Irish Examiner view: Satire dead as Trump makes peace
The ceasefire between Israel and Iran appears to be holding at the time of writing, though the swiftness of unfolding events in the Middle East has often made a mockery of presumption in the past.
The two nations' exchange of missiles was a worrying escalation in a region not short of hair-trigger tempers, so we should not belittle anyone who is seeking to calm the situation.
The performance of US president Donald Trump in these circumstances, however, bears closer inspection.
Many readers will be familiar by now with the clip of Mr Trump using bad language in describing Israel and Iran; it is a soundbite that will probably play well with his base, and he may plausibly justify his choice of words while portraying himself as a peacemaker.
That was surely part of the motivation for his outspokenness, particularly as it came before his trip to the annual meeting of Nato this week in Holland.
Depicting himself as a peace broker would surely have bolstered Mr Trump's authority with his Nato allies, particularly as he is keen to get those allies contributing more to Nato's running costs.
That authority was undermined by American intelligence reports suggesting the recent US missile attack on Iran did not obliterate that country's nuclear capability, as claimed, but merely set it back by a few months (reports Mr Trump immediately contradicted).
It may not be coincidental that this week, Nato countries have accepted the need to contribute more revenue — but some at least have avoided being bound to Mr Trump's spending targets.
This last development may have real-world implications in the future, but for now we are still processing extraordinary scenes: The US president cursing about other countries on air, and rubbishing his own intelligence services' findings, would have fuelled a month's worth of headlines at any other time.
This week those stories were outdone by a US politician nominating Mr Trump for the Nobel Peace Prize because of the Iran-Israel ceasefire.
When Henry Kissinger was nominated for that award, comedian Tom Lehrer declared satire dead.
This week we learned that it is not dead but decomposing.
Concrete supply: Infrastructure woes continue
It is widely accepted that one of the great challenges of modern Irish life is the pressure on our national infrastructure.
Energy is an obvious concern, not just because of our fragile energy security due to our location, but also due to the vast amounts of electricity consumed by data centres.
Water supply is another ongoing headache, not least because of the various travails of Uisce Éireann ever since that body was founded.
Now, we have learned that another key element in creating and maintaining large-scale infrastructure is in trouble.
Engineering consultancy firm RPS carried out a study for the Irish Concrete Federation, which found replenishment rates of quarries are inadequate — currently they are running at 61% of the annual consumption.
The study also found that planning permission was refused for over half of the volume of proposed extraction of sand, stone, and gravel in greater Dublin between 2017 and last year — while there have also been delays in obtaining planning permission to extend quarries or get permission for new sites.
One does not need to be a civil engineer to realise that if supplies of sand, stone, and gravel dwindle, then there are obvious implications for our building capacity.
It is notable that the lack of planning permissions is a key issue here, thus echoing the comments of the ESRI's Seán O'Driscoll in these pages recently.
He pointed out then that the Government needed to accept that there was a 'national crisis in Irish infrastructure' if progress was to be achieved, and this study adds weight to that claim.
Unfortunately, the response from the current administration does not seem to acknowledge that crisis.
The Government will engage with the concrete industry about their concerns, according to housing minister James Browne, but he added that the independent planning system also has to take its 'natural course'.
The various shambles we have witnessed in our planning system over the years do not depict that 'natural course' in a flattering light.
The 'business as usual' approach on show here is the last response needed for a national crisis.
Glastonbury festival: Kneecap drama
The Glastonbury festival opened yesterday, with thousands of fans pouring into the venue to see their favourite musicians.
This year there is an edge of controversy in the presence of Belfast band Kneecap; band member Liam Óg Ó hAnnaidh faces a terrorism charge for allegedly displaying a Hezbollah flag at a London show last year.
British prime minister Keir Starmer said this week that it is not 'appropriate' for the band to perform at Glastonbury, while Tory leader Kemi Badenoch has said the BBC — which normally broadcasts many of the acts at the festival — should not show Kneecap's performance.
