logo
Is IBC an effective resolution tool?

Is IBC an effective resolution tool?

The Hindu05-06-2025
The story so far:
More than eight years have passed since the enactment of India's Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code (IBC). According to data from the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Board of India (IBBI), creditors have realised ₹3.89 lakh crore under the framework, with a recovery rate of over 32.8% against admitted claims.
Why was the IBC enacted?
India enacted the IBC, its first comprehensive bankruptcy law, in 2016 to improve the overall corporate insolvency resolution process. Shifting control from debtors to creditors, the IBC introduced a time-bound resolution mechanism to streamline bankruptcy proceedings, reduce judicial delays, and improve creditor recoveries. According to current provisions, a maximum timeline of 330 days is allowed to find a resolution for a company admitted into the insolvency resolution process. Otherwise, the company goes into liquidation. So far, the Code has rescued 1,194 companies through resolution plans.
Is IBC a preferred route for debt recovery?
As per the Reserve Bank of India report on Trend and Progress of Banking in India released in December 2024, the IBC emerged as the dominant recovery route, accounting for 48% of all recoveries made by banks followed by the Securitisation and Reconstruction of Financial Assets and Enforcement of Security Interest (SARFAESI) Act (32%), Debt Recovery Tribunals (17%), and Lok Adalats (3%) in the Financial Year 2023-24. The realisation under IBC is more than 170.1% as against the liquidation value. Resolution plans, on average, are yielding 93.41% of the fair value of the Corporate Debtors (CDs), IBBI said.
Further, 1,276 cases have been settled through appeal, review, or settlement, and 1,154 cases have been withdrawn under section 12A. The Code has referred 2,758 companies for liquidation, as per IBBI data. Nearly 10 companies are being resolved against five going into liquidation.
Has IBC been an effective recovery mechanism?
Akshat Khetan, Founder, AU Corporate Advisory and Legal Services, pointed out that IBC has changed the underlying credit culture. As the Supreme Court once observed, 'the defaulter's paradise is lost' and the Code has created a credible threat that ensures timely repayment.
On the recovery rate of 32.8%, Mr. Khetan pointed out that it must be interpreted in light of the distressed nature of the assets that come into the IBC process, often after years of erosion.
As the National Company Law Appellate Tribunal has rightly remarked in one of its rulings, 'IBC is not a recovery mechanism; it is a resolution framework.' Compared to legacy systems, where recovery rates were often below 20% with timelines extending into decades, a 32.8% realisation is a leap forward, he said.
Mr. Khetan also stated that the statistic does not capture qualitative gains, such as job preservation, improved enterprise value, and restored investor confidence. In a framework designed to balance resolution over liquidation, the broader economic impact of IBC far outweighs numerical recovery alone, he said.
The provisions of the IBC have prompted debtors to take early action in distress situations, marking a shift in their behaviour. National Company Law Tribunal (NCLT) data show that 30,310 cases were settled prior to admission, covering underlying defaults worth ₹13.78 lakh crore till December 2024.
A study by the Indian Institute of Management, Bangalore, submitted to IBBI, said IBC has injected discipline in the credit allocation process and has prompted borrowers to adhere to stipulated payment schedules. The gross non-performing assets of the scheduled commercial banks have declined from a peak of 11.2% in March 2018 to 2.8% in March 2024. A part of that reduction is attributable to resolution processes enabled under IBC, it said.
The study also indicated a 3% reduction in the cost of debt for distressed firms post-IBC, compared to non-distressed firms , indicating an improved credit environment for distressed firms. The IBC has had a positive impact on corporate governance, reflected in the increased proportion of independent directors on the boards of companies resolved under the Code.
What are the major challenges?
In a recent report, India Ratings and Research said that judicial delays and post-resolution uncertainties continue to affect confidence in the IBC framework.
Even when resolution applicants are ready and the Committee of Creditors has granted approval, delays at the NCLT continue to push recovery timelines. In several cases, such delays result in extended litigation or failed implementation, increasing the risk of liquidation for a viable asset that requires timely execution, it said.
The future insolvencies also raise questions about the Code's readiness to handle non-traditional enterprise defaults. While the IBC is legally broad enough to accommodate various resolution strategies, key commercial elements such as intellectual property valuation, treatment of employee dues, and tech continuity require a clearer treatment under the framework to make it future-ready, India Ratings said.
To enhance its effectiveness, India must invest in strengthening tribunal infrastructure, allow for pre-packaged insolvency, and establish jurisprudential guardrails to protect bona fide commercial decisions from post-resolution uncertainty, Mr. Khetan said.
While challenges persist, including process delays and recovery rates below expectations, the Code's foundational structure remains sound. As implementation matures and jurisprudence evolves, the IBC is well-positioned to overcome these hurdles and fully realise its transformative potential in India's financial ecosystem, IBBI Chairman Ravi Mital said in the recent quarterly newsletter.
Does the SC verdict on Bhushan Steel pose a challenge to IBC?
The recent developments in the Bhushan Power and Steel Ltd. case have reignited concerns around the finality of resolution outcomes and the predictability of the framework.
While the decision upholds compliance standards, its timing and implications highlight the need for judicial clarity and faster adjudication to sustain investor confidence in the process in the long term, India Ratings said.
By questioning a transaction that had been closed and operational for years, it risks unsettling the core principle of commercial certainty. If resolution applicants fear judicial reversals even after significant investment, they may hesitate to bid, undermining the IBC's very purpose. The Bhushan verdict thus underscores the need for legal sanctity once a resolution plan is approved and implemented, Mr. Khetan said.
The IBC is not merely a piece of economic legislation, it is the backbone of India's credit ecosystem. Its future lies in striking a fine balance between judicial oversight and economic pragmatism. As India aspires to become a $5 trillion economy, robust and predictable insolvency mechanisms are indispensable. The Code must remain nimble, continually evolving to meet emerging realities while ensuring that commercial wisdom is not second-guessed endlessly, he said.
Almost 78% of the ongoing Corporate Insolvency Resolution Process (CIRP) cases have exceeded 270 days, post-admission by the NCLT, as on March 31, 2025, ratings agency ICRA said.
A sustained momentum would be needed to minimise haircuts for lenders, which remain high at 67%, it said.
Nevertheless, some of the recent judgments reinforce the need for timely and transparent resolution, thereby putting greater onus on the Committee of Creditors (CoC) and NCLT. However, such rulings may also impact investor confidence in stressed assets setting precedents that the decision made by the CoC and the NCLT may be challenged and overturned by the judicial system, thus impacting the effectiveness of the resolution process, ICRA said.
Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

