Charged: Du Val property developer Kenyon Clarke called to court over phone fracas
At the time, police said there was a 'disorder' incident. A spokesperson said: 'There were no injuries. One person was taken into custody at the time, however, they have been released without charge'.
The lack of a charge led to Murphy filing a private prosecution against Clarke with the Auckland District Court, telling the Herald he believed police would take no action.
In the court papers accompanying the private prosecution, Murphy alleged Clarke approached him after he shouted out the developer's name while taking photographs.
The papers claim Clarke then 'reached in through my wound-down driver-side window and snatched my iPhone 15 out of my hands' before walking to his home.
'The act of snatching the phone out of my hands was recorded in a short video to be included as evidence. Prior to the proposed defendant snatching the phone out of my hands, it was fully operable with no water damage.'
Murphy said one of the police officers called to the incident returned the phone to him, saying it had been recovered from the bottom of the Clarkes' swimming pool.
In an interview with the Herald, Murphy said the repairs to his phone cost about $1000 and he wanted compensation for the damage and costs.
Clarke told the Herald at the time: 'The guy's a total [expletive]. A total weirdo. He tried to run me over.' Murphy denies this.
Asked if the phone wound up in the pool, Clarke said: 'Who knows where the phone is? I don't give a [expletive].'
Murphy's private prosecution is now likely on the skids with police laying a charge and the courts generally unwilling to hear two cases against a single defendant over the same issue.
A spokesperson said: 'Police can now advise a 47-year-old man has been summoned to appear in Auckland District Court on 26 May charged with wilful damage.'
Clarke has been approached for comment and has referred the Herald to his lawyer, Ron Mansfield KC. A statement will be issued later today, Mansfield said.
According to emails copied to the Herald, Murphy has continued to send Clarke emailed demands for the repair costs to the phone.
In those emails, he also claims to have organised people to collect the alleged debt from Clarke at his home.
Kenyon and Charlotte Clarke's high-profile property empire was taken into government management in August and then placed in receivership with claims of mounting debts which the couple reject.
David Fisher is based in Northland and has worked as a journalist for more than 30 years, winning multiple journalism awards including being twice named Reporter of the Year and being selected as one of a small number of Wolfson Press Fellows to Wolfson College, Cambridge. He joined the Herald in 2004.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
NZ Herald
2 days ago
- NZ Herald
Court martial for soldier accused of covertly filming women during sexual encounters
He admits taking the videos and images - but says the women consented, or he genuinely believed they were consenting at the time. The women reject this, saying they had no idea they were being recorded. Court martial proceedings began today for Smith at Burnham Military Camp before Judge Tom Gilbert. A court martial is a military court that tries members of the armed forces for violations of military law. It is a structured legal process, similar to a civilian court, and a decision on guilt or innocence is made by a panel of military members - three in Smith's case. If a defendant is found guilty, punishments can include fines, demotions, or imprisonment. Until today, the Herald could not publish details of the allegations against Smith. Between August and November 2020, he is accused of 'intentionally or recklessly' making an intimate visual recording of a woman. He is further charged with deliberately making intimate recordings of a second woman in November 2020 and December 2020. The alleged civil offences contravene the Armed Forces Disciplinary Act 1971. Judge Tom Gilbert. Photo / Pool The names of women have been suppressed. Both were in new relationships with Smith at the time of the alleged offending. Judge Gilbert also suppressed the specific details of the content of the videos and images. He said the Herald could only describe the content of the material and 'what was engaged in between parties' as 'intimate sexual activity'. Anything outside that description was prohibited. During the trial, the court will hear from both complainants via audio-visual link, and the panel deciding Smith's fate will be shown the intimate recordings in question. A number of other witnesses will also be called. Prosecutor Flight Lieutenant Hannah O'Byrne outlined the Crown case against Smith this morning. Corporal Manu Smith at the Court-martial proceedings. Photo / Pool She said the first woman met Smith in July 2020, and a sexual relationship 'progressed quickly'. During sexual activity at her Christchurch home she 'felt something was off' and when she looked up Smith was 'pointing his cellphone at her'. She told him to stop recording and delete the footage. 'She told him off for recording her and he played it off as a joke,' said O'Byrne. The woman assumed the footage was deleted - but Smith later sent it to her via Snapchat. Snapchat is social messaging app where messages are designed to disappear after being viewed or after a set time 'She told him off again, saying she told him not to do that and it wasn't ok,' said O'Byrne. The woman stopped seeing Smith and reported the matter to the police. The second woman was at Smith's defence house in Burnham when she was recorded. O'Byrne said that during sexual activity,, Smith took three photos of the woman. 