Belfast band Kneecap.
It was not clear at press time whether the BBC would show the Belfast band or wait until nearer the time to make a decision — Kneecap are due to play on Saturday.
It is not for us to wonder that an experienced lawyer such as Mr Starmer should be expressing opinions which might be prejudicial to Mr Ó hAnnaidh's case.
But we are hardly the only people who feel that British politicians surely have better things to do than complain about Kneecap.
Read More
Irish Examiner view: Cork crime series reveals a city divided by neglect of the northside
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Times
43 minutes ago
- Irish Times
Pro-Israel countries to block Irish efforts to sanction Israel at EU summit
Pro- Israel countries, including Germany and Italy , are set to block efforts by Ireland and other member states to take action against Israel over its war in Gaza at today's summit of EU leaders in Brussels. Several member states, also including Austria , the Czech Republic and Hungary , will not agree for the EU to take action despite a recent review of an EU-Israel trade agreement that found Israel was committing human rights violations in conflict with it. The EU-Israel 'association agreement' governs relations between the bloc and Israel and includes a free trade deal. Ireland and other countries favour taking action, up to and including suspending the agreement, but officials accept that any move to sanction Israel at the summit would likely be blocked. READ MORE Several capitals traditionally supportive of Israel opposed the review even being mentioned in a joint statement – or 'conclusions' – that would be signed by all 27 national leaders. Haggling over the language in the joint communique was set to continue into Thursday. It would be 'bizarre' if a statement from EU leaders at the end of the summit failed to mention the critical review, one diplomat involved in the talks said. It is expected, however, that the conclusion will point to the 'dire' humanitarian situation in Gaza , and diplomats said the focus was likely to be on pressuring Israel to allow aid into the enclave rather than for any sanctions. The dispute over the wording in the statement illustrates the tense divisions that remain within the EU about how to push Israel to change course and let humanitarian aid flow into Gaza. 'There is no consensus on the issue around the European table,' the diplomat said. Taoiseach Micheál Martin said the EU's inability to reach a unified position on the humanitarian crisis in Gaza is a 'huge stain' on the union . Speaking in Brussels on Wednesday, Mr Martin said there must be 'consequences' for Israel's human rights violations. 'Europe needs to speak with a very strong voice, to end this blockade and get vital humanitarian aid into the population of Gaza – otherwise Europe will not have credibility,' he said. The Taoiseach is expected to have discussions with like-minded countries, including on the legislation to ban imports from the occupied Palestinian territories. Irish officials were cautious about the prospects for countries to co-ordinate such actions, but expressed frustration with the EU's lack of action. Yesterday, the Government published a summary of its proposed legislation to prohibit the sale of Israeli goods produced in the occupied Palestinian territories. As expected, it makes no reference to services being subject to a similar ban. This drew criticism from pro-Palestinian campaigners and Opposition parties. [ Where do Europe and Ireland stand as Donald Trump changes the world? Opens in new window ] The summary, or 'heads' of the Bill, will now be sent for pre-legislative scrutiny by the Oireachtas Foreign Affairs Committee. Meanwhile, Nato leaders on Wednesday backed a big increase in defence spending and restated their commitment to defend each other from attack after a brief summit tailor-made for US president Donald Trump . In a short statement, Nato endorsed a higher defence spending goal of 5 per cent of GDP by 2035 – a response to a demand by Mr Trump and to European fears that Russia poses a growing threat to Europe's security following the 2022 invasion of Ukraine. The planned increases will see hundreds of billions of euro more being spent on defence and military capabilities over the next decade. 'We reaffirm our iron-clad commitment to collective defence as enshrined in Article 5 of the Washington Treaty – that an attack on one is an attack on all,' said the statement, which came after Mr Trump sparked concern on Tuesday by saying there were 'numerous definitions' of the clause.
