Australian Greens leader says she has not read reasons for party's expelling of co-founder
The decision to terminate Hutton's life membership of the Greens was upheld by delegates of the state branches on Sunday, over what the party considers his pursuit of debate harmful to trans people but that he has framed as an issue of free speech.
Waters, a senator for Queensland, had backed the outcome of the appeal, saying it reflected 'good governance' and sent the message that 'nobody is above the rules'.
Speaking to the ABC's 7.30 on Tuesday, Hutton doubled down on his position.
He suggested some Greens members 'over the last decade or so' had aimed to 'convert it into the sort of party one of whose main preoccupations is with transgender rights'. He said he had 'no problem with transgender rights' but accused the party of harbouring 'an absolutely rigorous determination to stop any dissent'.
Hutton claimed he had been contacted by 40 former party members, 'about half' of whom had been expelled, and the others 'forced out by being subjected to massive complaints'. He suggested a faction within the party – which he described this week as 'a cult' – had 'weaponised the complaint system'.
Waters, appearing immediately after Hutton on the program, rejected his description of the party as 'authoritarian, aggressive and doctrinaire'. She insisted people inside the Greens were free to express their opinions – and do.
'You can have a robust debate and there's lots of differences of opinion when party members are actually debating and formulating our policies, but you can do that in a respectful manner,' she said.
When host Sarah Ferguson asked whether Waters took issue with Hutton's views or the way he had expressed them – asking why Hutton had been expelled – Waters replied: 'Look, I wasn't part of that process, Sarah. That was a process that the party ran.'
Pressed on the reasons for the expulsion, Waters revealed she had not read the documentation, dismissing responsibility for the decision.
'I haven't read the documentation because here I am in parliament hoping to talk tomorrow about introducing a climate trigger into our environmental laws and fixing the gender inequalities in our tax system amongst other things,' Waters said.
'This was a decision that was reviewed by the party, taken by volunteer party members, many of whom uphold the code of conduct on a regular basis.'
Any future decision on whether Hutton could return to the party was 'not up to me', she added.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Reuters
2 hours ago
- Reuters
Britain, Australia to deepen AUKUS commitment, economic ties
SYDNEY, July 25 (Reuters) - Australia and Britain's defence and foreign ministers arrived for talks in Sydney on Friday on boosting cooperation, including deepening the two countries commitment to the AUKUS nuclear submarine partnership. Britain's Foreign Minister David Lammy and Defence Secretary John Healey were met by Prime Minister Anthony Albanese in Sydney, where talks are expected to focus on boosting trade ties and progressing the AUKUS partnership for Britain and Australia to build a new class of nuclear-powered submarine. The United States is reviewing the trilateral agreement struck in 2021, and has pressed Australia to increase defence spending to counter China's military build-up in the Indo Pacific region. A new British-Australian treaty will underpin each country's submarine programmes and is expected to be worth up to 20 billion pounds ($27 billion) to Britain in exports over the next 25 years, Britain's Ministry of Defence said. "AUKUS is one of Britain's most important defence partnerships, strengthening global security while driving growth at home," British defence minister John Healey said in a statement. The treaty "confirms our AUKUS commitment for the next half century," he added. Following the Australia-United Kingdom Ministerial Consultations (AUKMIN), ministers are scheduled to travel to the northern garrison city of Darwin, where the British aircraft carrier HMS Prince of Wales has arrived for the Talisman Sabre war games. As many as 40,000 troops from 19 countries are taking part in the Talisman Sabre exercises held from July 13 to August 4, which Australia's military has said are a rehearsal of joint war fighting that contribute to stability in the Indo-Pacific. Britain has significantly increased its participation in the exercise co-hosted by Australia and the United States, with 3,000 troops taking part.