RBI Governor says growth resilient considering uncertain environment, which shows no signs of abatement: MPC Minutes
RBI Governor says growth resilient considering uncertain environment, which shows no signs of abatement: MPC Minutes

Economic Times

time2 minutes ago

  • Economic Times

RBI Governor says growth resilient considering uncertain environment, which shows no signs of abatement: MPC Minutes

Agencies RBI Governor Sanjay Malhotra The Reserve Bank of India Governor Sanjay Malhotra said the global economy continues to traverse a period of heightened uncertainty on account of trade and tariff negotiations and lingering geopolitical tensions. However, he added that the global growth has improved owing to front loading of exports in anticipation of tariffs, easing of financial conditions and fiscal expansion in advanced economies (AEs). "The pace of disinflation, however, has slowed down and inflation continues to remain above the target in most AEs," Malhotra said. The governor said that the domestic economy has grown largely in line with assessment set out in the June policy. He said that the growth projected at 6.5 per cent is resilient, considering the current uncertain environment which shows no signs of abatement. He added that this is lower than what the nation can achieve. "High-frequency indicators point toward buoyant rural economic activity and consumption, whereas urban spending continues to remain sluggish. During the remaining part of the financial year, growth is likely to receive support from both favourable supply-side factors as well as a supportive policy environment," Malhotra said. The RBI decided not to make any changes in to the repo rate and kept it at 5.50 per cent following the meeting from August 4-6, after having cut rate consecutively previously. Malhotra said that the southwest monsoon has progressed well and that sowing has been satisfactory, and reservoir levels are comfortable, paving way for positive farm outlook and urban development. He added that the urban demand is likely to witness a boost during the festive season, especially in a period of benign inflation. "Services sector activity is also likely to remain strong, as evident from forward-looking assessments from surveys. Uncertainty in external demand, driven by tariff and geopolitical uncertainty, remains the major drag on growth as it also hinders private investment intentions, which is yet to show visible signs of improvement," Malhotra said. Malhotra said inflation has continued its downward trajectory, with headline CPI inflation in June at 2.1 per cent - a 77-month low. In July, retail inflation fell to an eight-year low of 1.55%, below the central bank's 2-6% target range, driven largely by a drop in food prices. It also marked the sixth straight month of Consumer Price Index (CPI) inflation staying below 4%. The Reserve Bank of India (RBI) is mandated to keep inflation at 4% within the decline in inflation was primarily driven by the food component, which registered a year-on-year contraction of -0.2 per cent in June. "The extent of moderation in food inflation turned out to be larger than that expected during the June MPC meeting, as supply-side conditions turned out to be much more favourable," the governor said. "Although we are likely to see inflation undershooting the target in the near term, with a likelihood of monthly numbers even crossing the lower tolerance band of 2 per cent, headline inflation is projected to inch up from Q3 onwards. The uncertainties of tariffs are still evolving. Monetary policy transmission of the cumulative 100 basis points cut in the policy rate since February 2025, though hastened due to various measures, is still continuing. The CRR cut, that is likely to kick in from next month, will also facilitate further monetary transmission and stimulate economic activity," he added. Giving an over all picture of the economy, Malhotra said it paints a picture of strength, stability, and opportunity. "India's strong fundamentals, growth inducing policies, and forward-looking economic strategy clearly place it in a strong position. While growth has remained steady, inflation outcomes have been far more benign on account of higher food price moderation," he said. He said that the monetary policy needs to remain watchful considering the state of uncertainty on the external front, which is why the repo rate was kept unchanged at 5.50 per cent. "I also support retaining the neutral stance as it would provide monetary policy the necessary flexibility to respond to the evolving domestic and global economic conditions," Malhotra said.

RBI Governor says growth resilient considering uncertain environment, which shows no signs of abatement: MPC Minutes