'Without her consent - or even time to discuss what was happening. At the time,the she did not realise (photographs were being taken),' said the prosecutor. Prosecutor Flight Lieutenant Hannah O'Byrne. Photo / Pool Smith sent her the images on Snapchat, and she took screenshots. She told him to delete the photos, and he 'played it off as a joke'. Smith sent her the images on Snapchat, and she took screenshots. The pair engaged in sexual activity a few days later. 'She could not see what he was doing,' said O'Byrne. 'She did not realise she was being filmed.' Later on, she received a message from Smith on Snapchat. Given his messaging history, she decided to turn on screen recording before she opened it. It was the footage of her taken during sex. 'She asked if he had sent it to anyone else. He played it off as a joke,' said O'Byrne. The second woman reported the incident to police, handing over the screen recordings. Defence lawyer Matthew Hague. Photo / Pool The court heard that during their relationships with Smith, they had willingly and knowingly sent him explicit images and video, including naked photos. These were sent via Snapchat. Both vehemently reject Smith's explanation that they consented to him filming and or photographing them. The first woman began giving evidence before lunch. 'In the video, you can see me trying to swipe his phone away, telling him to put it away,' she said. She said there had been no discussion before sex about whether Smith could record. When she told him off, he was 'very blase'. 'He just said 'no, it's all good',' she recalled. She said she felt 'pretty gross'. 'My privacy had been invaded,' she said. In a brief opening address, Smith's lawyer, Matthew Hague, told the panel that his client denied all the charges. 'Let me be clear… what you've heard… is just allegations,' he said. 'It is not evidence. At present… the accused must be presumed innocent." The court martial is set to continue for at least three days. Anna Leask is a senior journalist who covers national crime and justice. She joined the Herald in 2008 and has worked as a journalist for 19 years with a particular focus on family and gender-based violence, child abuse, sexual violence, homicides, mental health and youth crime. She writes, hosts and produces the award-winning podcast A Moment In Crime, released monthly on
Otago Daily Times
2 days ago
- Otago Daily Times
Former Chch man pleads guilty to sex trafficking charges in the US
A Christchurch-born man has pleaded guilty to multiple sex trafficking charges in a United States federal court. Pornographer Michael James Pratt, the owner of adult website GirlsDoPorn, had been awaiting trial after he initially pleaded not guilty following his arrest and extradition from Spain to the United States, the New Zealand Herald reported. He pleaded guilty in San Diego on Thursday. In his plea agreement, the Herald reported Pratt pleaded guilty to conspiracy to sex traffic and sex trafficking. He is due to be sentenced on September 8. Prior to being arrested at a Spanish hotel in 2022, Pratt, 42, was on the FBI's top 10 most wanted list. The Herald reported the summary of charges states that sex trafficking conspiracy carries a maximum penalty of life in prison and a $250,000 fine. The charge of sex trafficking carries a mandatory minimum penalty of 15 years in prison and a maximum penalty of life in prison and a US$250,000 ($414,000) fine. Pratt was charged in October 2019 in California with sex trafficking crimes in connection with a scheme to deceive and coerce young women to appear in pornographic videos, the Herald reported. He liquidated his assets and fled the United States in mid-2019. Pratt was one of five co-defendants in the case. Three have been sentenced to prison, while a fourth awaits sentencing, the Herald reported. Christchurch pornographer shamed in court His childhood friend from Christchurch, Matthew Isaac Wolfe, was jailed for 14 years in March last year for tricking scores of women into becoming porn stars. Wolfe had claimed in court that he was effectively forced to go and work for his friend after the February 22, 2011, earthquake in Christchurch. Pratt and Wolfe met at primary school in Christchurch. While they attended different secondary schools - Christchurch Boys' High and Burnside High respectively - they remained friends. Ruben Andre Garcia, who was recruited by Pratt in 2013 and was the male model who engaged in sex acts on video with the women, was sentenced to 20 years in prison in June 2021, the Herald reported. Theodore Gyi, who served as a cameraman, was sentenced to four years in prison in November 2022, while Valorie Moser, the office manager, will be sentenced on September 12. In May, the Herald reported US authorities have moved to seize more than $1.2 million in cryptocurrency from Pratt.
NZ Herald
03-06-2025
- NZ Herald
Woolworths' Milkrun adverts show false prices for butter, Coca-Cola and cucumbers
Woolworths has apologised and blamed 'human error' for advertising incorrect prices on its Milkrun delivery app, including butter marketed for $5.50 when it was actually $9.55. It comes as the supermarket giant is already facing criminal charges for misleading consumers over pricing. The Herald was supplied screenshots of
