Indian High Commission upholds decision banning critic Sapna Samant from returning home
Dr Sapna Samant was warned in January her Overseas Citizen of India status could be revoked, but she was allowed a written appeal.
Photo:
Supplied
An Indian New Zealander has been stripped of her automatic right to return to her home country, being told she has tried to "fuel disharmony" among the community.
GP and filmmaker Dr Sapna Samant was
warned in January
her Overseas Citizen of India (OCI) status could be revoked, but she was allowed a written appeal.
The decision has now been upheld by the Indian High Commission in Wellington.
It has not replied to RNZ requests for comment.
"It has been brought to the notice of the government of India that [Samant] has reportedly involved herself in activities that are inimicable to the sovereignty and integrity of India and the interests of the general public," the High Commission's letter said.
It named her Twitter account, YouTube Channel, and a broadcast on radio station 95bFM.
"Contents used by the foreigner on the said platforms can cause disharmony among various members and sections of the diaspora and Indian society.
"She has been active in anti-India activities, and is often found carrying out anti-India propaganda. She has been issuing posts/tweets extensively, calling India an 'authoritarian country' and a 'majoritarian terrorist regime'. She has been trying to fuel disharmony among various members and sections of the Indian of the India community."
The Commission's decision did not mention one of the more controversial grounds given in January for rescinding her OCI - her involvement with the Green Party, or specifically, her presence on its website.
She stood as a candidate in the 2023 elections.
It said her appeal was "bereft of plausible explanation" and had not clarified or submitted facts which denied her role in the activities it had named.
The Indian government has cancelled more than 100 OCI cards over the last decade, but hers is believed to be the first in New Zealand.
The OCI is a status given to Indians who become New Zealand citizens, allowing them to keep certain birthrights - including travelling to India.
Samant said the appeal's outcome was not unexpected but was still disappointing, as she had held onto a little hope of a change of heart.
"It still makes me sad that we have to reach such a stage where India has fallen from being this vibrant democracy where arguing is a national trait," she said.
"And all kinds of perspectives were perfectly valid, because we all knew that we all loved India, and we want this country to to flourish.
"India is an authoritarian regime country at this point. It's an electoral autocracy, so you have elections in the name of democracy, but your representatives are actually not about democracy."
It meant she could not visit India unless the Government changed, and she worried about Indians at home and overseas being 'silenced' by the government's approach, she said.
Supporters of Indian PM Narendra Modi deny the administration is a threat to an inclusive society.
Samant said she had been hoping to take her foster son to India this year, and that she had received 'solidarity' from activist colleagues and friends.
"Nothing lasts forever. And I have great faith that I will visit my ancestral temple one day, which is on the west coast of India in a little village. I'm not sad that I can't ever go or I won't ever go, but I am sad in the moment. But I also know that there's a bigger cause. I'm not trying to make myself into a martyr, but it's a collective force."
Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero
,
a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
RNZ News
7 hours ago
- RNZ News
The Politics Panel for 4 June 2025
All things politics are discussed in this laser-focused version of The Panel. Today Wallace Chapman is joined by RNZ host of 30 with Guyon, Guyon Espiner and Maria Slade, BusinessDesk journalist. Political scientist Grant Duncan also provides analysis. They discuss a developing story involving allegations that the Prime Minister's deputy chief press secretary recorded audio of sessions with sex workers. Also, they dissect the latest RNZ Reid Research poll results, the huge press response to Jacinda Ardern's memoir, and more. Photo: RNZ/Marika Khabazi
RNZ News
8 hours ago
- RNZ News
Milford Sound plans: 'We've got to get on with it'
The government has announced $15 million will go towards infrastructure upgrades and conservation projects at Milford Sound. File photo. Photo: 123RF Tourism operators are welcoming more clarity on the government's plans for Milford Sound, but say it is now time for action. A 2021 masterplan for the popular tourist destination recommended banning cruise ships, closing the airstrip, a park and ride system and charging overseas visitors a fee. The government announced on Wednesday that about $15 million would go towards infrastructure upgrades and conservation projects, while confirming cruise ships and the airstrip will not be going anywhere , and it was sticking with unrestricted road access. Glenorchy Air managing director James Stokes said the update gave the local aviation industry much needed certainty. "The overall emotion is one of relief that we are going to definitely have an airfield in the future. We were confident that that's the way it was going, but good to hear it finally confirmed," he said. The funding was a good start as Milford Sound had some immediate infrastructure needs it could help to address, Stokes said. The tourism and hospitality and conservation ministers held a call for stakeholders on the day to outline the plans, including wanting to address long-standing concession issues for tourism operators. "I'm keen to see what this reform is going to look like and keen to see how they're going to make it easier for businesses to operate in national parks responsibly," Stokes said. "Just want to get on with it and see the work actually happen. We can't afford another year of nothing happening. We've got to get on with it." Trips and Tramps co-owner Steve Norris said the announcement had been a long time coming and was moving in the right direction. But it left him with questions. A key one was how the traffic and parking would be better managed now the government sought to attract more visitors to the area. "The summer just gone, the carpark's full most days and they're not putting any controls on the road right now... which is fine," Norris said. But in the long term, numbers were expected to increase and there needed to be a solution, he said. Visitor numbers hit 870,000 in 2019, up from 430,000 in 2013. Conservation