RBI Governor says growth resilient considering uncertain environment, which shows no signs of abatement: MPC Minutes

Time of India

time18 minutes ago

  • Time of India

RBI Governor says growth resilient considering uncertain environment, which shows no signs of abatement: MPC Minutes

The Reserve Bank of India Governor Sanjay Malhotra said the global economy continues to traverse a period of heightened uncertainty on account of trade and tariff negotiations and lingering geopolitical tensions . However, he added that the global growth has improved owing to front loading of exports in anticipation of tariffs, easing of financial conditions and fiscal expansion in advanced economies (AEs). "The pace of disinflation, however, has slowed down and inflation continues to remain above the target in most AEs," Malhotra said. The governor said that the domestic economy has grown largely in line with assessment set out in the June policy. He said that the growth projected at 6.5 per cent is resilient, considering the current uncertain environment which shows no signs of abatement. by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like This Could Be the Best Time to Trade Gold in 5 Years IC Markets Learn More He added that this is lower than what the nation can achieve. "High-frequency indicators point toward buoyant rural economic activity and consumption, whereas urban spending continues to remain sluggish. During the remaining part of the financial year, growth is likely to receive support from both favourable supply-side factors as well as a supportive policy environment," Malhotra said. The RBI decided not to make any changes in to the repo rate and kept it at 5.50 per cent following the meeting from August 4-6, after having cut rate consecutively previously. Live Events Satisfactory Monsoon Malhotra said that the southwest monsoon has progressed well and that sowing has been satisfactory, and reservoir levels are comfortable, paving way for positive farm outlook and urban development. He added that the urban demand is likely to witness a boost during the festive season, especially in a period of benign inflation. "Services sector activity is also likely to remain strong, as evident from forward-looking assessments from surveys. Uncertainty in external demand, driven by tariff and geopolitical uncertainty, remains the major drag on growth as it also hinders private investment intentions, which is yet to show visible signs of improvement," Malhotra said. Inflation in check Malhotra said inflation has continued its downward trajectory, with headline CPI inflation in June at 2.1 per cent - a 77-month low. In July, retail inflation fell to an eight-year low of 1.55%, below the central bank's 2-6% target range, driven largely by a drop in food prices. It also marked the sixth straight month of Consumer Price Index (CPI) inflation staying below 4%. The Reserve Bank of India (RBI) is mandated to keep inflation at 4% within the range. The decline in inflation was primarily driven by the food component, which registered a year-on-year contraction of -0.2 per cent in June. "The extent of moderation in food inflation turned out to be larger than that expected during the June MPC meeting, as supply-side conditions turned out to be much more favourable," the governor said. "Although we are likely to see inflation undershooting the target in the near term, with a likelihood of monthly numbers even crossing the lower tolerance band of 2 per cent, headline inflation is projected to inch up from Q3 onwards. The uncertainties of tariffs are still evolving. Monetary policy transmission of the cumulative 100 basis points cut in the policy rate since February 2025, though hastened due to various measures, is still continuing. The CRR cut, that is likely to kick in from next month, will also facilitate further monetary transmission and stimulate economic activity," he added. The big picture Giving an over all picture of the economy, Malhotra said it paints a picture of strength, stability, and opportunity. "India's strong fundamentals, growth inducing policies, and forward-looking economic strategy clearly place it in a strong position. While growth has remained steady, inflation outcomes have been far more benign on account of higher food price moderation," he said. He said that the monetary policy needs to remain watchful considering the state of uncertainty on the external front, which is why the repo rate was kept unchanged at 5.50 per cent. "I also support retaining the neutral stance as it would provide monetary policy the necessary flexibility to respond to the evolving domestic and global economic conditions," Malhotra said.