The Guardian
4 hours ago
- The Guardian
Morning Mail: new abuse allegation at family daycare, France to recognise Palestine as a state, Hulk Hogan dies
Morning everyone. In the latest horrifying allegation about misconduct in the childcare sector, a mother has exclusively alleged to Guardian Australia that her two-year-old daughter was sexually abused while at a family daycare – by the partner of the woman running the service. Despite investigations by NSW police and government, no action was taken against the man or the childcare service, which is still operating. In breaking news, Emmanuel Macron has announced that France will recognise Palestine as a state, saying there is 'no alternative' if peace is to be possible. Plus: The trade minister Don Farrell will warn today that Australia 'will suffer' if Donald Trump's trade wars persist, research calls for a big hike in jobseeker, Trump officials meet Ghislaine Maxwell and Hulk Hogan has died aged 71. 'Sense of wonder' | Henri Szeps (above), the actor best known for his role in the much-loved ABC sitcom Mother and Son, has died aged 81. Exclusive | A NSW mother alleges that her two-year-old daughter was sexually assaulted while at a family daycare by a man living on the premises, despite her parents having no idea he would be present at the home. Trade pain | Australia 'will suffer' for generations if Donald Trump's global trade wars persist, Don Farrell warns, as the Albanese government stares down an increasingly challenging economic environment in its second term. Rights 'safeguard' | The boss of Australia's human rights commission has questioned Labor's moves to make Asio's powers for compulsory questioning permanent, warning a planned expansion of the 9/11-era laws must include more safeguards. Exclusive | Raising jobseeker to 90% of the age pension would lift 590,000 Australians out of poverty, new research suggests, with the $11bn price tag paid for by curbing super tax concessions. 'Solemn decision' | French president Emmanuel Macron says France will recognise Palestine as a state. Meanwhile a group of far-right Israeli politicians and settlers has met to discuss a plan to displace Palestinians from Gaza and turn it into a luxury resort. The head of the UN agency for Palestinians said its staff are fainting from hunger amid an Israeli blockade. Maxwell meeting | Officials from Donald Trump's justice department met Ghislaine Maxwell, the late sex offender's longtime associate, in Florida where she is serving 20 years for sex trafficking. Back in Washington, the same department has formed a 'strike force' to investigate claims that the Obama administration carried out a 'treasonous conspiracy' to smear Trump's 2016 election win. Follow developments in the US live. Border clashes | Thailand and Cambodia fought in their most deadly border clashes in more than a decade on Thursday as Thai officials said 11 civilians and a Thai soldier were killed in rocket and artillery attacks. Hulk mourned | Hulk Hogan, the wrestling star turned vocal supporter of Donald Trump, has died at the age of 71 after a heart attack at his home in Florida. Trump skewered | South Park has kicked off its 27th season with a blistering episode taking aim at Donald Trump and its newly minted parent company, Paramount. Newsroom edition: the real net zero questions do not involve the Coalition Reged Ahmad speaks to editor Lenore Taylor, head of newsroom Mike Ticher and climate and environment editor Adam Morton on what's distracting Australia from acting on the climate emergency. Sorry your browser does not support audio - but you can download here and listen $ After the collapse of retirement funds such as First Guardian saw thousands of Australians out of pocket, Luca Ittimani looks at what went wrong and what you can do to avoid falling victim to risky schemes. The famous 1930s Cairo flats development in Fitzroy and the 122-year-old Younghusband Woolstore in Kensington are among the architectural treasures that will be open to the public this weekend as part of Open House Melbourne. Stephanie Convery and Adeshola Ore get a sneak preview. Sign up to Morning Mail Our Australian morning briefing breaks down the key stories of the day, telling you what's happening and why it matters after newsletter promotion Cycling | Australia's Ben O'Connor (above) of the Jayco AlUla team won the 18th stage of the Tour de France, a 171.5km mountain trek between Vif and the Col de la Loze but Tadej Pogačar's second place helped him retain the yellow jersey. David Rozman, a long-term member of Ineos Grenadiers staff, has left the Tour de France after an investigation was launched by anti-doping authorities. Swimming | The push by Australia's swimmers to match their excellent performance in the Paris Olympics begins on Sunday at the World Aquatics Championships in Singapore. Cricket | Ben Duckett and Zak Crawley combined for an opening stand of 166 on the second day of the fourth Test at Old Trafford as England reached 225-2 at the close after dismissing India for 358. Men working in childcare in Victoria are being turned away from jobs in what they say is a 'shadow ban' in the wake of abuse allegations, the Age reports. BP has walked away from a $55bn hydrogen energy project in the Pilbara due to lack of potential customers, the Australian says. Tasmania Labor's leader, Dean Winter, refuses to concede defeat in the state election, the Mercury reports, and is in talks with independents about trying to form a government. The NSW government is considering banning e-bikes and e-scooters from the train network amid concerns about lithium batteries sparking fires, according to the Sydney Morning Herald. Security | Australian and British ministers meet in Sydney. Queensland | Bruce Lehrmann's pretrial hearing and application to have rape charges dismissed is taking place at Toowoomba magistrates court. Economy | The federal trade minister, Don Farrell, will address the Lowy Institute in Canberra. If you would like to receive this Morning Mail update to your email inbox every weekday, sign up here, or finish your day with our Afternoon Update newsletter. You can follow the latest in US politics by signing up for This Week in Trumpland. And finally, here are the Guardian's crosswords to keep you entertained throughout the day. Until tomorrow. Quick crossword Cryptic crossword