Minister Tama Potaka said they now surpassed one million a year as Milford Sound was a magnet for tourists. Potaka was also keen to address long standing concession issues for tourism operators as part of conservation reform. It was an area Steve Norris also wanted to see addressed. But he was pleased to hear they were replacing the boat ramp in Deepwater Basin for recreational boaties and local operators. "Great news because that's probably 20 years past its use-by-date - the ramp that's in use at the moment - so that's very encouraging," he said. Work on two of the projects that received funding - cleaning up Little Tahiti landfill and flood protections - had either wrapped up or was underway, so he hoped the money would go towards new projects. The funding was coming from the international visitor levy and the Department of Conservation's capital works programme. Initial policy documents released by DOC suggested that one-off investment costs of between $450-500 million were needed to cover new infrastructure, transport services, visitor facilities, experiences, walking, tracks, carparks, and roadside developments. Tourism and Hospitality Minister Louise Upston said she wanted to attract more visitors to Piopiotahi while still protecting it. "We do know it is a real focus point for visitors coming to New Zealand so we don't want to restrict access to it and actually if you then mean the only route in is by road, that creates other difficulties," she said. When the masterplan was launched, the reasoning for removing the airstrip was because it was in a poor state, exposed to flooding and tsunami risks, expensive to rebuild and only carried about three percent of visitors. Upston acknowledged they needed to look at work to upgrade the airstrip, which could involve more helicopter use in the future. Tourism Industry Aotearoa chief executive Rebecca Ingram said the update addressed long standing uncertainty and gave direction to those wanting to invest in the region "There are a lot of things that the industry can agree on when it comes to Milford and improving the experience and safety are two of them," she said. "We have been strong advocates for a well-managed experience that is great for visitors, community, business and for the environment. "We look forward to working with the Department of Conservation as the proposal goes from plan into action." Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero , a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.
RNZ News
8 hours ago
- RNZ News
'We have massive problems with regulation' - Seymour defends Regulatory Standards Bill
Deputy Prime Minister and ACT Party leader David Seymour has hit back at criticism of his flagship Regulatory Standards Bill, defending the legislation against claims it breaches Treaty of Waitangi principles and contradicts its own standards when compared with the recently passed Pay Equity Bill. In an at-times heated exchange with Guyon Espiner, Seymour stood firm on the need for regulatory reform despite New Zealand's high international rankings in governance and legal standards. Espiner pointed out that New Zealand ranks 99 out of 100 for regulatory quality in the World Bank index, placing it just behind the global benchmark. Seymour dismissed the ranking, arguing it measured whether a country is "basically a third-world country" and failed to capture the real-world frustrations faced by businesses, particularly in agriculture and construction. "You can read all the indices you like, but once you start getting down to talking to the actual people … we have massive problems with regulation," Seymour said, citing delays in approval for lower-emission agricultural chemicals as one. ACT Party leader David Seyour in studio for an interview on season 3 of 30 with Guyon Espiner. Photo: RNZ / Cole Eastham-Farrelly Espiner went on to challenge Seymour on whether the government's recent Pay Equity Bill - pushed through under urgency - violated the principles laid out in the Regulatory Standards Bill itself. These principles include ensuring laws are not retrospective and that proper consultation takes place. Seymour did not deny the lack of consultation or the retrospective nature of the law change - which left 33 current pay equity claimants in the lurch - but argued it was irrelevant. "It was breached because it didn't matter," Seymour said. "All we did was dismantle a Byzantine crazy system… deciding how much the government would pay different workers it was employing anyway." He described the previous equity process as "effectively an internal government activity of arguing with each other" and derided those who had submitted pay appeals under the former system. "They said, 'We work so hard.' I said, 'Really? You think work is arguing with each other?'." The debate turned toward Māori engagement when Espiner pointed out the Waitangi Tribunal's conclusion that the Regulatory Standards Bill, due to a lack of meaningful consultation with Māori, breached the Treaty principles of partnership and active protection. Seymour insisted Māori voices were heard through public consultation. "We had 144 Iwi-based groups who submitted … If that's not enough, then I don't know what is." However, Espiner highlighted that of the 23,000 total submissions, only 76 supported the bill - a support rate of just 0.33 percent. Seymour dismissed the figure as misleading. "That quantum reflects nothing more than the fact that it's got easier and easier for people to make really, frankly, fake submissions … They've got bots, they can make a submission." Despite dismissing the opposing voices as fake, Seymour maintained that what mattered was not the opposition but the quality of the legislative framework, which is non-binding in its nature, thus not enforceable - despite the bill's $20 million price-tag. Seymour argued the Regulatory Standards Bill was about transparency, not enforcement. He compared it to the Public Finance Act and the Reserve Bank Act - also non-binding in nature, but important for government accountability. "There's nothing to stop a minister of finance writing to the governor of the Reserve Bank before an election saying, 'Run the presses, prime the pumps,'" Seymour said. "But it does allow the voters to judge them for doing it… and I want to do the same thing for regulation." Watch the full conversation with David Seymour and Guyon Espiner on 30 With Guyon Espiner . Subscribe to the podcast feed now to get every episode of 30 on your phone when it lands: On Spotify On iHeartRadio On Apple podcasts Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero , a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.
