes in an interview. 'Green hydrogen is a big part of South Africa's growth story because it allows us to beneficiate our upstream endowments. Mining, particularly for minerals like platinum, has one of the highest employment absorption capacities,' he said. He added that green hydrogen supports not only the decarbonisation of electricity, which remains South Africa's largest source of emissions, but also transport, where traditional renewables like solar are less effective. 'Green hydrogen gives us diversification in energy sources and could play a role in sectors where electrification is difficult,' he said. However, Ramokgopa acknowledged that the current cost of green hydrogen remains prohibitive. 'The technology is still maturing, and we're not yet competitive, but over time we expect costs to come down.' He also noted the need for regional alignment across the continent. 'Sub-Saharan Africa has the potential to produce 60% of the world's renewable energy, but currently receives less than 1% of global investment. He said that the summit, taking place 12-13 June at the Century City Conference Centre & Hotel, is about aligning policies and coordination to change that.