Irish Times
43 minutes ago
- Irish Times
Trump's perfectly landed swear word was his best performance yet
It's been nearly a year since a gunman attempted to assassinate Donald Trump , leading to the most memorable photo op of all time. It left me considering a similar Trumpian superlative: is he the greatest media performer of the 21st century? I have seen little since to disabuse me of the notion: the YMCA, the McDonald's stunt, the nutty Truth Social posts that cut through and generate their own column inches in newspapers. It's a self-sustaining, organic whirlpool of attention. And on Tuesday he gave the world his best performance yet. Standing on a lawn in front of a helicopter, unable to corral his anger at Israel breaking the terms of a ceasefire hours after it was brokered, he told reporters: 'We basically have two countries that have been fighting so long and so hard that they don't know what the f**k they're doing.' It at least made this writer – no acolyte of Trump – mutter, 'You know what? Fair enough.' Trump's speeches are convoluted, confused, long-winded, undulating and lack any beginning, narrative arc or obvious end point. These are not the traditional characteristics of a great speaker. His writing is frenetic and too reliant on the CAPS LOCK BUTTON to demarcate him as a great literary talent, or even a competent one. And yet it is impossible to look away. Pages are dedicated to parsing his social media posts. When he speaks, everyone listens – in a way that was not true of Joe Biden , as just one example. So what is the secret? He is funny – the nicknames for political opponents may be puerile but they do elicit a smirk. He is casual – you could hardly say many of his rhetorical interventions feel scripted, or prepared. He is extraordinarily rude – a recent screed about Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez read: 'Stupid AOC, Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez, one of the 'dumbest' people in Congress, is now calling for my Impeachment, despite the fact that the Crooked and Corrupt Democrats have already done that twice before.' READ MORE 'Funny' and 'casual' might be desirable qualities in a friend. 'Extraordinarily rude' is an undesirable trait in anyone. All three at once in a politician of Trump's rank? Is that genuinely unprecedented? But more importantly than all that, as far as his fans are concerned, Trump never veers towards the worthy or po-faced. He does not launch moralising invectives. He is not burdened by a humourlessness otherwise endemic to the Democrats, the Irish left, and indeed the left almost everywhere else. I suspect the left – unless they sort this out – will be condemned to trail in the populist right's wake for eternity. Take the Social Democrats in Ireland. The party should be sweeping at the ballot box: there is a young captive audience who lean in its political direction. On Gaza alone they could galvanise large numbers, not to mention cost of living, housing, and their leftish side of the culture wars. And yet the party couldn't even make 5 per cent in last November's election (if this is the Soc Dems' best ever electoral performance, something significant has to change). [ The idea that the Kremlin has kompromat on Trump seems increasingly plausible Opens in new window ] I am thinking of Holly Cairns 's speech at the Social Democrats' conference last year. She is presentable, sharp, professional and oh so worthy (furrowed brow, enumerating Ireland's failures, I did not laugh). In fact, all the Soc Dems are so rhetorically staid they somehow manage to make the top brass of Fianna Fáil look like raconteurs. This is a shame: first, because it is not inevitable that the left be devoid of fun while the right hoovers up attention; second, because it is an act of political self-harm. [ 'I couldn't think of anything worse to attend': Some Opposition TDs snub invite to US Independence Day celebration Opens in new window ] And now look to London: Keir Starmer's Labour is nearly as unpopular as the moribund Conservative Party , only one year into office. There are plenty of reasons: flip-flopping on welfare; an insurgent Nigel Farage ; running a government full of MPs who are very used to opposition and completely unfamiliar with power. But the scaffolding holding this coalition of bad qualities together is Starmer's buttoned up, staid, uninspired method of talking. There is no story, no tie-loosening, no flair; there are no jokes. Donald Trump expressed frustration at Iran-Israel ceasefire violations, by dropping the 'F' word when being questioned by media on the White House lawn And back to Trump, who disarms the viewer and demands their attention because he subverts expectations. He feels like a person – an odd one, no doubt – more than a media-trained politician. And with all of that he exposes the staggering rhetorical limitations of the Democrats . They lost last year because the establishment conspired to keep Biden in position way longer than was ever suitable. But they are still losing now because they cannot speak to the country like Trump. Either they don't know how, or they will not permit themselves to. Trump's rhetorical talent is not something to be celebrated. He has taken a sledgehammer to European security, political propriety and American civil norms. That he does this all with a wink and a wry smile and a perfectly landed swear word is impressive – and disarming. Changing language will not rescue the politics. But the left – or the centre, or even the centre-right – can meet the threat of the populist right with a bit of a lighter tone, a joke or two, and less moral posture. You can ventriloquise the problems of a nation without a permanently furrowed brow; it is not illegal to crack a smile.