A new era of financial oversight and regulation is here, says RBI Deputy Governor
A new era of financial oversight and regulation is here, says RBI Deputy Governor

Time of India

time2 hours ago

  • Time of India

A new era of financial oversight and regulation is here, says RBI Deputy Governor

The Reserve Bank of India ( RBI ) is embarking on a significant transformation in its regulatory approach, according to the central bank's Deputy Governor M Rajeshwar Rao . The central bank is gradually moving towards principle and outcome-based regulations; this shift aims to provide greater operational flexibility to regulated entities (REs), allowing them to align their activities with their specific needs while still adhering to a robust regulatory framework, he said. Rao made this observations during a recent address at the Department of Personnel and Training's Management Development Programme on Financial Market Regulations at the Indian Institute of Management Kozhikode. Underlining the complexities regulators face when crafting regulations, Rao said that there is no universally perfect regulatory model. However, he suggested that principle and outcome-based frameworks tend to suit mature markets better, as they can adapt to the unique challenges presented by evolving financial landscapes. by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like The Top 25 Most Beautiful Women In The World Car Novels Undo Rao's comments underscore a fundamental shift in regulatory philosophy. He stressed that regulators must adopt a forward-looking approach to effectively address emerging risks and ensure the resilience of the financial system. To achieve this, he called for a proactive mindset that embraces innovation and utilises data and technology to enhance regulatory efficiency. The deputy governor further emphasised the need for regulators to leverage technology not only to improve internal processes but also for supervisory functions. He advocated for regulatory horizon risk scanning and the need to stay updated with rapid technological advancements. Live Events In an era defined by digital transformation, collaboration with domain experts is essential for regulators to keep pace with ongoing changes in the financial sector, he said. Rao also touched upon the importance of refining regulations to facilitate compliance for REs. Simplifying regulations, enhancing clarity, and eliminating redundancies are crucial steps in this process. The RBI has already begun to incorporate examples and frequently asked questions into its regulatory documents to aid REs in understanding compliance requirements. Consumer protection emerged as a key theme in Rao's speech. He pointed out that regulatory policies must consider the interests of consumers, who are pivotal stakeholders in the financial system. By empowering consumers and safeguarding their rights, regulators can foster a more equitable financial environment. Striking a balance between stability and innovation is critical in regulatory policy, Rao noted. While it is essential to mitigate systemic risks and protect consumers, overregulation can stifle creativity and hinder competition. Conversely, a sole focus on innovation without adequate safeguards may lead to financial instability and a loss of public confidence in the system, he said.

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store