The Guardian
4 hours ago
- The Guardian
Why Trump's political playbook is failing in the Epstein case
The problem with a successful playbook is that you eventually keep doing the same thing mechanically. Fresh from intimidating ABC and CBS with meritless lawsuits, Donald Trump is suing Rupert Murdoch and the Wall Street Journal reporters who broke the story of a lewd birthday message for Jeffrey Epstein. But, unlike with the frivolous allegations against the big broadcasters, there's clearly a fact of the matter here: an authentic letter either exists or it does not; and there is plenty to be revealed in the process of finding out. Trump's time-proven move – whatever happens, just counter-attack – is likely to keep the very story he wants to kill alive. Meanwhile, the other elements of his playbook – deny, deflect, distract – only work if journalists and Democrats play along. They, not the seemingly all-important Trump base, are the actors to watch. We still debate whether Trumpism is a substantial ideology or not; what we are missing is that Trumpism, for sure, is a set of tactics for exploiting weaknesses in the US political, legal and media systems. Some of these tactics were inherited from his mentor Roy Cohn and many are now being adopted by Trump's followers – one must never admit guilt; one must always swing back; and one must reject, or ideally entirely bury, defeats (such as Trump's case against Bob Woodward and Woodward's publisher being dismissed recently). But there is also a less obvious element, and it has to do with managing political time (a challenge for all politicians, come to think of it). The point is not just seizing opportunities or exploiting opponents' weaknesses in a timely manner; rather, it is about the art of speeding things up or slowing them down to one's advantage. Think of how we appear to have become inured to Trump doing and saying things that would have ended previous presidencies (OK, previous presidents did not have AI-generated images of themselves as kings or popes available, but still). One reason is this: an administration that faces one or two big scandals in a four-year period may well be damaged beyond repair; one that produces three very big scandals a day seems to have nothing to worry about since no one can keep up. It is difficult to stick with one story, as the newest outrage already appears so much bigger (the Qatar plane scandal can feel like it happened years ago). To be sure, not all scandals are consciously produced, but there is little doubt that Trump's posting an AI-generated clip of Barack Obama being arrested in the White House and identifying Obama as a 'ringleader' of election fraud are meant to distract – which is not to deny that they would justify impeachment. While the frequency of scandals is maximized to game the news cycle, the legal system is used to slow things down. Releasing the grand jury testimonies in the Epstein case will take time, if the request is not rejected altogether by courts (as has already happened in Florida). Even if they are released, they are unlikely to contain anything relevant about Trump. The calculation is that, a few weeks from now, the files will be forgotten. None of this is to suggest Trump is a master Machiavellian who can manipulate Americans (or even just his base) at will. His approach partly works because institutional and cultural contexts have changed: news cycles are shorter, as are attention spans. His behavior has become progressively normalized – and generalized: shamelessness once unique to him is now in the manual of required GOP conduct (just think of blatant lies about Medicaid). Most important, a free press sticking relentlessly with scandals and ignoring intimidation can no longer be taken for granted; broadcasters in particular have become vulnerable to parent companies putting profits before everything else. Democrats, understandably not wanting to look like they mainly focus on the sordid details of the Epstein story, are tempted to move on and deal with the vaunted 'kitchen-table issues'. But it should give them pause that the story is apparently so scary for the other side that Republicans would rather shut down the House than deal with it in any shape or form. Are they right to panic? For sure, Trump made a mistake with his social media post urging followers to move on, which was the equivalent of 'don't think of an elephant' (while also providing further evidence for the Streisand effect: censorship generates the very attention meant to be avoided). Trump lobbying Murdoch to kill the story will give pause to all still naive enough to think of Republicans as free speech defenders. By now, the fact that releasing only the grand jury testimony is relatively meaningless has sunk in and – never mind the base – what political scientists call 'low-information voters' will be left with a lasting impression of a Trump-Epstein connection or at least a chaotic administration. In the lawsuit, Trump has to prove 'actual malice' on the part of the newspaper – a difficult hurdle to jump. Unlike with the Russia investigation, Trump himself is the instigator of a lengthy process overshadowing his presidency; unlike with the many investigations between his presidential terms, when his lawyers outran the clock, time is not really on his side. In fact, he might be lucky if the case is dismissed on a technicality – he apparently failed to comply with a Florida law that requires giving defendants five days' notice. Jan-Werner Müller is a Guardian US columnist and a professor of politics at Princeton University