Irish Times
43 minutes ago
- Irish Times
ESRI cuts growth forecasts and warns of constraints to building projects
The Economic and Social Research Institute (ESRI) has downgraded its growth forecasts for the Irish economy, citing US trade policy uncertainty which it said was already dampening investment and consumption. In its latest quarterly bulletin, the think tank also warned that the Government would have to prioritise certain infrastructural projects in its revamped National Development Plan (NDP) because of capacity constraints in a 'full-employment' economy. On the basis of a 10 per cent tariff on EU goods exports to the US with an exemption for pharmaceuticals, the institute forecast the economy here would grow, in modified domestic demand terms, by 2.3 per cent this year, down from 3 per cent previously, and by 2.8 per cent in 2026. 'With both trade in services and in pharmaceuticals currently outside the scope of the Trump announcements, Ireland is insulated to some degree in the short run,' it said. READ MORE 'This could change, however, and longer term US policy shifts could threaten the Irish foreign direct investment (FDI) led economic model if both tariff and non-tariff measures act to reshore activity by US firms back to the US,' it said. EU negotiators had been hoping to strike a deal with Washington to roll back the near-blanket 10 per cent tariffs imposed since US president Donald Trump 's 'liberation day' announcement in April. But officials in Brussels have begun to accept that any agreement may mean conceding to trade tariffs of at least 10 per cent. In its report, the ESRI also highlighted the potential capacity constraints facing Ireland as it tries to address long-standing infrastructural and housing deficits. 'Even though an ambitious rewrite of the NDP might be affordable in a financial sense, it could be that elements of the NDP will have to be staged in a way that creates sufficient capacity to deliver vital housing supply,' it said. A previous report by the institute indicated that up to 80,000 additional workers were needed for build projects in the NDP and to hit the Government's housing targets. The ESRI's Alan Barrett said the Government are going to have to look closely at prioritisation across the NDP 'and what are going to be the labour demands at any given point in time'. It may need to consider 'is it possible to sequence things in such a way that you don't have a situation in which one arm of the NDP is competing against an additional arm of the NDP', he said. In its report, the ESRI said the domestic economy faced two notable headwinds. 'The public finances are heavily dependent on windfall corporation tax receipts and residential construction is not accelerating sufficiently quickly to meet housing need,' it said. While total tax revenues are growing, the ESRI noted the dip in corporate tax receipts in May (they were down €1.1 billion on the same month last year) 'served as a reminder of the potential vulnerability'. 'History – in particular the economic collapse – provides a stark reminder that a vulnerability in the tax base can become a major problem if something arises to test the vulnerability,' it said. [ 'Not expensive, but not super cheap either': US tourists see value in Ireland despite Trump tariff impact Opens in new window ] The ESRI also warned that Government expenditure was increasing faster than planned in Budget 2025 and 'has increased considerably relative to the size of the domestic economy in recent years'. On housing, the institute reduced its forecast for completions in 2025 and 2026 to 33,000 and 37,000 units respectively, 'reflecting the first quarter out-turn and the ongoing structural challenges including production costs, supporting infrastructure, financing, and labour shortages'. Commenting on the report, Mr Barrett said: 'The economy continues to perform well and the ongoing increase in the numbers employed in Ireland is very welcome.' 'However, it is difficult not to be unsettled by global uncertainties,' he said.
